5 ms·
"It's important to note that Goldacre is writing from Britain, relying mostly on British examples." At least judging from this example, the majority of his boo
by Alex3917 14y ago
"It's important to note that Goldacre is writing from Britain, relying mostly on British examples."
At least judging from this example, the majority of his book is sourced from two earlier books that were written about the FDA and the American drug system:
The Truth About Drug Companies by Marcia Angell
Overdosed America by Jonathan Abrams
Those were published in 2004 and 2005, so there are a few studies published since then on the influence of pharma funding on trial outcomes, but nothing that contradicts the earlier results.
In general though the problems are exactly the same between the US and the UK. There are a couple drugs that are legal here and not there and vice versa, but the underlying system corruption is identical, because it's literally the same studies (or at least the same methodology) that is used to get the drugs approved in both countries.
Also, as I've said before, that science-based medicine blog is mostly industry propaganda. There is overwhelming evidence that drug companies have a massive influence on doctor's prescribing habits, e.g. http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=192314 http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=192314
Here they are literally arguing that doctors aren't influenced by the file drawer effect because doctors can tell the difference in methodological rigor between good studies and bad studies. That has to be one of the dumbest and most intellectually dishonest arguments I have ever heard. Science-Based Medicine (the blog) reminds me a lot of Brawndo. Their basic argument in every article is just "but it's what plants crave!!1"
- tokenadult 14y agoAlex, I have lived in more than one country, so I have made specific observations of precisely how little influence the FDA has on the drug regulations of other countries. And I previously provided numerous examples to you of the FDA keeping drugs off the market or removing drugs from the market based on evidence of safety and effectiveness. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4245571 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4245571 I would submit that the underlying system corruption is probably stronger among enterprises that sell schedule I controlled substances here in the United States than among those that sell government-regulated, physician prescribed medications. Both regulatory systems, the system that makes some drugs I've seen you speak up for contraband, and the system that makes some newly invented drugs legal items of commerce, may indeed need further reform. But it's an exaggeration (contradicted by thoughtful comments by drug industry researchers who have already posted replies in this thread) to say that the enterprises that develop new drugs for prescribed medical treatment are corrupt in general beyond what Goldacre claims with specific evidence.
- Alex3917 14y ago"But it's an exaggeration [...] to say that the enterprises that develop new drugs for prescribed medical treatment are corrupt in general beyond what Goldacre claims with specific evidence." edit: Response moved to pastebin: http://pastebin.com/cniysd82 http://pastebin.com/cniysd82 (Didn't realize how long that was going to get.)
- hahainternet 14y agoYou've damaged this comment page and shown your immaturity to the public.
- pstuart 14y agoI think you're being dramatic. Posting a too long comment in trying to make a point?
- droithomme 14y agoHe posted an extremely well researched, cited and thoughtful response. He did not resort to namecalling or logical fallacies. Your response is to call him names. Who is immature?
- Gatsky 14y agoMost of your points pertain to placebo controlled trials of antidepressants. No argument there... it's a very difficult area ripe for abuse. I wouldn't however use this as justification that all trials of all drugs are rubbish. Your arguments regarding non psychiatric medicines are weaker. For example, in oncology trials you state that the practice of excluding patients who are elderly or frail is 'not a good way to find out how to treat most cancer patients.' The reality is that it is very difficult to show any evidence of benefit in patients that aren't fit to start off with. This is because not being fit is a strong determinant of poor outcome. If you include them in the trial then it will be negative, and even those patients who might benefit won't ever get the treatment. This isn't bad science, it is just the required degree of pragmatism when resources for running trials are scarce. The way the research is done in reality is first you give the drug to the people most likely to benefit, and then if it works for them, test it in other groups less likely to benefit by running trials specifically in the elderly or frail groups. When these trials don't exist, and they often don't, the oncologist discusses the options with the patient and family based on the available evidence. They don't, as you seem to imply, give chemotherapy to everyone that walks in the door because Pfizer took them to lunch. So definitely agree for antidepressant trials. But not for everything else. Although I haven't read Ben Goldacre's book. Yet.
- pessimizer 14y agoPlease delete it. Post a link to it, but don't post the entire thing.
- demallien 14y agoWoah, you're way off when talking about sciencebasedmedicine.org. That's Steve Novella's site - and he's about as respected as you get in the sceptic community. If you want to claim that it's mostly industry propaganda, you'd better have some good evidence to back up the claim!
- Alex3917 14y ago"He's about as respected as you get in the sceptic community" Ever look up how respected skepticism is within the larger philosophical community? I mean look at my pastebin post: http://pastebin.com/cniysd82 http://pastebin.com/cniysd82 And this encompasses only a small fraction of the corruption within the pharmaceutical industry, because I wanted to make it readable. There are literally dozens of book published on this. But does SBM actually address any of the criticism? Not a single point of it, because there is no defense; in fact, it's all coming from high-level 'insiders' in the medical community -- JAMA, NEJM, the IOM, etc. Instead they just spin it in order to trick people who are predisposed to have faith in modern medicine. (And I use the term faith, because if you're familiar with these issues then it's unmistakably clear that this is really what it is.) What science-based medicine does (again, the blog, not the concept) is really no different than what the evangelical megachurches do, it's just dressed up in different language.
- shrikant 14y agoHonestly, a lot of the points you make about SBM (the blog) are quite disturbing to me, as it is one of my primary resources as a lay-person to keep up with developments in woo, quackery and general commentary on popular medical reporting. I hope you don't see these questions as confrontational because I genuinely would like to be pointed in the right direction for the some of these claims. (speaking as a relatively liberal person who recently joined a host of strongly conservative forums to get a picture of "the other side"...) > Ever look up how respected skepticism is within the larger philosophical community? I gather this means that it's not respected? Why is that? I find it hard to believe that scientific skepticism (and not the truther/birther/moon-landing-was-a-hoax kind) can find widespread opposition in any sort of critical thinking community. > Instead they just spin it in order to trick people who are predisposed to have faith in modern medicine. Are there any examples of this from the blog? I was (and am) under the impression that a lot of writing is backed up by fairly solid reasoning, references and such. > What science-based medicine does (again, the blog, not the concept) is really no different than what the evangelical megachurches do, it's just dressed up in different language. How so? This analogy sounds suspiciously like fundamentalists' claims of "scientism" and "science is just another religion!". If you mean something else, then do elaborate.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]