8 ms·
The AI bubble is 17 times the size of the dot-com frenzy and four times subprime
- ChrisArchitect 1y ago[dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45465969 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45465969
- metadat 1y agoThanks! Macro-expanded: The AI bubble is 17 times the size of the dot-com frenzy, analyst says https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45465969 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45465969 - 2 days ago, 94 comments There is some higher quality discussion there, and still ongoing.
- zerosizedweasle 1y agoAll the financial engineering to prop up the bubble is going to end badly, it always does. Edit: I think it's fair to say there is a fair bit antics by companies that are actually illegal, like in every bubble, that have been hidden by the mania. They get exposed as the tide goes out.
- jgalt212 1y agoThe real problem is continued socialization of risk when the inevitable bailouts come. The government is basically telling everyone to take crazy risks, because if the risk is big enough, we'll bail you all out.
- zerosizedweasle 1y agoMaybe though, if that happens, some heads will roll and some of the white collar criminals get decades in prison for their behavior unlike in 2008.
- tartuffe78 1y agoNot if they bribe the big man
- ryandrake 1y agoWhy do you think that will happen, when it pretty much never has historically happened?
- pesus 1y agoThat's probably less likely than ever.
- rtkwe 1y agoI think you could make an argument either way and have an equal chance of being right. Either Trump et al get bribed/flattered/are personally exposed to the fallout and bail out their fellow class members or he gets angry about it and decides to make heads roll via his increasingly captured and controlled DOJ. I still agree it's more likely the former than the latter but I can see the path that leads to the latter.
- scarface_74 1y agoIt came out soon after AOL acquired Tine Warner in 2001 that they artificially inflated income to prop their stock up for the merger to go through. No one was punished for it.
- IAmBroom 1y agoI'm shocked, shocked to find that gambling was going on there.
- twoodfin 1y agoIt’s not a felony to bankrupt your company or lose your investors’ money through good faith bad bets. Presuppose everything else that contributed to the GFC was straight up fraud: Prevent it all and the crisis is basically just as bad.
- jandrese 1y agoI would really hope that nobody considers AI companies to be foundational to the economy the way the housing market is. I know there is going to be people crying in Congress with "Think of the 401ks!" but I really want the hype men to feel some pain this time. It's really a shame that it's really the regular people who are going to suffer the majority of the harm when this bubble pops, as the Wall Street insiders get off mostly scot free yet again but I really don't want the government trying to prop up these assholes again.
- zerosizedweasle 1y agohttps://www.derekthompson.org/p/this-is-how-the-ai-bubble-will-pop https://www.derekthompson.org/p/this-is-how-the-ai-bubble-wi... Goes into good detail on how the bubble has infiltrated everywhere. Like if you went into a REIT thinking it was safe from the bubble, nope a significant portion of your investment is in the data center buildout
- ambicapter 1y agoIt seems like an (ugly?) truth that if you don't want to be exposed to bubbles, you have to take lower-return investments, by definition. Because the bubble is raising the high bar of what kind of return people expect on investment, so if you try to get close to that, you're going to end up affected by the bubble. The problem, of course, that no one wants to take a lower return on investment.
- zerosizedweasle 1y agoYeah, but I guess the point is that it is so big you can't escape it, it's everywhere. So the fallout will not be limited to a segment of the economy, it's going to hurt everywhere.
- BobaFloutist 1y agoAnd the reason nobody wants to take a lower return on investment is that doing so is trying to time the market. Let's say you heard Trump's talk of tariffs, got spooked when he won the election, and moved your investments. The S&P 500 has gone up ~33% since election day. How much growth can you realistically miss before correctly hedging against a crash still net loses you money? And that's assuming you pick the correct hedge. If the US economy well and truly crashes beyond return, to the point where the S&P 500 is actual garbage that will not recover in the next 5-10 years, that might bode poorly for the dollar, so that's it for your treasuries, money market funds, CDs, etc. Gold is always an option, until it's at an all time high because just as the economy is roaring along a ton of people are nervous. So, you can invest in gold, but it's expensive, which means it could actually dip if we get stability. Ok, so you invest in foreign markets - but the Global Financial Crisis was global, the Great Depression was global, everything was global. What do you actually hedge in? Oil? Well, the rapid development of green energy might actually, finally render that an unsafe investment. Green energy? Think again, the president is on a crusade against it. There's literally nothing that's actually a safe investment, and even if you did find a safe investment, the big crash might not happen until everyone else riding the wave has doubled or tripled their investment, by which point they'll be on par or even above you post crash. I'm actually very happy I'm nowhere near retiring, since regardless of how else you feel of the current governing of the US, I think it would be hard to argue that they're fighting a war against conventional wisdom, and that makes investing very scary.
- mjr00 1y ago> The government is basically telling everyone to take crazy risks, because if the risk is big enough, we'll bail you all out. This is the widespread sentiment, yes, and why the bubble is so crazy. The feeling a lot of people have is; even if shit hits the fan, rather than let stocks/assets decrease in value relative to cash, governments will just print money and keep stocks/assets "stable" while making cash worthless. The US proved they're willing to do this during COVID. What you're betting on by holding assets despite the bubble is that they're willing to do it again.
- zerosizedweasle 1y agoYeah, but can they afford it? The government's debt obligations and inflation made it possible, the circumstances have changed considerably. They could wreck the economy for a long time by doing something like that again (particularly if it isn't a war or something).
- wilkommen 1y agoI think they can afford it one more time, but this will be the last time. I think this will be the time that wrecks the economy.
- coldpie 1y agoThe people in control of the economy are not affected by the state of the economy. There is no incentive for them not to gamble because there is no downside. If they win, they get even more money and power. If they lose, they'll still have their yachts and land and hobby rocket, newspaper, and social media companies.
- joules77 1y agoPutin the magnificent has said "whoever leads in AI will rule the world". So it is a war. An arms race. Weirdly being run by private capital cuz there was no incentive(unlike during WW2/Cold War) to fund a state run Manhattan Project for AI. Watch what happens if a breakthrough comes out of China, Russia or a shed in Nigeria. What is happening on Wall Street or who is loosing cash or jobs will drop instantly down the list of priorities. Money will be printed to the moon.
- cowsandmilk 1y agoWhy would the government bail out AI companies? They didn’t bail out the dot-com bubble. Bailing out the auto industry was about the UAW. Bailing out financial institutions went with programs to keep people from being foreclosed on and losing their homes. The AI bubble doesn’t have those incentives and is mostly (all?) private company valuations.
- hrpnk 1y agoThere was a nice podcast from Prof G Markets about how the bubble could collapse: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oeepx2ZLrCA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oeepx2ZLrCA In short it's companies turning to issuing debt, fuelled by increase in M&A activity, potential IPO of OpenAI, followed by collapse as tricks to increase revenue will fail to meet expectations and companies that mismanage debt will go bust.
- sph 1y agoUnderstood: sell everything as soon as OpenAI announces their IPO.
- wslh 1y agoOne of the best ways to be in a bubble is to live in the middle of transactions.
- aaroninsf 1y agoBuried lede: what is the transformative potential of ML/AI? It's not a bad bet that many are making that "changes everything" is real in this case. Hitching a ride to the technology getting civilization over the hill is a reasonable goal. But what institution, technology, play...? Following the money shows where bets are being placed. But none are safe, the disruptive consequences of network effects make diversification appear wise. The industry is littered with the bones of giants. Personally I am looking at ML/AI as analogous to the Great Oxygenation Event. What things look like—at least, on land—afterward, none know, least of all the cranky old oligarchs who are hell bent on consolidating control and ownership.
- tejohnso 1y ago> ChatGPT-3 cost $50 million, ChatGPT-4 cost $500 million and ChatGPT-5, costing $5 billion Is that actually true? And is most of it because of the compute requirements of the models or scaling cost due to exponential growth in usage? I hope it didn't actually cost ten times more to create ChatGPT-5 than it did ChatGPT-4.
- margalabargala 1y agoThose numbers do in fact match what a quick search says. But I can't find anything directly released by OpenAI, so maybe these are all just estimates. And presumably include price of hardware.
- jandrese 1y agoI think that's mostly training costs. There is a serious level of diminishing returns and the primary way companies have been trying to get ahead is throwing more and more hardware at it. AI already burns something around 5x as much power as crypto mining and it's only growing. You hear sometimes about the AI singularity and how they will continue to become smarter at an exponential pace until they're basically gods in a box, but the reality is we're already well into the top of the S curve and every advance requires more effort than the one before.
- bugglebeetle 1y agoYou should be more concerned that Chinese labs can train models that are just as good for 10X less because Americans treat the USD’s status as the global reserve currency as the ultimate bitter lesson. Who needs better math and engineering when you can print money to buy more GPUs???
- goalieca 1y agoThe author literally said gpt is spending 10x more for equivalent. This really means ChatGPT had that intelligence at that cost a year or two ago. Smaller domain models are better at focused tasks in that area but can’t be generalized.
- ttul 1y agoThis article is pretty low quality IMHO. Lots of conjecture about the value of LLMs. We are far too early in this hype cycle to know what will come of this new tech. There is, however, no doubt that incredible amounts of capital are flowing into data center construction and much of that capital allocation will end in tears. There will be losers.
- cvoss 1y agoThis article is all vapor. After reading it in it's entirety, there is only a short section that's actually about the headline, and it communicates nothing about what the headline means. What is 17x what?
- cogogo 1y agoA quick and dirty google shows that global financial institutions wrote down 1-2 trillion in mortgage related securities, a ~6trn drop in the us real estate mkt and another 6trn destroyed in the equities mkt. Not sure I really trust these numbers but they are the right order of magnitude. I have a very hard time believing the AI bubble is as big as the subprime bubble. But it very well could help trigger a massive correction and recession on a similar scale because everything else that has been propped up by low rates will likely correct with it.
- simonh 1y agoIn the subprime crisis 10 million American families lost their homes and 8.7 million people lost their jobs. In the case of the collapse of an AI bubble, I don't see as much of a direct relationship to effects on the average Joe. Yes all those billions spent by tech investors will get written off, the companies heavily invested in AI will shed well paid tech jobs in a sector that was craving talent anyway. I think the biggest effect would be the fact that all that capital was spent on AI tech rather than productive assets and businesses. That's a big opportunity cost, and would hit growth, but I don't see it wiping out ordinary people in the same way. The pain will be heavily concentrated on investors and for everyone else it will just be a slow drag but not a catastrophe. The real problem is if there are other negative economic effects that compound with it.
- smsm42 1y ago> In the subprime crisis 10 million American families lost their homes When you say "lost their homes", do you mean "I owned the house and somehow I now own no house and have no money for it, it just evaporated", or do you mean "I took a loan I could not afford, on a house I could not afford, while investing a tiny amount of money or none at all into the deal, and hoping to profit from ever increasing prices, and using my equity as an infinite-money ATM, and when that stopped, the bank took the house back"? If the latter, then what was lost is not "homes" but unrealistic prospects of profits from the thin air. If the former, I'd like to know how exactly a subprime crisis could cause something like that.
- yread 1y agoAre those numbers inflation-adjusted? I feel like inflation in market caps/valuations was a lot higher than in consumer prices
- WillPostForFood 1y agoThe boldest claim isn't he boldest claim first - it's not just that AI is in a huge bubble, it is that interest rates are artificially low.
- micromacrofoot 1y agoand the US has a president that's seemingly doing everything he can do make them lower
- CuriouslyC 1y agoThe mistake this article makes is assuming LLM scaling is one thing. It's not. RL is spiky. It produces narrow improvements on specific capabilities. They're not making the model generically smarter, they're RLing in holes in the model's capabilities. In reality we don't have one scaling curve, we have thousands of them. We're in diminishing returns in "top line smarts" but we're raising the floor in a wide variety of areas that people who don't heavily eval models for a living might not notice.
- citizenpaul 1y agoThe AI hype bubble now represents something like 20-30% of the stock market depending on who you ask. For reference the great depression started with a 24% drop of the stock market. The people running this AI game know there is 0% chance the government will let this play out naturally because it would cause another great depression. Bailout Guaranteed. The plebs can take some inflation,higher taxes and national debt increase for the hucksters to get some yachts and lambos. I mean what were you going to do with that money? Feed your family? Pay rent? Jeeze get a life.... In this round of con there is not even a way for an average pleb to get any scraps since the AI bubble is almost completely hidden behind private equity. Except maybe Nvidia stock. The bubble is starting to froth/pop IMO. An incestuous cycle of players propping each other up with circular investments(ie I'll loan you money to buy my product so I can sell it to you) began last month with Nvidia "funding" OpenAI datacenters. Actions like that mean they are out of external ways to keep shuffling the debt. Like when WeWork CEO started loaning the company its own money to buy its own product to rent. Edit: Oh $hit AMD just did the same thing with a circular funding deal with OpenAI. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45490549 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45490549 Channel Stuffing Money printer go brrr. I can't belive there is even discussion if there is a bubble at this point. Its literally wolf of wall street "Never let them cash out that makes it real" style deals all over the place.
- Zigurd 1y agoAI isn't the only component of the bubble. SpaceX which has a genuinely successful business with Falcon 9, is also a huge bubble. SpaceX launches an amazing 25 times as many rockets as ULA in a year. But 2/3 of those are Starlink launches. No outside revenue. And SpaceX is valued at about 200X the valuation of ULA.
- cantor_S_drug 1y ago> I'll loan you money to buy my product so I can sell it to you. I predict this will happen among Nations as well. US will provide money to Japan so that Japan can invest that money in US (at Trump's discretion) so that everything is kosher.
- 1y ago
- profsummergig 1y agoNvidia certainly has a headstart, and great products. But many (many) labs around the world are working on alternative chip designs for math processing. Once a couple open-source chip designs come online, that can compete with Nvidia, it will all come crashing down. Think Android vs iPhone. Stoked.
- maigret 1y agoHas Apple crashed?
- navigate8310 1y agoAt least it has an open-source capable competitor.
- scarface_74 1y agoSurely you aren’t talking about Android as “open source”. To a first approximation no one wants a phone running only AOSP without Google’s proprietary parts.
- gjvc 1y agoyou might want to recheck your measurements
- lern_too_spel 1y agoFor definitions of "no one" that include 1 billion people.
- JustExAWS 1y agoSo yes, if I’m willing to go to China and use Chinese OEM customized phones with Chinese apps, I will be golden…
- 1y ago
- jdalgetty 1y agoSo as someone investing for hopefully an eventual retirement, what am I supposed to do?
- specialist 1y agoLike everyone else, wait until the very last second, just as the market peaks, to unload your assets. Before the institutional investors and insiders beat you to the punch.
- runeks 1y agoDepends: when are you planning to retire?
- cogogo 1y agoIf you believe the rule of law and ~general financial stability of the US will persist just keep on investing regularly and ride it out. Markets have a long history of bouncing back and they will keep doing it until they don’t. When/if that happens your retirement dreams might seem quaint compared to the global socioeconomic reality. The people who could sustain the most near term pain are those who have already retired and are living in a fixed income.
- klooney 1y agoIf the US collapses, conversely, stock/bond market investing choices won't matter.
- specialist 1y agoSome day, some wizened legal types will prepare their cases as these bubbles take shape. Instead of waiting for a warmed over post-mortem, long after the bubble pops, before even considering their options. It's a bubble. Of course there's malfeasance, lies, corruption, etc. Assume criminality. These endless boom-bust cycles will continue unabated until there's credible threats of doing some hard time.
- bawolff 1y ago> It's a bubble. Of course there's malfeasance, lies, corruption, etc. Assume criminality. Fun fact, we live in a society with rule of law. You can't just assume criminality because you don't like something, you have to actually prove it.
- scarface_74 1y agoWe do? Have you been reading the news where the President is firing AGs who won’t go after his enemies and firing FBI agents who didn’t agree to perp walk his enemy? Not to mention he just pardoned 1500 domestic terrorists in January. Public companies are outright bribing the President to get mergers passed (Paramount) and the entire confiscating TikTok to give it to his buddy at Oracle on the cheap can’t be ignored. On the federal level, there really isn’t any legal standard anymore.
- bloomingeek 1y agoThis is the shameful truth! Who knows what the consequences will be in the future...why? Because the corruption is so widespread, it's almost impossible to track it all. Deflection is the order of the day and the press is too scared/corrupt to report almost anything for fear of being sued by the current administration, which SCOTUS has basically capitulated to almost everything the pres wants.
- gtsop 1y ago"The rule of law" is the rule of the economic elites over the weak plebs. The "rule" is formed, shaped and ignored so they can have their way. Anything goes when you operate on the upper levels, we are not naive kids.
- rich_sasha 1y agoThe weird thing that makes it different to subprime is that AI is real and really could become AGI. But it might also be overvalued. So it's not like there isn't a product (there is) and there's no growth prospect (there is). But it is scary how much now hangs in the balance of one bet. It almost feels like it's going to end badly either way. If the Great AI Bet succeeds, a tiny proportion of the world will own all intellectual power. But if it fails, the impact of the write-offs on the broader economy will be terrifying.
- sunir 1y agoYou can’t buy stock in AI. You can buy stocks in companies. The internet was destined to be big sure during the dot.com but most companies crashed. The bubble popping issue would be that there isn’t a good way to recover the capital used to build the AI models.
- IAmBroom 1y agoYou can't(couldn't) buy stock in the internet, either. It's always "stocks in companies". I mean, unless you go back to "tulips are a sure thing; their prices always go up!". But buying stocks in an S&P massively invested in AI is essentially the same as "buying AI", when the bubble pops.
- leptons 1y ago> AI is real and really could become AGI There is zero evidence that current "AI" (LLMs) are ever going to become "AGI". If you want a pathological liar for an "AGI", then sure, LLMs are already there.
- lackoftactics 1y agoWhat would count as proof of AI trajectory to AGI? Currently we have: - cross domain competence - composable tool usage - constant improvement without clear signs of stagnation...some can count gpt 5 as not much progress but there are still world models with huge gains compared to year before There is a bunch of things missing for sure like mechanistic reasonic, better context lengths, determinism, better world modelling, continuous learning. The bet is crazy and whole world is gambling on AI, right now, because of those signs of potential. That's precisely why we landed here, the evidence was good enough for big tech to gamble on it...
- HNrenewables 1y ago[dead]
- myth_drannon 1y agoI wonder how the tech job market would look without the AI bubble. Is the AI the cause of the unemployment crisis(if we believe the CEOs who layoff a quarter of the company because "AI is replacing thousands of developers") or if we didn't have this crazy AI bubble, the market would be a much worse bloodbath.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mgh2 1y agodupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45465969 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45465969
- scarface_74 1y agoWho gets hurt when the bubble pops? And who will the government need to bail out? Last time, a lot of the companies were public and the general public saw stock losses. This time the only companies that are publicly really exposed by the AI bubble are Nvidia with all of their circular financing and Oracle. Of course Tesla has always been a meme stock. Defined contribution plans - for now - can’t have private equity in their funds. Defined benefit plans and endowments are exposed. Apple famously hasn’t invested that much in AI, Google is spending a lot on infrastructure. But between search and GCP and YouTube they have a real business plan and are funding based on profits. Amazon is in the same boat. Microsoft is bowing out of spending money on training and focused on inference - and they also have Azure. Meta is making money using AI for ad targeting and probably in the future to generate ads. I can also see consulting companies being hurt (I work in cloud consulting) as businesses are throwing money at them to “AI enable” their business.
- lm28469 1y ago> Who gets hurt when the bubble pops? Given how investing is heavily promoted by all these neobanks I have a feeling a lot of people will get burnt. Back in the days, not even 10 years ago, you had to research and go out of your way to invest, now you can do things like "automatically round up your transactions to buy NVIDIA" from your bank app. The only ways to get out of the middle class are: lotteries, crypto, putting everything stock market for 20 years and living like a student in the meantime.
- JustExAWS 1y agoMost people in the middle class can’t afford to put any decent chunk in their 401Ks let alone invest any meaningful amount above that. But funny enough, most of the people I know that do invest in individual stocks, bitcoin etc are people in the servjce industry who are single and make decent money on tips. I live in very heavy tourist town. But since this is a site of tech heavy participants, if you are a software developer or adjacent, you are on average making twice the median local wage for your area if you are in the US even as a enterprise Dev 2-5 years out of school and should be able to invest at least 15% if your income.
- simplecto 1y agonow do crypto
- wg0 1y agoIf you marvel at the output of generative AI be it pictures, logo, music, 3D models, prose or code - you probably are yourself way too under-skilled to be gainfully employed or not yourself capable of generating similar or better output. Conversely - any expert (prolific writer, coder, painter, photographer, videographer or log/web designer) isn't as much amused or going to scream out of excitement that what these models are producing (vides, pictures, logos, essays, code) - they could never ever have thought anything better than that. This fact alone is enough to warrant that a big bust is coming. Not a matter of if but when.
- radlad 1y agoPossibly - or we might discover that for a large amount of use cases, AI output is "good enough," even if the experts don't love it. A C programmer will snub an Excel sheet, but it doesn't change the fact that it's genuinely useful for a wide number of use cases. As an aside, the AI Art Turing Test was a bit eye-opening for me: https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/how-did-you-do-on-the-ai-art-turing https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/how-did-you-do-on-the-ai-ar... I say all of this as someone who hopes that art remains human.
- stale2002 1y ago> you probably are yourself way too under-skilled to be gainfully employed or not yourself capable of generating similar or better output. Have you considered the posibilities that "subpar" coding skills are still extremely valuable? I say this because almost every single extremely high paid engineer that I know at rocketship unicorn startups to FAANG companies are all using AI coding as an essential part of their work flow. Its ubiquitous. And we get paid tons of money. We aren't just copying an pasting hundreds of lines of code and pushing to prod, of course, but its an invaluable tool for significantly speeding up an engineers coding workflow. This contradicts your claim, as these aren't need grads, these are all highly paid professionals.
- bparsons 1y agoHas anyone articulated a theory for what the profit model might actually look like for the big LLMs? In the .com era, the valuations were crazy, but people generally understood how you could eventually make money on all of this stuff. If models are requiring larger and larger infrastructure buildouts, does anyone have a clear sense of what users will have to pay in order to make the businesses profitable?
- sunir 1y agoThe dot.com had no idea. They talked about eyeballs.
- SoftTalker 1y agoI think they had an idea that it would be fees per transaction or a subscription model. They just had no customers.
- sunir 1y agoThey all thought it would be advertising or ecommerce. Subscriptions weren't a cultural phenomenon yet. That was a decade later.
- bparsons 1y agoThey knew you could sell stuff on the internet. The payment processors were just clunky. It was fairly obvious at the time how it would all work. I think the surprise was the degree to which ad revenue would eat the world. Maybe it will be the same this time.
- micromacrofoot 1y agono one can predict the future, they were guessing then and they're guessing now guesses in the past look better because we tend to pay more attention to the correct ones
- dgs_sgd 1y agoWith the direction of OpenAI, hyper personalized ads inserted directly into chat and their app experiences could be a path. Not saying it will work, but they’re definitely exploring it.
- some_guy_nobel 1y agoIs anyone acting on this? E.g. selling index funds, moving to HYSAs/bonds, etc.?
- wilkommen 1y agoI would say if you're holding a lot of money in a S&P 500-tracking index fund, switch to holding a total stock market fund instead. It's probably a bad time to hold SP500 right now, but you don't want to get out of the market entirely because there's no way to know when the bubble pops. So hold a total stock market fund instead, so that you don't have an outsize amount of your portfolio invested in the companies leading the SP500 (which are the most likely to lose the most when the bubble pops).
- tempestn 1y agoI agree with using a TSM fund rather than an S&P 500 index, but be aware that you're still mostly holding S&P 500 companies. The S&P 500 covers about 80% of the total market cap of US public companies, whereas the Russell 3000 is 98%. (This is, of course, because the 500 largest companies are so much larger than the median.) If you really want to diversify away from the biggest growth companies you could try a value and/or small/value tilt. Those might all be good advice, but they do come with their own caveats, whereas using TSM instead of an S&P 500 fund is just good advice in general.
- wilkommen 1y agoWow I did not know that. I might switch to something weighted/tilted differently.
- JohnnyMarcone 1y agoI reacted more to the current administration than AI. I added a small allocation to international equities. I may increase my bond allocation a bit, but that's because I'm already heavy in stocks and want to focus a little more on preservation.
- kogasa240p 1y agoBuy precious metals.
- bawolff 1y ago> Artificially low interest rates have stimulated investment into AI So chatgpt was released in nov 2022. Interest rates started going up shortly after. Am i missing something, it seems like the AI bubble and very low interest rates don't overlap except maybe at the very beginning.
- Zigurd 1y agoThe Saudi sovereign wealth funds and similar Middle Eastern investors, Masayoshi Son, a16z (though not all of their funds), Tesla's board, and others seem to be operating in some kind of alternative reality where watching out for your limiteds and shareholders isn't a factor. Do they think they are really TBTF? Is that why JD Vance is where he is? It's not just the size of the bubble that's scary. It's that some people obviously think they're going to get away with it.
- baggachipz 1y ago> It's that some people obviously think they're going to get away with it. Cynical, I know, but they absolutely will get away with it. The wrong people will be punished, as usual. They will claim that "there was no way to know" this could happen.
- snickerbockers 1y agoThey will do what they always do, which is to vaguely imply that if they are left to the consequences of their gambling addiction then China will get ahead of "us". Note that the general public are only included as part of "us" when Sam Altman needs the general public's funding.
- samrus 1y agoHopefully their grift fails when china also doesnt have AGI or anything like it. But idk, people can be delusional
- Havoc 1y agoThe valuations vs revenue numbers definitely are alarming but the fact that it is a general purpose tech makes me reluctant to pull cash out of the market. dotcom bubble may have been a thing, but the underlying tech was valid and created the big techs out of thin air. Admittedly after much pain & flushing out the pets.coms of the world If we're at another moment like that do you really want to be sitting on the sidelines?
- thenaturalist 1y agoHave you seen OpenAI's revenue projections?
- HarHarVeryFunny 1y agoIn the dot-com crash, the NASDAQ lost 80% of it's value, which is something I'd certainly like to be sitting on the sidelines for. The trouble with a crash is that it happens fast, and you are likely not going to be able to get out fast enough. There is also the psychology involved - say you lose 20% in one day, then do you sell, or wait for a bounce back before selling? What if there is no bounce, and it goes down another 20% the next day, then what do you do? Nowadays there are "circuit breakers" that will stop the market if it is crashing, so maybe you hear about the start of the crash an hour late, by which time the trading has been halted. What do you do now - put in a market sell order? If every one is trying to bail out at the same time, then the market will reopen at a much lower price (matching buy & sell orders), and so it goes ...
- tempestn 1y agoAnd conversely, if you try to preempt the crash, you might end up sitting out most of the run up. Lots of people called the dot.com bubble in the late 90s and got out, only to end up worse off than if they'd just held through the whole boom, crash, and recovery. (Of course, I'm sure there were also some that managed to time the market successfully! Not sure I'm that lucky though.)
- HarHarVeryFunny 1y ago
- crazygringo 1y agoNo it's not, because nobody knows how big the AI bubble is. Or even if it actually exists at all. Because the concept behind a bubble is that it's inflated over the true value due to speculation or non-speculative overinvestment. But there's still a true value. So you can say AI valuations are whatever multiple of previous whatevers, but you can't say the AI bubble is. Because if there's an AI bubble (and there probably is, but nobody knows), nobody knows how big the bubble part is versus that solid part. Obviously, if anyone did, they'd make lots of money by investing accordingly. And of course the reason we can't figure out the bubble size is because nobody knows what the true value of LLM's will be over the coming decade or two. It's hard to know even what the order of magnitude will be. And how much will be captured by existing LLM companies.
- deepanwadhwa 1y agoI did not know GPU backed loans was a thing. It seems risky.
- baggachipz 1y agoIt's not just, risky, it's insane. The GPUs lose value almost as soon as they're installed.
- lxgr 1y agoOn the other hand, auto loans are a thing. It’s all a question of how the assets are valued.
- baggachipz 1y agoDo you mean car title loans? Because that's basically what the GPU-backed loans are. Car title loans have terrible terms due to the diminishing value of the car. These GPU-backed loans are being booked at much, much more favorable terms, as if the GPU holds its value for a long time. This simply isn't the case, so if the loan is defaulted on, the loaner will have a rude awakening when all they get are worthless GPUs.
- rtkwe 1y agoIsn't that part of why down payments are so necessary? It takes the loan amount below the immediate depreciation amount of the asset so the bank/lender is less exposed to the risk.
- lxgr 1y agoI’d imagine the main benefit of downpayments to be behavioral, since otherwise the borrower has no stake in the asset initially.
- rtkwe 1y agoI doubt that's the main driver for lenders and people are generally pretty attached to and excited about their new cars. They also do have a stake they'll still be out time and money even if insurance covered the entire cost of the vehicle.
- emil-lp 1y agoActually no-one can see a bubble, that's what makes it a bubble.
- jostmey 1y agoBut what if AI succeeds and it’s the rest of the economy that implodes? Long-term, I’m sure AI will lead to massive productivity gains. Short-term, I think it’s going to be chaotic. I don't know which will implode, AI or repetitive white collar work or something else
- jt2190 1y agoThis article is referencing a subscriber-only letter. I think this video is from the same source as the letter MicroStrategy Partnership: “Power Plai - Julien Garran - 02 October 2025” https://youtu.be/uz2EqmqNNlE https://youtu.be/uz2EqmqNNlE > Make no mistake, I think that this is the biggest and most dangerous bubble the world has ever seen. The misallocation of capital in the US (which also includes housing, VC and crypto) is already 17x the Dotcom bubble and 4x the 2008 real estate bubble, and as it unwinds it will not just threaten significant economic malaise, it will threaten to overturn the entire globalist agenda, that developed with the advent of Thatcher and Reagan in from 1979 and 1982, accelerated with the fall of the Berlin Wall fell in 1988, and sped up again with China’s accession into the WTO in 2002.
- mkrishnan 1y agoI would rather be in AI bubble than Crypto currency bubble.
- postexitus 1y agoIf bitcoin has not popped so far, AI will never pop.
- croes 1y agoBitcoin needs less resources than AI, and Bitcoin totally failed its purpose as a currency.
- samrus 1y agoBitcoin not popping is a testament to human delusion. It cant function as a stable store of value becuase theres nothing preventing if from hyperdeflating, and yet people are still buying it. What are they even buying? The deflation based gains? Deflation based on nothing but speculation? It doesnt do anything. Its madness I dont think the GenAI bubble will be as resilient because its not being funded through discretionary expenditure. Its being funded with capital expenditure. If your cousin spent his savings on bitcoin and isnt getting any benefit from it (or even loses it in a drop) thats fine because millenials dont have savings anyway. But if a company spends on AI and doesnt get a positive value prop in a while, they will pivot and pull their money out, because shareholders will get mad
- _aavaa_ 1y agoWhether it failed is (unfortunately) beside the point. Number still go up.
- croes 1y agoPrices for artwork also go up, gold goes up and if NFTs would still be a thing they would go up too.
- postexitus 1y agoyou mean NFTs popped
- samrus 1y ago
- coffeecoders 1y agoThe troubling part is we are in the AI bubble whether we opted in or not. The downstream effects are everywhere - real estate (data centers), energy (power consumption), education (automated tools), employment (tech layoffs), and equity markets (Nvidia propping up the spoos). It's not one sector this time, it’s systemic adjacency. During the dot-com crash, retail got burned. During subprime, it was the global financial system. Today, AI exposure is distributed among mega-cap public companies, a16z-style VC funds, sovereign wealth, and shadowy circular debt deals between hyperscalers and AI startups. Even if you are not betting on AI, your retirement fund is.
- m_ke 1y agoWorse than the bubble is what's happening to the rest of the economy. If you remove AI related spending the US economy is trending in a really bad direction. This bubble popping will definitely take down crypto with it and rip through other adjacent industries.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- devn0ll 1y agoOn the one hand, I'm like: so what, I got no skin in this game... But then again, they will most assuredly get community-money bail outs. And _also_ raise prices on GPU's.
- Animats 1y agoHere's an useful exercise. Suppose someone makes an advance that makes LLMs training require 90% less compute, but does not make them any smarter. (Recent results from China indicate substantial compute reductions are possible.) Demand for GPU time drops. What happens to the economics of the AI boom?
- dilyevsky 1y agoDemand most likely won't drop due to Jevons and the worst will be big labs and Nvidia probably drop significantly in valuation but still pretty good. Also recent china results only show that you could build cheaper model hitting the benchmarks not actually generally competitive irl.
- fluoridation 1y agoAgreed, with one caveat: demand for hardware can drop if the optimization is so substantial that deployed hardware is already capable of fulfilling any possible request in a timely fashion. Say, anyone becomes able to run any state-of-the-art model on any desktop computer. 90% is not enough, though. It has to be at least three or four orders of magnitude. The ones driving demand are big datacenters, so they need to be in a position where just throwing more hardware at the problem solves nothing.
- thomasdeleeuw 1y agoI remember something like that happening. Someone optimzed something and boom, one billion of valuation gone. It seems ridiculous on the surface, and definitely smells of a bubble to me.
- Animats 1y agoThat's happening to the automobile market in China. Electric car and battery manufacturing costs go down with scale. Way down. Huge electric car glut in China. Car prices crashing. Government worried.[1] Profit margin of China car companies is down to around 4%. [1] https://www.cnn.com/2025/09/26/cars/chinese-electric-cars-price-wars-intl-hnk-dst https://www.cnn.com/2025/09/26/cars/chinese-electric-cars-pr...
- smsm42 1y agoI lived through dotcom boom and bust, and there had been a lot of craziness, but when the dust settled, we have now a functioning internet economy, and I am able to sit at home in my pajama pants working for an international company that has employees all over the globe, while enjoying many other conveniences the internet brings me - and all this is enabled by what started during dotcom era. It is true that it did not match the most wiled-eyes predictions, but also a lot of things did change, and a lot of things did improve. If the AI boom followed this trajectory - which is of course no guarantee of, but if we assume that - then there is going to be a lot of crazy stuff to come, but at the end of it, the dust will settle and we will be mostly better off from it. Some people would become billionaires, some undeservedly so, some people would be ruined, some also unfairly so, but for most people, at the end it won't be that huge.
- samrus 1y ago100% We are in the era of people using geolocation to remind them about their grocery list when they're near a store. In 10 years we will be in the gps and uber era. Its just that it will be bumpy when this bubble crashes. And the US isnt as stable and sane as it used to be. I wonder if the economy can be steered through waters this rough
- seydor 1y agoHow can the AI bubble burst in the public markets? It is circular investment within silicon valley. Even if AI proves nothing, overall the tech market is in the same spot where it started
- dgs_sgd 1y agoNot all AI investment is private. You could argue that public companies like Google, Meta, and Microsoft have had their stock appreciate at least partly because of the AI frenzy.
- cantor_S_drug 1y agoTINA. There is no alternative. People are forced to play the game.
- BurningFrog 1y agoYou only know it was a bubble after it burst. Right now, I don't know if it's a bubble, and neither do you.
- IAmBroom 1y agoA famous economist who has predicted 17 of the last 3 recessions...
- VBprogrammer 1y agoI've been playing with Llama 3.2-3B this weekend and, while I haven't spent enough time with it to figure out the limitations, it's definitely good enough to be useful. That's running at "as fast as I can read" on a £100 Intel Arc GPU. I'm tempted to buy a Arc770 (£250ish) to see if I can run the OpenAI open weights models... I think it's reasonably likely that these massive investments turn to dust when they get squeezed by the commoditization of LLMs.
- Fischgericht 1y agoDisclaimer: I am not a doomsday apologist, just a Nerd collecting, analyzing data and doing projections out of it. There is not only an AI bubble, but a US Dollar bubble, too. Most people don't get it what "Stock markets, gold, real estate, crypto, EVERYTHING is up" actually means: That the currency you are paying in is losing value at rapid pace. I do not yet understand how the market manipulation actually works, but if you exchange from an Asian country to US Dollar right now, an amount that will buy you a excellent dinner for the whole family no longer even buys you a hamburger in the US. The part I also do not understand is why the only thing that right now is "cheap" as seen from the US perspective are foreign currencies. I also don't understand why other countries are not liquidating their USD reserves. How can you as a country not see that your reserves now would be much safer in Asian countries including even the Chinese Rimibi? Well, maybe the answer to the USD losing value rapidly is that in reality there ARE market actors in the background moving to other currencies, but are really really good at hiding it. But in any case: No doubt, the western part of the global financial system will be crashing within the next 3 weeks. With the US being on the brink to civil war anyway, you should be able to extrapolate what a financial crisis and bank run in the US in combination with everyone and their dog owning war-grade weapons will end up at. Right now you have heaps of people in the US who are completely ignoring any data but invest only based on being member of a fanatic cult - every time you read news that Tesla no longer is able to sell cars, or that their robots do not work, or that their Robotaxi stuff is a scam, the Tesla share value goes further up. The same applies to AI. That AI will never make any profit is no longer niche knowledge, it's headlines at Bloomberg, WSJ, FT & co. You have to actively ignore that information - still, AI stocks go up. So what is missing for the bubble to finally burst? Anything that makes those cult members start to doubt. Anything that triggers "Maybe putting all my retirement savings into crypto is too risky" or "Maybe Elon actually isn't the messiah", "I put all my money into a Trump meme-coin. Is this really more important than getting my teeth repaired?". Or anything that triggers those sheeps that are invested into this to simply needing cash quickly. So, for example due to a natural disaster, or some pandemic, the Epstein stuff finally blowing up on Trump etc. The list of things that now may trigger the implosion is gigantic. Due to that it is possible to predict where it will start - it might not be the AI bubble. It very well even may be something rather classic like the "Deported migrants no longer pay towards their mortgages / loans" stuff happening right now. But in summary: Due to the very high number of potential triggers it is stunning it hasn't imploded yet, and if you read/watch interviews from scientists in this area, the common theme these days is: "WTF is going on here?! This should have imploded LONG ago!".
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoWhat's the mood in the bay area? If this is 17 times the size I can't imaging how much optimism/fun you all are having. I was there for the first dot com boom. So much optimism. It seemed every party someone announced they were pregnant we were all so optimism for the future and comfortable, ready to start families. The restaurants were all full with new spots popping up all the time. It was a really fun time to be there. I know there are some layoffs but at 17x even with some layoffs I can't imagine 17x more energy/money then back in the first dot com.
- notmyjob 1y agoAI is about 30 times as big a deal as .com. The subprime thing was just the finance sector learning how to make lines go up on charts (add value).
- maxglute 1y agoIf AI bubble burst... the AI compute (where most of investment/capex going towards) depreciates 1-5 years, specialized data centers a little longer. For reference most of the $$$$$ in capex of dotcom burst went into civil engineering / dumb fiber pipe layout and left US with a fuckload of fiber that lasts 30/40/50+ years. Still using capex from railroad bubble 100 years ago. Both bubbles at least left durable (agnostic networks for future to build off, i.e. upgrade switching and fiber + rail get more efficient utilization. VS specialized LLM data centers with bespoke cooling/power/networking needs - if LLM bubble fails there's a good chance they can't be repurposed economically because their OpEx is probably what broke the model in the first place. I feel like people are failing to grasp how big of a F US will eat if AI bursts relative to past bubbles. I mean it's better than tulip mania since fraction of capex will go towards electrification infra (assumign it gets built), but most of the $$$$$ is going towards fast obsolescent AI hardware also closer to tulips than fiber or rail in terms of stranded depreciated assets.
- DragonsBreath 1y agoBank of England Warns of Impending AI Disaster https://futurism.com/artificial-intelligence/bank-of-england-impending-ai-disaster https://futurism.com/artificial-intelligence/bank-of-england... The AI bubble is 17 times the size of the dot-com frenzy - and four times subprime https://www.morningstar.com/news/marketwatch/20251003175/the-ai-bubble-is-17-times-the-size-of-the-dot-com-frenzy-and-four-times-subprime-this-analyst-argues https://www.morningstar.com/news/marketwatch/20251003175/the... "It's a take from independent research firm the MacroStrategy Partnership, which advises 220 institutional clients, in a note written by analysts including Julien Garran, who previously led UBS's commodities strategy team. Let's start with the boldest claim first - it's not just that AI is in a bubble, but one 17 times size the dot-com bubble, and even four times bigger than the 2008 global real estate one. And to get that number, you have to go way back to 19th century Swedish economist Knut Wicksell. Wicksell's insight was that capital was efficiently allocated when the cost of debt to the average corporate borrower was two percentage points above nominal GDP. Only now is that positive after a decade of Fed quantitative easing pushed corporate bond spreads low. He then calculates the Wicksellian deficit, which to be clear is not only AI spending but also includes housing and office real estate, NFTs and venture-capital. That's how you get this chart on misallocation - a lot of variables, but think of it as the misallocated portion of GDP fueled by artificially low interest rates. But he also took aim at the large language models themselves. For instance, he highlights one study showing the task completion rate at a software company ranged from 1.5% to 34%; and even for the tasks that were completed 34% of the way, that level of completion could not be consistently reached. Another chart, previously circulated by Apollo economist Torsten Slok based on Commerce Department data, showed the AI adoption rate at big companies now on the decline. He also showed some of his real-world tests, like asking an image maker to create a chessboard one move before white wins, which it didn't come close to achieving. LLMs, he argues, already are at the scaling limits. "We don't know exactly when LLMs might hit diminishing returns hard, because we don't have a measure of the statistical complexity of language. To find out whether we have hit a wall we have to watch the LLM developers. If they release a model that cost 10x more, likely using 20x more compute than the previous one, and it's not much better than what's out there, then we've hit a wall," he says. And that's what has happened: ChatGPT-3 cost $50 million, ChatGPT-4 cost $500 million and ChatGPT-5, costing $5 billion, was delayed and when released wasn't even noticeably better than the last version. It's also easy for competitors to catch up. "So, in summary; you can't create an app with commercial value as it is either generic (games etc), which won't sell, or it is regurgitated public domain (homework), or it is subject to copyright. It's hard to advertise effectively, LLMs cost an exponentially larger amount to train each generation, with a rapidly diminishing gain in accuracy. There's no moat on a model, so there's little pricing power. And the people who use LLMs the most are using them to access compute that costs the developer more to provide than their monthly subscriptions," he says. His conclusion is very stark: not just that an economy already at stall speed will fall into recession as both the data-center and wealth effects plateau, but that they'll reverse, just as it did in the dot-com bubble in 2001."