22 ms·

I'm Peter Roberts, immigration attorney who does work for YC and startups. AMA

• sercand 10mo ago
  I have green card and last time I left is 2 years ago, How can I return back to the US?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    If you have been outside the U.S. for 2 years without having obtained a reentry permit, then you could be considered to have abandoned your green card. But all isn't necessarily lost. The ability to keep your green card will depend largely on the reason that you were outside the U.S. for 2 years and likely will require you to apply for a returning resident visa.
• constructive 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, thanks for doing the AMA! I have a Delaware registered LLC (10 years old), I managed to get even an EIN remotely. However, I can't open a bank account remotely and so I have just been paying the registered agent fees and Delaware gov taxes for the LLC all these years. I however, genuinely want to come to the states to open the bank account and actually expand my business into the US. The LLC hasn't really had any annual meetings/etc. but taxes are always paid on time. How do I use my LLC to apply for a B1/B2 to visit the US? OR should I just close it and try the normal route? Thanks in advance!
  • gsck 10mo ago
    My understanding of the B-1 visa is all you really need is a letter of employment. Might get tricky with you providing the letter of employment to yourself however.
  • dennis16384 10mo ago
    But you _can_ open a bank account remotely for a DE LLC. Both Wise and Mercury supported this for years.
    • constructive 10mo ago
      thanks!
  • proberts 10mo ago
    It's going to be difficult to answer this in this forum because really what you are asking is how can you get a B-1/B-2 visa because the existence of a non-operating LLC really has no bearing on that question.
• vecter 10mo ago
  Thanks for the AMA Peter! What impacts are you seeing as a result of the $100K H-1B fee which took effect on 9/21/25?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    In the end, it's largely put a stop to H-1B sponsorship of workers outside the U.S. That doesn't mean that all these workers can't get visas to work in the U.S. but other - tougher visas - have to be explored.
• devty 10mo ago
  Thanks for having another round? In your view, who are the winners and losers of the recent H1B changes? And any changes on your perspective for YC harboring international talent in SF Bay Area?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    In the end, the new requirements - really, just the $100K payment for now - are manageable/avoidable and absent this requirement, the rules and their application haven't really changed. The bigger change, which hasn't happened yet, is the across-the-board increase in prevailing wages. And this will have a profound effect on H-1B employment since the increases will be significant.
• gsck 10mo ago
  I have recently taken a job with an American based company and will need to complete a few weeks training in Miami. Based on the information they have given me I need a B1 visa and maybe an ESTA since I'm in the UK, and a C-1/D for moving through the US. However they keep flip flopping between me needing a B1 and me just using my ESTA for the training, and their communication hasn't been the most straight forward. Which visa do I need to get to enter the US for the training?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Whether you present a B-1 visa or ESTA for admission, you will be seeking admission as a business visitor. Under these circumstances, my advice is almost always not to risk a denial of a B-1 visa application (which happens all the time) and to travel on ESTA. The only relative downside is that ESTA limits admission to 90 days. But of course run this all by the company's immigration counsel.
  • throwaway219450 10mo ago
    Not a lawyer. The VWP (ESTA) for business specifically says: > attend short-term training (you may not be paid by any source in the United States with the exception of expenses incidental to your stay) "source in the US" might be problematic if you're paid by the US company directly and not a UK arm. You'd have to take those days as unpaid, except for a per diem? If you're paid in pounds by a UK source, ought to be fine. I would confidently say you do not need a C visa. That's for immediate transit (like you have to change airports or something, and you would use an ESTA anyway). A D visa is for people like airline crew who have to stay and have to work whilst there (like getting an aircraft ready for international departure from a US airport). If you needed that, your company ought to know.
• saradhi 10mo ago
  Could you please help with any insights about the social media vetting rules? This has been a blackbox to the visa applications - started with student visas, now being forced on work visas too from Dec 15th.
  • proberts 10mo ago
    That's right, both before US Consulates when applying for visas, before CBP when applying for admission, and before USCIS when applying for a benefit (H-1B, O-1, green card, etc.), social media is being reviewed, not across-the-board but more and more. And there's really no option to keep social media as private if asked to turn to public by a Consular Officer or CBP Officer. The review is broad and not limited to social media that is critical of US policy but extends to a review of an individual's entire background to make sure there were no violations of US immigration law, including unauthorized employment.
    • nisegami 10mo ago
      CBP actually made me give them my facebook password when entering on a J1 visa in 2017, so I'm surprised to hear so much talk about this. Is it more that the practice of checking social media is more widespread now?
      • barbazoo 10mo ago
        If one didn’t have an account with meta they just wouldn’t get the visa then or how does it work? Does the government have any direct link to meta re what accounts people actually have. I’m surprised people aren’t up in arms about this, I guess it affects mostly visitors and immigrants but the fact that the government needs to see your activity on a private company’s web app is wild to me.
        • monerozcash 10mo ago
          "I don't use social media" is probably a good answer, it just has to be true. If they ask you "well, do you use any social media?" You'd presumably have to answer with HN, which maybe doesn't sound all that great :)
• poki89 10mo ago
  My H-1B with my current employer expires on Jan 10, 2026 and can’t be extended because I don’t have an I-140. Another startup plans to file my O-1A at the end of December. Can I remain in the U.S. while the O-1A petition is pending?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    The regulations and long-standing USCIS policy and practice support remaining in valid status in the U.S. after January 10th as long as the O-1 petition is filed before January 10th. But we are hearing stories of USCIS starting to take a different view and treating someone in that situation as out of status even though the O-1 change of status petition is pending and was timely filed.
• miotintherain 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, thanks for the AMA! I work for an American company and I am based in Europe. I visit the US for work every now and then. I heard a lot of horror stories regarding border entries. If I am ever in a situation where the border police asks for access to my personal phone and pin code, what are my options? Can I refuse and what happens then?
  • stevenwoo 10mo ago
    Border Patrol can wait longer than you want to wait at the airport, you should not bring your personal phone if you don't want them going through all the contents, they can hold your device for an inconvenient amount of time if you are an American citizen. If you say no and are not an American citizen you can be denied entry at the airport and sent home.
    • cmrdporcupine 10mo ago
      Being quickly denied and sent home is the best possibility in that scenario. If you're on American soil they can just detain you. Or worse. If you ever want nightmares, read the story of Maher Arar.
    • fsckboy 10mo ago
      >you should not bring your personal phone if you don't want them going through all the contents isn't the right move here: wipe your phone, travel to destination, then restore from cloud backup? in the middle, you can let them inspect your wiped phone.
      • nerdsniper 10mo ago
        For non-citizens, there's not really any law against them installing malware on your phone which could persist through a factory reset. Though I've not heard of such malware for flagship phones.
        • lrvick 10mo ago
• sjtgraham 10mo ago
  How does the Supreme Court’s elimination of Chevron deference affect USCIS’s ability to narrowly interpret the EB-1A regulatory framework, particularly at Step 1 of the Kazarian analysis? I am specifically interested in two areas: (1) whether, under a strict textual reading of the judging the work of others criterion in 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3), participation in code review where the beneficiary evaluates and approves the technical work of others in the same field should qualify without USCIS applying extra regulatory limitations, and (2) whether USCIS can continue using its historically restrictive approach to comparable evidence under 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(4) now that courts are no longer required to defer to agency interpretations. I understand that even if these issues favor the petitioner at Step 1 they may not change the outcome of the final merits determination under Step 2, and I am trying to determine how a post Chevron, strictly textual approach might influence Step 1 outcomes for petitioners whose achievements do not align neatly with the ten listed criteria.
  • bubblethink 10mo ago
    What has Chevron got to do with EB-1A adjudication? The Kazarian step 1 step 2 stuff is hokey. It is ultimately a subjective evaluation that will remain under the executive.
    • skobes 10mo ago
      Wouldn't this fall under Auer deference (agency's interpretation of its own regulation)? There is some uncertainty about whether Auer deference survives after Loper Bright.
      • bubblethink 10mo ago
        But this isn't an ambiguous area of law. The statute is pretty clear in the text here - that the EB1-A criteria are necessary but not sufficient. That's what the step1 (necessary) and step2 (sufficient) boil down to. You can litigate on what qualifies as necessary if the agency is doing something weird, but ultimately it is a subjective evaluation. The court isn't going to adjudicate on the merits, USCIS is.
• kimyanna 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, have you been seeing either a slowdown or increased denial rates to N-400 applications (5 year rule)? Just curious if it's more or less business as usual or if there is any impact on N-400 applications (we've heard of the neighborhood checks etc.) Thank you!
  • proberts 10mo ago
    It's not business as usual anymore. Clients have shared that interviewing officers have shared that flexibility and leniency in adjudicating N-400 (and green card) applications is over. So officers are taking a much tougher stance on criminal records and extended absences from the US. That being said, applications without any issues are being approved although the approvals are taking longer.
• aliljet 10mo ago
  Is there clarity right now around foreign students attempting to obtain h1bs in the future?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Yes. F-1 students can get H-1B visas. The issue is the $100K payment which applies if the H-1B petition is filed not with a request to change status but with a request to notify a consulate. But if it's filed with and approved as a change of status, then a subsequent H-1B visa application will not trigger the $100K payment.
• subtlestorm 10mo ago
  How does Extra Ordinary O1 visa scam work ? I have seen Facebook ads from attorneys running ads for H1Bs to O1 touting 95% “success rate”
• jonpurdy 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, thanks as always. It seems that i-131 Reentry Permit processing times are greater than 12 months these days. If an i-131 is pending, would you advise that person to return briefly to USA before their 1 year date of exit (ensuring that they are never out of USA for greater than 1 year prior to approved i-131)? Or does a reentry permit allow them to remain out of country for longer than that even if pending (presuming it gets approved)?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    If the RP application ultimately gets approved, then it would "protect" that absence of one year that occurred before the issuance of the RP (although the RP validity period will start when it's approved not when it was filed). The reason to still reenter before you are outside for one year has to do with qualifying for naturalization rather than maintaining green card status.
• rathboma 10mo ago
  Thanks for answering questions! Do you think H1B visa holders looking to move to a Green Card (in coordination with their employer) should be concerned about rejected applications or other issues?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    There is no issue specific to those in H-1B status impacting the ability to get a green card but I would say that it's getting tougher to get green cards in general, particularly through the National Interest Waiver and Extraordinary Ability routes.
• jquery 10mo ago
  Should individuals on a green card be concerned about anything, such as criticizing this administration?
  • deleted 10mo ago
    [deleted]
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Definitely moreso than before but it's not so much about being concerned as being aware. For example, travel to certain countries could trigger aggressive/tough questioning on reentry and certain public comments about the government also could trigger aggressive/tough questioning.
• kappi 10mo ago
  [flagged]
  • Fraterkes 10mo ago
    I don't really get your point, there's high unemployment outside the US too in many places?
    • deleted 10mo ago
      [deleted]
    • RedRaven7 10mo ago
      [flagged]
      • Fraterkes 10mo ago
        Ah okay. I'm not american, but I do hope that the situation for you and other Americans improves soon.
      • fooker 10mo ago
        > Why is the US an open economic zone Do you know of the fable of a goose that laid a golden egg once a day? You are proposing to kill the goose to see if you can get multiple golden eggs at once. > country with an identity Like it or not, the identity is 'land of opportunities' and not 'land of anglo-saxons who emigrated before ~1850'
        • RedRaven7 10mo ago
          [flagged]
          • fooker 10mo ago
            > America put men on the moon without millions of foreign immigrants Did you drop out of middle school? America saw the highest rate of immigration in history between ~1910-1960. A majority of the scientists and engineers in the Apollo program were immigrants or children of immigrants. > Why is it only ever white nations that are expected to let everyone else in? They are not, have you considered moving to Russia?
• bravura 10mo ago
  I know this is a general question, but: Assuming a US startup is considering engineering hires outside the United States, how does one currently assess the likelihood of getting them a visa to work in the USA? And what timeline and cost would be involved?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Unfortunately, a case by case analysis would be required. However, if they are from a country with its own visa (that is, Australia, Canada, Chile, Mexico, and Chile), it's relatively easy to get engineers visas.
    • dnemmers 10mo ago
      Not sure you meant to, but you wrote Chile down twice in your list.
• clumsydude 10mo ago
  In October, the state department introduced a new policy: > Applicants for U.S. nonimmigrant visas (NIV) should schedule their visa interview appointments at the U.S. Embassy or Consulate in their country of nationality or residence > Applicants must be able to demonstrate residence in the country where they are applying, if the place of application is based on their residency. What sort of proof is required to demonstrate residence? What about cases where an applicant legally has residency in a particular country (e.g. PR card or work visa) but in practice lives in the US as an H-1B/TN/L-1/O-1/etc. worker or H-4/TD/L-2/O-3/etc. dependant? Especially for the dual intent visas?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    There's a lot of uncertainty here and the outcome will depend in part on the interpretation by the particular Consulate but my general understanding is that applying in a country where you hold permanent status but where you are not currently living would be risky.
• kethinov 10mo ago
  Suppose you could wave a magic wand and change US immigration law in any way you like. What changes would you make?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Good question. There's so much I would change. I'll give this some thought and respond later today.
    • fooker 10mo ago
      Looking forward to this answer! Many of the absurdities of the US immigration system exist for good reasons and it would be great to understand the nuances.
    • brendoelfrendo 10mo ago
      Thanks for offering to answer this question. Immigration law is so often an inflammatory topic, but I think your perspective as someone who has to work with the law, the US agencies that enforce it, and the people trying to navigate it could be really valuable.
  • USMCAThrowAway 10mo ago
    Not Peter but would like to spur discussion on positive changes that could be made. - Paper-free overhaul of the entire immigration system. - Green Card recapture [0]. - Country of Birth caps abolished for Green Cards. Impossible to justify this as it doesn't serve the intended purpose since AC21 was passed. - EAD/AP premium processing - so many livelihoods ruined and immigration journeys derailed because people can't get work authorization or cannot travel. - TD holders granted working rights incident of status same as L2S. Now for the not-so-popular suggestions... - Diversity Lottery - there's bipartisan support to cancel the program and it's really hard to justify bringing almost 55k with a min of high school education into the country. - Removal of F2B, F3, F4 family based categories to move inline with other developed nations immigration systems such as Canada [1]. [0] - https://www.fwd.us/news/green-card-recapture https://www.fwd.us/news/green-card-recapture [1] - https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/services/immigrate-canada/family-sponsorship/spouse-partner-children/who-you-can-sponsor.html https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/se...
• zamalek 10mo ago
  Thanks for the AMA Peter! Do you think there are risks involved with leaving (and hence returning to) the country on a Green Card?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    I don't but a quick discussion with an immigration attorney to make sure that there are no hidden issues probably isn't a bad idea.
    • zamalek 10mo ago
      Thanks for the response, greatly appreciated!
• garbawarb 10mo ago
  A question about TN status for a Canadian living in the US. There are some income-generating things I'd like to do outside of my work visa (play a music gig, upload music to Spotify, act in a movie). My understanding is that I can't do these things in the US. Am I able to do these things if I do them outside of the country, or is there any way to make them work? For example, if I went to Canada, recorded an album, uploaded it, then came back to the US.
  • barbazoo 10mo ago
    I got no answer but it sounds really fun what you’re planning to do :)
    • garbawarb 10mo ago
      It's no fun if you legally can't do it...
      • fencepost 10mo ago
        Just remember, if you want to put your content on youtube be sure you're demonetized by cursing up a storm. (not real advice. I think.)
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Yes, if the activity occurs while you are outside U.S., then you can get paid for it without having to have U.S. work authorization to do it. So, yes, recording an album while outside is fine but it becomes a little more complicated if you are now getting paid for downloads while you are in the U.S.
    • garbawarb 10mo ago
      While I'm inside the US, can I perform work for non-US entities? For example, remotely teaching a music lesson do someone in a different country or writing a book and publishing it abroad but not in the US.
• BergAndCo 10mo ago
  [flagged]
• figmert 10mo ago
  How serious is/was this whole $100k for H1-B applications? How has this impacted the hiring process?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    The subsequent clarifications has significantly lessened the impact since it only applies to those who are the beneficiary of H-1B petitions filed with a request for consular notification rather than with a request to change or extend status. So it has impacted the ability to get H-1Bs for those outside the U.S. but that was always a small number.
• garbawarb 10mo ago
  I'm living in the US on TN status and I'm interested in starting a startup, a subscription-based mobile app. But I have a pending PERM application and leaving my company would mean abandoning the whole thing, which I'm not eager to do. Is there any legal way I could start a startup without having to do that?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Concurrent employment is an option, meaning you could keep your primary full-time TN while getting a concurrent part-time TN. The problem is more that self-employment isn't allowed on the TN.
• ninjaquiv 10mo ago
  [dead]
• sombragris 10mo ago
  Someone studied in the US under a F1 visa and a scholarship. No other substantial income other than that. This person while in the U.S. had to file tax forms, although there was no tax to be paid because this person had no income outside the scholarships. The student finished the studies in, say, October last year and then left the country for his home country. The student graduated and does not intend to return to the U.S. The educational institution sent the student's home address some tax form that he had to file by April 15, but the former student forgot to do that. The question is: would the student have problems getting a U.S. visa as a tourist and entering the U.S. several years after that? If yes, how could that be fixed? Thanks in advance.
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Yes, unresolved tax issues can cause U.S. immigration problems.
  • fencepost 10mo ago
    Pretty sure the best time to file tax-related stuff is before it's due and the second-best time is immediately after you become aware of it. Filing late is almost guaranteed to be better than not filing at all, and if there was no tax due then I suspect there also won't be late filing penalties.
• hobs 10mo ago
  What's the best way for a lawyer more familiar with other parts of the law to break into immigration?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Join AILA, attend AILA local chapter meetings, and attend the annual AILA conference. And get a mentor if possible.
• swatson741 10mo ago
  How has AI impacted your profession?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    In a limited way. Where it has impacted our clients is it has made it much easier for them to get reference letters when reference letters are required. But our basic every day work is largely unaffected by AI. So far.
• OsrsNeedsf2P 10mo ago
  Is it normal for incubators to ask founding engineers to come over on tourist visas?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    I'm not sure about that being a requirement but participation in an accelerator/incubator while in the U.S. as a business visitor is fine and common.
• jml78 10mo ago
  Just a high level question. My youngest son was adopted. He isn't white. He is naturalized. Should we go ahead and renew his passport so he can carry around a passport card at this point(we never got one in the past because they seemed like a waste). It seems crazy but with people being grabbed off the street for being brown, it seems prudent have a quick way to prove citizenship.
  • proberts 10mo ago
    It's awful to have to consider these things. But since you ask, he also could carry his naturalization certificate. The other option is to get a Certificate of Naturalization but that's akin to getting a passport.
  • rayiner 10mo ago
    [flagged]
    • tdeck 10mo ago
      I've never been murdered either. Good to know that doesn't happen at all.
    • deleted 10mo ago
      [deleted]
    • jacquesm 10mo ago
      I don't think they were addressing you.
      • rayiner 10mo ago
        They said “people [are] being grabbed off the street for being brown”—if that were true, I feel like I would have noticed.
        • jacquesm 10mo ago
          It is true. There are 100's (probably 1000's) of confirmed news stories by now. Just like people get into car accidents is real, even if you personally haven't been in a car accident yet. And people dying is real, even if you are still alive. You are a sample of '1' and you don't get to invalidate other people's experiences based on your own. The only reason you do not notice, given that it is true is because you would either rather have it not be true or because you are actively working not to notice.
• hiprob 10mo ago
  Anything notable about Ukrainians? Especially since Trump's inauguration?
• nicechianti 10mo ago
  [dead]
• RedRaven7 10mo ago
  [flagged]
  • baxtr 10mo ago
    That’s a very valid question. However, I’m not sure why an immigration attorney would be able to answer it.
    • RedRaven7 10mo ago
      [flagged]
  • ponector 10mo ago
    At $22/h you are actually competing with offshore workers in remote low COL locations. How would you justify it's you should get the work/money, not imigrant worker? The fact your parents immigrated earlier than they should justify it in your opinion?
    • RedRaven7 10mo ago
      22/hr for offshore work? Where, India? The fact that I'm American justifies it. If Americans flooded into say, Somalia, bought up all the houses, took up all the jobs etc, you'd be horrifically offended. Americans have no where else to go. This is my home and I will not abandon it. You can't just drop 50 million extra workers into a country and expect people to just take it.
      • ponector 10mo ago
        You say people born in other countries do not deserve american pay in America? It's like saying you are white male and it justifies higher salary. Also if you struggle to compete with immigrants who usually have no network, English is not their native language, have many other disadvantages - you are doing something wrong or are not competitive in the first place. The fact is you should not fight against imigration, you should fight for decent payment for it and same rights
• dcreater 10mo ago
  Have you handled cases/seen outcomes of self employed founders' H1B applications under the new rule?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Yes. The forms only require disclosure of ownership if it is above 50% so this has made it much easier for international founders (with cofounders) to obtain H-1B status. The challenge comes when ownership exceeds 50%.
    • dcreater 10mo ago
      Yes im referring to cases when the founder has >50% or in fact 100%. Curious how the statistics/success rates are looking?
    • garbawarb 10mo ago
      What about exactly 50%?
    • shrubble 10mo ago
      If the company has 3 founders with equal ownership, it would not have to be disclosed? Is there a requirement that one founder be in the USA and be either a citizen or green card holder?
• jbellis 10mo ago
  Has the current administration made it harder to qualify for an o1 visa?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    A bit but not significantly so.
• pain_perdu 10mo ago
  I moved to the USA in 2016 thanks to Peters help and every successful interaction I have had with USCIS since then has been because of his sage advice. You will not find a more knowledgeable or kind adviser than Peter.
  • proberts 10mo ago
    That's good to hear. Thanks!
• js4ever 10mo ago
  Are you noticing any contraction (or increase) of immigration?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Early on in this administration, yes, but now, it seems as busy as ever although this latest suspension of immigration processes for those from 19 countries has definitely sent a chill.
    • Izikiel43 10mo ago
      Were those 19 countries a significant source of work in the system?
• deleted 10mo ago
  [deleted]
• pm90 10mo ago
  hey peter, Im on an h1b visa (year 10, have approved i140 and pending gc application). Ive never done an h1b stamping as I was paranoid about being denied. Will doing the stamping now trigger the 100k h1b fee?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    No since the underlying H-1B petition was filed and approved before this $100K payment provision went into effect.
    • pm90 10mo ago
      thank you!
• zerkten 10mo ago
  What if you have deleted social media accounts? It's possible to state that you had them with whatever identifiers, but do you have to prove their existence in some way so they can check an archive (assuming it was Twitter)?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    If I understand you correctly, there's no obligation to maintain access to deleted social media accounts or to archive them.
  • LightBug1 10mo ago
    Are those "Donald Trump is a rancid, orange Turnip" posts coming back to haunt you? Me too. I'd brave it out and stick to your guns. After all, facts are facts.
• jonathanstrange 10mo ago
  What do you consider the probability that there will ever be free elections in the US again? Please answer with a value between 0 and 1.
  • proberts 10mo ago
    I'll get back to you after the midterms.
• gernigg 10mo ago
  [flagged]
• lafalce 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, thanks for your time :) I am planning to move to San Francisco to join the startup ecosystem. Regarding the H-1B visa, what does the current process and timeline look like for a new applicant? Given the lottery constraints, are there specific 'red flags' or common mistakes I should avoid when looking for a sponsor?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    The issue right now is that if you are sponsored for an H-1B while outside the U.S., the sponsoring employer will be subject to the additional $100K payment and this of course will dissuade most potential employers.
• canucktrash669 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, let's play hypotheticals. USMCA (CUSMA) is dead, Trump actually acted on his threat and the US left the treaty. I assume it means TN visas are dead in six months if the written notice clause is respected. Is the zombie CUSFTA now out of dormancy? Can we now use the TC visa? If CUSFTA dies as well, what are the other options and how long does it take to process?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    I don't CUSFTA would immediately go into effect again. I believe Congress and the President would need to act to revive it.
  • garbawarb 10mo ago
    If this happened would existing TNs still be valid till their end date?
    • proberts 10mo ago
      Typically, a benefit once granted (unless improperly granted) can't be taken away.
  • roncesvalles 10mo ago
    Just my opinion, but I think USMCA dying is massively unlikely. Already there is some resentment in the Republican base for souring ties with Canada (e.g. bourbon producers, tourism) and I do see Canada-US ties moving in an upward trajectory in the recent months. The USMCA is also used by US citizens to work in Canada. And considering how watered down the H1B changes have been, I don’t think this administration has an appetite for materially pissing off coastal hi-tech. At most we’ll see tightened category adjudications.
• kingstoned 10mo ago
  How easily can one get E1 treaty trader visa and what volume and quantity of trade are recommended? If I have a company registered in my home country (eligible country) and have payouts from a US provider like an advertising network, affiliate provider or some marketplace etc. and my clients are all US companies, can I apply for that visa? Would a low six figure yearly revenue with monthly payout be sufficient for that?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    There's no minimum amount of trade specified in the regulations and the answer depends in part on other factors (such as how active the foreign and U.S. companies are and whether they employees and funding) but the minimum annual trade is generally understood to be at least $100K/$150K.
    • kingstoned 10mo ago
      Can you have just one US client like a marketplace or network that gives you monthly payouts totalling $150k a year? The client is a famous US based company.
• aryanchaurasia 10mo ago
  What if I am selected in YC but i don't have us visa?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    That's a question for YC because if I understand you correctly, you are asking if you can participate in YC without being in the U.S.
• proberts 10mo ago
  Thank you for all your questions and comments. I'll be taking take a short break.
  • ninjaquiv 10mo ago
    [dead]
  • bloodyhand 10mo ago
    [flagged]
• lackstein 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, thanks for the AMA! I'm currently living in the US on TN status and am married to an American. Have you heard of anyone on TN status having difficulty applying for a green card? And do you have any sense of what the wait times currently are, particularly how long until you can get a travel authorization?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    We've obtained lots of marriage-based green cards for those in TN status. The issue is intent at the time of the most recent entry prior to filing a green card application since the intent at that time cannot be to apply for a green card. Generally speaking, if there's a gap of at least 90 days between entry and filing, USCIS's concern about intent goes away or is at least greatly lessened.
  • kdazzle 10mo ago
    There was just an article in the NYT where ICE is arresting people at the end of their green card interviews for essentially no reason. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/26/us/trump-green-card-interview-arrests.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/26/us/trump-green-card-inter...
    • USMCAThrowAway 10mo ago
      Those targeted in this article are spouses of US citizens that had entered the US on ESTA and allowed that status to lapse whilst awaiting their AOS. That was tolerated previously. It does appear that these arrests have stopped since the NYT article was written.
    • rayiner 10mo ago
      That’s misinformation. They’re being arrested because they were in the country illegally, usually overstaying a visa: https://www.newsnationnow.com/us-news/immigration/green-card-interview-spouses-detained https://www.newsnationnow.com/us-news/immigration/green-card... They have a green card interview because they married an American. But you can’t get an adjustment of status if you are in violation of your current visa terms.
• loxodrome 10mo ago
  Can a US citizen with a foreign spouse bring the spouse to the US on a tourist VISA and adjust status? What if they already filed the i-130 with consular processing?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    That could be viewed as fraud at the time of entry under both scenarios. I recommend that you speak with an immigration to come up with a workable plan. Note that if your spouse applies for his or her green card visa (known as an immigrant visa) at a U.S. Consulate, he or she can visit you on a tourist visa for extended periods of time while waiting for the interview at the U.S. Consulate.
    • loxodrome 10mo ago
      Thanks for the info. Tricky situation because we have a kid who has dual citizenship, and we are not in the US, but want to move back.
      • refurb 10mo ago
        Your best bet is to plan a year or so ahead and get sponsorship in the queue so the spouse can enter with a green card. Timelines are about 8-14 months. But as PRoberts said, a non-citizen spouse can't enter on a tourist visa with the intention to change status. A spouse can visit, but then change their mind while in the US. But CBP is well aware of people trying to shortcut the process this way, so it can be very challenging convincing CBP your non-citizen spouse intends to leave. But it can be done showing a job, property or other elements that would require someone to go back.
• jjmarr 10mo ago
  How has the Section 174 elimination of 5-year amortization for domestic SWE salaries impacted decisionmaking on whether to hire overseas? Since overseas workers are still subject to 15-year amortizations I'm wondering if people are getting pulled in from Canada.
  • proberts 10mo ago
    Those are excellent questions but really more directed to those hiring at tech companies. From my limited perspective, I haven't an impact on hiring.
• USMCAThrowAway 10mo ago
  I've asked this question in a few places but never gotten an answer. A TN visa/status holder that applies for a EB Green Card by filing form I-485 is considered to have shown immigrant intent and will no longer be granted TN status in the future. Is this bar permanent or would an applicant who failed to obtain a Green Card or surrendered it in the future be able to seek TN visa/status provided they could prove strong links to Mexico/Canada?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    There's no permanent bar but the standard would be high to show with a subsequent TN application that the applicant possessed good faith intent to return to Canada/Mexico. We've argued that successfully.
    • USMCAThrowAway 10mo ago
      Thank you.
• rao-v 10mo ago
  I've got friends who tell me they'd never consider applying for YC because they are on a classic H1B with a tech company. What typically happens with folks on a H1B who make it into YC?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    That's hard to respond to other than to say that there are multiple visas that allow participation in accelerators and training programs.
    • rao-v 10mo ago
      That makes sense ... is there a typical path? Basically - are they right in thinking it's a high risk thing for them or should I encourage them to take a shot? My understanding is that their time spent on the company before YC accepts them is the biggest risk factor?
      • garbawarb 10mo ago
        As a non-lawyer, it seems that you'd have to leave your company to join YC, meaning you'd forfeit your H1B visa.
      • proberts 10mo ago
        No I don't think it's high risk at all because even if the path were something other than H-1B, they always could go back to H-1B.
• EarthAmbassador 10mo ago
  This question arises from the current regime's efforts to reverse naturalization. For anyone who has one US citizen parent and one non-citizen parent, where the citizen parent has passed before the child applicant for naturalization reaches 18 years of age, resulting in the applicant applying for and receiving naturalization as an adult, can that same currently naturalized citizen also obtain natural born citizenship status through the deceased citizen parent and would it be advisable?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    If I understand you correctly, you are asking whether the naturalized citizen was a citizen at birth based on his or her father's citizenship. To answer that question, we would need to know when the naturalized citizen was born and the countries where the naturalized citizen's U.S. citizen parent lived from birth until the birth of the naturalized citizen.
    • EarthAmbassador 10mo ago
      Thanks, you got it right. 1970 is the birth year and father lived in the United States for decades prior but had a child while out of the country, the naturalized citizen. The question is really about whether natural born citizenship is available to children of an American citizen when the child is born abroad, but the parent was deceased before majority age. Naturalization would probably be sufficient, but given that even naturalization is theoretically at risk, maybe obtaining outright natural born status is better insurance. There is an N-form for this sort of thing.
  • deleted 10mo ago
    [deleted]
• unixhero 10mo ago
  We are in the Nordics. Do we stand a chance at PR or citizenship in the US?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    I'm not sure I understand what you are asking.
    • macinjosh 10mo ago
      [flagged]
      • filleduchaos 10mo ago
        I would expect someone who apparently feels so strongly about this to be able to do the bare minimum of looking up the publicly available statistics (https://ohss.dhs.gov/topics/immigration/yearbook https://ohss.dhs.gov/topics/immigration/yearbook) on visa and green card allocations. I do understand that performative victimhood is much easier as it does not require much intellectual honesty.
• deleted 10mo ago
  [deleted]
• anonimmigrant1 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, I have a valid h1b visa stamp till 2027 but when my new employer filed for my H1B from outside the US I got an RFE for the 100k. The company lawyers are arguing against fee payment since I has a valid H1B visa stamp. What are my chances of denial?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    The subsequent guidance on this question was in conflict and unclear. On the one hand, the guidance indicated that if the beneficiary had a valid visa stamp, then the petitioner wouldn't be subject to the payment but on the other hand, it indicated that if the petitioner selected consular notification, then the petitioner would be subject to the payment. So I think it could go either way.
• jacobmartinez3d 10mo ago
  I am a native citizen currently watching my first child grow up without me while my wife waits in line for her nearly 2-year-long immigration process. Every attempt to expedite her processing has been denied, even during Typhoons where she loses power and access to hospitals. I feel forgotten, and cast aside by the system - like my family situation is inconsequential and undeserving. Is there really nothing native citizens like me can do to get our family here outside waiting in a generic line with everyone else in the world?
  • proberts 10mo ago
    That doesn't make any sense. I'd need to know all the facts to advise. Please send me an email to schedule a call (proberts@robertsimmigration.com). Which Consulate is she applying through?
    • fantod 10mo ago
      Isn't 1-2 year wait time standard for spousal immigration?
      • nasaeclipse 10mo ago
        No. My spouse and I came here together and we applied for her green card in Japan. It took about 2 months.
      • justinram11 10mo ago
        This was around 2020-2022 during COVID, but the whole process from start to finish from Taiwan took a little over two years for us (we had issues with the financial supporting documents that took 3 months round trip twice to get resolved -- so potentially would have been closer to 18 months had we done everything correctly). Extremely frustrating process to say the least (my Taiwan resident card was sorted in less than a month).
  • zingar 10mo ago
    Shocked and curious to know why anyone would downvote a story like this.
• onetimeusename 10mo ago
  Is there a way for someone on h1B to start a company in a roundabout way by doing something like placing company shares into a trust and having a unpaid board seat? Is that pushing luck? Not for me but a friend who I had plans to go into business with but we're facing a chicken or egg problem until she gets a green card or changes her visa status.
  • proberts 10mo ago
    There are ways for someone in H-1B status to start a company and not in a roundabout way. The approach will depend in part on whether she will leave her current employer and get an H-1B through her startup, stay with her current employment and get a concurrent part-time H-1B through her startup, or just stay with her current employer and somehow work on her startup.
    • malandrew 10mo ago
      > or just stay with her current employer and somehow work on her startup. The first two options make sense but this latter option sounds like a risk. As I understand it, she can't earn any active income from this startup unless see has an I-129 for it. A share grant counts as income. I mean, yeah you can work on a side project in your spare time that could become a business, but the moment employment and active income enters the picture that becomes something else.
    • mizzao 10mo ago
      If she is issued equity (reverse vesting restricted stock) and not paid a salary, does she still need work authorization for the startup?
  • malandrew 10mo ago
    Why don't they just start a company in the country where they are from or why don't you start a company with someone who is a citizen or has a green card? The entire premise of your question is misaligned with the intention of the H1-B visa. Yes, everyone abuses its intent, but that isn't justification for more people to find more ways to abuse it. The abuse of that visa (and other visas) is why folks just want it abolished outright. I guess the purpose of a system is what it does, but it was sold to the American electorate as a way for companies to get access to talent that they simply cannot find domestically. Trying to use the H1-B to hire a very specific person instead of any person with the skillset needed for the role would be in contradiction with the labor market test (LMT) needed for PERM status. An H1-B can only work for the employer on the I-129 petition. There are some forms of passive income allowed but to placing shares in a trust and having an unpaid board seat just seems like an attempt to cheat the process because ultimately the goal is for her to work for this startup. Doing what your proposing puts a target on her head where anyone that is anti-H-1B can report her to USCIS and get her deported. Moving home, working remotely and then applying for an L-1 seems like the correct approach here for what you're trying to do.
• proberts 10mo ago
  Thank you again for all the interesting questions and comments. I will be logging off now but checking in again tomorrow for any unanswered questions. Have a great weekend.
• rhosseinzadeh 10mo ago
  Hi and thanks for doing this. I went through CBP twice in the span of 20 hours. I was granted entry once and denied the second time. The second time, I had to sign some electronic pad and later a form (I-275) was given to me. Did I have the option not to sign? And is this contradictory decision in span of 20 hours legally OK? Below are some more details: At Toronto Pearson (Terminal 3) on December 1-2, 2025, I went through CBP twice and the first time I was granted entry and second time denied. I am a dual Canadian-Iranian citizen. On day one I was given a detailed biographical form, questioned repeatedly about my purpose of travel (Conference), employment, etc and especially about any Iranian military service. I provided old passports and a university transcript showing that I have not been in Iran since 2019 and prior to that I was studying in the university. They also explicitly questioned me about a prior incident in which Canadian police claimed an explosive trace ("Tetryl") on me, which I disputed as an error. CBP took my belongings (backpack, watch, wallet, phone), conducted a body inspection in another room (through search, hands inside my pants followed by groin search) took my fingerprints multiple times and took my phone after requiring the pass code and it was out of my possession for about an hour. After several hours they told me I was "negative" but by then my flight had departed. I was given only a piece of paper with CBP stamp. Since there was no flight for my airline for the rest of the day, I was brought back to the Canadian side. The day after, I went through CBP again and when I showed them their paper with stamp I was told "we are not going to take your word for it" and the full process happened again (although no body check or phone check this time). A different officer then stated that my documents were not sufficient to prove I had not done military service in Iran and that I now needed an official exemption letter or something similar from Iranian authorities. He added that I should have been "advised differently" the night before. Finally, my picture was taken and I was asked to sign on a pad twice. Only afterward did they print and hand me a form (I-275) showing a withdrawal of my application. I was escorted back to the Canadian side. Did I have the option not to sign? If in future I decide to visit US is this going to be held against me? I can provide more details or the form if necessary.
  • difiidi 10mo ago
    [dead]
• mariopt 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, thank you for doing this AMA. How can an European Senior SWE land a job, let’s say, SF and have some kind of guarantee regarding the visa before flying into the US. The 100K cost for the H-1B is so absurd that it crushes any hope of me ever participating in Silicon Valley or any other tech hub in the US. Is the tech alive or are companies just relocating to EU/others?
• hoerzu 10mo ago
  dear Peter Roberts, your responses have been super helpful. I'm a unlucky position of losing esta for smoking weed once in New York. looking into waiver of inadmissible as you recommended should I get I writing from a therapist before or after o1 application? should it be d3 or i601?
• deleted 10mo ago
  [deleted]
• askPeter 10mo ago
  Can a person on a nonimmigrant visa file for patent unrelated to the employer?
• joshdavham 10mo ago
  You've stated in a previous comment that non-US citizens can be denied entry to the United States if border officers request access to your phone and you decline to do so. ... but what about when non-US citizens leave the US? For example, as a Canadian, if I'm down in the US and, on my way back up to Canada, a US border officer requests access to my phone and I decline... what happens then?
• conqrr 10mo ago
  Can I get an H1b for just 10hr/week like a part time job and be valid status in the US?
• germandiago 10mo ago
  Hello Mr. Peter, A few I registered a company in Delaware as a foreign company for SaaS business. I have been unable to complete an organization certificate for my website. Unfortunately I could not get one since my legal phone is not the way to reach me and they tell me that they cannot change that phone to reach me according to my legal representatives in Delaware. I need some kind of certificate of good standing or being able to have a verifiable phone and/or email to reach me in a "reliable" way from a third party source. How could I proceed for this, since I am not knowledgeable of the law in Delaware. Probably I need an attorney and I would be happy if I can be recommended one that could emit such verification.
• final_aeon 10mo ago
  Hello sir, my question is: What do you think of the trump admin?
• sharl07 10mo ago
  [dead]
• heltale 10mo ago
  Hey Peter, I’m an F1 visa student and I’m trying to found a company with two Americans while being an Indian citizen. I plan on taking significant equity and will be part of the cofounders. Are there any significant hurdles that I should be on the lookout for here? I’d like to sign the founders agreement and found the company while I’m still pursuing my education but I’m not sure whether my visa status would throw any wrenches here.
  • fleroviumna 10mo ago
    [dead]
• deleted 10mo ago
  [deleted]
• h99 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, founder of a YC startup here. My startup got acquired and I now have a new O1 visa but in my indian passport I still have the old O1 visa stamped. I’ve now traveled internationally. Can I enter the US with my old visa? Asking because the waiting times to get the new visa stamped are ridiculously long. Thank you for your time!
• dhruv3006 10mo ago
  What should i keep in mind if i move to sf from India?
• cromka 10mo ago
  I have worked in the US on an L1B converted to H1B visa for about 5 years, left for Europe in 2021. Including the time I was absent from US soil while employed on an H1B and the time I had remaining on it before I left, I would be able to recapture about 18 months for an extension. Can I now return to work for a US company again if they hired me and would they be subjected to the $100k fee?
• nwhnwh 10mo ago
  How do you feel about the world?
• mertleee 10mo ago
  [dead]
• RecursionSucks 10mo ago
  Is it still a good idea to apply for global entry while on H1B? Are there any repercussions if a global entry application is denied for whatever reason?
• benzesandbetter 10mo ago
  Hi Peter, thanks for doing this AMA! I'm a US citizen and my girlfriend is Iranian. She's been in the states for 7 years, first on a student visa then applied for her green card 1.5 yrs ago on NIW, currently "pending status change". She's a jeweler and metal artist and owns a jewelry brand in the US. Never had any legal problems in the US, and nothing in her background of social media that would be a detriment to her review process. Curious about your thoughts on the outlook for green card processing for Iranian citizens in general, given the administration's recent movements. In her specific situation, would marriage provide a more robust chance of having her GC application approved? Is it even possible to re-apply for the GC while she's in the current "pending status change" state?
• HexSentinel 10mo ago
  [flagged]
• anataylorcouger 10mo ago
  [dead]
• sueraccount 10mo ago
  that's useful
• fantasista74 10mo ago
  Hi Peter! I am Russian and changed my status from B2 to O1 in 2021. In 2023, I traveled outside the USA. Following the interview at the U.S. Embassy, my O1 visa application was placed under 221(g) administrative processing for almost two years, until the approved petition expired. In 2025, my new O1 petition was approved by USCIS. I again had a visa interview at the U.S. Embassy, and my O1 visa application was placed again under administrative processing. After 3 months, I received an email from the U.S. Embassy informing me that I had been found ineligible for a visa under 214(b). Do you know what are the best solutions in this situation? I do not know the reasons for the denial, as during both interviews the consular officers asked only general questions, such as what I do (sports management), what kind of sports I work in, etc.