4 ms·
US Dept of Interior denies canceling largest solar project after axing review
- kdkwlapfjdlaj 1y ago[flagged]
- jameslk 1y ago> my guess is that they want to collect bribes (sorry, 'presidential library donations') Green account, making an off-topic comment about partisan conspiracies… and it’s voted to the top
- Larrikin 1y agoIs it a conspiracy if companies are paying it?
- jameslk 1y agoAre these specific companies paying for said bribes? Or is it still guesses?
- 8note 1y agoshouldn't you expect that they havent paid the bribe?
- rootusrootus 1y agoIt is a conspiracy as long as evidence is not forthcoming.
- golden-face 1y agoGreen account myself, it's an older code, sir, but it checks out.
- mrdoops 1y agoSolar is great but the bottleneck is on battery capacity to carry those noon hours into evening for peak usage. Last I checked we had plenty of lithium and are mostly held back on refinement.
- _factor 1y agoDiscarded EV batteries with 70% life remaining seem like a viable path to energy storage for households.
- vlan0 1y agoI hope we see this more at the municipal level. Just thinking about dense neighborhoods with sizable lithium storage solutions raises eyebrows. One house fire could spread so quickly.
- nradov 1y agoIt's tough to turn that into a scalable, sustainable business. There are so many different types of EV battery packs and you can't just pull one out of an old car and hang it on someone's garage wall. You would typically have to break the old pack down, test the individual cells, and use them to construct a new pack. This is such a labor intensive process that it might not really be cost effective.
- specialist 1y agoYa, I'm unclear how old EV battery packs are being repurposed, at scale. Maybe someone's gathering up identical packs, eg a specific generations of Tesla Model 3 packs, and turning just those into power walls or grid storage. That said, methinks since battery recycling tech has scaled up ahead of demand, it's cheaper and faster to extract the misc minerals and make new, much much better, batteries (for grid storage). I'm noob, so really wouldn't know. I guess we'll see.
- polski-g 1y agoNew sodium battery tech just came out, allegedly 1/10 the price.
- breadwinner 1y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45553487 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45553487
- renewiltord 1y ago[flagged]
- FridayoLeary 1y agoOne article brought quite a lot of complaints from conservationists over the project which i find ironic. As someone else here said if rules exist they should be applied equally to everyone. In this case the biden administration suspended them in order to help the project and now they are being reinstated.
- bawolff 1y agoI don't see why its so ironic. The environment isn't a binary. Its a complex system where the same thing can have both good and bad effects on different parts. Conservationists aren't climate change scientists. They are both going to be focused on the separate parts of the environment they specialize in.
- FridayoLeary 1y agoWe can evaluate if these projects as a net positive or negative for the enviroment. The enviroment can be divided into local and wider. Which is why i'm suspicious of how good electric cars are for example. If this project will wreak havoc on the local enviroment that is certainly very important and the irony of the situation is that it is getting sidelined in favour of broader enviromental concerns. I don't know what respective weights to attach to them, but the cynic in me says that washington prefers a big project which has better optics, then more local concerns.
- jjk166 1y agoConservation and environmentalism are two different things. Preventing a particular population of turtles from being disrupted is conservation, reducing smog in a city is environmentalism. Their goals may overlap, and many people who care about the environment also care about the things that live in those environments, but their goals may at times be at odds. Delaying the implementation of a solar plant, which helps reduce pollution at the expense of consuming a small area of land, is a perfect example.
- noitpmeder 1y agoSo did they cancel it or didn't they? If they deny doing it, what blocks the project from continuing?
- renewiltord 1y agoWhat blocks the project from continuing is the local environmental lobby and the national environmental lobby that has pushed for laws like NEPA that the group of projects was exempted from requiring individual approvals for. Effectively the project required the exemption that allows them to group things together because regulation that some environmentalists lobbied for that is supported by the majority of environmentalists in America is used by some environmentalists to block all projects. Consequently, the cost for the projects is high and the certainty of their completion is low. These make the projects risky. The federal government revoked this exemption so that the projects have to go through the same environmental review as every other project, because that is what many environmentalists have argued for and the most powerful environmentalists have won. Therefore many things are simultaneously true: * the dept of the interior did not cancel the projects * they returned them to normal conditions * normal conditions make the projects hard to do * they de-facto canceled them by making them hard to do
- more_corn 1y agoNo silly. They just canceled the PERMIT for the project. The developers are welcome to resubmit seven separate applications in the future which will all be processed at snail’s pace and the arbitrarily canceled again.
- remarkEon 1y agoWhy can't we just build reactors. Solar requires a ton of physical acreage (sorry, it's just true), plus all the battery storage and transmission and so on. Of course this requires some byzantine "environmental review" (ironic). I just want us to build reactors. We are going to look back on the 20th century anti-nuclear crusade with such disdain, it's really really sad.