7 ms·
How Airbus took off
- dandersch 1y agoThere was also residual suspicion of European industry among US airliners. [...] Against this backdrop, Airbus did everything it could to deemphasize its European heritage as it toured the US. The European tech industry on the other hand managed to curb that suspicion by becoming a complete non-threat.
- ma2rten 1y agoEurope is quite conservative, in the sense that they would not invest billions into an unproven venture. It makes sense that it would excel at an industry that requires putting safety above everything.
- nrhrjrjrjtntbt 1y agoThe article says they did a lot of customer research and even lobbying, leading to fuel efficiency focus and reduced size, and sticking the finger up to various offended European countries (not taking delegates to US, eschewing RR engines). This seems like savvy being sustained over decades. It must be cultural.
- eastbound 1y ago> and reduced size After launching, then dropping, the A380. Perhaps they didn’t do enough customer interviews there.
- vanviegen 1y agoEven if you ask every person to walk the earth what they want, that won't allow you to know future demand. The market shifted largely from hub-and-spoke to point-to-point during development. Without the benefit of hindsight, it must have looked like a solid bet.
- p_l 1y agoWhen A380 started, and even when it was delivered first, the answers to "what will be the preferred form of airline transport network organisation, in detail" was not yet fully answered. And A380 simultaneously served as base (in many critical areas) for the quite quickly made A350 et al
- adrian_b 1y agoThis is explained in TFA. A380 was also the result of "customer interviews", but after all the years needed to complete the project the customers have changed their mind, preferring direct flights over hub-and-spoke flights.
- fleroviumna 1y ago[dead]
- rsynnott 1y ago> Europe is quite conservative, in the sense that they would not invest billions into an unproven venture. I mean, in this particular space: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concorde https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Concorde
- pqtyw 1y agoIMHO Europe changed massively since the 80s and 90s in that regard, though. Arianespace was pretty much SpaceX of the 80s and there were quite a few tech companies back then. Due to various reasons stagnation entirely took over Europe after the start of this millennium. Hard to say why. Certainly not putting all the blame on them (since Britain isn't doing that great either) but I don't think especially the Euro and the EU becoming much stronger helped.
- ggm 1y agoThe chart of Airbus vs Boeing hull sales would have benefited from a center line Airbus above boeing below style. Stacked charts for two families work better that way than stack from baseline.
- quacked 1y ago> Airbus prevailed because it was the least European version of a European industrial strategy project ever. It put its customer first, was uninterested in being seen as European, had leadership willing to risk political blowback in the pursuit of a good product, and operated in a unique industry This really buries the lede, given that over the past 40 years Boeing sawed off both its own feet and drank cyanide. Total cultural change at the executive level that prioritized returns over good engineering.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- eastbound 1y agoI’m a staunch capitalist but Boeing vs Airbus is a demonstration of a big failure mode of capitalism (However, both have huge state intervention - Boeing’s factories are placed to give jobs to populations, it’s electoral choices, and that caused the airframe scandal).
- nocoiner 1y agoWhat are you talking about? Which airframe scandal?
- mdorazio 1y ago737 MAX. That whole saga was because of Boeing trying really hard to not certify a new airframe so that they could quickly push out a competitor to A320 Neo. The result was hundreds of deaths.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago737 Max was a compendium of failures. Airframe wasn’t one of them. If anything, the 737 series’ airframes are perfected to a fault.
- 1y ago
- locallost 1y agoMy overall feeling is "did they take off, or did Boeing stumble?", but looking at that chart of deliveries it seems Airbus started taking off almost 25 years ago. So the recent struggles of Boeing would really be just the straw that broke the camel's back. My guess is Airbus will dominate for the next few decades.
- nocoiner 1y agoI think this is about right. About a quarter-century ago, airbus finally became a manufacturer that could go head to head with the 737 and win more often than not. Since then they’ve generally gone from strength to strength while Boeing has been primarily concerned with financial engineering.
- NewLogic 1y agoIt is quite simple, they had the more recent cleansheet single aisle airframe design with enough ground clearance for modern high bypass engine designs. This has baked in a lot of inherent efficiencies including manufacturability meanwhile Boeing leadership refused to invest in a 737 replacement needed in the 2000s.
- kotaKat 1y agoDon't forget the greatest stumble with the Bombardier CSeries. I feel like if Boeing shut their mouth and bit their tongue at a little casual dumping they wouldn't have ended up with Airbus taking over the CS100 and adding yet another directly competitive aircraft into an "all Airbus" lineup that Boeing didn't have.
- fleroviumna 1y ago[dead]
- thesumofall 1y agoI worked for Airbus a long time ago, and obviously I have some rose-tinted glasses, but what stands out in my memories: - While the French and Germans love to hate each other, they culturally complement each other very well. I don’t think Airbus could have happened as a purely French or German project (and yes, the UK and Spain are also part of Airbus but are much less visible) - Despite being a highly political entity, you wouldn’t feel any of that day to day. Even up to the highest management levels, it felt like an engineering company focused on incredibly hard engineering challenges. Every once in a while, there was fighting over which country would get which work share for a new project, but it felt more like internal teams pushing their pet peeves rather than external political influence - It was a truly international company. My first team had eight colleagues based in four countries. To make it all work, they had some very early video conferencing systems where the equipment would take up entire side rooms.
- rkomorn 1y agoYour note on politics is interesting because my anecdotal experience was quite different. I worked at an Airbus offshoot in Silicon Valley and my visit to Toulouse for a bunch of meetings with the teams working on new tech and AI things were somewhat shocking. The amount of sniping in meetings, and the amount of post-meeting behind the back sniping was somewhat shocking. This was somewhat mirrored to a lesser extent even in our videoconf meetings and other collaborations. It left me wondering how a group of people who seem to think so poorly of each other and work so dysfunctionally could actually come together to build some of the most amazing machines on earth (because modern airliners truly are such things). The best take I could come up with was "Maybe all the adversity and mistrust means the end up building things that survive intense scrutiny."
- donkeybeer 1y agoWas that country political politics or office politics politics?
- rkomorn 1y agoOffice politics, I guess, though it was kind of tinged since the offices were in different countries, but it still was Airbus-level, not nation-level, I guess.
- Animats 1y agoIt's going to be interesting to watch COMAC really get going. They've been struggling for 17 years now to get the C919 into service. It's still using a US engine (currently embargoed by Trump, but that may change). The Aero Engine Corporation of China has built an engine which is supposed to be flight tested "soon".
- pyrale 1y agoThis article is pushing its narrative so hard that it feels like the author's selection process was "I want to say something about Europe, which company would support my claims". It's quite hard to understand whether the author wants to focus on Airbus (in which case, the article spends way too much time comparing EU/US and talking about Boeing), Europe (in which case it's missing plenty of other companies/sectors) or industrial policy (why speak about Europe at all? Chinese companies are a much more recent example of succesful industrial policies).
- overfeed 1y agoI would love to read an indepth article comparing how the US is whiffing EVs compared to China. Manufacturer attitudes, protectionism, government policies on vehicles and the background on renewable energy.
- stefaniedaene 1y ago[dead]
- Jyaif 1y ago> They also mastered the world of DC lobbying, successfully outmaneuvering Boeing and Lockheed’s attempts to use anti-trust regulations to shut the European entrant out of the US market. No amount of engineering can compete with good old bribes.
- littlestymaar 1y agoThis is tangential to the main point of the article, but this concluding sentence annoyed me greatly: > Governments are generally better at supporting companies in established markets where innovation takes place slowly and incrementally. This is likely why state-backed efforts have found it easier to be competitive against aerospace companies than Silicon Valley giants working at breakneck pace I always finds it fascinating that companies like Facebook, Google, Amazon or Microsoft (granted the later isn't a “silicon valley giant” proper) managed to build a narrative portraying themselves as “innovative companies” when they are the opposite of that: they are, and have been for almost two decades now or even more for Microsoft, very close to the complacent and short-term-profit-maximizer Boeing portrayed in this article. They just happen to benefit from a much stronger network effect than Boeing, and work in a business where economies of scale are insane.
- Ekaros 1y agoWhen you really think of those companies they mostly seem stagnant. They buy other companies, but for innovative company with essentially unlimited amounts of resources. Wouldn't you expect a big innovation at least say every other year?
- Peteragain 1y agoThere is also the idea that innovation is hard in established organisations. William Langewiesche's book "fly by wire" highlights some of the improvements that Boeing no dought knew about, but hadn't got round to. They were busy playing catch-up.
- jen729w 1y ago> Europe is a graveyard of failed national champions … Airbus is the rare success story. Oh, come now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_companies_in_Europe_by_revenue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_largest_companies_in_E...
- jemmyw 1y agoThey mentioned Concorde in that list of failures. But while it was a financial failure in of itself, it was probably the precursor to Airbus - a strong collaboration between the UK and France to save their failing airliner businesses. I doubt it was an overall failure.
- rvnx 1y agoIt is like saying that the tunnel that links the France and Great Britain was a failure
- FabHK 1y agoAnd just some context on the technological side: 20 Concordes were built, 1 lost, for a 5% hull loss rate. 386 DC-10 were built, 32 hull losses, for an 8.3% hull loss rate. 561 A300 were built, 25 hull losses, for a 4.4% hull loss rate. 1574 B747 were built, 65 hull losses, for a 4.1% hull loss rate. Now, that's not normalised by "years active", and some hull losses are not attributable to the aircraft at all (e.g. terrorist attacks), but basically the Concorde safety record was on par to jets from that generation (introduced around 1970).
- rbanffy 1y agoThe Concorde numbers are so low the confidence interval is much larger than the others. It could be a freak accident there was only one catastrophic failure. And, mind you, that catastrophic failure was a pretty freakish accident itself.
- FabHK 1y agoIndeed, before that freak accident the Concorde had 0 hull losses. But even with it, it was not out of the ordinary, that's my point.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- 4ndrewl 1y agoThis seems a little disingenuous - the US taxpayer will always keep Boeing solvent, even if they were down to selling one 737 per year.
- InTheArena 1y agoWhich is why Airbus is around today. The amount of launch aide (including Marshall plan dollars!) that the European governments flushed into Airbus to keep them afloat for years is why they are still around.\
- anovikov 1y agoIt's simply a company that operates in a rare industry where safety and reliability is more important than time to market or cost. Which makes risk-averse, hyper-conservative and consensus-seeking European culture at a relative advantage vs American "fake it till you make it" one.
- numpad0 1y agoIsn't Airbus also just succeedingcompany to Sud Aviation and Aerospatiale? They've done Caravel jetliner, Exocet missile, Puma helicopter, early Ariane rockets, etc etc, by the time they started working on A300... Having such experiences would certainly help designing and delivering great airliners.
- prasadjoglekar 1y agoThere's a very nice video from Mustard about the Airbus story. https://youtu.be/ln-ffJM9sJc https://youtu.be/ln-ffJM9sJc
- lorenzohess 1y agoIt started its engines and left the ground
- TheMagicHorsey 1y agoI wouldn't say so confidently that Airbus is better than Boeing. Its just better than Boeing at THIS moment. They've been trading places over the decades. A company selling commercial airliners is really only as good as the order book for its latest aircraft. And a single stumble in developing a model can sink your orderbook for an entire decade or more. Ultimately both Boeing and Airbus are moribund bureaucracies that survive only with the dual intravenous injections of state subsidies and duopoly. Making commercial aircraft is a capital intensive process, but its ripe for disruption. With China on the rise we may get a third competitor on the scene with completely different cost structure. There's also disruption coming from down below. New tools (including AI and more sophisticated manufacturing automation) are making it possible to enter the market with shorter timelines. If regulators can get off their asses, we might actually see the duopoly disrupted by new national and subnational champions. More will be better than two.
- trollbridge 1y agoIt may be painful to admit, but the Airbus model simply works better than the Boeing model. Whatever advantages America has, they don't apply to commercial/passenger aerospace anymore.
- neuroelectron 1y agoTldr: turbine engines
- JCM9 1y agoBoeing had a tough patch, but anyone that follows aviation knows Airbus has had its fair share of massive screw-ups over the years too.
- InTheArena 1y agoA quick control-F didn't find the name John Leahy. Without that part of the story, I think you really miss what took Airbus from an also-run European institution to a global force. Some of his story there is really something.
- scrubs 1y agoI think more truth would be shown by critiquing Boeing's organizational culture that allowed this decline. In particular does it have the chops to get over its lethargy? No doubt boeing has earned a negative assessment. Now what? My recollection was Airbus had boeing at a competitive disadvantage and a number of factors combined to optimize for short-term benefit not medium to long with severe consequences. So what about that boeing?
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoBribes. Europe has (or had in the past) very different rules about bribery, especially overseas. I know the American company I worked for lost bids we had won when we refused the kickback schemes the government that granted the bids expected us to include. Some American companies package/tie deals to other deals with other foreign entities so that the kickbacks happen on the side, but it's nothing like the bribery the Europeans did that we had to compete with.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]