6 ms·
"Critics point to research linking paraquat exposure to Parkinson’s, while the manufacturer pushes back, saying none of it is peer-reviewed." What lead it to b
by JumpCrisscross 11mo ago
"Critics point to research linking paraquat exposure to Parkinson’s, while the manufacturer pushes back, saying none of it is peer-reviewed."
What lead it to being "banned in dozens of countries all over the world, including the United Kingdom and China"?
- blibble 11mo agoin most civilised countries: chemicals added to food are banned until proven safe ... then you have the USA
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> chemicals added to food are banned until proven safe Is that the case here? Paraquat wasn’t banned for any reason, it just hasn’t been approved yet? That doesn’t comport with how the word “banned” is usually used.
- blibble 11mo agoyes, the companies producing it tried getting it approved, and it was for a bit and then the approval was overturned as the evidence was crap so, back to the original state: banned until proven safe
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> then the approval was overturned as the evidence was crap Source? I’m curious for this context.
- cess11 11mo agoI think they might refer to the EU approving of paraquat, which was appealed by Sweden and other countries and it was a legal process churning on until 2007 when the presumed link with Parkinson's and other factors led to the decision to ban it.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> when the presumed link with Parkinson's and other factors led to the decision to ban it Do you have a link to this decision? I'm having trouble finding it on my own.
- cess11 11mo agoFirst instance: https://curia.europa.eu/en/actu/communiques/cp07/aff/cp070045en.pdf https://curia.europa.eu/en/actu/communiques/cp07/aff/cp07004... ECJ: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX:62004TJ0229_SUM https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELE...
- finghin 11mo agothat means it could not be sold as fertiliser since that term is presumably regulated.
- Aloisius 11mo agoWhat civilized countries are we talking about? Because paraquat was approved for use over much of the world at one point, including countries people claim require substances be "proven safe."
- witte 11mo agoChevron clasically has ignored health and safety requirements to the point where there was once the “Chevron Doctrine” which deferred legal interpretations to specialized regulatory agencies which established clearer guidance against murky legislative directives. The Doctrine was recently overturned by the ostensibly rogue SCOTUS as highlighted by the harvard business review: https://hbr.org/2024/09/the-end-of-the-chevron-doctrine-is-bad-for-business https://hbr.org/2024/09/the-end-of-the-chevron-doctrine-is-b...
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- mistrial9 11mo ago"Under Chevron, if a judge found that the agency had made a reasonable interpretation of an ambiguous congressional directive, they were obliged to defer to the agency’s interpretation of the law, effectively ending any substantive review of a challenged rule. The repeal of Chevron is a huge blow to regulators, evidenced by the fact that the decision had been cited more than 18,000 times over 40 years." the Chevron Doctrine is new to me; it appears that the parent comment was not answering "why was it banned internationally" but rather emphasizing weakness in US procedures
- JumpCrisscross 11mo agoDid we have a regulation banning paraquat that was overturned when Chevron was overturned? If not, it’s irrelevant.
- stuffn 11mo agoChevron didn’t establish clearer guidelines. It was weaponized by both parties to create defacto laws without proper legal procedure. It should’ve been unconstitutional from the beginning as only Congress can make laws. Regulatory agencies are far easier to control, generally contain administration-friendly plants, and are not expected to provide any justification for their decisions. The result is laws that change as the wind blows, confusions, and rights restrictions done by people who should have no business doing so. The “reasonable interpretation” rule allowed Congress to completely defer to them and force citizens to spend tremendous capital getting a case to the Supreme Court. Chevron’s overturn was objectively a huge win and hardly a “rogue” decision. That editorialization is not a fair representation of the problems it has caused when regulatory agencies begin attempting to regulate constitutional rights. It was overly vague and gave far too much power to people who cannot be trusted with it. We shouldn’t need Chevron Deference to make laws that protect people from harm done by corporations. Period. If we do, it’s a failure of Congress to do their jobs and a mechanism should be in place to have a “reset button” (like many other countries when they form a government).
- tastyfreeze 11mo ago[Edit] The below comment is inaccurate. The pesticide sprayed for gypsy moths was DDT. I am leaving this comment because it should be known that this was a thing even though it is now off topic. P̵a̵r̵a̵q̵u̵a̵t̵ DDT is also linked to the polio pandemic. It was sprayed everywhere gypsy moths were found. Great success at killing moths. Also weakened human children to to where a common disease could get into spines and cause paralysis. Researching this kind of stuff is not for the faint of heart. Its horrible all the way down. Not recommended for the faint of heart.
- kens 11mo agoParaquat is a herbicide, not an insecticide, so why would it be sprayed for moths? I searched for information linking moths, paraquat, and polio, but couldn't find any. Is this claim a hallucination?
- nospice 11mo agoIt is. The polio link was suggested for DDT, which was a controversial insecticide. But it was probably bunk, as were most other concerns about DDT: https://apnews.com/article/fact-check-polio-vaccine-ddt-pesticide-480376540979 https://apnews.com/article/fact-check-polio-vaccine-ddt-pest...
- deleted 11mo ago[deleted]
- tastyfreeze 11mo agoWell damn... my bad. Comment before coffee. It was DDT. "Moth and the Iron Lung" by Forrest Maready Forrest was interviewed by Bret Weinstein if you are interested (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L7wYUnQUESU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L7wYUnQUESU)
- paddleon 11mo agoum. My uncle died of polio, and I was a medical researcher (phd) for a while. Polio can cause paralysis just fine on its own, it doesn't need DDT or paraquat to help it. And you are also right that widespread spraying of DDT lead to all kind of problems (killed all the birds, for one, leading to "Silent Spring"), which one reason it was banned. another reason is the mosquitos developed resistance.
- zug_zug 11mo agoSo assessments of safety of a chemical aren't hard science. They are statistical judgment calls (often based on things like giving a much, much higher dose to a rodent and looking for short-term effects). And the reason that is is because there's no affordable, moral way to give 100,000 farmers [nor consumers] a small dose of a product for 20 years before declaring it safe. So the system guesses, and it guesses wrong, often erring against the side of caution in the US (it's actually quite shocking how many pesticides later get revoked after approval). Europe takes a more "precautionary principle" approach. In those cases of ambiguity (which is most things approved and not), they err to the side of caution. Notice how this claim here is again shifting the burden to the victims (their research doesn't meet standard X, allegedly). Absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence.
- threethirtytwo 11mo agoThe US is very capitalist and consumer based. They error on the side of “does it make money?” Or “will I lose money?”
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> assessments of safety of a chemical aren't hard science These are still data. I'm curious for the contexts that lead other countries to actively ban the substance. If it simply hasn't been approved in other countries, one can't use that information to infer about its safety.
- zug_zug 11mo agoBecause of its high toxicity, the European Union withdrew paraquat from its market in July 2007 [1] So it's clearly poisonous to humans in high doses, I guess the argument is that perhaps the smaller doses exposed to farmers may not lead to sufficient ingestion to cause harm. The parkinsons seems like pretty clear evidence against that. > If it simply hasn't been approved in other countries, one can't use that information to infer about its safety. I don't know why you're trying to defend this with counterfactuals/hypotheticals instead of just googling. Feels like you're bending over backward here. [1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3657034/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3657034/
- jdasdf 11mo ago>What lead it to being "banned in dozens of countries all over the world, including the United Kingdom and China"? political pressure. Same reason lots of stuff is banned in the EU even when it's safer than other things that aren't banned.
- nosianu 11mo ago> political pressure. Same reason lots of stuff is banned in the EU even when it's safer than other things that aren't banned. You avoid the question instead of answering it (What caused that "political pressure"? Does such a thing just occur randomly in nature?), following it by an assertion that you don't bother to provide any evidence for.
- 3D30497420 11mo agoI believe the EU tends to follow a precautionary principle, namely a substance generally must be shown to be safe before it’s approved. In contrast, the US follows a risk-based approach where a substance can often be used unless it’s shown to be harmful. So it isn't really that many "safe" things in the EU are banned, rather they have not been approved. Pretty sure this is specific to food additives, though may apply to other areas.
- JumpCrisscross 11mo ago> believe the EU tends to follow a precautionary principle It does, but that isn't relevant here. There were poisoning cases in France that lead to the ban [1]. [1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3657034/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3657034/
- _zagj 11mo agoThere's a synthetic opioid called MPPP, which, if inappropriately synthesized (IIRC, using too much heat in one step), yields MPTP, which is non-toxic in and of itself, but has the ability to penetrate the blood-brain barrier, where it is then metabolized into MPP+, which is potently neurotoxic to the dopaminergic neurons of the Substantia Nigra, reliably producing a Parkinsonism in those exposed to it (from wikipedia): >The chloride salt of MPP+ found use in the 1970s as an herbicide under the common name cyperquat.[4][3] Though no longer in use as an herbicide, cyperquat's closely related structural analog paraquat still finds widespread usage, raising some safety concerns. EDIT: the neurotoxicity of MPTP was discovered after a number of heroin addicts developed a sudden, irreversible Parkinsonism after injecting bad batches: https://archive.org/details/TheCaseoftheFrozenAddict https://archive.org/details/TheCaseoftheFrozenAddict The doctor featured in that NOVA episdoe summarizes the history of MPTP and its relevance to Parkinson's research and epidemiology here: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5345642/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5345642/ > Over the last two centuries the pendulum of opinion has swung widely as to whether the cause of PD was due to genetics or environment causes [69]. While MPTP has not yet been found in the native environment, beginning in the 1980s the pendulum swung dramatically in the direction of the environmental hypothesis, spurred not only by the observation that a simple pyridine (MPTP) could induce so many of the features of PD, but also the striking similarity between its toxic metabolite, MPP+ and paraquat (differing only by one methyl group) [70], an herbicide that is used worldwide. Since that time, a large number of studies have shown pesticide exposure is a risk factor for PD [71]. Interesting, this risk is enhanced by the presence of certain genetic variants [72], consistent to the adage that “genetics load the gun, but environment pulls the trigger”.
- _zagj 11mo agoActually, surprisingly (or perhaps unsurprisingly, given the interesting history and a large chunk of HNers being functional drug addicts--albeit not necessarily of opioids), MPPP was discussed here just last year: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41053383 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41053383
- downrightmike 11mo agoThe other thing you should know is that they use it to help the plants grow, but they use larger amounts to kill the plants at the same time so they can uniformly harvest. So we eat more of this crap than you'd expect, because they are using it beyond expected ways
- Aloisius 11mo ago> What lead it to being "banned in dozens of countries all over the world, including the United Kingdom and China"? Almost everyone who banned it did so because of acute toxicity - it requires careful handling to use safely. Unfortunately, it was commonly used to commit suicide in many countries. In other countries, it was deaths from accidental ingestion, lung damage from unsafe handling, etc. I don't know of any country that banned it because of a purported link to Parkinson's.