11 ms·
California invests in battery energy storage, leaving rolling blackouts behind
https://web.archive.org/web/20251025210426/https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2025-10-17/california-made-it-through-another-summer-without-a-flex-alert https://web.archive.org/web/20251025210426/https://www.latim...
- metabagel 1y ago> California and Texas are constantly trading places as the top state for battery storage.
- zanon234 1y agoI think Texas will stay ahead for the foreseeable future. California keeps shooting itself in the foot with regulatory hurdles and permit issues.
- redundantly 1y agoAnd Texans will keep losing power during winter storms due to lack of regulations.
- oldpersonintx2 1y ago[dead]
- landl0rd 1y agoThis is ignorant culture war politics and/or anti-Texasism. I should point out that cold temperatures place a huge demand on the grid because consumers don't want to winterize for the marginal once-a-decade blizzard any more than utilities; around half our homes have relatively inefficient resistance heaters as opposed to furnaces. We have a lot more growth in the past few years than most other places, both in relative terms, and in absolute (big state + high growth introduces more absolute friction than small state). Demand is forecast to rise over 20% from 2024 levels vs. an American average under 5%: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/images/2025.07.31/main.svg https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/images/2025.07.31/main.svg So no wonder our reserve margins run thinner when we're already having to build at such speed just to keep pace with regular demand. Texas has been building a ton of wind and solar to supplement generation capacity and is taking some leadership in the next-gen nuclear stuff for a reliable base load, but in the mean time the shortage of CCGTs is going to bite in a state where demand goes up this much, this fast. SB6 passed this summer also should help with reasonable control and oversight. ERCOT actually does a pretty okay job, all things considered; it's hard to invest heavily in winterization for rare events when you're having to invest heavily in new generation to keep up with steadily increasing baseline load.
- cbsmith 1y ago> ERCOT actually does a pretty okay job, all things considered; it's hard to invest heavily in winterization for rare events when you're having to invest heavily in new generation to keep up with steadily increasing baseline load. I'm going to have to strongly disagree here. It's particularly easy when you have to invest heavily in new generation to keep up with steadily increasing baseline load. Retrofitting winterization is more expensive. If you build in support for winterization when you build the capacity in the first place (which is what happens with sane regulatory oversight), it's all quite inexpensive. It'd be one thing if the cold was a once a century surprise, but when you know you're going to have cold events multiple times over the lifetime of your equipment, it's really easy to do this right.
- jeffbee 1y agoI don't think their comment was either ignorant or anti-Texan. Essentially all of the conclusions in the FERC report on the February 2021 events were those of regulatory failure. Generating assets did not have winterization plans that state inspectors actually enforced, most of the failed assets failed at temperatures above their design minima, natural gas delivery system were totally deregulated at the state level, ERCOT winter forecast practices were poor, etc.
- jacobolus 1y agoConsidering how much the Texas state government has been illegally trampling its own residents’ rights recently, mostly for the sake of private corruption, and backed by incredibly bad faith anti-social rhetoric, perhaps reflexive anti-Texas-elected-officials-ism is a reasonable baseline position.
- energy123 1y agoThe large majority of normal people would take the half price electricity than the highly regulated, never-ever-have-an-outage electricity that's way more expensive.
- nullc 1y agoAs if that were the choice... In PG&E land we have extraordinarily expensive (e.g. hitting over 0.60$/kwh) electricity that has outages more often than Texas. High prices go hand in hand with low reliability because the same incompetence and corruption results in both.
- sugarpimpdorsey 1y ago[flagged]
- 3eb7988a1663 1y agoTexas also has higher energy demands (residential AC + industry + bitcoin friendly). Seems intuitive that they would have more to gain from larger battery infrastructure.
- potato3732842 1y agoCA also shoots itself in the foot by having all its wealth and population in mild areas so those places run the show and nobody takes it seriously until it's a hot-summer, everyone cranks the AC, the grid keels over and then "how could this have happened". It's literally the stick in spokes meme. Sure there's some guy in the desert who's been screaming about how this stuff matters, but nobody listens to him because they were calling him a dumb yokel the other 364 days of the year.
- jacobolus 1y agoCan you be a bit more explicit? Do you have a specific person in mind as a model of this "guy in the desert" that people keep calling a "dumb yokel" but who actually a power-grid savant or whatever? Aside: alongside your hero, there are some extremely kooky people living out in the CA desert.
- Braxton1980 1y agoWhat's some examples of this that Texas doesn't have?
- mh- 1y ago> California hasn’t issued an emergency plea for the public to conserve energy, known as a Flex Alert, since 2022. Feels like that statement deserves to be contextualized with weather data. There were a few summers leading up to that where all of the major metro areas shared concurrent record high heat days, and sometimes coincided with poor air quality from wildfires (meaning more people closed their windows and ran AC even if they wouldn't have otherwise.) > It was only five years ago that a record-shattering heat wave pushed the grid to its limit and plunged much of the state into darkness. They mention it here, but then don't talk about whether similar circumstances have been faced since. Don't get me wrong, this is encouraging, but the article invited this kind of reaction by putting "leaving rolling blackouts behind" in the title. Funny enough, if you look at the article's original title via the URL slug, it was much more measured: california-made-it-through-another-summer-without-a-flex-alert
- vondur 1y agoYeah, I think you are correct, 2022 was a hot summer with a September heat wave which broke some records for power demand. Also keep in mind that there was a big increase in hydropower generation in 2023 and 2024 due to the really wet/snowy winter seasons.
- khuey 1y ago> There were a few summers leading up to that where all of the major metro areas shared concurrent record high heat days, and sometimes coincided with poor air quality from wildfires (meaning more people closed their windows and ran AC even if they wouldn't have otherwise.) This is underselling it, if anything. The multi-day heatwave around Labor Day 2022 extended across most of the western US, not just California. The electricity demand during that event set what was at the time the all time record for the entire Western Interconnection (since surpassed in 2024) and set what is still today the all time record for CAISO.
- mh- 1y agoI didn't want to overstate it given I wasn't bringing any data to the conversation, but your account matches my recollection as well.
- standardUser 1y agoThis is the way. It's become standard practice in China, which now leads to the world with half of all battery installations.
- WillPostForFood 1y agoChina is a mixed bad, they also lead the world in new coal power plants. https://www.npr.org/2023/03/02/1160441919/china-is-building-six-times-more-new-coal-plants-than-other-countries-report-fin https://www.npr.org/2023/03/02/1160441919/china-is-building-...
- fellowniusmonk 1y agoLess mixed than the states, more manufacturing and install momentum for renewables and far lower kwh install costs. So many people told me 10 years ago we shouldn't even bother trying to reduce global emissions because China would burn us all to the ground. So many brain dead takes.
- Mistletoe 1y agoNow I just think about where those takes started and all roads always lead back to the same culprits. Your parents and the hillbillies don’t come up with these takes on their own, they always starts somewhere and benefit the person whispering it in their ear. https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2025/10/the-pivot-1.html https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2025/10/the-piv... > The EU also hit a landmark in 2025, with more than 50% of its electricity coming from renewables by late summer. > This has not gone unnoticed by the fossil fuel industry, which is collectively shitting itself. After a couple of centuries of prospecting we know pretty much where all the oil, coal, and gas reserves are buried in the ground. (Another hint about Ukraine: Ukraine is sitting on top of over 670 billion cubic metres of natural gas: to the dictator of a neighbouring resource-extraction economy this must have been quite a draw.) The constant propaganda and astroturfed campaigns advocating against belief in climate change must be viewed in this light: by 2040 at the latest, those coal, gas, and oil land rights must be regarded as stranded assets that can't be monetized, and the land rights probably have a book value measured in trillions of dollars.
- labrador 1y agoI remember the bad old days of rolling black outs when Enron was doing energy arbitrage with Calfifornia's electricity. A more recent negative event was the battery fire at Moss Landing on the Monterrey Bay near where I live. If we use Sodium-ion batteries in the future we won't have that risk. "On January 16, 2025, the Moss Landing 300 battery energy storage system at the Moss Landing Vistra power plant (Monterey County, Calif.) caught fire." - The 300-megawatt system held about 100,000 lithium-ion batteries. - About 55 percent of the batteries were damaged by the fire. https://www.epa.gov/ca/moss-landing-vistra-battery-fire https://www.epa.gov/ca/moss-landing-vistra-battery-fire
- SoftTalker 1y agoAny time you have hundreds of megawatts of energy stored in a small area there is risk. This includes steam boilers, nuclear reactors, batteries, dams, etc. No getting away from that. Not saying that some battery chemistry might not be easier to manage than others.
- jaggederest 1y agoWell we're probably going to see flow batteries take over in fixed position arrays which will mitigate the risk of fire pretty substantially, being low density and liquid. It's challenging though not impossible to light salt water on fire.
- pfdietz 1y agoI thought the prospects for flow batteries were becoming fairly dire due to the decline in cost of Li-ion cells. LFP promises better fire behavior than older Li-ion technologies, I think.
- jaggederest 1y agoI suspect for extremely large batteries or seasonal shifting (summer->winter) flow batteries will still have a place, but I could be wrong.
- NedF 1y ago[flagged]
- dylan604 1y ago<snip>random whacko comments</snip> >Come back in 5 years time when the batteries are 10 years old and failing like the bridges and schools and universities. This however is a valid point to make. In my experience with battery systems, regular maintenance and replacing failed units is one of the things that people are quick to not do on preventative schedule. Instead, they wait until the unit is completely dead and then gasp at the cost of battery replacement. Based on how companies like PG&E do not do regular maintenance on their lines, it doesn't bode well for the batteries.
- stavros 1y agoTo be fair, they were all valid points to make. The gonorrhea thing just kind of set the tone wrong.
- blackoil 1y agoUnless all batteries are installed at once and will fail after a fixed duration it won't be a big issue. After 10-20 year 2-5% batteries will fail and will have to be replaced, along with any new capacity addition. We can emphasise on diversifying the supply chain or having multiple technologies so that a Covid like scenario doesn't completely conks the system, but it isn't much different from any other system we use. And in case of battery, we actually get a real-time info about its health and so can easily calculate capacity of the system. Batteries go from 90% to 0% in extremely rare case.
- random3 1y agoThere's this post about sodium-ion batteries from two days ago - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45677243 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45677243 My understanding is that they are particularly good for large scale storage. It looks like it's relevant part of China's strategy. Yet, there seems to be close to 0 in the US in general (except from some pilots). I find it weird at least to boast about battery energy storage as a strategy while ignoring the most relevant aspect wrt to the future of battery-based storage.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> It looks like it's relevant part of China's strategy For grid storage? Source?
- random3 1y agohttps://www.energy-storage.news/world-first-grid-scale-sodium-ion-battery-project-in-china-enters-commercial-operation/ https://www.energy-storage.news/world-first-grid-scale-sodiu... Also in US https://www.peakenergy.com/news https://www.peakenergy.com/news
- dwood_dev 1y agoWhile Sodium Ion may be the future of grid batteries, it's not the present. As long as LFP is cheaper, there is no reason to go with Sodium. This calculus will probably change in 3-5 years, but today Sodium is more expensive and therefore has little demand without some form of discount or subsidy. The switch will be rapid once the economics make sense, but they don't yet.
- nharada 1y agoCATL is claiming mass production of their sodium-ion batteries starts in December, with a target price of $10/kWh. If that ends up even partway true it'll completely change the economics of power storage.
- 1y ago
- Lammy 1y agoI don't really care if the power stays on for five-nines as long as I'm still paying 61¢/kW-h for it :/ https://www.pge.com/assets/pge/docs/account/rate-plans/residential-electric-rate-plan-pricing.pdf https://www.pge.com/assets/pge/docs/account/rate-plans/resid...
- blindriver 1y agoThis. Electricity costs are almost 5x the cost in Nevada.
- bradlys 1y agoCriminally overpriced. We're not getting shit for it either. God forbid you live in any of the more woody parts of California either. You'll have to have your own battery or generator anyway. As someone who plans to live in the Santa Cruz Mountains long term, I will be going completely off grid as PG&E will just cut power forever rather than fix anything.
- dmix 1y agoWhy is PG&E so poorly run? I don't live there, just follow the news and their name comes up constantly in negative press.
- know-how 1y ago[dead]
- bradlys 1y agoIt’s a public company, not run directly by the government. It has a monopoly dictated by the CA government. They have no interest in doing good service but instead in making money. They don’t have to really answer to anyone. Supposedly the CA government could implement things to improve the lives of Californians that would influence how PG&E operates but CA politicians are bought off by this corporation. So, there we have it
- 1y ago
- batterystorage 1y ago[flagged]
- qaq 1y agoCA has strange pockets of pretty well setup infra. Like Carlsbad has a desalination plant, and a modern standby ng power plant
- kylehotchkiss 1y agoI wish we’d put some desal plants in the north of the state and start feeding into the CA aqueduct and unlocking more Central Valley farmland
- andbberger 1y agofarming with desal water is insane. even with abundant power.
- qaq 1y agowhy ? at scale desal water via solar looks to be very reasonable thing ?
- ZeroGravitas 1y agoCurrent legal setups generally actively encourage people to waste water that they have property rights to. It would be infinitely better return on investment to reform that and put proper incentives in place, rather than work around it with technology.
- andbberger 1y agofarming requires a _lot_ of water.
- kylehotchkiss 1y agoLeaving otherwise fertile farmland empty to use the lands allocated water on another field is insane, insane problems call for insane solutions
- delabay 1y agoInteresting how they never mention that these are Tesla Megapack 2 XL units (LFP chemistry) manufactured at Tesla’s Lathrop, CA “Megafactory.”
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Interesting how they never mention that these are Tesla Megapack 2 XL units It's a story about California's battery storage. Tesla hasn't built all of that capacity. For a Tesla (or other battery producer) press release? Sure. For an article about the general phenomenon? Irrelevant to the point that if it were included I'd be suspicious of the article being a plant.
- delabay 1y agoBy my estimate (GPT5) Tesla has up to 17% of all front and behind the meter battery storage in CA, and is also the vendor growing the fastest in CA. The California battery storage story is also a Tesla story, but based on the positive tone of the article, it clearly made more sense to leave Tesla out of it.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> By my estimate (GPT5) Please don't do this.
- jrflowers 1y ago> By my estimate (GPT5) You know treating a thing that makes stuff up as a source of truth is the same thing as making stuff up right? You might as well have written By my estimate (as revealed to me in a dream)
- danans 1y agoRelatedly, CA utilities have begun offering hourly variable priced rate plans, which will allow consumers with batteries to theoretically achieve lower average rates if your batteries can rate-follow. It's still not available for net metering plans, though. https://www.pge.com/en/account/rate-plans/hourly-flex-pricing.html https://www.pge.com/en/account/rate-plans/hourly-flex-pricin... https://www.pge.com/en/account/rate-plans/hourly-flex-pricing.html https://www.pge.com/en/account/rate-plans/hourly-flex-pricin...
- cbmuser 1y agoThe electricity mix in France is still way cleaner than in California: - France: https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/zone/FR/5y/yearly https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/zone/FR/5y/yearly - California: https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/zone/US-CAL-CISO/5y/yearly https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/zone/US-CAL-CISO/5y/year... And their kWh costs less than 20 Cents in the standard plan: - https://particulier.edf.fr/content/dam/2-Actifs/Documents/Offres/Grille_prix_Tarif_Bleu.pdf https://particulier.edf.fr/content/dam/2-Actifs/Documents/Of... They even offer flex prices going down as low as 12,32 Cents/kWh. Nuclear power rules.
- alecco 1y agoNothing to be proud of. Dangerous ancient reactors owned by an almost bankrupt company about to be nationalized. https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2023/02/03/the-long-road-to-extending-life-of-french-nuclear-reactors_6014297_7.html https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2023/02/03/the-long...
- olejorgenb 1y agohttps://archive.ph/RQxKM https://archive.ph/RQxKM
- pas 1y agoif they can run them safely they should. is ASN not trustworthy? they are doing reviews every 10 year, and as they get older they can increase the frequency of reviews. also the article mentions no dangers with regards to the reactors.
- KptMarchewa 1y ago>almost bankrupt company "Published on February 3, 2023" Since then, in 2023 and 2024 EDF posted over 10 billion a year profits.
- alecco 1y agoIn 2022 they lost 18bn because they had to repair widespread "stress corrosion cracking". And it was nationalized.
- nandomrumber 1y ago> they burn extremely hot and cannot be extinguished with water, which can trigger a violent chemical reaction. The blaze emitted dangerous levels of nickel, cobalt and manganese > In the first six months of this year, CAISO’s grid was powered by 100% clean energy for an average of almost seven hours each day. emitted dangerous levels of nickel, cobalt and manganese 100% clean energy
- Braxton1980 1y ago>100% clean energy Who said that?
- harimau777 1y agoWhile virtually no technology is clean if you count "what happens if it catches on fire"; I think it's still likely that this is much better than the status quo.
- nodesocket 1y ago"leaving rolling blackouts behind..." I'll take this bet CA blackouts aren't over.
- Gigachad 1y agoAdelaide, Australia used to have constant rolling blackouts, including a state wide blackout once. After that, Tesla (pre insanity era) built a grid battery storage system which essentially fixed the problem. I'm sure there were other improvements to the grid at the same time. But these days the grid is incredibly stable while also being majority solar and wind powered. The battery is able to buy and sell power daily and profit on the difference between high and low demand times. And if there's an equipment fault somewhere, it can respond fast enough to cover the time between a generator going offline, and the backup ones starting up.
- steve_taylor 1y agoBy the time that blackout occurred, the grid was already quite stable and rolling blackouts were a thing of the past. The state-wide blackout was the result of a severe storm, which included lightning, gale-force winds and three tornadoes, taking out critical transmission lines, combined with inadequate protection circuits not set up to account for lightning strikes. When the state failed over to the Victoria interconnect, the interconnect shut down because the load was too high. So although the grid was stable, it had some failure points that were exposed during this severe and unusual storm. The battery array was just one measure taken to increase grid resilience in such a scenario. The general idea was to have an instantly dispatchable electricity supply ready to go at any time while bringing gas-powered electricity online. A nice side effect of the battery is that it flattens out wholesale price spikes and makes a bit of money for itself in the process.
- slashdave 1y agoYou'll lose. Combined with solar, batteries are perfect. They cover the time of day when solar wanes, but air conditioning is still needed.
- theultdev 1y ago
- alecco 1y agoThe Financial Times has a much better article: https://ig.ft.com/mega-batteries/ https://ig.ft.com/mega-batteries/
- msarrel 1y agoWe're still going to have rolling blackouts because PGE turns the power off.
- ezfe 1y agoOkay but literally there haven't been in years
- whiterook6 1y agoWhen they say their battery storage capacity is 15,000 MW, do they mean MWh? Because watts are time-independent, or rather, they're like speed to Joule's (watt-hour's) distance.
- teruakohatu 1y agoI struggle to understand why journalists consistently failed to use Wh as a unit of power. People generally can understand it because it is how they are billed and how appliances are rated. Even on HN people will defend not using Wh because there is some grid or city in the USA that bills differently.
- ericd 1y agoLater, they say “lithium ion batteries only have 4 to 6 hours of capacity”, which again, what? But maybe that implies that the actual capacity rating is their “capacity” x 4-6.
- ajross 1y agoUh... "Wh" is not a unit of power. Watts are units of power. Watt-hours measure energy. Probably journalists are getting this wrong for the same reason you are.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 1y agoI do not know why this particular one gets engineers so annoyed. Energy and power are synonymous in conversation with normal people. There is very little real world scenarios where people would be exposed to the precise meanings -of course everyone gets it wrong.
- ajross 1y agoBut the premise of the comment I was replying to was exasperation that journalists got it wrong!
- dxxvi 1y agoDoes it make the electricity price go down or up? It seems to me that the electricity price never goes down.
- IAmBroom 1y agoPerception isn't objective, and inflation still exists. However, price gouging by monopolies also exist. See Enron and their intentionally caused rolling brown-outs.
- Manuel_D 1y agoOne of my biggest pet peeves is when outlets talk about energy storage exclusively in terms of output and neglect to mention capacity. Does 15.7 gigawatts of storage mean 15.7 GWh? Capacity is as important, if not more important, than output.
- chihuahua 1y agoBased on the following sentences from the article, it's probably 4 to 6 times more than 15.7 GWh (60 to 90 GWh, apparently): "Battery energy storage is not without challenges, however. Lithium-ion batteries — the most common type used for energy storage — typically have about four to six hours of capacity. It’s enough to support the grid during peak hours as the sun sets, but can still leave some gaps to be filled by natural gas."
- onlyrealcuzzo 1y agoFrom a grid perspective, the output (delivery) is typically more important than total capacity - because it's acting sort of like a power plant. Power plants don't have capacity, really. So you hear about the output GW, not the capacity GWh. For battery plants, they might mention duration (4 - 6 hours), which makes converting to capacity in terms of GWh trivial.
- Manuel_D 1y ago90 GWh would be something like 10% of global annual battery production.
- UltraSane 1y agoThis also greatly annoyed me. 4 hours is the standard for grid storage batteries in California.
- pahkah 1y agoAs someone who's interested in all this, I agree it would be nice to have more precision around capacity. Especially as it relates to longer term storage. But! In this context, output is more salient than capacity. You'll see a lot of stories about grid-scale storage that use output. (https://physics.stackexchange.com/q/854999 https://physics.stackexchange.com/q/854999 offers a fuller explanation than what I'll give here.) This is because grid operators are most concerned with immediate power output. They need to keep the grid balanced, and if they need a gigawatt to do it, it doesn't matter if the batteries have 100 GWh if they can only discharge at 1 MW. Since the batteries described here are used primarily to handle the peak of the duck curve (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_curve) it seems like 4 hours of capacity (the article mentions that the lithium-ion batteries have 4-6 hours of capacity) is sufficient to get over that difficult hump. Anyway, to get back to your question of how many GWh, if we assume that the batteries have 4 hours of storage, then we're looking at around 4h * 15.7 GW = 63 GWh of battery capacity. (4 hours is what I've seen as standard for lithium-ion, conservative if the article's claim of "four to six hours" is true.) Hope this helps ease the peeve!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- andbberger 1y agoand there was a huge fire at the moss landing plant which left heavy metals and god knows what else raining down onto sensitive marine mammal habitat. kayak up elkhorn slough and you'll encounter dozens of otters, seals... less than a kilometer from the battery plant. I don't think we're going to be appreciating the environmental consequences of that accident for years. heavy metals don't decay, they'll be there forever. a pox on david brouwer and his faux environmentalism, and the politics and economic machinations that ever proposed solar and batteries as an alternate to baseload fission plants. (in fact brouwer did his damage long before solar was ever practical, so he has even less ground to stand on)
- benzible 1y agoI'm hungry for good news about technical solutions working - especially right now when Trump just killed the US's largest solar project (6.2 GW in Nevada), ended USDA solar support for farms, and posted "We will not approve...Solar". So I wanted to check if California's battery story holds up. The data is actually encouraging. Peak demand hit 48,323 MW in 2024 - higher than the 2020 blackout year's 47,121 MW [1]. Weather was severe: 2023 broke 358 California temperature records, 2024 saw valleys top 110°F during multiple heat waves [2][3]. Battery discharge reached 5-7 GW during Sept 2024 peaks, offsetting ~16% of demand [4]. That's real. Fair caveat: 2020 had compounding failures (imports fell 3,000 MW short, gas plants failed, planning issues [5]), and recent years benefited from better coordination and wet winters. But batteries were clearly the biggest new factor - going from 500 MW in 2020 to 15,700 MW today is massive buildout, and it performed when tested. Nice to see an existence proof that we can make progress on adapting to climate change's second-order effects, maybe even progress on root causes - through technology, at scale, in the United States of 2025. [1] https://www.caiso.com/Documents/CaliforniaISOPeakLoadHistory.pdf https://www.caiso.com/Documents/CaliforniaISOPeakLoadHistory... [2] https://news.caloes.ca.gov/extreme-heat-breaking-records-at-home-and-beyond/ https://news.caloes.ca.gov/extreme-heat-breaking-records-at-... [3] https://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-forecasts/california-heat-wave-temperatures-to-top-110-as-july-begins/1663794 https://www.accuweather.com/en/weather-forecasts/california-... [4] https://blog.gridstatus.io/caiso-beats-the-heat/ https://blog.gridstatus.io/caiso-beats-the-heat/ [5] https://calmatters.org/environment/2020/08/california-2020-rolling-blackouts-explainer/ https://calmatters.org/environment/2020/08/california-2020-r...
- nickzelei 1y agoWhat does it mean saying California hasn’t done a Flex Alert since 2022? PG&E issued 3-4 in September/October this year. Is that different?
- klempner 1y agoAre you sure you're not thinking of "SmartDay" days that are part of the SmartRate program? Flex Alerts are CAISO and ultimately about grid stability. SmartRate/SmartDay are ultimately about marginal cost of production on PG&E. The two are certainly correlated -- at the very least, a Flex Alert day is almost guaranteed to be a SmartDay. Notably, the SmartRate program is capped at 15 days per year, and in practice PG&E will keep a few in reserve for surprise late season events, but even if there are no Flex Alert days they're still going to be called on electricity-is-expensive-even-if-the-grid-is-stable days.
- 1970-01-01 1y agoNo, more coal and gas is the only way. /S
- tjwebbnorfolk 1y ago> ...leaving rolling blackouts behind This is a pretty good candidate for "famous last words"
- rahimnathwani 1y agoFunny to read this today. I live in San Francisco, and we had a blackout today.
- radium3d 1y agoI haven't had a rolling blackout in our particular grid in several years. The battery energy storage has been a great benefit. Our home battery energy storage system has been fantastic as well for localized unplanned outages.
- gradientsrneat 1y ago> cannot be extinguished with water Why? I thought lithium ion batteries actually contained negligible amounts of lithium? Or is this for some other reason?
- IAmBroom 1y agoAround 7%, it seems, so not negligible. There's also a similar amount of manganese, which can also burn.
- dekerklas 1y ago[flagged]
- WanderZil 1y agoNice! About time they figured out large-scale storage. Hopefully this means no more “flex alerts” every other week.
- gacklesschlong 1y ago[flagged]
- Yeul 1y agoIf there is one resource that America has in spades it's empty land. My own country every m² is valuable.
- DaSHacka 1y agoBut unfortunately, everyone wants to live in a small subset.
- rexpop 1y agoWhy is this unfortunate? Urban living shrinks each person’s land and energy footprint by packing people efficiently, cutting carbon emissions through public transit and walkability, preserving open natural spaces, and enabling more efficient infrastructure. It's true that concentrating populations in cities increases housing demand, but that doesn't automatically mean costs must rise—housing prices are driven by supply constraints and policy choices, not just demand. If cities allow enough new construction and implement policies like inclusionary zoning or affordable housing mandates, supply can keep pace with demand, preventing price spikes and even lowering costs per unit over time. So, while demand goes up, smart urban planning can ensure affordability without conceding that costs inevitably follow.
- IAmBroom 1y agoYou're right on the national level, but we can't put all our energy creation in the US midwest and just "transport" it somehow 1,000 miles to urban centers. The US NE Corridor has almost zero empty land, but consumes a major portion of the energy.
- clarionbell 1y agoAll this talk about energy independence and not a word on where are the solar cells, batteries and wind turbines made. If your grid is standing on components with short life time and which you can't manufacture at scale, you are not independent. You have just traded one dependence for another.
- mattmaroon 1y agoWind turbines and solar panels have similar lifespans to natural gas power plants which are also made somewhere else.
- IAmBroom 1y agoSteam turbines are made in the US, and they are the principal mechanical component in natural gas power generation.
- zizee 1y agoSorry, what is the previous dependency? If you're talking about longevity of solar or wind turbines, given that their lifespan is measured in tens of years, it does give you some ability to respond to some external group cutting your supply off. It's not remotely the same as oil/gas dependency.
- dekerklas 1y ago[dead]