4 ms·
"If medical errors were a disease, they would be the sixth leading cause of death in America—just behind accidents and ahead of Alzheimer's." This is wrong, it
by Alex3917 14y ago
"If medical errors were a disease, they would be the sixth leading cause of death in America—just behind accidents and ahead of Alzheimer's."
This is wrong, it's at least the third leading cause of death. And realistically if you don't smoke and you exercise once in a while, medical 'oopsy daisies' are probably your #1 risk of death:
C.f. The IOM's report To Err is Human: http://wps.pearsoneducation.nl/wps/media/objects/13902/14236351/H%2007_To%20Err%20Is%20Human.pdf http://wps.pearsoneducation.nl/wps/media/objects/13902/14236...
And then also read Lucian Leape's commentary in JAMA on why it is probably a huge underestimate: http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=192842 http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=192842
(Leape is one of the authors of the original IOM report, and the report cites a lot of his own research, including his study estimating that only 5% of medical errors are ever discovered.)
C.f. also Barbara Starfield's estimate in JAMA: http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=192908#REF-JCO00061-1 http://jama.jamanetwork.com/article.aspx?articleid=192908#RE...
Realistically, all of these estimates are at the low end. In fact most of them only count deaths in hospitals (and severely undercount them), when at least half of all medical errors are thought to happen at local doctors offices, plastic surgery clinics, nursing homes, etc.
C.f. also the CDC figures for Hospital Acquired Infections, which IIRC the IOM report doesn't count as being medical errors:
http://www.cdc.gov/HAI/pdfs/hai/infections_deaths.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/HAI/pdfs/hai/infections_deaths.pdf
My personal rule of thumb is to avoid taking any drugs or getting any non-trivial medical procedure unless I've read at least three books about it. The problem is that all the papers published in medical journals are basically complete bullshit (except the occasional well-done NIH ones), which means if you want real information about a given drug then the only way to get it is to subpoena the FDA, or read a book written by someone who has.
The way drug approval works is that you need 2 tests demonstrating that the drug is better than a placebo, but you're allowed infinite tries to get there. So often a drug will be better than a placebo in only 2 out of 10 trials, but it will still get approved and only those two trials will get published in medical journals. And then those journal articles will have very little in common with the actual data from the FDA trials because the pharma companies completely spin it, which is why the vast majority of the most popularly prescribed drugs are not only no more effective than placebos, but in fact significantly worse when you look at the total quality/length of life.
- grueful 14y agoI think one of the major turning points in the future will be to trigger a "space race" which makes a grand project of developing substantive improvements to medical care and quality of life. There have been significant improvements here motivated by e.g. battlefield medicine, and great results out of academic or humanitarian labs, but much of our current work is stuck in a loop between patents and the FDA approval process. Good intentions aside, the system acts to motivate certain patterns of action in order to stay profitable and continue growing year-to-year which aren't optimal for our long-range interests. How one would go about motivating such a grand project - I have no idea. Perhaps it's a matter of continuing to make such small improvements as we can until the system is primed for one giant leap. The road of progress was never a well-paved or straight one except in hindsight. I think that small teams and open sharing of knowledge are both key ingredients. The amount of resources currently in play in medicine is staggering, but social systems tend to lose efficiency very quickly as they scale. Perhaps startup culture will be a key piece in making this happen, but the timescales involved in speculative medical research tend to be beyond the scope of the typical VC-backed endeavor.
- gcb 14y agoTo get rid of this rationale read any of the many Nietzsche biographies.
- derleth 14y ago> a "space race" which makes a grand project of developing substantive improvements to medical care and quality of life. How about a "space race" to destroy destructive nonsense like homeopathy, anti-vaccine idiocy, reiki, and all of the other non-scientific crap people try to use instead of real medicine. Getting rid of quackademic medicine would be a good first step. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quackademic_medicine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quackademic_medicine http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/quackademic-medicine-trickles-out-to-community/ http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/index.php/quackademic-me...
- grueful 14y agoI'm all for that. The key problem is defining it. There exist historical examples of quackery which wasn't, e.g. hand washing. Stricter rules about null hypothesis testing would be a start, but the bigger problem is one of education. We're still plagued by government that gives the nod to creationism and horrifically distorted sex ed in public schools. I'd like to say we've become empirical enough about what practices we place belief in that we could just treat all cases of quackery as malicious fraud - but the very prevalence of such issues tends to support the opposite conclusion.