4 ms·
New England's last coal plant has stopped operating, according to its owners
- toomuchtodo 1y agohttps://www.gem.wiki/Merrimack_Station https://www.gem.wiki/Merrimack_Station
- 3eb7988a1663 1y agoBefore anyone jumps the gun and says this is a political move, this is quite likely just economics. Peak coal was in 2007, and has been falling rapidly since. We are currently generating about 1/3 the electricity from coal in 2023 vs 2007[0]. [0] https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-in-the-us.php https://www.eia.gov/energyexplained/electricity/electricity-...
- not2b 1y agoYes, natural gas is now cheaper than coal for power generation, and solar has become much cheaper. Even disregarding environmental concerns, it's just not a good choice any more.
- ericd 1y agoI'm curious, in case anyone knows, how much of the economic disadvantage of coal is because of environmental reg compliance versus other, more fundamental costs?
- eru 1y agoWell, if you want to answer that question, you probably also need to figure out the hypothetical cost of the other power sources minus environmental regulations. Nuclear would be (and used to be) massively cheaper, before regulations went wild against it. I'm deliberately saying 'went wild', because the earlier nuclear power generation that was built to saner standards also has turned out to be incredibly safe already. (Basically, anyone who avoided insane Soviet bullshit had safe nuclear power, as measured in eg fatalities per Joule of electricity generated.)
- juliankauai 1y agoExcept of course, Fukushima. Or any nuclear plant that gets hit by tsunami, earthquake, terrorism,or other natural disaster.
- yobbo 1y agoWere there any deaths from the Fukushima nuclear disaster? A large area was evacuated and "human costs" were great. But as I recall, no deaths from radiation.
- Gibbon1 1y agoPeople whose metabolic reserve is low often die when you stress them. I saw a study claiming 440 excess deaths from the Los Angeles fires. I'll make an assumption that permanently moving old and health impaired people from the Fukushima exclusion zone had a similar increase in mortality. And then a bit of looking leads me to this. "The evacuation itself also was not without severe consequences. The accident was in the winter, and the evacuation of 840 patients or elderly people in nursing homes and health-care facilities apparently resulted in 60 immediate deaths due to hypothermia, dehydration, trauma and deterioration of serious medical conditions (Tanigawa et al 2012) and upwards of 100 deaths in subsequent month" https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0952-4746/33/3/497 https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/0952-4746/33/3/49... Like the Grapes of Wrath where the family starts out for California and the grandparents both die on the way.
- LarsAlereon 1y agoIt looks like the top-end estimate is that the Fukushima disaster may have caused up to 500 additional total lifetime deaths from cancer. Roughly 23,000 people per year died of diseases attributed to coal power plants in the United States alone from 1999-2020. Edit: Changed "linked to" to "attributed to", because this is the estimated count of people who would not have died of disease if coal power plants were not running.
- pfdietz 1y ago
- LarsAlereon 1y agoI think it's primarily a fundamental cost issue. It's simply far cheaper to get an equivalent amount of energy from fracking a natural gas formation than having to literally dig coal out of the ground.
- pragmatic 1y agoYou can't put coal in a pipeline. You have to physically handle every piece of coal. Extract, load ship, unload. Natural gas is shooting out of the ground in North Dakota. You can compare to wind and solar also. The economics aren't favorable.
- pfdietz 1y ago> You can't put coal in a pipeline. Yes you can! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_pipeline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coal_pipeline A slurry is transported in one variety of these. The trick is to induce a swirl in the flow, so even though particles are constantly falling out of suspension, they stay suspended. It's mathematically analogous to how putting a twist in magnetic field lines in a tokamak (or stellarator) prevents ExB effects from driving the plasma into the wall, as they would in just a plain toroidal magnetic field. Lots of water is needed and drying the coal before burning it adds cost.
- myrmidon 1y agoReally interesting, thanks for the link! Acre-feet as a unit just made me realize how many options you get for volume with multiple base units (a foot-mile-inch is ~12m³ in case anyone was wondering). The non-metric system continues to impress (not in a good way)!
- xbmcuser 1y agoCoal requires manual labour and mining so even without environmental regulations it's expensive. In the US coal use decrease had very little to do with environmental factors most of it was because fracking brought in cheap natural gas and pushed coal out.
- jhallenworld 1y agoIts does, but you should see the machines they use for coal mining these days, particularly in Wyoming. A giant strip mine seems to require like 20 workers, but with giant trucks and excavators. Even for underground mines, check out the massive longwall mining machines they use- it's kind of astonishing. They pretty much take all the coal. I think this is lost in the political talk about protecting mining jobs- the main original competition is more efficient mining operations. Anyway, it really says something that natural gas and solar are cheaper than coal given this context.
- fragmede 1y agoYou should see this one! https://youtu.be/azEvfD4C6ow https://youtu.be/azEvfD4C6ow It's a bit dated (completed in 1978) and cost approximately $100 million. At one point it was the heaviest land vehicle, clocking in at 13,500 tons. It's since been succeded, but this bucket-wheel excavator needed only five people to operate. Those five people could mine 240,000 tons of coal[8] or 240,000 cubic metres of overburden (rock/soil on top of the coal) per day. That's 2400 coal wagons! After totally tapping out all of the coal at the Tagebau Hambach mine, in 2001, it took a crew of 70 together to move it 14 miles to the next mine. This move cost 15 million German Marks. (Just watch the linked documentary.)
- thelastgallon 1y agoThats the wrong question. The question to ask is what is the death rates per unit of electricity production: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-production-per-twh https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-from-energy-p... Coal beats everything else by a mile. We also get mercury pollution for free, so no more eating fish.
- ericd 1y agoI'm not a coal proponent, just trying to understand the veracity of an argument that I think R's make sometimes (that coal isn't economically viable primarily because state regs make it too expensive).
- chris_va 1y ago(disclaimer that I manage a climate&energy research group) Most of the comments here are speculative. The TLDR is that coal plants have trouble ramping their production up/down quickly, unlike natural gas which can do so in minutes. So, if you have a grid that is being thrashed by variable production (renewables), this results in variable pricing and demand for baseload. Coal cannot economically compete in that market (and neither can nuclear, which has the same problem).
- mrDmrTmrJ 1y agoGiven that renewable power power is self correlated (all the solar panels are producing at once - or they’re not, all the wind turbines are turning at once - or they’re not) - renewable energy leads to low prices when it’s produced and high prices when it’s not. Why not put massive, grid scale batteries “behind the meter” at a nuclear or coal plant to enable continual production but only sell power when prices are high and store power when prices are low?
- soni96pl 1y agoOnce you have batteries you may do so with solar or wind
- ericd 1y agoYeah, but sometimes the intermittency is pretty extreme, and you can get away with significantly less overpaneling and storage if you have a mix of power sources. Not many experts advocate for 100% renewables.
- pfdietz 1y agoRight; batteries aren't really suitable for the low frequency part of the supply/demand mismatch. Daily storage, great, perhaps up to 1 week, but lower frequencies they are increasingly expensive. But there are other storage ideas that do much better for that. For example, burning an e-fuel like hydrogen, or ultra low capex thermal storage.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- monero-xmr 1y agohttps://www.eia.gov/dashboard/newengland/overview https://www.eia.gov/dashboard/newengland/overview Solar makes up 4% of New England electricity. Not much sun there. Needs nuclear to succeed
- toomuchtodo 1y agoUnlikely. The ISO has 3.5GW of solar and nuclear capacity equally (I’m aware of capacity factor of solar vs nuclear, but the ISO also reports ~6GW of behind the meter distributed solar which only manifests as reduced demand). The ISO needs more batteries, renewables, and transmission from hydro in Quebec, Canada (1.2GW), but nuclear is not needed to succeed long term and those two generators will eventually be decommissioned, as their license only extends their operating period to ~2050. Twenty five years is plenty of time to replace their 3.5GW of output; 18GW of battery storage, 17GW of wind, and 13.5GW of solar is in the ISO’s interconnect queue or has been proposed by developers. https://www.mainepublic.org/climate/2025-01-03/central-maine-power-aims-to-finish-controversial-western-maine-power-corridor-in-2025 https://www.mainepublic.org/climate/2025-01-03/central-maine... (“Central Maine Power aims to finish controversial western Maine power corridor in 2025”) https://www.mainepublic.org/politics/2023-11-30/documents-reveal-nexteras-hidden-attempts-to-derail-cmps-transmission-line-corridor https://www.mainepublic.org/politics/2023-11-30/documents-re... (NextEra, which owns the Seabrook nuclear power plant in N.H., stands to lose tens of millions of dollars every year if the NECEC comes online and attempted to use political donations to scuttle the Quebec Hydro transmission line) https://www.iberdrola.com/about-us/what-we-do/smart-grids/necec-project-canada-united-states-and-new-england https://www.iberdrola.com/about-us/what-we-do/smart-grids/ne... (“The new transmission line between Quebec and Maine will provide 1,200 megawatts (MW) of renewable hydroelectric power to the New England power grid in Lewiston, Maine, sufficient to meet the demand of 1.2 million homes. Once built, NECEC will be New England's largest renewable energy source, saving customers $190 million per year.”) https://www.iso-ne.com/about/government-industry-affairs/new-england-regional-profile https://www.iso-ne.com/about/government-industry-affairs/new... https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/clean-energy/northeast-heat-wave-solar-battery-benefits https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/clean-energy/northeast-... https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/zone/US-NE-ISNE/live/fifteen_minutes https://app.electricitymaps.com/map/zone/US-NE-ISNE/live/fif... (Quebec, interestingly, has ~40GW of hydro generation capacity)
- indymike 1y agoIncluding regulatory and litigation expenses, this is simply not true. That said, coal is very dirty and is not the best choice for power generation because of pollution. Coal is pretty cheap, and it's take most of my lifetime to change the cost through regulation, litigation and lawmaking.
- KevinMS 1y agoNE is starved for natural gas. They replaced the coal plants with gas and didn't bother to build enough pipelines (and even blocked them). We are getting a lot of our gas from Tankers from Europe and even Russia before the war. So now NE has nearly the highest electricity costs in the country even though we're not far away from some of the most abundant natural gas in the planet.
- juliankauai 1y agoTrump just closed the already approved largest solar power project in the US. That’s political. I’m all for fusion but we need power now for the transition. Losing the solar project for 3 million people is a big loss. it takes a long time to get any type of big power up to speed.
- recursive 1y agoI understand the problem is transmission much more than generation. There's a backlog of power sources waiting to come online for infrastructure to catch up. Or so I heard.
- mulmen 1y agoWhere did you hear this?
- recursive 1y agoI believe it was an episode of the podcast "Shift Key". Season 2, episode 5 is called "A Beginner's Guide to the Interconnection Queue". The hosts talk to some industry people who present the case. They say that there practical reasons why the interconnection queue is slowing down renewable generation deployment significantly. I don't know if this podcast presents a balanced view, but it sounds convincing to me.
- dalyons 1y agoTransmission wasn’t the problem with this project. It was cancelled out of spite
- rat87 1y agoits an economic move but it would be good not bad if it were a political move coal is bad and we should be moving away from it faster
- fsckboy 1y ago>Before anyone jumps the gun and says this is a political move, this is quite likely just economics. Before anyone jumps the gun and says this is likely economics, RTFA at least a few paragraphs: Granite Shore Power, the company that owns the coal plant in Bow, New Hampshire, said they ceased commercial operations September 12th, about a year and a half since they announced they would retire their facility by 2028 as part of a settlement agreement with environmental groups.
- kstenerud 1y agoIt's going to be a mix of both. If it were massively profitable, they'd just pay up whatever they need to, get whatever influential politicians on their side, do a bunch of marketing, and then continue operations.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- nielsbot 1y agoIs a settlement agreement w/ environmental groups considered political?
- kccqzy 1y agoCalifornia will also soon stop using coal. Currently there's just one coal generating station left, in Utah.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoCalifornia Will Stop Using Coal as a Power Source Next Month - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45567645 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45567645 - October 2025
- aquova 1y agoUnless "coal generating station" means something in particular, this isn't true at all, there's around 200 coal power plants in the US
- smelendez 1y agoThey mean station powering California, not in the US overall.
- ericd 1y agoSadly, still quite a lot in PJM, the highest power usage grid in the nation (DC region): https://www.eia.gov/electricity/gridmonitor/dashboard/electric_overview/balancing_authority/PJM https://www.eia.gov/electricity/gridmonitor/dashboard/electr...
- thehappypm 1y agoThere actually is some coal in New England, and if there was (for some reason) a desire for New England to be energy independent, coal might be part of the mix as a result. This article discusses some less-successful attempts to get into that coal.. and it’s delightful to see the date of its publication. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/massachusetts-coal-1853-04-09/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/massachusetts-coa...
- cwal37 1y agoSecond US organized market to do so, and third in the region, after NY(ISO) and Ontario (IESO). With HQ there as well, it’s actually quite a large coal-free chunk of grid. What will be interesting is the extent to which offshore wind and imports from HQ will be able to materialize according to plan. OSW is having a hatchet being taken to it in the US currently, and imports from HQ into NY and NE have been way down recently while big new lines are also built. Not exactly in the ISO forecasts, but very much supported by state policy has been the rapid expansion of behind the meter solar in New England. Really taken the edge off of summer days in particular, although also susceptible to smoke from Canadian wildfires. Not the most exciting markets day-to-day, but interesting long-term things happening.
- bobthepanda 1y agoFor those who have trouble parsing this HQ is HydroQuebec.
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoMeanwhile, just last week: Climate goals go up in smoke as US datacenters turn to coal https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45545277 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45545277
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- fujigawa 1y agoOverall this isn't the W you think it is; New England still leads the nation in heating oil consumption by a large margin. Nearly 2M households in New England heat their homes with oil (usually boiler, sometimes furnace). For those unfamiliar, a tanker truck comes by your house every couple of months and pumps diesel fuel into a tank down cellar, which literally gets burned like a flamethrower to boil water to heat your home. It's dirty but keeps your home toasty warm when it's -20 outside. Maine in particular has very little natural gas infrastructure. Electric is impractical as New England winters are cold as balls and the houses are usually old and not that well insulated.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 1y agoHeat pumps (they work down to -10F, and can be supplemented with fossil or wood heating, if needed). https://www.nhpr.org/new-england-news/2024-07-24/new-england-states-win-450-million-to-launch-heat-pump-adoption-program https://www.nhpr.org/new-england-news/2024-07-24/new-england... https://portal.ct.gov/deep/energy/new-england-heat-pump-accelerator https://portal.ct.gov/deep/energy/new-england-heat-pump-acce...
- pfdietz 1y agoEven if powered by gas combined cycles generators, heat pumps use less natural gas than a gas-fired condensing furnace.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoIn my experience, sometimes the heat pump cannot keep up with the rate of envelope heat loss below certain temperatures (think a mid January polar vortex with sustained temperatures under -10F for days in the Midwest). Also, loss of power will mean loss of heat, where at least with a fossil gas furnace, as long as you have enough power to ignite the burners and run the blower, you’ve got heat (I’ve been able to run this with a vehicle inverter on an EV and a “suicide” extension cord with male plugs on both ends, isolating the furnace circuit; would’ve been perfect if it could’ve generated its own power for the blower while consuming fossil gas for heating). Looking for a self sustaining cogeneration unit that can produce heat and power if needed, if anyone has recommendations, for when I need to recommend it. Heat pump whenever possible, but backups when needed.
- deepnotderp 1y agoYay for fracking! Yay for natural gas!
- zackkatz 1y agoUnfortunately (and unbelievably!), Massachusetts still burns trash. > There are more than 100 municipal waste combustion facilities in operation across the United States. Five of these are located in Massachusetts. https://www.mass.gov/guides/municipal-waste-combustors https://www.mass.gov/guides/municipal-waste-combustors
- jcranmer 1y agoWhat's wrong with burning trash? It means there's much less material to send to landfills, plus it's one of the most economical ways to recycle metal from household waste streams.
- jabl 1y ago'Old school' trash burning can produce quite nasty emissions. Not much of an issue with modern plants that burn at higher temperature and have some amount of flue gas filtering etc. Certainly beats landfilling and producing that same power by burning fossil fuels.
- nielsbot 1y agoFTA: > In Maine, a paper mill burns coal to power their own operations. I guess burning coal is cheaper than buying power from the grid and installing solar would be a huge outlay? But this sentence just sounds crazy to me in 2025.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]