7 ms·
Tariffs Are Way Up. Interest on Debt Tops $1T. and Doge Didn't Do Much
https://archive.ph/JsFlD https://archive.ph/JsFlD
- kelnos 1y ago(Can't read the article due to paywall and no working mirror on archive.is right now.) I mean... duh? This shouldn't be news to anyone paying attention. DOGE was shock-and-awe theater, and a means to shake up agencies and gain access to sensitive information. At best, they saved a few tens of millions of dollars, which at that level isn't really worth the effort. The GOP always cries about spending and the deficit, but when they're in charge, they spend just as much as Democrats (if not more!), and, to make things worse, cut taxes (usually for the rich more than anyone else). The largest part of the federal budget isn't the discretionary spending, anyway. And the effects of the tariffs have been obvious to anyone not drinking the MAGA Kool-Aid.
- downrightmike 1y agoAnything DOGE "saved" was quickly burned by punching cities in the nose, trying to get a rise out of them.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mikestew 1y agoAs long as I’ve been alive, the biggest deficit hawks (read: Republicans) are the biggest spenders when it’s their turn on power.
- walkabout 1y agoThey keep cutting taxes, too. That's a big part of the problem. A space alien newly arrived on Earth and looking at just actions taken, GAO/CBO reports, and the actual historical data, would conclude that, at least since 1980, Democrats were the ones who cared (a lot) more about the budget deficit than Republicans. The notion that voting for Republicans is the best move for a voter whose major issue is the deficit, is just marketing.
- FeloniousHam 1y agoThere was a time, probably before Reagan came to office, that the cutting/reforming taxes yielded positive returns. But fifty years on, the high-hanging fruit has all been picked. This is widely acknowledged by "true conservatives" (takes one to know one). Everything goes to the debt, the only way out is through cuts to entitlements or broadly raising taxes, both deeply unpopular.
- toast0 1y ago> The GOP always cries about spending and the deficit, but when they're in charge, they spend just as much as Democrats (if not more!), and, to make things worse, cut taxes (usually for the rich more than anyone else). The largest part of the federal budget isn't the discretionary spending, anyway. IMHO, the GOP wants to reduce government spending for ideological reasons, but doesn't generally have any particular thing it wants to reduce spending on, and certainly doesn't want to take the blame for cutting any particular programs. So they do a tax cut, because voters like tax cuts; and chances are Democrats will be in power when the deficit / debt gets big enough that it needs to be addressed. Then Democrats will have to do the poor PR business of raising taxes or making specific cuts. If Democrats make specific cuts to reduce government spending in order to make the lower taxes work, the GOP furthered their ideology and got good vibes for lowering taxes, while the Democrats got bad vibes for cutting programs. I don't like it, but it works for the GOP, so I'm sure we'll see it continue.
- baal80spam 1y ago[flagged]
- standardUser 1y ago[flagged]
- imglorp 1y agoYes, a heist. But why? For Palantir? Russia? To hold for attacking party enemies later?
- standardUser 1y agoI optimistically hope it was just more tech company data mining, except in a particularly vile way. But there's always the chance it gets used for a lot more than targeted ads.
- smt88 1y ago> But why? For Palantir? Russia? To hold for attacking party enemies later? The simplest explanation is that they stole it for xAI. Given DOGE employees' ties to Russia and Musk's ties (mostly through debt) to both Russia and Saudi Arabia, I could believe either of those countries benefited.
- Esophagus4 1y agoThis seems like attributing to malice what could be attributed to incompetence. It seems more plausible after reading the ProPublica article that they were swinging hammers in the dark trying to find evidence of “fraud” or other political point scoring grifts. Combined with reckless incompetence. I’m skeptical that the simplest explanation is that they stole it for xAI or Russia, I think that requires proof.
- sys_64738 1y agoThis data is out there in the wild now and can never be put back in the bottle. All the DOGE bros will hopefully be rounded up and jailed for many decades. We also need Musk to serve jail time.
- syndacks 1y ago
- miguelxt 1y agoGift link: https://www.wsj.com/economy/federal-budget-fiscal-2025-e8d21595?st=FVmLm8&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink https://www.wsj.com/economy/federal-budget-fiscal-2025-e8d21...
- throitallaway 1y agoColor me surprised. DOGE didn't touch the #1 candidate (defense spending) so it shows you where their priorities were.
- elcritch 1y ago> 1. Tariffs are bringing in real money. > The U.S. collected $195 billion in customs duties, more than double the prior year. That doesn’t capture the full jump because tariff rates only ramped up in April, halfway through the year. That's actually more than I expected. > President Trump seeks to shift the government’s reliance on income taxes toward taxes on imported goods. Still, tariffs contribute a relatively small 3.7% of overall federal revenue, compared with 51% for the individual income tax. We really need to close large ccorporate tax dodges as well. Too many smaller companies pay 35% rates while the Apples and NVIDIAs pay a fraction of that rate. There's apparently plenty enough corporation money sloshing around to spend trillions on GPUs for AI in the US.
- mullingitover 1y agoThe tariffs don't actually bring in money, they just move money from one place (US taxpayers, who'd otherwise use it productively) and put it elsewhere (the treasury). Now normally this might be put to some sensible use, perhaps building infrastructure, but since this revenue is being used to offset huge tax cuts for a tiny group of people determined to turn around and use the capital for (let's be real here) speculation it's a net negative. In the end we're going to look back at this chapter of 'Devil Take the Hindmost: A History of Financial Speculation' and say "Well obviously those idiots should've see that coming."
- jtbayly 1y agoTo say that tariffs don't actually bring in money is simply wrong. We are talking about income to the government. Yes, tariffs take actual money and give it to the government. It doesn't matter where it came from, inside or outside the US. If your definitions are used, then literally nothing actually brings in money. It just moves it from one place to another.
- ivape 1y agoIt's going to be the biggest heist in American history. That tariff revenue is as good as gone. It's not about whether the money can actually be brought in, but more about the reality that crooks have access to the pot. It's really all about that. These are not fiscal conservatives generating revenue to pay down debt, these are actual crooks that will gift it to each other.
- jjtheblunt 1y agofrom paragraph 1: "That is largely because the main drivers of spending kept rising: social programs, including Social Security and Medicare, and interest on the public debt, which topped $1 trillion by one measure for the first time."
- BugsJustFindMe 1y agoIt sure would be nice if, instead of cutting taxes for the ultra-wealthy, that money being given back to the people who need it the absolute least were instead used to reduce the public debt. And how much money did DOGE spend on its quest to save nothing by trashing scientific research?
- InTheArena 1y agoThis is a problem that is far far older then DOGE. And maybe, just maybe, the answer is to both raise taxes and reduce spending?
- danaris 1y agoThe thing is, the most common spending that they attempt to cut is spending that has multiplier effects on the economy, because it's giving money (whether directly or indirectly) to the poorest people.
- InTheArena 1y agoReally? Please provide a decline in net dollars (excluding projected drawdowns) that demonstrates this point. On a dollar-by-dollar basis, regardless of economic station, _every_ American has seen a combined discretionary + non-discretionary increase in benefits since 1980. The group that is less advantaged is the upper-middle class, which has seen relative stagnation.
- wilg 1y agoOf course that's the answer, it's just people don't want to do that.
- cowpig 1y ago[flagged]
- gruez 1y ago>They managed to bury the FBI report on the matter under a Bill Barr "no collusion" memo. Yet the Biden administration couldn't turn up anything in 4 years?
- cowpig 1y agoIf I'm understanding correctly, you are implying that there was a Biden Administration-led investigation on foreign interference that did not surface evidence? Is that true? Where should I start to learn more about that?
- gruez 1y agoMy point is that there was the Muller Report, which was scathing but apparently not scathing enough for the you. If Democrats thought there was more stuff that was "buried", they could have easily did their own investigations in the 4 years they were in power. The fact that they didn't suggests there probably aren't more bombshell left, contrary to your implication that there might be. Absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence, but at the same time we shouldn't give any weight to unsubstantiated allegations that there's shady stuff going on and that it was "buried" by previous administrations.
- billy99k 1y ago[flagged]
- cowpig 1y agoWere you aware that Paul Manafort, the chair of Donald Trump's 2016 election commission, was convicted of conspiracy against the United States and conspiracy to obstruct justice? He was serving a jail sentence until he was pardoned by Donald Trump.
- thinkcontext 1y agoThe only serious attempt I've seen to address US budget issues was the Simpson-Bowles Commission under Obama in 2010. It recommended a menu of tax increases and benefit reductions. It was promptly ignored by Congress which was not surprising. As an exercise it was useful just to demonstrate what a serious proposal would have to look like and the nature of compromise that would be needed. Of course, in the 15 years since the fiscal situation has gotten worse, so any of the recommendations it made then would need to be more severe now. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Commission_on_Fiscal_Responsibility_and_Reform https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Commission_on_Fiscal_...
- BugsJustFindMe 1y agoWhat are your thoughts on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_Budget_Reconciliation_Act_of_1993 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_Budget_Reconciliation_... ?
- voxl 1y agoAny budget proposal that cuts Medicare or social security is dead in the water and it's ridiculous for any group to even consider it. Not only would it be political suicide but it would also literally kill people.
- mullingitover 1y agoSocial security lives in a parallel universe to the budget, so they could cancel the program entirely and it wouldn't affect the deficit. Mixing it up with the regular budget is a way to confuse people into being open to killing it, a long-term goal of the cadre of financial geniuses who brought us The Great Depression. Medicare is another story, and until the US has a come to Jesus moment on single payer healthcare and confronting the regulatory capture in healthcare it will only get worse.
- walkabout 1y ago> Social security lives in a parallel universe to the budget, so they could cancel the program entirely and it wouldn't affect the deficit. 100% true, if you're operating in sane-world where anything makes sense. Here in insane world, my pet theory is that, given another year (maybe two, they might wait until after the midterms, assuming they hold on to congress) we're going to see an attempt to nullify the government debt owned by Social Security by converting it into some convoluted scheme involving crypto-backed-by-the-stock-market or something. Ta-da, debt reduced, deficit reduced (by the amount of interest on the debt owned by the trust fund)! Plus sooooo many opportunities to steal. This'll kill the program stone-dead, but it'll take a little while. Kinda like how they already killed Obamacare by removing the individual mandate, and they're just waiting for the death-spiral to hit bottom so they can declare the program a failure and proof that we should never try to fix healthcare in any kind of actually-decent way again.
- churchill 1y agoRight from the start, any impartial observer could tell that it wasn't a sincere effort grounded in truth. First, the goal of the tariffs was to reduce US deficit spending. Then it was reducing debt. Isolating & containing China. Dissuading them from invading Taiwan. Replacing the income tax. Retaliating against Europe, Japan, & S. Korea for unfair trade practices. Compelling other countries to buy American. Onshoring manufacturing. Forcing foreigners to pay a premium to access American markets. Forcing Canada & Mexico to get illegal immigration & narcotics trafficking under control. Punishing Brazil for persecuting Bolsonaro. Compelling third countries to accept expelled immigrants. Then they pivoted to: Art of the Deal! He's deliberately making unrealistic demands as an intro offer. Which is it again?!
- black_13 1y ago[dead]
- InTheArena 1y agoSome intellectual curiosity: If tariff revenue is rising, and the economy hasn’t shrunk (yet), and DOGE has returned money (recission later being authorized) then some money was clearly generated. Alternatively, Doge could have been totally ineffectual and tariffs returning nothing, but this article seems to indicate otherwise. This means that less money then planned was spent. Against a null hpothesis, that indicates that the situation is "better" then doing nothing at all (at which point, the rise in government lending costs, the out of control benefit costs, and all of the other stupid crap that has been festering out there since Bill Clinton won the white house for ridiculing Bush for raising taxes comes home to roost. I'm solidly in the never-trump camp, and maybe there was an argument made after the paywall, but this feels like an ideology in search of a headline.
- lesuorac 1y agoWell, the two main counter points are. 1. Doge isn't free. They have staff with expenses which haven't been accounted for in your argument. 2. Cancelation of forward facing contracts shouldn't affect the immediate numbers. But it's like laying off the entire company; you're going to record a record Q4 with all those sales but no expenses however come Q1 good luck for the company. Although people have posted links so you can read the article [1] which largely points out that spending is up by $220 billion. Which is about 2.2 trillion worse than Doge promised. [1]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45530994 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45530994
- IT4MD 1y agoInaccurate headline. DOGE did a lot at government agencies, including violating any and all possible best practices, copying entire databases of citizens, then handling the data in unknown ways. Trust me. DOGE has done a great deal, just none of it is reasonable or sane from our perspective.
- wilg 1y agoIt's very important to realize that it isn't true that DOGE didn't "do much". It's just that what they did was kill hundreds of thousands to millions of people worldwide.
- ramon156 1y agoCan you elaborate? I haven't been keeping up with DOGE
- peterashford 1y agoLots of people have reported on this, but here's the Lancet https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(25)01186-9/fulltext https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6...
- throw10920 1y agoThat study does not take into account the possibility that other countries may increase their foreign aid to compensate, and therefore is useless for making real-world predictions.
- _aobj 1y ago[dead]
- frogperson 1y agoYou really must stop taking Republicans at their word. The stated goals of Doge are obviously different from the actual goals. Try not to listen to their words, only watch their actions. In this case, Doge's actions are to shrink government, especially any agencies that were opposing or investigating Musk in any way.