6 ms·
In-Party Love, Out-Party Hate, and Affective Polarization in Twelve Democracies
- anon291 1y agoGet offline. Meet people. Most people want the same thing. This is honestly crazy that we do this to ourselves
- euroderf 1y agoBut think of all the faux engagement! Think of all the advertising revenue! Won't someone think of the poor shareholders?
- cosmicgadget 1y agoWhat like "prosperity for ourselves and our children"? I think the issues arise when it gets a smidge more nuanced then that.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> the issues arise when it gets a smidge more nuanced then that The issues arise when folks get distracted from common prosperity. I meet so many people in the Rockies and New York who are up in arms about some imaginary problem, or a problem they have no influence over and which cannot affect them, one they solely know about due to social media.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoWhat's that problem? Do we achieve common prosperity through regulation or deregulation? Welfare state or trickle down? Fiscal responsibility or speculation? Strong dollar or weak dollar? Free market or protectionism? The parties (one in particular) can't even keep a consistent policy from year to year, I am not sure how we can hold hands and find the unified path to common prosperity.
- anon291 1y agoWhile all these things matter, I'm not sure what level of business regulation v deregulation causes you to turn to violent rhetoric.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoI thought the topic was "if we talked in person we would realize we have a common objective so things would be fine". Violence is definitely a kind of disagreement but my point was that irl discussions don't solve polarization, i.e. "regulation/deregulation cannot lead us to prosperity". Also plenty of politicians have said regulation is literal communism and literal communism makes a lot of people mad.
- palmfacehn 1y agoSpecifically, it feels like the lack of discernment goes off the rails and falls into the chasm of derangement where people assume that their opponents do not have that common goal. Anti-natalists and population control advocates excluded, most of us do share that goal. The differences are in the proposed approaches. There are legitimate discussions which can be had about those approaches to achieving that common goal. The discussion is no longer in good faith where partisans deny that common goal or assume evil intent.
- weregiraffe 1y agoWhat about the millions of, for example, Muslims, who have a very particular idea of what "prosperity" means? Especially for your female children.
- woooooo 1y agoDo fundamentalist Muslims have a realistic chance of imposing those views on your nation? Because, if not, you Fell For It Again. (Aside, every western Muslim I've personally met has been chill)
- zpeti 1y agoRealistic is a very broad term, but do you think they don’t have an effect? And where you are from matters a lot, you will probably answer very differently if you are from California or if you are from Birmingham UK.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- febusravenga 1y agoIn western Germany, France, UK? Traditionally catholic countries, core of European enlightenment culture. Yes there is small, but realistic chance. That's why right shovinism is rising in eu
- 1y ago
- anon291 1y agoYeah but when you discuss nuances in person rather than online your natural social chemistry in your brain kicks in and we all behave like actual people instead of mindless savages
- cosmicgadget 1y agoWith the downside that it's harder to reference (and look up) sources, and have wide participation or an easily-accessible record. And ultimately you're not going to convince many people to stop voting based on that one book.
- anon7000 1y agoThere are a large number of policy issues the average American should be able to agree on, but have been polarized to the point that we don’t solve them. - Get money out of politics. Everyone complains about corruption, no one tries to do a constitutional amendment to get rid of Citizens United. - Strong privacy protections for your online data. Does anyone like the fact that your data gets sold and then used against you by car insurance companies? - Break up big companies that are taking their power too far. Seriously, take your Syscos, Nestles, AB InBevs of the world and break them up. No company deserves to have that much power over consumer markets, and the centralization of that power definitely makes prices higher. My conservative parents definitely don’t like how when Walmart and Rite Aid came to small-town midewest, all the local drug & grocery stores went out of business. - Every American knows our private health insurance system sucks. I mean every person you meet either doesn’t have good coverage, hasn’t used it much, or has had had a terrible experience with it. - We need to do away with police overstep like asset forfeiture, where the government can basically just rob you. I’m not talking defund the police, but you could sit the average American down, and probably come to agree that the police state has too much power and not enough accountability in a couple areas. There are so many stories along these lines which could get republicans and democrats on a similar page, and it comes down to the frustrations we ALL have with the systems we live in. It doesn’t matter who you voted for, when health insurance starts scamming you out of a procedure you need, it’s frustrating on a deeply personal level. And we all feel like we don’t have much control over federal policy — partly because businesses & moneyed interests can protect their interests while everyone else struggles, no matter who’s in charge. (And btw, this isn’t a elected officials on both sides are the same comment, more of a “we Americans have a lot of shared frustrations regardless of party”
- mock-possum 1y ago- same sex marriage should be treated equally to heterosexual marriage - the tradition of gender being strictly tied to genitalia at birth should be abolished, with individuals able to change gender (and genitals) at their whim Oops Americans don’t agree on queer rights and equality oops - everyone should be treated equally and afford equal protection under the law, regardless of where they were born or what the colour of the skin is or what their genitals look like Oops oops
- obscurette 1y agoUnfortunately it's not that simple any more. There are already very fundamental issues on which we are already very polarized, online or not. One of these is safety for example – far too many people are ready to give up any freedoms in the name of security. Ideas for EU chatcontrol, camera networks etc don't come from some bureaucrats, there is a very broad social demand for this.
- mcny 1y ago> there is a very broad social demand for this I don't believe you. My guess is the demand comes from manufactured consent, not from people who deeply understand the issue.
- ako 1y agoVoters in democracies are usually not people who deeply understand issues. We outsource that to politicians, but politicians have a second agenda, serving the people who paid their campaign.
- Nasrudith 1y agoThe very concept of manufactured consent seems very much projection on Chomsky's part. Very much, 'they don't agree with me but I know what their real interests are so I can speak for them better than they can for themselves' crap to turn the masses into sock puppets to win arguments.
- jdub 1y agoIt's possible you've missed the entire 20th Century and 21st Century thus far, so an exhaustive list of examples would be impractical, but perhaps take a moment to ponder just a couple: - "yellow cake uranium" - "a land without people for a people without a land"
- dragonwriter 1y ago> The very concept of manufactured consent seems very much projection on Chomsky's part Per Chomsky, the co-authored work is more Herman's than his, and anyhow the phrase and concept is from Walter Lipmann, 66 years before Herman and Chomsky's work with the title inspired by it (and 51 years before their first book on the topic.) But, no, neither the idea that deliberate propaganda is a major source of political beliefs or the particular manner and mechanisms by which the US media is involved in delivering that propaganda is "projection". > Very much, 'they don't agree with me but I know what their real interests are so I can speak for them better than they can for themselves' crap Manufacturing Consent doesn't pretend to be an exploration of what the “real interests” of the public are; it can't be misleading "projection" at doing that, because it doesn't do it at all.
- hermannj314 1y agoIf you see yourself in the hegemon, sure. This strategy has also led to horrible brutality against marginal groups.
- protocolture 1y agoLots of people just want to use political processes to hurt their perceived enemies.
- weregiraffe 1y ago>Get offline. Meet people. Most people want the same thing. A lot of people want more freedom. It's easy to identify with this, until you get into details. For example: - Lower taxes. - Easier access to weapons. - Lower age of consent. These are all things that increase freedom, by some definition.
- rapnie 1y agoGo for balanced freedom. Against humanity, and place humanity first.
- weregiraffe 1y agoBut who gets to define humanity?
- spencerflem 1y agoGtfo with this. The problem is not ‘polarization’ it’s that so many people are willingly and knowingly cruel when they get the chance.
- dmichulke 1y agoCruel as in - physically violent, - destructive to others' property, or - expressing negative opinions verbally?
- jasonsb 1y agoNone of the above. Cruel as in manipulating others and taking advantage of others for their own personal gain whenever they get the chance.
- spencerflem 1y agoThey are sending the military into cities to shoot people. ICE prisoners are made to lap water off the floor like dogs. My trans friends are making plans to flee the country in advance of their existence being criminalized
- Muromec 1y agoEU denies asiel requests already filled by trans people from US citing no real threat to safety.
- spencerflem 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- pavlov 1y agoGerman Jews fleeing in 1933-39 couldn’t get asylum in most countries either (including USA). They say shit isn’t bad enough, until it is, and then it’s too late to leave.
- gsf_emergency_4 1y ago>The trends reported from our data generally support Gidron et al.’s (2020) conclusion of a gradual decline of in-party liking
- zwaps 1y agoInteresting in the second graph, the countries which we traditionally consider to be well working societies are those where out-hate has not crossed in-love
- kubb 1y agoDriving polarization is a conscious strategy of leaders and the media (especially a particular large corporate media outlet, which is worldview shaping for a large part of the population), isn’t it? You could argue that the system rewards it in the short term which is all that matters. There’s also one party with way less scruples when it comes to the methods it uses, which polarizes the other party against them. There’s no way to make friends with someone who wants to „take care” of you by violent means.
- skrebbel 1y ago> the system Which system? This article compares 12 countries, which have wildly varying systems.
- kubb 1y agoThe one with the most cultural influence across the western world, whose messaging is parroted by everyone else? Come on let’s not pretend we don’t have a default.
- skrebbel 1y agoI don't know man, in an article that compares 12 countries, writing a comment about one of them without specifying which one is somewhere on the spectrum between plain lazy and American imperialism. Sure we all know which one they mean but it's still a bad comment.
- kubb 1y agoFair criticism.
- naruhodo 1y agoNo analysis of the association of the mass media owners to the political party in or out of power? Traditional media are still political thought leaders. In the US, the media is giving cover to the fascist takeover of government.
- foxes 1y ago[flagged]
- skrebbel 1y agoThey define in-party and out-party very weirdly for multiparty systems like the Netherlands, Denmark and Norway. In NL, if I'm a leftie, I have 3-4 reasonable parties to choose from. Most people voting for any of these parties won't deeply hate any of the other. Similar stuff on the right, or along a conservative/progressive axis. But the authors do this: > Thus, we follow these studies and define the in-party as the party receiving the highest score among all parties rated by the respondent on the party feeling thermometers.4 The out-party measure is drawn from the average of all other parties’ feeling thermometer scores, weighted by their respective vote shares. By mixing all the other parties that aren't the in-party, they mix parties the voter is quite OK with, with parties that the voter deeply and passionately detests. I can't imagine this not skewing the graphs enormously. For example, if you're right wing in NL you get to choose between the anti-Muslim party, the conspiracy theory anti-Muslim party, the farmers-against-immigrants party, the God-wants-the-death-penalty party, and the regular oldschool conservative right wing party (who call themselves "liberals", by the way). Most right-wing voters will have a strong preference among this lot, but at the same time they won't mind deeply if one of the other options wins elections instead. But they hate hate hate the progressives! A few weeks ago right wing protesters attacked and trashed the HQ of one of the more progressive parties (D66). The hatred is very deep (and mutual), totally unlike what the graphs in this article show you.
- victorbjorklund 1y agoAgreed. I'm from Sweden and most here are OK with another party on their side. But the hate towards the opposite side is still there.
- Jensson 1y agoBut according to the article its much less hated in Sweden than for example USA or Greece, and we can see how the out party used to not be as hated in USA but is very hated now, while the levels in Sweden were always kind of modest while Greece the out party was always hated. So its interesting to see these dynamics.
- 1y ago
- rapnie 1y agoAre there good studies on the role of social media in relation to these trends, that people can recommend?