3 ms·
> We know the engine did not explode, because we continued to receive data from it. Uh, they say the engine did not explode. The failed engine shut down and ve
by stcredzero 14y ago
> We know the engine did not explode, because we continued to receive data from it.
Uh, they say the engine did not explode. The failed engine shut down and vented gasses ruptured the engine fairing. How about someone change the inaccurate headline? "That smooth SpaceX launch? Turns out one of the engines exploded"
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- anovikov 14y agoI don't know how do you come to conclusion that there was any kind of mechanical damage anywhere. There was most certainly none. The engine simply shut down, most probably because one of the many possible abort criteria happened, e.g. some of the controlled variables of engine, like pressure, flow, temperature of fluids/gases in many places, or turbopump RPM, etc. exited the permitted corridor of safety. It can be due to something as simple as a faulty sensor indicating a false reading, or the condition being too strict (both happened to SpaceX before). Then the engine was shut down, and the lower temp plume of the engine which being shut down appeared to you like 'smoke of explosion' on video. I am in fact near certain that the engine remained mechanically fine after shutdown and nothing else exploded or was broken. They will figure this out for the next flight.
- jlgreco 14y agoIf spacex says there is an engine fairing, I'm going to say there is one.
- anovikov 14y agoYeah now i see from the slow-mo that the aerodynamic shell got ruptured, but it's no big deal, it's obviously not designed to handle any loads from INSIDE.
- damoncali 14y agoThey said the engine fairing ruptured. That is most definitely mechanical damage.
- cameldrv 14y agoThe engine is designed to hold high pressures, but it ruptured, and then the rapidly expanding gasses tore off other parts of the engine. It didn't disintegrate, but that sure sounds like an explosion to me.
- pyre 14y agoNot a rocket scientist, but using a car analogy, this sounds like the engine block vented gases and blew off the hood of the car, while the engine block itself received no damage.
- parfe 14y agoHow about a "spontaneous self-initiated partial disassembly event"? I watched the video and don't see why a burst of flames and debris would not be described as an explosion, other than marketing.
- jlgreco 14y agoAh yes, you have got to love rocket scientist terminology. The wikipedia page for the Vanguard rocket used to have an image of one of them exploding captioned with " Vanguard rocket undergoing rapid unplanned disassembly shortly after launch at Cape Canaveral".
- stcredzero 14y agoYes, but the point is that the engine didn't explode. The fairing flew apart, not the engine. That's a big difference.
- InclinedPlane 14y agoThe headline has been changed though the URL is still the same (which is expected given the way most CMSes work).