4 ms·
Survey response times creating trend bias. If the economy has been growing at N% a quarter, that’s your baseline until evidenced otherwise. The evidence comes
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
Survey response times creating trend bias.
If the economy has been growing at N% a quarter, that’s your baseline until evidenced otherwise. The evidence comes in the form of BLS surveys and payroll data, both of which are lagging indicators.
Why lagging? If you’re hiring and firing, you’re going to be preoccupied with that before responding to a survey. So the folks who are doing the most change to their baselines tend to respond late. Similarly, if you’re hiring a firing a bunch, you may not get your numbers into ADP precisely correctly the first time around.
- kasey_junk 1y agoNit: the ADP numbers are not survey based. They come directly from adp’s payroll data set which is immense but biased. So you don’t see hiring/firing delay in the birth/death data like you do with the bls stats, but actual dataset bias is a factor. The more murky part of their numbers is how they calibrate to the bls numbers.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> the ADP numbers are not survey based Correct, why I said “BLS surveys and payroll data.” > you don’t see hiring/firing delay in the birth/death data like you do with the bls stats, but actual dataset bias is a factor True.
- busterarm 1y agoAlso biased by being only the customers of ADP. Sure, that's 1/5 of US jobs, but it's also going to be concentrated in some industries more than others -- would be nice to see how that lines up with where job adds and losses landed.
- cameldrv 1y agoIf you're hiring and firing you'd better get the data into ADP ASAP or you're going to be paying people who no longer work for you or not paying people who do. This should be about as close to real-time (neither leading or lagging) as you're going to get.