4 ms·
Get the Fainting Chair
- adambratt 14y agoI feel like I'm one of the few people that really likes the new mapping in iOS6. Granted I don't live on a college campus nor do I travel to rural areas often. The 9 or 10 times I've used the navigation so far it's been flawless. I used to have a Droid Incredible and the navigation in iOS6 is far better in my opinion. The GPS seems to be a bit more accurate and the map UI just seems cleaner as well.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoHave you tried a recent version of Google Maps on Android? It has improved a lot over the last couple of years.
- adambratt 14y agoI last used it about a year ago. However, I think that was on Android 2.3 still.
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoThe internet at large seems to have picked up the "Android doesn't get updates meme" and so remains unaware of that fact that even crappy low-end Android's running 2.3 (and before) get the latest updates to Google Maps and have been streets ahead of iOS Maps for a very long time.
- shawnc 14y agoAs will Apple Maps in a few years. Good to have some decent alternatives out there. I know, people will argue with me that Apple is the evil one here...
- Karunamon 14y agoHmm, mature, tested, and working platform now, or broken and weak platform which may be better "in a few years". Difficult decision.
- erichocean 14y agoI see you're talking about Android circa 2009. We're talking about Apple's new Maps app.
- Karunamon 14y agoVery funny. Unfortunately I was talking about the Maps application, of which Android's offer is currently better in every conceivable way.
- arrrg 14y agoIt's not better in every conceivable way. Traffic info in Germany kind of sucks from Google, it's the best you can get (TomTom's traffic info) in Apple's app. Extremely detailed, extremely current.
- Karunamon 14y agoWhat use is the traffic data if the underlying map/POI data can't plot a decent route to overlay traffic info on?
- arrrg 14y agoFunny you should say that. Turn-by-turn (and especially the walking directions) kind of suck on Google Maps in Germany. It sends you on very weird routes. Turn-by-turn in Apple's maps app is kinda great. No weird routes and such. TomTom is pretty great in Germany. I can't speak for any other countries. The POIs do suck and some labels are seriously out of place. Also, search sometimes tends to send you to weird places. Those are serious inexcusable issues, but the whole turn-by-turn part is pretty great and the actual maps are pretty comprehensive (at least in Germany).
- arrrg 14y agoTurn-by-turn is not so great in Germany. Traffic info sucks. Both of those are much better in Apple's new maps (especially the traffic info, extremely current and detailed). Sure, that's limited, but it isn't all bad.
- pohl 14y agoYou're not alone. It has been working well for me, too. But maybe Omaha is well covered or I'm not using it enough. I have been wondering, though, whether there has been any effort to quantify exactly how bad iOS 6 Maps really are. I mean: if this topic were about anything else, HN denizens would be quick to lecture us about how all the complaints are coming from a self-selected sample, not a random one, and how the examples are cherry-picked - not necessarily representative, and how the plural of anecdote is not data. While there are clearly a lot of errors (and some of them very funny) the world is a very, very big place. So I wonder how bad is "bad", really? What unit(s) of measurement would one use to quantify it? I imagine you would need a different unit of measurement for each kind of error: one for the melted bridge, one for not finding the Starbucks down the street, one for having an airport in the middle of a field...
- psychotik 14y agoAssuming it was acceptable to both parties, why wasn't it possible to add turn-by-turn capability to the existing Google-powered app and ship that instead? Is this something that couldn't have been done without major changes?
- adambratt 14y agoI think this is what point #2 covered. Google was willing to add in more functionality but only if Apple would give them an increased amount of branding. Apple didn't want to answer to Google so they decided to build their own.
- masklinn 14y ago> Google was willing to add in more functionality may have been willing and to let apple access. The application itself was never under Google control, only under Google API restrictions.
- jamesaguilar 14y agoThe reason can be found in the negation of the first seven words of your comment.
- jonny_eh 14y agoOh Gruber, all that analysis and your little footnote strikes me as the most likely explanation.
- vondur 14y agoThe link to the melted bridge is pretty darn funny. I agree with his premise about the maps, Google Maps in iOS lags the Android version pretty badly. Gotta do what you gotta do I suppose...
- andrewcooke 14y agoi went searching for more info as i don't know much about all this, and found Apple is actually responsible for building the app, which is why so few of the many advancements that have come to Google Maps on Android at http://fury.com/2012/06/wills-and-wonts-at-WWDC-2012/ http://fury.com/2012/06/wills-and-wonts-at-WWDC-2012/ which no-one else seems to be mentioning (the implication seems to be that google made the ios app crappy on purpose, which the above seems to contradict).
- ceejayoz 14y agoWithout knowing the details of the Apple-Google contract, it's still hard to say. It's entirely possible that Google forbade use of directions for turn-by-turn navigation in it.
- tptacek 14y agoThat is what the WSJ reported.
- jws 14y agoI believe when the original contract was put in place, Google was licensing their street data from one of the GPS incumbents with a "no turn by turn" restriction. It was only later that Google made their own street data and could offer turn by turn. In that light, it makes sense that Apple's contract had the restriction.
- bryanlarsen 14y agoI think the explanation goes more like this: Google took a look at the maps shipped with the beta version of iOS6 and though to themselves "There's no way that Apple can bring this up to Apple quality software in 3 months, we've got lots of time to ready our replacement". They were right about the first part, but wrong about the second.
- lnanek2 14y agoSeems pretty good situation for Google that most of my closest friends with iPhones are decrying the loss of Google Maps due to Apple. One person I met even swore she would not upgrade to iOS 6 until GMaps is available. Google can now step in and play the hero, having netted a ton of good grass roots PR for their solution. Just because users are pissed and press is loving a story doesn't mean some company isn't benefiting from that.
- brk 14y agoThere is also the possibility that Apple truly wants the full Google Maps experience on iOS. However, if they bundle it in, then they could be perceived as leaking more user data. But if Google releases the app, and users have to consciously install it, they can't blame Apple (well, they might blame Apple unfairly) for violating their privacy or the overall spirit of iOS.
- emn13 14y agoThat analysis sounds like nonsense. His options #1 and #3 are a false and (and misleading) dichotomy. (#1 being continue as is, and #3 being cut the cord) Of course apple wants to ship its own mapping stuff once it can. But there's no reason it can't continue as-is until their own stuff is done. So Gruber's claiming some kind obviousness here which is based entirely on the fiction that there was no middle ground. Based on his analysis of decisions made by people he can't even name and certainly doesn't know, he so confident in this that he insinuates that Google (and of course Apple) would have come to the same conclusion, thus that Google is lying about being suprised. I think that's reading waaaayy to much into all this. Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity. Of course google expected apple to do this at some point. The surprising part is that they did it so early, when their own stuff is hardly done, when the alternative (wait a little longer) has so few apparent downsides.
- tptacek 14y agoI find it a little baffling the amount of animus Apple's mapping has generated on HN. The alternative to Apple doing their own mapping was to continue relying on Google. How is it not a great thing that Apple is competing with them on this? Don't we need more well capitalized global mapping infrastructure?
- Locke1689 14y agoI have only one rule regarding my technology purchases: it has to work. Apple maps don't, so no iPhone for me. I'm not sure if that's what you mean by animus.
- tptacek 14y agoNot at all! If Apple's maps don't work for you, that strikes me as a very good reason not to buy an iPhone. I might even go so far as to suggest that "reasons not to buy an iPhone" are a good thing; the whole market could use more competition. It's the "Apple has made a terrible irresponsible mistake" stuff that confuses me. Incidentally, where are you that Apple's maps don't work for you? I'm in Chicago and they work better for me than the old one did.
- Locke1689 14y agoI recently moved from Chicago to Seattle, but I rarely like to drive in Seattle so transit directions are essential for me. Edit: What were your problems with Google maps in Chicago? I remember it was kind of stupid sometimes (e.g., it would tell me to take the pink line 3 blocks and transfer instead of just walking three blocks and getting on the red line), but I don't remember them being inaccurate.
- tptacek 14y agoYou don't think maybe not baking in transit was a good move? Allows space for companies to build apps with transit as a real focus?
- melvinmt 14y ago> But all three of those options came with a heavy price. Maybe for Apple Inc, but a better Google Maps app (#2) isn't a "heavy price" for the user.
- tptacek 14y agoMy guess is you read Gruber's summary of the WSJ story but didn't take the time to read the WSJ story itself. Google refused to provide Apple with turn-by-turn. Turn-by-turn is a huge win for users.
- tonfa 14y agoGoogle did not have turn by turn data when the iPhone was introduced, so it's not surprising the deal did not include it. (Android maps app had turn by turn only one year after the first Android phone was released).
- tptacek 14y agoApple tried to negotiate access to it and failed, is what the WSJ reported.
- melvinmt 14y agoNo I didn't read the WSJ article (just tried it, but there's a paywall) but from what I understand from this article is that they were willing to add more features (incl. turn-by-turn) in exchange for more "branding" as John Gruber puts it.
- tptacek 14y agoNo, the WSJ reported that they were not, and the quote you're taking from Gruber's article is based on that WSJ article.
- problemdomain 14y agoIt's hard to "take the time" to read a story behind a paywall when you have no desire to give money to the entity owning the wall. Based on the publicly-available information, it's not clear that Google did any such thing. They might have refused, or Apple might not have liked their terms, or Tim Cook may have held a seance to get advice from the ghost of an angry Dijkstra, or a hundred other scenarios of varying plausibility. It's hard to say.
- cookiecaper 14y agoPlease, this guy. He defends Apple as if it were a deity. I don't think I've ever seen a truly substantial criticism of Apple come out of him. Do we really believe that Apple is infallible? It makes sense for Apple to seek liberation from Google's chokehold on Maps, and to make plans to deploy this when it was ready. So, out of his extremely malformed recounting of Apple's available options, choice #3 is the best in the long term, but it's not the best choice right now, when Apple's in-house version is leading people down dead-ends into wooded areas when they're almost out of gas (http://theamazingios6maps.tumblr.com/post/31930446388/neither-of-those-exist-the-bottom-one-is-in-a http://theamazingios6maps.tumblr.com/post/31930446388/neithe...) and doing similarly perilous things all the time. This should be blatantly obvious to everyone. iPhone would continue to thrive even with less featureful maps support. The addition of Latitude would not be an invasion of privacy as Gruber suggests, because it's off by default and in fact when I try to enable Latitude (on road trips, so family can track progress) I typically have a hard time finding it. While neither option 1 nor option 2 is ideal for Apple, both were plausible, reasonable solutions until their in-house maps solution was ready. This, again, should be obvious. It is immensely irresponsible to rip out something as critical and relied upon, not just for convenience but for safety, as Maps and replace it with a half-baked, disastrously incomplete lookalike. I totally sympathize with Apple wanting out of Google's grip, but we need to be serious here. They released far, far too early, and their draconian and self-serving policies for App Store inclusion have left customers (in some cases literally) stranded. Apple did a bad thing with this maps release. I would call Google right up and strike a deal to push an OTA update that put the old maps back right away if I were them.
- rimantas 14y ago> Please, this guy. Yes this guy. One of the best writers about things related to Apple. > He defends Apple as if it were a deity. No, he does not. > I don't think I've ever seen a truly substantial > criticism of Apple come out of him. My guess the reason for that is that you just dismiss Gruber as "this guy" and don't read what he writes. Do we really believe that Apple is infallible? No.
- cookiecaper 14y ago
- jws 14y agoImagine an alternate reality where Apple released the Map program with google-grade road and POI[1] data, perhaps even pictures of Scotland that show something other than clouds[2]… Wouldn't every map app maker cry foul and whine (perhaps with the mouths of lawyers) about Apple using their incumbent (pronounced "monopoly" by lawyers) position to put them out of business? By launching with sad POI data[3] they enter the map market as the underdog, or at least that cute three legged dog. Virtual immunity from an antitrust meme on the internet. In a couple months they could have a "look how great they are now" meme instead. Remember what Coca-Cola's president, Donald Keough, said about introducing "New Coke" just to have it reviled and drive people more firmly to Coca-Cola Classic: The truth is we are not that dumb, and we are not that smart. EOM [1] POI is arguably the easiest part of mapping if you have tens of millions of people to enter corrections. [2] Clouds over Scotland is fixed by writing a couple checks to imagery companies and running your source blender program again. [3] Without exception, the POI location failures I'm seeing are because the data is wrong in Yelp. Reporting to Apple didn't yield a quick response, reporting to Yelp got it changed in Yelp, but it is still wrong in Maps. It remains to be seen how frequently Apple will update.
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoI think Gruber said it best: "I don’t understand why so many reviewers bend over backwards to grade these things on a curve. If Google or Nokia Maps had the problems and deficiencies the Apple Maps have, these same reviewers would (rightly) trash it, and declare (again, rightly) that Google had finally lost its touch. These aren’t “beta” maps. They’re bad maps. It’s that simple. It’s true that their presentation seems closer to Google-caliber than their data, but improving the data is the hardest part of making maps like these. By the time Apple releases “a serious update or three” the entire market will have changed. The truth is, Apple has released a would-be Google Maps competitor that pales compared to Google Maps. Just say it. The mass market doesn’t buy, and doesn’t want to buy, products based on what they might become months from now if these companies somehow dramatically improve the software. They buy products for what they are today, out of the box. Google and Nokia are Apple’s industry peers. These are the big leagues, this is The Show. They’re charging customers real money to buy these things. They should be judged by the same standards." Of course, he wasn't actually talking about Apple maps then so he didn't try quite so hard to see it from their point of view. http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/04/21/mccracken-beta-hardware http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/04/21/mccracken-beta-h...
- tptacek 14y agoThis article has nothing to do with "grading" Apple maps. But, OK, everyone! Turn off your brains! It's a Gruber article; all we're going to talk about is Gruber!
- ZeroGravitas 14y agoNo, but if it had been a competitors product it would have been graded, and harshly. But instead it's an Apple product that's clearly a bit rubbish so we get some meandering drivel about how they were forced to do this for the greater good and Google is smart and evil but also incompetent and ignorant, and Apple is noble, pure and selfless for foisting half-baked maps on its users. Because a phone constantly reporting your position back to Apple so it can build maps and sell phones is so much less creepy than doing so to help Google build maps and sell ads.
- abcd_f 14y agoDon't care for what he's got to say. Not anymore. He lost me at "rotating pedestal smoothly rising from the stage floor" in his iPhone 5 post. If it wasn't obvious whose paycheck he was on before, it became pretty damn clear after that.
- dfc 14y ago"More Google branding, less user privacy." I highly doubt user privacy was one of the reasons Apple chose this path. Does anyone have any corroborating evidence for this claim? I can imagine they did not want to share user data in order to retain a competitive advantage but I have trouble believing it was in the interest of preserving user privacy.