4 ms·
The writing quality and complexity of amateur content, even long-form is only around the level of a YA novel, truth be told alot of the stuff I was reading back
by corimaith 10mo ago
The writing quality and complexity of amateur content, even long-form is only around the level of a YA novel, truth be told alot of the stuff I was reading back in junior high in my school library had more depth than this.
It's good that you can get people reading, but reading the equivalent of pulp is very different from real novel that isn't so bounded by tropes or genre limits.
- Kim_Bruning 10mo ago90% of everything is crap. --Sturgeon's law. Maybe even 99+% these days, seeing how easy it is to publish your first finger-painting online. Doesn't mean there isn't any good stuff, or even a lot of good stuff. 1% of a lot is still a lot. (ps. and once you get people reading, they tend to keep doing it and develop taste over time. if it's even just a few who wouldn't have done it before. That's good, right?) (pps. For example: at 2M words, I think pirateaba might exceed the "first 1M words are practice" threshold)
- squigz 10mo agoWho cares? If people enjoy it, let them enjoy it. I've read a few YA novels as an adult that I enjoyed, even though I regularly read more complex stuff. Most people, for most of history, have only ever enjoyed what might be considered "low quality" entertainment - pulp fiction, shitty plays, etc. > real novel that isn't so bounded by tropes or genre limits. Interestingly, even discounting YA and other stuff like that, you are only describing a very small subset of novels.
- SubmarineClub 10mo ago>Who cares? I do? Why would I want my kids to be consuming crap when they could be engaging with great works and high art?
- pavel_lishin 10mo agoWhat if that's not the choice? What if the choice is "engage with art they enjoy and appreciate, or not at all"?
- Telaneo 10mo agoThey're great works to you, and a slog to them. They can read Minecraft strategy guides and Yahoo auction fan fics for all I care, since that's a lot better than nothing. I remember not wanting to read what school assigned me and how that killed my desire to read most fiction writing, and would prefer that not happen to more kids. Art is a matter of taste, and if you go counter to your audience's taste, don't be surprised if they disengage.
- squigz 10mo agoBecause what constitutes "crap" and "great works and high art" is highly subjective both to personal tastes and the culture of the time.
- Aerroon 10mo agoIf the works are so great then you've got nothing to worry about. Kids will read them on their own. Of course we both know that's not true, because the works are not that great.
- TitaRusell 10mo agoJane Austen was considered pulp. So was Charles Dickens. And Conan Doyle. Nobody considered those high literature back in the day!
- ThrowawayR2 10mo agoThat cherry picks the best of the best without comparing them with the other 99.9% of their contemporaries who were pulp authors. They and their literary output are forgotten for good reasons.
- squigz 10mo agoI don't think GP is cherrypicking anything; rather, illustrating how what is seen as slop one day may be seen as "great works" down the road.
- ThrowawayR2 10mo agoAre you suggesting Jane Austen, Charles Dickens, or Conan Doyle were considered slop during their own lifetimes? If not, my point stands.
- Kim_Bruning 10mo agoHow can I forget Harry Potter And The Methods Of Rationality [1]. HPMOR is written by Eliezer Yudkowsky to promote rationalist concepts, and is somewhat influential in startup and AI circles. Directly: Emmet Shear {co-founder of Twitch (YC S07)} is apparently superfan and gets a cameo. So for once I get to post something that's almost on-topic for yc. :-P [1] https://hpmor.com/ https://hpmor.com/ [2] https://techcrunch.com/2023/11/21/what-does-a-harry-potter-fanfic-have-to-do-with-openai/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/11/21/what-does-a-harry-potter-f...
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- beepbooptheory 10mo agoMaybe not the best thing for kids to be reading! https://www.thecut.com/article/milo-youngblut-max-snyder-zivians-cult-murders.html https://www.thecut.com/article/milo-youngblut-max-snyder-ziv... Even without the, you know, murder stuff, I think we can do better for kids than another generation of "rationalists", considering the track record here.
- onraglanroad 10mo ago> How can I forget Harry Potter And The Methods Of Rationality If you find out, let me know. I wish I could. I've never read such self absorbed drivel in my life. To be fair, I've not read any Ayn Rand, so I might be judging harshly.