4 ms·
Games Preservation Is Hard and Sometimes Involves Private Detectives
- egypturnash 1y ago> “We are talking about more subtle things,” Paczynski explains, “like the game not supporting modern controllers, the game not supporting ultra-wide screens or modern resolutions, or even a simple thing like being able to minimize the game.” I dunno if it's really preservation when you have to completely rework the game to work on a screen three times wider and 4x denser than anything that existed when the game was designed, and hack in a completely new way of talking to the controllers. Just package up the whole thing in an emulator and call it a day. Even if they're still both running versions of Windows, a 2025 computer and a 1997 computer are completely alien systems that have about as much to do with each other as a 2025 computer and a Nintendo 64.
- PaulHoule 1y agoNot the GoG way. I remember working at a library field where there was a tremendous amount of concern that digital assets like floppy disks and files would become 'unplayable' over time. You might not be able to pay people to do it but the video game emulation community shows that it can be done as a labor of love.
- cindyllm 1y ago[dead]
- Firehawke 1y agoGoG is packaging a large chunk of their library in an emulator already. DOSBox is what got them started, in fact.
- sumtechguy 1y agoProjects like eXoDOS and DOSBox (and its derivatives) have basically allowed most of DOS and win31 games to be in a very playable state. GoG is doing the detective work of finding out who owns it and trying to monetize parts of it as well as fixing some of their own stuff. When it comes to many of the late 90s win9x/winxp games those are in the territory of 'maybe runs'. Due to the way windows is subtly changing the API and what a standard windows install comes with. Also APIs that now return even more stuff than what they tested with. Such as a video caps function may now return 500 items when it was tested to run with 60 and the input buffer maxes at 256. Never mind many of them act totally bugged out if you hand it a 4k screen and you have scaling turned on. Had one game from a few weeks ago that I could not get to run. Turns out it was an intel video driver bug. Really old intel driver worked. One from 2 years ago didnt. One from a few weeks ago did. Old nvidia worked, newer ones broken. One windows box worked the other didnt. Shims like dgVoodoo2 and dxwrapper help to a point But still have lots of issues. Then on top of that if there is a online component the game will at best hang/timeout at worse crash out. Have one game if I open the leaderboard on it will crash the game. The board was apparently turned off 15 years ago.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- xandrius 1y agoYep, it's like one day we expect an old game to work in VR++ and my 950pi smellovision implant. If it runs on a runnable emulator of the target platform then we're good.
- entropicdrifter 1y agoBut we do want that, right? We want people in the future with their unknowable future digital-experience-providing devices to be able to experience the video games of the past/today, right? So in the interest of making older games future compatible we (those interested in preservation) do need to pursue those things. How else can we guarantee they'll run on future devices? Emulators are one good way to make things run on newer devices, but emulators will in turn need the features to be able to run on 4K/8K screens, XR devices, etc.
- hamdingers 1y agoIt's probably closer to conservation and restoration. One day there won't be any more working 1997 computers, so getting the game to work on a 2025 computer extends the lifespan of the media by at least 28 years. It's not unlike digitizing VHS tapes. > Just package up the whole thing in an emulator and call it a day. This is indeed one of the ways GoG ships games, but it doesn't work in all cases.
- 1313ed01 1y agoQEMU does a pretty good job at pretending to be a 1997 computer, or a 2025 computer, and it seems to work well to run QEMU inside of QEMU already, so should be somewhat likely that old virtual machines can be kept alive by running inside of increasingly deep levels of virtual machines running inside of newer virtual machines. Legal, non-free, operating systems to install in those virtual machines is trickier. No old freeware version of Windows (yet?). Installing a minimal Linux distribution with WINE, for games that can be made to run in WINE in QEMU, might be the most stable way to preserve a 1997-era game. Except for 1997 DOS games (there were surprisingly many still being published in 1997!) that run so well in DOSBox(-X).
- EvanAnderson 1y agoI wonder how many games are impossible to preserve because of the copyright system and apathy on the part of rights-holders. As an example: I look forward to the day when the license to the "No One Lives Forever"[0] franchise gets sorted out. Through acquisitions and divestitures the ownership to the rights for the game and its sequel have been "lost". I suppose eventually it'll fall into the public domain, society will collapse, or the heat death of the universe will occur. At least one of those is an eventuality, I think. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Operative:_No_One_Lives_Forever https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Operative:_No_One_Lives_Fo...
- ndiddy 1y agoJapan has a scheme for orphaned games where if you can prove you did due diligence in searching for a rightsholder and couldn't find one, you can go ahead with rereleasing the game and the royalty payments get held in escrow by the government in case the rightsholder comes forward. I wish the US had something similar for cases like these.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 1y agoIn meatspace you can take ownership of abandoned land if you maintain it for a time. It's called adverse possession. Where is the SW equivalent? We should be able to gain ownership of abandoned software.
- Fwirt 1y agoThis is often misunderstood and varies by jurisdiction. Often called "squatter's rights", it is often thought to mean "if I use this land for a long time without anybody noticing it becomes mine", but e.g. in my jurisdiction, you also have to have prove that you didn't know it wasn't yours. For example, if your backyard fence has been 5 feet over the property line for 10 years and nobody noticed, but then suddenly your next door neighbor has the property surveyed and tells you to move your back fence, you can take them to court and potentially claim that extra 5 feet as your own. But you can't just scoot your back fence over a couple inches every year and then eventually lay claim to your neighbor's backyard because they didn't notice it was shrinking, nor can you "find" "abandoned" land, build a house on it, and then claim it as your own. I believe there are a few jurisdictions where this actually is the case, but it's fewer than many people believe. And then of course you have the reality of squatters invading people's homes while they are on vacation for a week and the police being completely unwilling to get involved, which I understand was a big problem in France for a while. IANAL
- pathartl 1y agoThe reality is Valve often does a better job at preservation than GoG. They know that a game released on Steam in 2009 that hasn't received any updates will never be updated to support things like modern controllers, which is why they wrote Steam Input. Even then, there's so many other things that can go wrong with games. With DOS-era titles, DOSBox does a pretty fantastic job, as long as you use a fork with useful features like DOSBox-X. With Windows titles the possibilities to preserve games is almost endless thanks to hooking. I've spent the past few years compiling a personal archive of games to get them in a playable state. For me, this often involves support for modern controllers and _at least_ natively rendering at a higher resolution. Compatibility shims like dgVoodoo make it easy to bump up the rendering resolution of a game, while preserving aspect ratio for games that may only support 4:3. Graphics are basically solved with projects like dgVoodoo, and there's numerous dinput -> xinput solutions out there, but that's rarely the whole picture. WinSock could really benefit from a wrapper that tunnels traffic over the internet (VPNs are really like using a steam roller to drive a nail). Registry API calls really could be redirected to read from config files instead of relying on the weird bastardization of WOW64 and the VirtualStore. Hell, even file access could be redirected so we can contain all of a game's files. I'm actually working towards implementing the latter two as a way to preserve the functionality of installers and allow their reimplementation through something like PowerShell.
- b_e_n_t_o_n 1y agoNot just Steam Input, they maintain SDL and strongly encourage everyone to dynamically link it in order to keep older games going.
- benoau 1y ago> The reality is Valve often does a better job at preservation than GoG. They're solving very different problems: executing old games well that they still have the right to distribute vs reinstating access to games that have left circulation entirely (except perhaps abandonware sites). Neither of these is better or worse than the other.
- pathartl 1y ago
- vivzkestrel 1y agoWe need someone to help us restore servers for Ghost Recon Future Soldier https://github.com/koteykaby/raven https://github.com/koteykaby/raven we have already built a backend on quazal protocol https://github.com/Phoenix-Network-Ltd/Ghost-Recon-Future-Soldier-Research https://github.com/Phoenix-Network-Ltd/Ghost-Recon-Future-So...
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoRelated: Reviving Classic Unix Games: A 20-Year Journey Through Software Archaeology https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45865159 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45865159
- pessimizer 1y agoThis has also been true for board games. https://web.archive.org/web/20150927182132/http://www.thegamesjournal.com/articles/AcquiringGameRights.shtml https://web.archive.org/web/20150927182132/http://www.thegam... edit: when people tell you the old internet still exists, they're lying. This is yet another site with hundreds of historically valuable articles that I didn't know had disappeared.
- oskarkk 1y agoPrevious discussion on this a month ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45620394 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45620394 And the longer text from the original source: https://www.thegamebusiness.com/p/when-we-launched-resident-evil-on https://www.thegamebusiness.com/p/when-we-launched-resident-...
- dbg31415 1y agoOnline games are nearly impossible to preserve. Most games are online games now. Multi-player games depend on servers, economies, and communities that exist only as long as someone's logging in and paying the bills. When those servers go dark, the logic, data, and social fabric disappear with them. Owning the client isn't owning the game. The real thing was the networked experience -- like trying to preserve a concert by saving the recording but not the crowd. Legal and technical barriers seal the deal. Server code is proprietary and rarely released. Reverse-engineering it breaks copyright law in most countries, so preservation sits in a gray zone. Even when fans rebuild servers, the result is closer to a reenactment than a recovery. And they seldom scale to the heights of the actual game. Future historians will have YouTube clips and half-working emulators -- fragments of worlds that were never meant to last.