4 ms·

I don't have access but it seems you can impose a friend into a video? Are we not rightsholders to our own likeness? It seems like a person should be able to bl

I don't have access but it seems you can impose a friend into a video? Are we not rightsholders to our own likeness? It seems like a person should be able to block a video someone shares without their consent or earn revenue then if their likeness is used.

minimaxir 1y ago
You have to explicitly opt into sharing your likeness with permission controls. > person should be able to block a video someone shares without their consent That is already implemented.
- solid_fuel 1y ago
  > You have to explicitly opt into sharing your likeness with permission controls. Ok... how is that supposed to work? I don't have an OpenAI account, there are no permission controls for me. Someone else could easily upload a picture of me, no?
  - pants2 1y ago
    No, you have to register yourself with a video where you're required to say a unique code. So unless you've posted a video of yourself online saying every number from 1 to 99 they won't be able to copy your likeness
    - noduerme 1y ago
      So only the heads of companies who lead shareholder meetings are vulnerable to this exploit? Cool.
    - solid_fuel 1y ago
      That's more than I expected from them, genuinely. But it still doesn't seem like a very solid solution. I wonder how much variation in look and voice it accepts? My partner likes to cosplay, and some of the costumes are quite extensive. If they want to generate a video in a specific outfit will they need to record a new source video? The problem exists in the other direction, too. If someone looks a lot like Harrison Ford, will they be able to create videos with their own likeness? I wonder how this extends to videos with multiple people, as well. E.g. if both my friend and I want to be in a video together.
    - WmWsjA6B29B4nfk 1y ago
      It’s not like making a video of someone saying a number, given a single photo and any voice sample is a very difficult problem today. We can just fast-forward a few weeks into a world where this „registration“ is already broken.
    - kouteiheika 1y ago
      This seems... pretty easy to get around? There are already open weight models which can take any photo and audio and make a video out of it with the character speaking/singing/whatever, and it runs on normal consumer hardware.
      - pants2 1y ago
        So you wouldn't know what the three numbers are ahead of time, you'd have to be using a real time face replacement model (or I guess live-switching between pre-rendered clips) and somehow convince the app that you're the iPhone selfie cam. But at that point you might as well just use WAN 2.2 Animate and forget about Sora.

minimaxir 1y ago

You have to explicitly opt into sharing your likeness with permission controls. > person should be able to block a video someone shares without their consent That is already implemented.

solid_fuel 1y ago
> You have to explicitly opt into sharing your likeness with permission controls. Ok... how is that supposed to work? I don't have an OpenAI account, there are no permission controls for me. Someone else could easily upload a picture of me, no?
- pants2 1y ago
  No, you have to register yourself with a video where you're required to say a unique code. So unless you've posted a video of yourself online saying every number from 1 to 99 they won't be able to copy your likeness
  - noduerme 1y ago
    So only the heads of companies who lead shareholder meetings are vulnerable to this exploit? Cool.
  - solid_fuel 1y ago
    That's more than I expected from them, genuinely. But it still doesn't seem like a very solid solution. I wonder how much variation in look and voice it accepts? My partner likes to cosplay, and some of the costumes are quite extensive. If they want to generate a video in a specific outfit will they need to record a new source video? The problem exists in the other direction, too. If someone looks a lot like Harrison Ford, will they be able to create videos with their own likeness? I wonder how this extends to videos with multiple people, as well. E.g. if both my friend and I want to be in a video together.
  - WmWsjA6B29B4nfk 1y ago
    It’s not like making a video of someone saying a number, given a single photo and any voice sample is a very difficult problem today. We can just fast-forward a few weeks into a world where this „registration“ is already broken.
  - kouteiheika 1y ago
    This seems... pretty easy to get around? There are already open weight models which can take any photo and audio and make a video out of it with the character speaking/singing/whatever, and it runs on normal consumer hardware.
    - pants2 1y ago
      So you wouldn't know what the three numbers are ahead of time, you'd have to be using a real time face replacement model (or I guess live-switching between pre-rendered clips) and somehow convince the app that you're the iPhone selfie cam. But at that point you might as well just use WAN 2.2 Animate and forget about Sora.