4 ms·
New Poll: Democratic Socialism Is Now Mainstream
- zer00eyz 1y ago> 59% of respondents (and 58% of Republicans) blame landlords and banks more than government regulation for the high cost of housing. I find this stat odd. It runs counter to another set of data that exists, the rate of home ownership: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RHORUSQ156N https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RHORUSQ156N Home ownership is a great indicator of "I will vote" and furthermore its an indicator of "I will vote to protect the price of my home" https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/if-you-lived-here-you-might-be-voter-now https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/insights/if-you-lived-here-you-... So for as much as this data may be true, I'm fairly certain that it isnt an accurate measure of how people are going to vote.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoYup. A nation where the majority of the electorate our homeowners, benefitting financially when housing is scarce and expensive, and organizes politically to ensure housing stays scarce and expensive, yet consistently tells pollers that it’s caused by anything except their actions.
- postflopclarity 1y agoit's also increasingly the only politically viable alternative to fascism.
- YZF 1y agoThe questions/results: https://images.jacobinmag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/12083310/dfp_dsafund_jacobin_toplines_0829.pdf https://images.jacobinmag.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/120... I find this format (ranking) a bit confusing. I read the article and the Wikipedia article about "Democratic Socialism" and I still can't quite understand what exactly this means, Marxist Democracy? Anti-Capitalism? From the survey: "A democratic socialist elected official in your town or city, whose agenda is primarily focused on how to make life more affordable for working people in your community by bringing down the costs of housing, groceries, and electric bills." So this is the definition of a "democratic socialist"? Doesn't every politician say they'll bring down costs and make things more affordable? The question being how? How is this elected official going to do that? "Democratic socialists believe that the government should take a more active role to improve Americans' lives." -> Is this a survey or a sales pitch? "What is your familiarity with the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA)? " -> 4% I am a DSA member, or personally know DSA members, 20% "familiar with the organization" What would be an example of a successful country that where government is more or less based on these principles? Scandinavian countries? China? Obviously(?) these trends are driven by social media? "15% of Donald Trump voters prefer democratic socialism to capitalism. These voters tended to be younger and non-white." -> Does your average person even know what these mean?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- worik 1y agoDemocratic Socialism has a long history, and is easy to understand in a wider political context It is transforming society to socialism (a system which is based on needs and capabilities rather than ownership of private property) by using the available democratic institutions. Easiest to understand in contrast to Revolutionary Socialism that advocates the complete overthrow of the existing institutions. Scandinavian countries, yes, China no. It is not hard to understand
- YZF 1y agoApologies for not being that familiar. Why not like China? Because it got there via a revolution? But otherwise the same end goal just via democratic means? What you're describing sounds like the USSR or China to me. The survey didn't really discuss the idea of Revolutionary Socialism but I imagine that likely has some support as well. If my tone sounds negative it's because I am negative. I support the state being more involved but all examples of pure socialism that I'm aware of end up as a total failure - because it is unworkable. In the US somehow healthcare is considered socialism but I mean "real" socialism (like the idea the grocery stores are owned by the state somehow being able to make food more affordable). The https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model probably doesn't work for everyone either. I think the term "mixed-market capitalist" is more appropriate there. Maybe people are also confused vs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_democracy
- worik 1y agoRevolutionary Socialists (e.g: USSR, China - both back in the day) and Democratic Socialists might seem the same from a distance. But the nature of violence is to lead to more violence, and both the USSR and China have great deals of state violence (as does the USA - I think it is the history of revolution, perhaps?) Democratic socialists have to convince you. Not so much th Bolsheviks, they just make you. > all examples of pure socialism that I'm aware of end up as a total failure "Pure socialism" is a bit silly. How could there ever be such a thing? The Bolsheviks and the CCP were fascists to my way of thinking. In Western Europe , France had a number of revolutions but recovered. The rest of them went the Democratic Socialist route. Democratic Socialists, by necessity originally and these days as a positive policy, believe in a mixed economy. Point is I do not think that Western Europe can be classed a "total failure" nor as "pure socialism". > "real" socialism (like the idea the grocery stores are owned by the state Yes. Mixed economies work better. It comes down to culture for a lot of places.
- Spivak 1y agoThe different political labels are interesting but also deeply frustrating because it paints people at odds when they're not. There's two baskets: one is a "centrally planned" economy led by government spending. One is "free market" economy led by market forces. You can't leave either basket empty or your economy crashes. The government spending keeps money moving during the busts. All we're arguing about how full each basket should be and which sectors of the economy go where. This shouldn't be some us vs them thing dammit, we all have the same vision for the economy and arguing over the details—because they are details—ought to be civil rather than territory grabbing and flag planting.
- thankyoufriend 1y agoI love this take, thank you. In my reading, I came across the term "Mixed economy" which I think aligns with what you're saying. Nobody is arguing in good faith that socialism/communism would have 100% coverage of the economic system. There would be room for luxury goods to operate under roughly the same economic conditions. The key difference being that basic needs like food housing and Healthcare would operate under state control for the benefit of all citizens. We would have some vote in their operation via representatives, unlike now where we have 0 say in private operations unless we pay to play. And some people don't have the means to pay, so they don't get to play.
- kulahan 1y agoI’ll just say thank GOD at this moment in time I’m not relying on Trump not to take away healthcare and housing from people he doesn’t like.
- Spivak 1y agoYeah, this is ultimately why I don't love the idea of single payer. But honestly I'm (slowly) warming up to it as the fears of government controlling healthcare in the way you describe are starting to happen anyway. I guess we'll see how bad it gets and how successful government is at sticking their fingers in private healthcare.
- StefanBatory 1y agoIs Jacobin a reliable source? As far as I know, while I wouldn't call it a rag, it is very ideological to the point you'd be better very careful taking anything from it for granted. It is interesting though, that's true too. And well... As a Pole, it saddens me to see this. Mainly because it's clear that Americans don't know what socialism is, to conservatives, state existing is literally communism, to progressives, if a state has health care, it is socialism. I was reading a book recently - What Everyone Needs to know about China - and there was one sentence I remarked. Author naming Norway socialist country. In an otherwise reputable publisher. Communism and socialism are evil ideologies, and never again. Words have their meanings, and this I fear will mangle it all up. After all, if communism is health care, it can't be that bad, right?
- hypeatei 1y ago> 59% of respondents (and 58% of Republicans) blame landlords and banks more than government regulation for the high cost of housing. I know it's popular to blame landlords, but this isn't a serious take. Landlords are operating in a market of artificially constrained supply, so of course prices are going to rise! The issue, IMO, is on three groups: NIMBY homeowners, voting landlords, and local government officials because they all propose/support policies that make it harder to build homes in their locality. Someone wanting even more government involvement in housing at this point would be quite surprising.
- jmclnx 1y ago>I know it's popular to blame landlords Depends, if a person owing 1 or 2 properties, probably correct. If a large company with multiple units, yes 100% that companies fault.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoIndividuals who own one or two properties are just as capable of exploiting scarcity for maximum rent as companies. What’s important is whether you care about resolving the scarcity so that neither has the power to exploit it, or whether you’re OK with scarcity just so long as your preferred party is the one benefitting from it.
- JohnTHaller 1y agoThey're also operating in an environment where the commercial loans they have on the buildings essentially prevent them from lowering the rent. The building is valued at a multiple of the monthly revenue. If they were to lower the rent to get a new tenant, the monthly revenue of the building would decrease, and the owner would have to give the bank additional collateral in the form of cash. So, they leave it empty, which prevents the building value from decreasing. And the mortgage payments are suspended while the building is empty with the payments and additional interest tacked onto the end of the mortgage. This is specifically about commercial buildings in NYC and will vary for residential and other areas.
- 1y ago
- RickJWagner 1y agoSure, it’s popular among the shrinking pool of Democrats. Democrats as a whole are polling at record low levels. 34% surveyed approve of the Democrats, 59% disapprove. That’s not from a single poll, it’s an average of the most recent polls. https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/favorability/rcp_averages https://www.realclearpolling.com/polls/favorability/rcp_aver...