5 ms·
tbh wolfram alpha was the craziest thing ever. haven't done much research on how this was implemented back in the day but to achieve what they did for such comp
by idk-92 1y ago
tbh wolfram alpha was the craziest thing ever. haven't done much research on how this was implemented back in the day but to achieve what they did for such complex mathematical problems without AI was kind of nuts
- globular-toast 1y agoWolfram Alpha is AI. It's just not an LLM. AI has been a thing since the 60s. LLMs will also become "not AI" in a few years probably.
- phs318u 1y agoNot sure why you’re getting downvoted. The marketing that LLM=AI seems to have been interpreted as “_only_ LLM=AI”
- svdr 1y agoI think the difference now is that traditional software ultimately comes down to a long series of if/then statements (also the old AI's like Wolfram), whereas the new AI (mainly LLM's) have a fundamentally different approach.
- globular-toast 1y agoLook into something like Prolog (~50 years old) to see how systems can be built from rules rather than it/else statements. It wasn't all imperative programming before LLMs. If you mean that it all breaks down to if/else at some level then, yeah, but that goes for LLMs too. LLMs aren't the quantum leap people seem to think they are.
- ozim 1y agomaybe not on their own - but having enough computing power to use LLMs in a way we do now and actually using them is quite a leap.
- TheOtherHobbes 1y agoThey are from the user POV. Not necessarily in a good way. The whole point of algorithmic AI was that it was deterministic and - if the algorithm was correct - reliable. I don't think anyone expected that soft/statistical linguistic/dimensional reasoning would be used as a substitute for hard logic. It has its uses, but it's still a poor fit for many problems.
- globular-toast 1y agoYeah, the result is pretty cool. It's probably how it felt to eat pizza for the first time. People had been grinding grass seeds into flour, mixing with water and putting it on hot stones for millennia. Meanwhile others had been boiling fruits into pulp and figuring out how to make milk curdle in just the right way. Bring all of that together and, boom, you have the most popular food in the world. We're still at the stage of eating pizza for the first time. It'll take a little while to remember that you can do other things with bread and wheat, or even other foods entirely.
- eloisant 1y agoYou're talking about non-deterministic algorithms, who yes are often associated with AI but existed way before LLM's
- fragmede 1y agoI doubt that if the underlying parts changed, anyone outside the industry or enthusiasts would know what that is. How many people know what kind of engine is in their car? I stomp on the floor of my Corolla and away we go! Others might know that their Dodge Challenger has a Hemi. What even is that? Thankfully we have the Internet these days, and someone who's interested can just select the word and right click to Google for the Wikipedia article for it. AI is just such an entirely undefined term coloquially, that any attempts to define it will be wrong.
- magicalhippo 1y agoWould really like something selfhosted that does the basic Wolfram Alpha math things. Doesn't need the craziest math capability but standard symbolic math stuff like expression reduction, differentiation and integration of common equations, plotting, unit wrangling. All with an easy to use text interface that doesn't require learning.
- krackers 1y agoThat's wolfram mathematica.
- jhallenworld 1y agoTry maxima, it's open source: https://maxima.sourceforge.io/ https://maxima.sourceforge.io/ I used it when it was called Macsyma running on TOPS-20 (and a PDP-10 / Decsystem-20). Text interface will require a little learning, but not much.
- jgalt212 1y agoMaxima is amazing and has a GUI. My only beef with it is it doesn't show its work step by step.
- harrall 1y agoPersonal faves: - Mathematica - Maple - MathStudio (mobile) - Ti-89 calculator (high school favorite) Others: - SageMath - GNU Octave - SymPy - Maxima - Mathcad
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- skylurk 1y agoTI-89 has surprisingly good symbolics tools and solvers for something that runs all year on a single set of AAA batteries. Feels like magic alien tech.
- pjmlp 1y agoIt is basically another take on Lisp, and the development approach Lisp Machines had, repackaged in a more friendly syntax. Lisp was the AI language until the first AI Winter took place, and also took Prolog alongside it. Wolfram Alpha basically builds on them, to put in a very simplistic way.
- krackers 1y agoIt's one of the only M-expression versions of Lisp. All the weird stuff about Wolfram Language suddenly made sense when I saw it through that lens
- NuclearPM 1y agoThank you for being honest.
- ge96 1y agoI used it a lot for calc as it would show you how they got the answer if I remember right, also liked how it understands symbols which ibv but cool to paste an integral sign in there
- fooker 1y ago> without AI We only call it AI until we understand it. Once we understand LLMs more and there's a new promising poorly understood technology, we'll call our current AI something more computer sciency
- simonw 1y agoMy favorite definition of AI: "AI is whatever hasn't been done yet." - Larry Tesler, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect