4 ms·
Oh no, how will we survive? Everybody knows that these threats are hollow (Apple's stock price would take a gigantic hit) but even if they followed through I'm
by jacquesm 1y ago
Oh no, how will we survive? Everybody knows that these threats are hollow (Apple's stock price would take a gigantic hit) but even if they followed through I'm pretty sure we would hardly notice. If both Apple and Google stopped trading here then that might actually be good and create enough oxygen for local competition to flourish.
- AAAAaccountAAAA 1y agoRealistically, it would be local competition completely under Brussels' thumb.
- troupo 1y agoAh yes, the heavy Brussels thumb of ... checks notes ... "don't track your users, don't hinder competition and let people chose if they want algorithmically generated slop"
- gruez 1y agoDon't forget chat control! We would want pedophiles and criminals to have access to phones, now do we?
- wizzwizz4 1y agoChat Control hasn't happened, and if it does, the court will shut it down. (It's still worth fighting, but it's not something that non-activists need to worry about.)
- AAAAaccountAAAA 1y agoOne can't rely on courts only to protect civil freedoms. If and when totalitarian measures become politically acceptable and desired, the politicians will simply amend the EU treaties and national constitutions to allow mass surveillance, and disband or subvert CoE and other limitations to their power.
- zoul 1y agoOh yes. As opposed to the “kiss the ring or else” market freedoms of the US.
- AAAAaccountAAAA 1y agoSo far, they have implemented only cosmetic measures to address those issues, while seriously considering outrageous things like Chat Control.
- gruez 1y agoEuropeans would "survive", but end up with crappier phones. There's a reason why nobody buys nokia anymore.
- aaa_aaa 1y agoPixel is superior.
- ranger_danger 1y agoBecause it was sold to Microsoft whose only strategy was to kill it off?
- gruez 1y agoAnd why was it sold off? Winners don't tend to get offloaded to other companies.
- ranger_danger 1y agoNot only did Apple and Google divebomb their sales, but Nokia's own hardware was plagued with bugs and comparatively inadequate features, like small displays and slow CPUs. MS would later re-sell Nokia to HMD in 2016, who still release some feature-phones, including ones running an "S30+" OS that has nothing to do with Symbian.
- jacquesm 1y agoI have one of these running KaiOS and it works surprisingly well. It also seems to be immune to battery life degradation (it works just as well as it did when I got it) and in general has been rock solid. I think in the almost six years that I've had it, it has spontaneously rebooted once and other than that it just works. It is simple, has buttons (no touch screen), has an earphone jack and is so solid you can drop it and the chance is larger that you damage the thing it lands on that that you damage the phone. It still looks like new in spite of being in my pocket together with keys and other stuff. I'd buy another in a heartbeat if this one ever dies but I suspect it will just keep on working.
- gjsman-1000 1y agoOr, as Apple and Google may bet, the EU does not have the talent required to make a good smartphone without reliance on China, the US, or other unfavorable parties, which defeat most advantages of supposedly local development. They are calling the EU's bluff, and it's possibly a smart business decision to do so.
- sroussey 1y agoEh, plenty of Chinese companies very used to government regulation that would thrive in the EU and not be bothered by their (relatively lesser) regulations.
- gjsman-1000 1y agoIt's not that China won't thrive in the EU; it's that from the EU's perspective, reliance on China may be even worse. Especially morally, considering China has no problem trading with Russia.
- CafeRacer 1y agoAs if europe has a lot of problems trading with russia. I mean, realistically, most of the loud words are just that.
- pembrook 1y agoI think you would be surprised to learn China has far less regulation than the EU. Part of this is China being a far more dynamic, high risk, Wild West-style capitalist system that’s communist only in very specific areas. The other part being, you don’t really have to write stuff down as much when you can just manipulate subjects of your authoritarian regime at will.
- f33d5173 1y ago> The other part being, you don’t really have to write stuff down as much when you can just manipulate subjects of your authoritarian regime at will. That creates a web of implicit rules that need to be complied with just as much as if they were written down, while having the downside of unclear boundaries and exceptions. An environment with more rules, but with them written in ink and with lawyers that can be consulted to interpret them is preferable.
- ranger_danger 1y ago> gigantic hit I don't think so... EU is only 7% of their revenue globally according to their CFO, and DMA can fine them up to 10% of global revenue, so it may actually be cheaper to just leave the market.
- troupo 1y agoTheir execs are not above lying under oath. I hardly believe that a wealthy continent with a population of 450 million is just 7% of their revenue.
- gjsman-1000 1y agoThe simple but unpopular answer is that the EU is no longer a wealthy continent. The EU is finding this out on a daily basis.
- troupo 1y agoWhich is, of course, a bullshit answer.
- gjsman-1000 1y agoActually, it's far closer to the truth than you may think. France? Their debt is killing their country and causing escalating political crises. Germany? Energy costs are killing their competitiveness. Hard to compete with energy costs of $0.44 per kWh on average; before labor costs. Italy? Need I say more? Their economy is notoriously stagnant. The remaining 24 EU countries make up less than 50% of the EU's GDP. Meanwhile, US and EU GDP went from almost 1:1 in 2008, to 1:0.65 and still declining. To give you a sense of how severe Germany's problems are, the US state of Mississippi is almost ready to pass Germany's GDP per capita.
- troupo 1y ago1. So much emotion 2. None of that says that the EU isn't rich 3. None of that proves that the bullshit about revenue Do you know how I know that? Because that "7%" comes from this quote: "Just to keep it in context, the changes apply to the EU market, which represents roughly 7% of our global App Store revenue." App Store revenue is not all of Apple's revenue. Oh, and those same execs claim they don't even know if App Store makes money or loses it, so how would they know.
- _1tem 1y agoNobody said the EU wouldn’t survive. But EU consumers will be very angry at Brussels.
- jacquesm 1y ago> But EU consumers will be very angry at Brussels. Why would they be angry at Brussels? If Apple decides to pull out of the EU market that's on them. EU citizens will be a lot less angry at Brussels than Apple's shareholders will be.
- _1tem 1y agoEU consumers will travel to other countries or buy through second hand markets, which is what happens in Russia now. Apple will lose little revenue. Apple can easily spin this as a win to shareholders showing how much competitive advantage was preserved by not having to build the EUs interoperability demands. In the end the EU consumer gains nothing from all of this but loses their beloved Apple devices.
- bigyabai 1y ago> In the end the EU consumer gains nothing from all of this but loses their beloved Apple devices. 'Beloved' lol. You can just tell American hands typed this. "What if the Europeans can't consoom anymore? Won't they riot in the street when they have to use SMS over iMessage?"
- jacquesm 1y ago