4 ms·
> Mamdani's and by extension, his voters', ignorance about the effects of price controls Mamdani isn’t pitching widespread price controls, but rent control ove
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> Mamdani's and by extension, his voters', ignorance about the effects of price controls
Mamdani isn’t pitching widespread price controls, but rent control over a small section of New York housing twinned with abundance-style new development.
“In a 2022 paper, the political scientists Anselm Hager, Hanno Hilbig, and Robert Vief used the introduction of a 2019 rent-control law in Berlin to study how access to rent-controlled apartments influenced local attitudes toward housing development. The fact that the new law included an arbitrary cutoff date (it applied only to buildings constructed before January 1, 2014) allowed the authors to create a natural experiment, comparing otherwise-similar tenants in otherwise-similar buildings.
Heading into the experiment, the authors hypothesized that having access to a rent-controlled apartment would keep tenants in their existing units longer and therefore make them more resistant to neighborhood change. Instead, they found the opposite: Residents who lived in rent-controlled apartments were 37 percent more likely to support new local-housing construction than those living in noncontrolled units” [1].
[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/economy/archive/2025/11/mamdani-housing-rent-control/684790/ https://www.theatlantic.com/economy/archive/2025/11/mamdani-...
- testfoobar 1y agoMy understanding is that he is proposing a 4 year freeze on about 1 million units. https://www.curbed.com/article/zohran-mamdani-housing-rent-freeze-mayoral-election-win.html https://www.curbed.com/article/zohran-mamdani-housing-rent-f... archive: https://archive.ph/hnK4Q https://archive.ph/hnK4Q "The 34-year-old democratic socialist’s pledge for a four-year pause on any increases on the city’s 1 million or so stabilized units, effectively giving a reprieve to about 2 million stabilized tenants, was at the center of his campaign" I'm not directly familiar with Berlin. But this story about shortages is the expected outcome: https://www.reuters.com/markets/europe/germany-must-build-320000-apartments-yearly-meet-housing-demand-study-shows-2025-03-20/ https://www.reuters.com/markets/europe/germany-must-build-32... BERLIN, March 20 (Reuters) - Germany, lagging in its building goals to alleviate a housing shortage, needs to construct 320,000 new apartments each year by 2030, a study on Thursday showed.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> 34-year-old democratic socialist’s pledge for a four-year pause on any increases on the city’s 1 million or so stabilized units Out of 3.7mm [1]. > not directly familiar with Berlin Not comparable. Berlin froze rents “on more than 1.5 million” apartments in 2020 [2] out of about 2mm. 25% versus 75%. Also, Berlin’s politicians didn’t propose a construction agenda. Mamdani has. (“New York City voters on Tuesday delivered a strong message in support of building more housing, passing three proposals that pitted City Hall against the City Council in an effort to rewrite decades-old development rules” [4].) [1] https://www.nyc.gov/content/tenantprotection/pages/fast-facts-about-housing-in-nyc https://www.nyc.gov/content/tenantprotection/pages/fast-fact... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/31/world/europe/berlin-gentrification-rent.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/31/world/europe/berlin-gentr... [3] https://www.berlin.de/en/news/8283996-5559700-housing-stock-berlin-growing-slowly.en.html https://www.berlin.de/en/news/8283996-5559700-housing-stock-... [4] https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/04/nyregion/nyc-ballot-measures-housing.html https://www.nytimes.com/2025/11/04/nyregion/nyc-ballot-measu...
- testfoobar 1y agoIncreasing supply brings down prices. But a builder will not build at a loss or an imminent threat to their rental income from expansion of rent freezes. A city with an expanding rent-freeze is not inviting new supply.
- ThrowMeAway1618 1y ago[flagged]
- testfoobar 1y agoFirst - a rent freeze directly transfers inflation costs to the property owners. It is a tax by another name. Second - there is no similar freeze on property taxes - or the expected inflation in maintenance costs, insurance, and so on. Again - a tax on property owners by another name. Third - starting with a rent freeze is an indicator of a property owner unfriendly administration. Any builder would have to calculate this into their expected returns on capital investment.
- Workaccount2 1y agoMamdani will learn that you need to be friends with the people your voters hate to get things done. Developers are the single most important players in lowering housing costs, but they are part of the "landlord" contingent in voters minds. If he doesn't learn that, the city is going to be in bad shape. Impossible to get an apartment unless you want to get an illegal sublet at regular old $4500/mo prices.
- hakfoo 1y agoThe market isn't going to function ideally in a place like New York. In other cities, a significant market-based response to high rents and housing demand is to increase supply with another ring of suburbs. Is there anywhere within reasonable commute radius left to develop around NYC at scale? Uncapping rents might trigger some refurbishment of idle or marginal space by dangling enough money in front of landlords, but you're not going to pull another 500,000 units out of your rear that way. We can acknowledge that NYC housing is a finite and desirable resource, but we can also say that we don't want to turn it completely into an auction for the highest bidder. Rent control helps encourage diverse and vibrant communities, part of what makes the city compelling in the first place.
- Workaccount2 1y agoYou build up. Which is expensive, so developers will want assurances and no "20% affordable units" bs. There also is always going to be pain. NYC has incredible global draw, so demand runs deep. It might be that you can never build your way under $2k/mo apartments there.
- gedy 1y ago> Is there anywhere within reasonable commute radius left to develop around NYC at scale? I get the challenge of existing property/buildings other states, etc - but it always seems weird to me that you can have single story buildings less than one mile from Manhattan in Hoboken, etc. (as the crow flies, I get transit, etc). Feels like the big problem is we can't change anything easily anymore.
- arijun 1y agoThat article says the main benefit of rent control (besides popularity) is an increase in YIMBY sentiment, but it seems it still has the downsides detractors dislike about it. It doesn't do much to convince me it isn't a populist campaign promise.
- nobody9999 1y ago>Mamdani isn’t pitching widespread price controls, but rent control over a small section of New York housing twinned with abundance-style new development He's not actually pitching any new price controls. He's proposing a temporary rent freeze on rent stabilized (rent control is tiny in comparison and unaffected by this) apartments that are already subject to limits on rent increases. How do I know this? I live in a a rent stabilized apartment. The rent for which, even though increases are "limited" (usually somewhere around 3-5%) has more than doubled since I moved in. So no. Mamdani isn't suggesting making any changes to the law as it has existed for at least 50 years, rather he's suggesting stopping rent increases while fast-tracking new housing, which would likely stabilize the housing market. As an aside, which most folks don't understand, is that the vacancy rate in NYC is ~1.5%. Healthy housing markets have vacancy rates of 4-6%. Like many places in the US (and elsewhere), NYC has a housing shortage. But in NYC, that shortage is much more severe than almost anywhere else in the US.
- misiti3780 1y agohow many decades have you been in your stabilized apartment ?
- nobody9999 1y ago>how many decades have you been in your stabilized apartment ? Ask your wife. She spends a lot of time here. By the way, When did you stop beating her?