4 ms·
For those talking about "don't borrow if you can't pay": Should a society allow a system where a person is allowed to gamble one of their organs for a chance a
by joe_the_user 14y ago
For those talking about "don't borrow if you can't pay":
Should a society allow a system where a person is allowed to gamble one of their organs for a chance at a million dollars?
The argument against this extreme example would be: society has an interest in keeping people from doing dumb things that gets them in over their heads because one person being really screwed actually impacts the lives of others. The same applies to student loans. Sure, only "dumb" people take out loans without it being a good deal for them. But we have some interest in preventing "dumb" people from screwing themselves up so much it starts to hurt us too.
- stretchwithme 14y agoPrivate lenders don't loan money when the business plan makes no sense. When the education won't increase a student's earning power enough to pay back the money, a private lender is not likely to lend to them. The government makes no such judgment when lending, for education, mortgages or anything else it decides to "encourage". And the result is oversupply and a drop in demand, followed by a long drought in the production of the thing the government encourages. A bust. Government is not smarter than the student. The student will at least learn from his mistake.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoWe can make a stronger macroeconomic argument for keeping always-recoverable debts very, very low. And it's a simple one: the larger the amount of guaranteed-recoverable private debt in the economy, the less available aggregate demand to actually purchase goods and services and thereby run the actual economy. Dumb people might be dumb, but very many clever people depend on stupids and suckers for their income. If "dumb people" (in actual fact: anyone who has made a mistake ever) cease to have any money, all those "smart people" lose their incomes too.