3 ms·
> If they can operate in London, they will have really shown that autonomy is working Go back through Waymo’s historic announcements on HN. This is said every
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> If they can operate in London, they will have really shown that autonomy is working
Go back through Waymo’s historic announcements on HN. This is said every time.
Autonomy works. Waymo has solved it. There isn’t yet a number 2, though China has strong candidates. But where you can find Waymo, it works so well that we need to see it in a familiar context to believe it really exists.
- ifwinterco 1y agoAll the existing places Waymo operate are in the US though, as OP says London is very different. Will be interesting to see if they can get it working or not
- AlotOfReading 1y agoThey've been operating in Tokyo for a bit now.
- 4ndrewl 1y agoIt's unclear as to where in London this is being rolled out, but central London traffic is notoriously slow, which may help. But we also don't have the concept of jaywalking - you can cross wherever, whenever and there is quite the cycling infrastructure to deal with.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> we also don't have the concept of jaywalking - you can cross wherever, whenever and there is quite the cycling infrastructure to deal with This is true in New York and, to a lesser degree, San Francisco.
- tialaramex 1y agoI mean, it's now technically true (since some point in 2024) in NYC, but historically it was merely practice to not uniformly enforce this rule and that's basically a more extreme version of the reality across the US. However unlike a cop deciding whether to fine people for "jay walking" the Waymo doesn't care whether you're the mayor's grandmother or a wise-talking black teenager if you're in its path, those are both humans and it's not allowed to hit humans. There aren't going to be many humans in the street in outer Phoenix because where would they even be going? But the Mission, just like Leicester Square, has plenty of pedestrians who might just run into the street in front of you given any reason or opportunity and you need to be ready for that. So I agree this isn't novel for Waymo, but while technically jay walking is now legal in NYC that's not why Waymo (which also has pencilled in an NYC launch) needs to care about it already.
- xnx 1y agoThe linked article is bad. It would've been better to link to the official announcement or page (https://waymo.com/waymo-in-uk https://waymo.com/waymo-in-uk): "select boroughs in London, including Barking and Dagenham, Brent, Camden, Ealing, Royal Borough of Greenwich, Hackney, Hammersmith and Fulham, Haringey, Islington, Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea, Lambeth, Lewisham, Newham, Redbridge, Southwark, Tower Hamlets, Waltham Forest, Wandsworth, City of Westminster, and the City of London."
- verzali 1y agoThat's a big area, covering much of the centre of the city. It will be impressive to see it working well.
- potato3732842 1y agoYour comment is a slight of hand. Yes it "works" but it is an MVP. Everywhere it's rolled out people say yes it drives, but it drives like a rookie that can follow the rules but doesn't have any of the predictive power that every driver who doesn't suck has some of. Like for example how traffic will often modulate its spacing or time its lane changes to reduce issues with merging or exiting traffic and certain intersections with most traffic doing the same thing become an efficient repetitive cycle, Waymo doesn't "get it". So it works, in the same way a newly licensed teenager "works". It's no cabbie. Edit: It's been over a year since I've ridden in one. Good to hear it's potentially better now.
- sixhobbits 1y agoAfter taking both Uber and Waymo in San Francisco I think I disagree with this. Only caught a few so maybe I didn't see the bad sides, but from what I saw it was able to predict flows and navigate far more smoothly than humans in many situations. Really comfortable and overall safe feeling ride. It's different than human drivers for sure, but to me at least it's better. I agree with MVP part, my understanding is that there's still a lot of Wizard of Oz stuff in terms of regularly mapping and remapping its routes and having a lot of human operators remotely checking and maybe controlling the fleet, but I'm impressed personally.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Everywhere it's rolled out people say yes it drives, but it drives like a rookie When did you last update this hypothesis? The Waymos I’ve been in creep, honk and modulate their aggressiveness quite naturally. In the cities they operate in, they’re a premium product to cabs. The part where you’re right is on freeways. But my point is that tends to be ignored when folks gatekeep “real” autonomy. Instead, it’s some random peculiarity of their city which humans traverse at low speeds. Exactly the thing Waymo has mastered.
- minwcnt5 1y ago> People say yes it drives, but it drives like a rookie I think you just made this up. Almost every anecdote I've heard, and I spend a lot of time in two cities where it's launched, is that "it drives better than most humans". Which is exactly how I would characterize it too. It doesn't drive exactly like a human. But for every subtle human behavior it doesn't do, there are probably several things it does much more skillfully than a human.
- IshKebab 1y ago> This is said every time. Sure, but in terms of traffic difficulty they've done like level 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and now they're jumping to 100! This is different. It's not the most difficult place to drive (good luck in India, Turkey, southern Italy, etc.), but it's still far more challenging than any American city. And it needs fundamentally new capabilities like being able to negotiate with other drivers visually and read implicit signals. You can't do it all just by following what the traffic lights say.
- xnx 1y ago> it needs fundamentally new capabilities like being able to negotiate with other drivers visually and read implicit signal This is also important in the US and is a capability the Waymo Driver has. > it's still far more challenging than any American city. How would you rate the difficult of London vs. Boston?
- eszed 1y agoI've driven extensively in both, and London's hands-down more challenging°. Boston drivers are significantly more aggressive, though, so Waymo might find the reverse. I dunno. —— °Which makes it more fun: I love driving in London, but I'm a weirdo. My biggest regret about my last / first visit to Delhi is that I let my wife talk me out of driving. It may indeed have been a prudent choice, but I think I was there long enough to "get" enough to manage next time.