6 ms·
Samsung might not have tried to copy the iPhone
- magoon 14y agoAlso submitted to evidence was an internal Samsung document which reviews Samsung's way vs Apple's way, and it made quite a compelling case that Samsung put forth significant effort in copying Apple's form and function. I'm sure much of the "evidence" can be debunked in such a way as this article has, but taken as a whole I think Apple's case was convincing. If you want to see other good examples of wholesale copying, go to a brick & mortar computer store (such as the new Microsoft Store) and view how all of the PC laptops have island key keyboards, aluminium or similar metal casings, cameras on top, drop hinges, and massive button-less touchpads.
- fieryscribe 14y agoDo you have a link to this internal document?
- magoon 14y agohttp://www.theverge.com/2012/8/8/3227284/samsungs-directions-for-improvement#3639115 http://www.theverge.com/2012/8/8/3227284/samsungs-directions... Particularly interesting is the last slide, #126, which includes in its Directions For Improvement "Remove a feeling that iPhone's menu icons are copied by differentiating design"
- fieryscribe 14y agoProof of copying is an instruction to differentiate the design so it doesn't seem like they're copying?
- lusr 14y agoI really don't understand criticism of the Samsung document, and I say this as somebody who currently owns an iPhone 4S - and my previous phone was an iPhone 3G. I also own a Samsung television and home theatre system, and plan on buying a Macbook Pro at the end of the year. I like to think I'm pretty unbiased in this matter as I've spent equal amounts of money on products from both companies, at the same time, and I'm happy with all my purchases. From my cursory review of the document, all I can see it doing is compare the user experience between the two products. To me it's the difference between a clean-room reverse engineering exercise to build a competing product (implement, compare, revise) vs. a cloning manual (nowhere in that document does it instruct Samsung hardware/software engineers to copy Apple's form and function, it simply highlights areas of improvement; there are areas where I'm sure they concluded Samsung's implementation was better but they didn't write "hey guys we're busy cloning here, stop innovating!"). Look at #114 for example, which describes how Apple's phone has an animation when deleting notes. They don't write "we need an animation when deleting notes" (which would be copying). They identify the purpose of the animation ("fun factor") and recommend introducing some kind of "fun factor" in their own product, and leave details to designers to independently arrive at. In fact, I recommend reading the very last paragraph in that document: "Remove a feeling that iPhone's menu icons are copied by differentiating design." This is no more sinister than making car wheels round. Now you could argue that Samsung was just very clever about the way they went and copied things, but there's no concrete evidence of this theory of intent that I've seen presented. As a matter of practicality, are you honestly telling me if you manufactured [cars, fridges, stoves, watches, laptops, televisions, software, ...] you wouldn't look at your competitor's [cars, fridges, ...] to make sure your design didn't miss anything obvious? After the first reviews of your new product come in criticizing basic design flaws and viewing it as a "step backwards from competitor A", are you seriously telling me you'd be totally happy to stand there in front of your shareholders and say "Well yeah we could have done some competitive research but that'd be really unfair to our competitors they're actually pretty nice people and we don't want them to be mad!"? Yes Apple probably spent a fair bit of money researching their UX and Samsung piggy-backed on their research. No more so than Apple piggy-backing on Xerox's work 30 years ago. And their payoff was they were first to market and have become the biggest company in US history. I'm struggling to see where the damage is, or the loss for consumers.
- wmeredith 14y agoI don't see how anyone can defend Samsung seriously. I'm sure there is minutiae in the case that could be disputed. However, in the light of evidence like the comparisons in this imgur album [http://imgur.com/a/by8Xq http://imgur.com/a/by8Xq], saying that Samsung didn't copy the iPhone as well as the rest of Apple's trade dress seems silly.
- untog 14y agoWell thank goodness that imgur albums can't be submitted as evidence in court. I'm curious about a number of those images- when did Samsung ever use the Apple dock connector (or something that looks like it) on their phones? When did they copy and paste an iOS screenshot onto their phone?
- magoon 14y agoThat's the Galaxy Tab 30-pin dock connector, and you can see it compared to Apple's in the third slide of this iFixit teardown: http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Samsung+Galaxy+Tab+Teardown/4103/1#s19248 http://www.ifixit.com/Teardown/Samsung+Galaxy+Tab+Teardown/4...
- untog 14y agoInteresting, thanks. This is why the imgur album really isn't very useful- there's no context/citations.
- rimantas 14y agoEnjoy: http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/galaxy-tab-accessories/ETA-P10JBEGSTA http://www.samsung.com/us/mobile/galaxy-tab-accessories/ETA-...
- BCM43 14y agoI'm getting a 404.
- BitMastro 14y ago
- praptak 14y ago"Groklaw suggests, rather shockingly, that Apple's lawyers might have been a little selective in how they presented some of this evidence to the court, by picking little parts of it that offered a different shade of nuance." Obviously it was their job to present the evidence in this way. Samsung's lawyers should have countered that with the full picture.
- demetris 14y agoI imagine the “rather shockingly” clause was a misplaced attempt at irony. I cannot think of any other reason the author would put that there.
- mratzloff 14y agoI don't see how intention matters in a patent dispute anyway.
- wklauss 14y agoThis is linkbaiting at its best. Groklaw is arguing that he cannot find the actual phrase that the media used over and over again in the documents but the jurors didn't decide on the case over that phrase (I'm not getting into the actual verdict or my personal opinion on it), nor they decided according to what the media said on those days. They did based on what Apple and Samsung attorneys argued on the trial, and they both presented a lot of evidence to make their own case. Whats more, even Groklaw admits "I didn't grab all the exhibits, simply because it got incredibly expensive. But I have almost all of them, certainly the ones that seemed most interesting". Id admire that he is willing to sit through the paperwork but this is beyond pointless. If something was said that was not on the evidence records and somehow misrepresent the situation I'd assume that Samsung lawyers would jump on it. Same for Apple. If Groklaw is making the case that the media did a poor job and started using and reusing a phrase that was not on the records, well, thats a problem for the media but not, as CNET suggests, a problem with the veredict itself.
- tatsuke95 14y ago>"They did based on what Apple and Samsung attorneys argued on the trial," Or did they based on what some over-bearing jury foreman argued, a man who wanted to prove a point with patents, and has a reasonable bias against Samsung? I think that's the point Groklaw are making. The more they dig in, the more it looks like this guy has and continues to have an agenda. That said, how did the Samsung attorneys not weed this guy out pre-trial? That was a huge blunder.
- thirdtruck 14y agoIt looks like he failed to provide relevant information during jury questioning. That, and the lawyers from both sides have only limited time to investigate all of the candidates. We can see clear bias now, after the fact. Samsung had to weed through a much larger haystack that featured much more obvious bias that they did catch.
- 37prime 14y agoCNET might not have tried hiring intelligent writers.
- RexRollman 14y agoI have no doubt that Samsung copied Apple, I just disagree with how the copying is being treated by the courts.