12 ms·
This all has very big "uncured bacon" energy to me (if you didn't already know: there's no such thing; vendors of uncured bacon performatively drive the same ch
by tptacek 1y ago
This all has very big "uncured bacon" energy to me (if you didn't already know: there's no such thing; vendors of uncured bacon performatively drive the same chemical nitrite reaction using vegetable extracts). For example: yogurt becomes a UPF simply by dint of adding carrageenan, which is on the order of calling dashi a UPF because of the kombu.
It's not that there isn't a very legitimate issue underneath all this: packaged, hyperpalatable, low-nutritional-density low-satiety foods are probably a major driver of health problems. It's just that "UPF" isn't the right metric for isolating those foods, and with the wrong metrics you end up in a similar place as California does with the Prop 65 warnings.
We went through a similar thing with "pink slime" (transglutaminase preservation techniques).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V-a9VDIbZCU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V-a9VDIbZCU
- supportengineer 1y agoI only get the bacon that says "No nitrates, no nitrites"
- tptacek 1y agoIf you're talking about American-style bacon, and it tastes like bacon, there's no such thing. They're just exploiting labeling rules by selecting very specific nitrite sources. Nitrites are what give bacon (and ham) its flavor. <strike>This is before we get to the whole premise of avoiding nitrates. Would you eat a beet? That's a serving of industrial bacon's worth of nitrates right there.</strike> Later (Actually, super bad example, since the concern is nitrosamines which are formed in the presence of proteins. The point about the illegitimacy of nitrite-free bacon stands!)
- supportengineer 1y agoI fucking hate beets. For bacon, what do you think of these? Applegate: https://www.raleys.com/product/10400628/applegate-naturals-hickory-smoked-uncured-sunday-bacon https://www.raleys.com/product/10400628/applegate-naturals-h... Coleman: https://www.raleys.com/product/103101180/coleman-natural-bacon-uncured-smoked-applewood https://www.raleys.com/product/103101180/coleman-natural-bac...
- joshyeager 1y agoThe Coleman bacon doesn't list ingredients. But the Applegate bacon lists celery powder because that is a source of nitrates. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celery_powder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Celery_powder
- supportengineer 1y agoThe Coleman one is the one I usually get these days, I used to get the Applegate.
- tptacek 1y agoI don't know much about either brand but there are good reasons to buy fancy bacon instead of Smithfield and Hormel, just because of the quality and ethics of the livestock inputs. But nitrites aren't one of those reasons.
- stonemetal12 1y agoFound an image of coleman bacon ingredients list, celery powder is on it as well.
- tptacek 1y agoApplegate is notoriously celery-extract-cured. Same chemical endpoints in your body as industrially produced nitrite powder. There's a really easy way to tell: does it taste like American bacon? Then: nitrites.
- Figs 1y agoCelery powder / extract / etc. are nitrites.
- stronglikedan 1y agoCounterpoint: I fucking love beets. (and bacon. but not together. yuck)
- 1y ago
- littlestymaar 1y ago> Nitrites are what give bacon (and ham) its flavor. Are you sure about that? Because it's the first time ever I stumbled upon this argument. The explanation I heard is that there are legit bacterial food safety concerns (salmonella and listeria, IIRC) that justify using nitrites even if they are by themself harmful, the benefit/risk ratio is simply favorable to nitrites.
- tptacek 1y agoPretty sure. I make bacon and dabble with salumi. It's definitely not strictly a food safety issue. I sometimes put a pinch of pink salt in with my duck confit cure, and it comes out distinctively hammier. Nitric oxide interacts with myoglobin in ways that alter your taste perception; sort of the way I understand miracleberries make things taste sweeter (by cutting off your perception of bitterness), nitrites do to the metallic flavor compounds in meat.
- bigstrat2003 1y agoIt's both. Curing is a preservative technique and it gives bacon and ham the flavor people enjoy. Like a lot of food preservation techniques (jam, etc) curing was most likely developed for preservation first, and then people came to enjoy the flavor it gave.
- Freedumbs 1y agoThis is partially true. The use celery extract or whatever they can get away with legally. Smoking is what gives bacon the flavor. Buy your cut of meat, season, and smoke it with a very low temp for long time, you have bacon. No nitrates.
- tptacek 1y agoNo you won't. You'll have smoked pork. Nitrite curing is the difference between ham and pork, and is part of the source of American bacon's flavor. You can make or buy unsmoked bacon; it will still taste like bacon. It is weird to me that people try to make an issue out of this, because it's not like the flavor change in cured meat is hard to miss. Just buy some pink salt! Corned beef tastes like corn beef because of nitrites.
- UmGuys 1y agoThis is false, buy some pork belly and smoke it. I've done it.
- tptacek 1y agoIf there is a thing a reasonable person can do with pork belly, I have done it. I think you have the higher evidentiary burden here, regardless of our respective experience. You can check Ruhlman's Charcuterie and Salumi books, you can check AskCulinary, you can check the food Stack Exchange, you can just notice that literally every packaged bacon product, whether or not it claims to be cured, is in fact cured (usually with celery powder), or, of course, you can just take some sliced pork belly and make a 5% pink salt/salt mix and throw it in a zip in your fridge overnight and see. I get that you like smoked pork belly. I do too. I don't even object to you calling it "bacon". All sorts of things that aren't American bacon are called bacon. But nitrites are absolutely part of the distinctive flavor of American bacon. The whole thing is silly, because we can just point to ham and corned beef, two products where the debate doesn't even make sense; we only see it with bacon, and we only see it because vendors lie about whether their products are cured.
- aidenn0 1y agoThat means they use celery powder as the source of nitrates, not that it has no nitrates.
- bsder 1y agoYou're still getting the industrial levels of nitrates/nitrites. They just stuff it in as an extract from celery. The problem isn't the curing, per se. In old school hand curing, almost all the nitrate/nitrite has reacted and is gone by the time you buy the meat. The problem is the industrialization of the process. In order to not have to inspect the cured meat (as that would take people--the horror!), industry injects a massive amount of curing agents such that even when the meat is "fully cured" there is still a ton of it left in the meat itself.
- Ekaros 1y agoI suppose it would not be bacon without curing. But I suppose uncured bacon would be thinly cut pork belly... For curing you really need only salt(or nitrite or sugar). Nitrates do have benefits in longer processes.
- tptacek 1y agoYou can go to any Asian grocer and get thin-sliced pork belly and cook it up yourself to see the difference. It is not subtle. For American bacon flavor, you need nitrites (nitrates are a slow-release source of nitrites).
- fsckboy 1y ago>which is on the order of calling dashi a UPF because of the kombu when you use a comparison like this, you choose an example that people will understand so they can then, by analogy, extend that understanding to the point you are trying to make... like the kombu in the dashi, you say? dash-it-all, that's a combunation I hadn't considered!
- tptacek 1y agoIf you don't do a lot of cooking, just think "this is a definition that suggests virtually all traditional Japanese cooking is UPF".
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Affric 1y agoYeah to go to Japanese cuisine with words we don’t use otherwise in English is quite funny.
- BirdieNZ 1y agoI found it a helpful analogy. Cooking almost any Japanese food will quickly introduce you to dashi and kombu, and I didn't know what carrageenan was.
- benrutter 1y ago> It's just that "UPF" isn't the right metric for isolating those foods I've heard this criticism a fair bit, and I sort of agree. The only thing is, what is the right metric? And if we don't have one, and know these foods are causing harm, should we just use UPF as a term anyway?
- tptacek 1y agoI don't know, it's a hard problem, but I think there's good public policy evidence that when you do these things wrong (as with Prop 65 cancer warnings and nitrates) you lose all the benefits the labeling tries to provide.
- Scarblac 1y agoThe thing is that, although the list used (the "Nova classification") is obviously somewhat arbitrary, the fact that everybody uses it makes research results comparable to each other.
- nradov 1y agoComparable how? If I compare one meaningless number to another meaningless number on the same scale then I can see which one is larger, but I won't learn anything scientifically valuable or practically useful.
- neilfrndes 1y agoThe book Ultra-Processed People by Chris van Tulleken really opened my eyes about UPF. I highly recommend it. Here is a video of him delivering a lecture at the royal institution about the topic: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=j1oOoYnCfJs https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=j1oOoYnCfJs I don't think adding kombu to dashi would count as UPF according to the book's definition.
- tptacek 1y agoI don't know that it does, but I do know that carrageenan does, and they're both just seaweed extracts. Later This video is really frustrating. The first half of it is making relatively banal arguments about the importance of food to health. He's setting up an argument that I think basically everybody agrees with (hyperpalatable packaged food are a major driver of illness). But then he gets to UPFs, says the definition is totally agreed on, and then says they're all made by investor-driven large corporations. That's just straightforwardly false. I made a mac & cheese out of some stored roasted cauliflower (never put a raw cauliflower in your fridge). To melt the aged cheddar I used, I added a half teaspoon of sodium citrate (a miracle ingredient). My cauli-mac is now a UPF. No giant corporation made it. My argument isn't that packaged food isn't exactly as much of a problem as the UPF people say it is. My argument is that "UPF" is not the right axis on which to determine which foods are and aren't healthy.
- Amezarak 1y agoI think it’s misleading to suggest a substance is okay because it’s “just” an extract. Normal foods contain lots of substances that when extracted, are obviously bad if concentrated and consumed in larger quantities than would be had during normal consumption of whatever the source is. Additionally, even if that substance is perfectly safe, the extraction process may effectively increase (as a %) the amount of byproducts. For example - and this is totally made up - suppose ice cream normally contained 1ppm microplastics, but adding carrageenan increased that to 10ppm because of the microplastics in seawater and the failure of the extraction process to remove them. Or even things that are “good” in their normal dosages might be “bad” at higher doses found in extracts. In general, I would suggest it’s a good heuristic to avoid foods containing ingredients added for stability, preservation, or color. Maybe it’s fine but the benefit vs just eating fresh food that doesn’t need it is basically nil even in that case. Carrageenan would fall into this category. (It seems like there is some research suggesting carrageenan is not great for you but I’m not an expert: I’d not heard that and avoid it simply because it’s not anything I would add to a food I made.)
- asdff 1y agoWhy does yogurt need carrageenan though? The bacteria already solidifies the milk.
- tptacek 1y agoSome yogurt formulations will separate without it.
- asdff 1y agoYeah you get whey sure. Not an issue either dump it out or stir it.
- herbst 1y agoEverything you had to shake or stir in the past now contains carageen. Milk based drinks, cream, cream salads, even ice cream contains it usually and often undeclared
- IAmBroom 1y agoAs a fellow fermenter of yogurt, I get you. But I guarantee that will not survive competition in the marketplace.
- fcpk 1y agocarrageenan has however been shown to induce radical microbiome changes in those consuming it.
- tedunangst 1y agoAre you confusing pink slime and meat glue?
- tptacek 1y agoNo, "pink slime" refers to processed meat trim that is packaged and made palatable with meat glue.
- tedunangst 1y agoDo you have a source for transglutiminase used to put the pink slime back together? This is the first I'm hearing it. I thought they just stirred it into the ground beef.
- tptacek 1y agoStuff like this: https://www.glutenfreesociety.org/meat-glue-the-hidden-ingredient-in-your-food/ https://www.glutenfreesociety.org/meat-glue-the-hidden-ingre...
- tedunangst 1y agoThat article is very confused. They're saying that transglutaminase, street name meat glue, extracted from bacteria is literally the same thing as pink slime. Lean finely textured beef, street name pink slime, comes from cows. However processed, it's still beef. You can't squeeze it out of bacteria. Reading the Wikipedia articles it's pretty clear these are different things, even if both are added to beef in some way. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pink_slime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pink_slime https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transglutaminase https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transglutaminase
- tptacek 1y agoOf course it's confused. I barely read it. I just remember, as a meat glue enthusiast (glue two skirt steaks together sometime! amazing!) that TG was at the heart of a "pink slime" controversy, as one of the ways manufacturers made salable products out of mechanically separated meat. I don't, like, agree that it's a real issue! That's my point. TG is more than enough to make a food product "UPF", but a lot of TG meat products are probably a whole hell of a let better for you than non-UPF "olive-oil fried potato chips".
- ThePowerOfFuet 1y ago>For example: yogurt becomes a UPF simply by dint of adding carrageenan What the hell are you doing putting crap like that in your yogurt? Love, Europe
- tptacek 1y agoEuropean yogurts are also stabilized with carrageenan. Also: you irradiate your dairy to the point where it's shelf stable, so you're nobody to talk. At least our milk doesn't glow in the dark.
- ninalanyon 1y ago> European yogurts are also stabilized with carrageenan. Not in my part of Europe! There are only two ingredients in plain yoghurt here in Norway: milk and a bacterial culture. Flavoured yoghurts typically add fruit puree and sugar.
- tptacek 1y agoNo true Europeans!