4 ms·
Leaked Windows 8 tablet pricing suggests Microsoft may have already lost the war
- daspecster 14y agoI doubt Microsoft is targeting the consumer market. Most of these tablets will probably be bought by businesses which then force their employees to use them in their already fully integrated Microsoft ecosystem. So...I guess it depends on what Microsoft's priorities are.
- vyrotek 14y agoSo Microsoft lost due to Asus pricing? I think I'll wait until Microsoft officially releases their product and pricing before making that call. I actually really want a Surface tablet.
- runjake 14y agoTwo points: 1.) The article title and contents say it SUGGESTS Microsoft has/will lose the war. It doesn't declare anything. 2.) Historically speaking, pricing commodity gear isn't rocket science. History shows that competitors in the space almost always are on price parity.
- moistgorilla 14y agoJust so people know, this is not talking about the pricing for windows rt and windows x86, which is what most of us care about.
- dmix 14y agoApple has demonstrated that providing a premium product at a higher price point does not equal failure. There's been a hundred low price and low quality tablets pumped out of asia that we never hear about after launch. Why is that the strategy that should be followed?
- tomjen3 14y agoBecause MS is not a premium product. Once Unix was a premium product, MS had DOS. Now Apple is a premium product and MS has Windows. MS has made billions on cheap computing, Apple has made them on expensive, premium products. The problem is that now MS is trying to sell budget devices, at the most expensive price. That won't work.
- recoiledsnake 14y ago>Because MS is not a premium product. >MS has made billions on cheap computing, Apple has made them on expensive, premium products. True but quite misleading because you're comparing software with hardware. A lot of OEMs especially Sony have had laptops costing north of $2000 that sell quite well. MS probably makes the same amount on them, but Sony gets a premium on models like the SZ series and Z series. One of my friends dropped $2400 on this laptop a year ago. http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-HN07CVHIrfM/TmibCh6iDyI/AAAAAAAAAPA/9Jk56qP5bk0/s1600/sony-vaio-z-series.jpg http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-HN07CVHIrfM/TmibCh6iDyI/AAAAAAAAAP...
- bduerst 14y agoI get what you're saying, but he's comparing packages that consumers buy. MS was OS of choice for the cost leaders in the market. Apple was the quality leader.
- EwanToo 14y agoWindows isn't a premium product, but Office definitely still is. It costs significantly more than Apple's (or anyone else's) equivalents, and still sells by the bucket load. The fact that surface (and other win8 tablets) can run Office gives it a huge market that the iPad currently can't get to. It's been well known for months that Office for iPad exists and works, but MS aren't releasing it. The reason for that delay is fairly obvious.
- r00fus 14y agoOk, let me ask then - does MS Surface run Office better than a cheaper netbook? Does the Surface run iOS or Android killer apps? If the answer the above questions are "no", then why get a Surface?
- lambda 14y ago"No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame." I'm not a big supporter of Windows 8, but writing them off based merely on price and specs seems a bit shortsighted.
- politician 14y ago> based merely on price and specs Beyond the price and capabilities, what else should the consumer consider?
- tomjen3 14y agoCapabilities != specs. But as an example, why not consider easy of use?
- grueful 14y agoMost consumers neither understand nor care about the spec sheet. Reasons that make sense to an engineer are alien to most of the market. They typical consumer asks for more gigahertz either as a status symbol or because something is slowing down their existing machine to the point that routine interactions are painful.
- s_henry_paulson 14y agoThis was an attack article through and through. The author chides them for not using a more powerful processor (that would kill the battery life), when Microsoft worked directly with Intel and had them build a processor designed specifically for the Windows 8 kernel that would offer the longest possible battery life. Shortsighted indeed.
- happycube 14y agoDifference being iPod 1 had a much, much better UX than a Nomad. Anything with less than 200DPI is not going to deliver that in 2012. Even at $300 it would be barely competitive, and at $600 it'll join the Xoom in forgotten tabletland.
- snogglethorpe 14y ago
- arocks 14y agoOf course, consumers would not be comparing Microsoft, Android and Apple tablets as Apples to Oranges. There are various factors which influence a 'buy decision' and price is just one of the factors. For example, if Windows 8 tablet becomes a highly coveted or must-have gadget then the premium pricing might look rational or justified.
- mtgx 14y agoWhy would it though? Windows RT doesn't even have access to x86 apps, which means it's starting its ecosystem from scratch. And that means it's even further behind than Android in tablet apps.
- kyriakos 14y agoif windows 8 has even half the success of windows 7 it will automatically become a big player in the tablet market considering all those convertible laptops that are showing up. pricing will matter but getting an i7 processor and SSD in tablet form does cost a lot and if they are to be compared to Apple's products I believe they should be compared to MacBook's rather than iPads. Talking about Windows 8 x86.
- mrgreenfur 14y agoTotally agree. If they are desktop replacements then they aren't iPads.
- ajross 14y agoRight, that's the "Tablet + Laptop Replacement" market. And I agree, I think MS would be expected to keep that, because it's still not reasonably possible for anyone but the most casual consumer to replace their desktop software with a tablet yet. But the notable price in the linked article is the $600 for the Tegra 3 box, which obviously won't run much of the desktop software. Asus is already selling a 7" Tegra 3 laptop (the Nexus 7) at 1/3 that price. Is a 10" partially-desktop-incompatible (!) tablet really worth three times the price of a broadly equivalent Android device already in the market?
- rsynnott 14y ago> pricing will matter but getting an i7 processor and SSD in tablet form does cost a lot These prices are for a Tegra 3 and an Atom. One assumes that if you want an i7 it'll be a little more :)
- stephengillie 14y agoThese price points jive fairly well with Steve Ballmer’s comments in an interview with The Seattle Times last week, which suggests that between $300 and $800 is the “sweet spot” for the bulk of the PC market. Instead of starting as a status symbol and accessory and growing into a full-use device, Surface seems to be coming in as straight PC replacements, and it's being priced appropriately. The keyboard dock is shown as an accessory, but as a necessary accessory - ads seem to show Surface docked as often as solo, and it's the best bridge to people who believe they'll never give up their laptop. When viewed this way, it's like shrinking the laptop to remove the keyboard, leaving just screen and processing guts. (I work with someone who likes to complain about how he believes tablets are useless) The $600 model says it comes with Office 2013 preloaded -- is that full office or just the demo? Remember that Office 2010 retailed for more than $400.
- kyriakos 14y agofull office apparently.
- Drakim 14y agoObviously for Microsoft including a $400 copy of their own software doesn't actually cost $400, unless one hundred percent of the people who get the surface would buy Office 2010 if it wasn't included.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mtgx 14y agoOffice 2013 starts at $139, and the Windows RT version will only have a limited version of that.
- 7952 14y agoWhy not give tablets away free with a Software licence or subscription? At this point tablets could be much cheaper than most enterprise software licences. Why not an office tablet, or a Sharepoint tablet? I am sure it would suck, but it would have more benefits to Microsoft than a tablet that no-one will ever buy.
- vondur 14y agoWe don't know what Microsoft will be charging for their own surface tablets, I'd hold off making any conclusions until then. I'm going to guess that Microsoft will be undercutting their "partners" in the tablet market.
- WrkInProgress 14y agoThere's no mention of the storage on these Asus tablets. The article compares to the 16 GB "new iPad" but if it has 32 GB or 64 GB, it's actually priced in line with the respective model on the former and $100 cheaper on the latter.
- taylodl 14y agoMicrosoft knows what they're doing? That's the funniest thing I've heard in a while. For the record, Microsoft has never had a success in the mobile space (PDAs, tablets, phones, MP3 players). They've come close a time or two but never in the past 15 years have they been the leader in any of these categories. Microsoft dominates the desktop. The XBox is an extension of the desktop. They're hoping to leverage their desktop dominance into a laptop-lite tablet. I'm betting they could care less about the user experience of Win 8 on the desktop. After all where else are their customers going to go? Apple? Linux? A few might. Most won't. This way they can focus all their energies into the tablet and then use their desktop dominance to move people to their tablets instead of Apple's. After all how many iPad owners have a Windows desktop? It's probably the best strategy they have. We'll have to wait and see how well it pans out for them. And no, I have no intention of buying one of these things.
- freehunter 14y agoThe Xbox, which is not a general purpose computing device, is an extension of the desktop, while a tablet (which is a general purpose computing device) is not? How does that make any sense?
- taylodl 14y agoThe tablet is an extension of the desktop. Microsoft has never been successful with them though. Now that the iPad has shown what a tablet can do perhaps Microsoft will be more successful this time around.
- lamebrain 14y agoI'm guessing they will attempt to dismiss iPads and Android tablets as "toys" and tout theirs as the only tablets able to do "real work" or whatever because they run Windows/Office. It will be lame and annoying, but it probably won't work. Well, I take that back. It will probably work on some folks, the kind that wear khakis all the time. You know what I mean.
- unwiredben 14y agoOne thing I've not seen anyone mention: MSRP for the Windows ecosystem devices tends to not be what the devices are actually sold for. There's a lot of margin built into those prices to allow for sales and other retail actions. Apple doesn't have to add buffer to their MSRP as they tend to not leave much margin for other retails; the reason you can buy an iPad at Best Buy isn't because BB makes much money on the iPad, but because they can make big money on the accessories.
- sixothree 14y agoI don't think I could bring myself to spend $800 on a 10" tablet, nor could I convince myself to spend $600 on a tablet that runs Win RT. Besides, Windows 8 is just plain gross to look at and nothing ever fits on the screen.