4 ms·
Is he going to die no matter what or is this survivable?
by almosthere 1y ago
Is he going to die no matter what or is this survivable?
- jasongill 1y agoUltimately, yes; he will die no matter what.
- almosthere 1y agoAs you get older this pedantry gets really tiring.
- brongondwana 1y agoThe good news is, you have less time to be annoyed by it
- IncreasePosts 1y agoPersonally, my belief in my own immortality only increases the older I get. Yes, Socrates died, but he clearly wasn't smart if he died. Me, on the other hand? I'm batting a thousand.
- yard2010 1y agoWould it kill you? Well, ultimately yes..
- lgas 1y agoNot necessarily. Could get hit by a car later the same day.
- dooglius 1y agoThere is a deeper point here, not just pedantry. The point is that harm is a spectrum not a binary and one cannot meaningfully answer a question that assumes a binary.
- lwhi 1y agoYes, there is a such a thing as a bad question after all.
- kmbfjr 1y ago(Tired quip “you must be new here”) Yes, it is tiring. In this case, not really because it is at least for me, humorous in a Doc Martin sort of way. But elsewhere and on places like Reddit where the pedantry is often at best unjustified and at worst, wrong, it has made me spend less time on the sites.
- hshdhdhehd 1y agoUnprovable.
- thayne 1y agoI'm not an expert but it definitely doesn't sound like an immediate threat to his life.
- hunterpayne 1y agoHe will be fine. He might not still have his job in a few months but other that, he will be fine. 300 CPM isn't even close to dangerous. You get a higher dose every time you fly in an airplane, or go to La Paz, Bolivia.
- cma 1y ago> They ingested some amount of cavity water Isn't it much worse internally than hitting your outer skin?
- orwin 1y agoYes, but: depends on what he ingested. Deuterium/tritium cannot emit Alpha particles, the ones blocked by your outer/dead skin (also they're an order of magnitude more dangerous than the other at equivalent grey), so he's fine in that way (unless there is more in the pool, but that would be a bigger issue). The issue with ingesting deuterium/tritium is that the dose will now have to be calculated/estimated per organ, and while I don't remember exactly how it's done, it's more complex than calculating the mSv he took (I can't give you more details, I'm not competent, I've observed a radiologist a week my bachelor year to decide which master I would do, I'm now working in software which should tell you everything)
- kevincox 1y agoAccording to https://www.mlive.com/news/2025/10/michigan-nuclear-plant-worker-had-to-be-decontaminated-after-falling-into-reactor-pool.html https://www.mlive.com/news/2025/10/michigan-nuclear-plant-wo... he returned to work the next day (presumably at the nuclear reactor) and only suffered minor injuries due to the fall.