12 ms·
Hey Yahoo, You’re Optimizing the Wrong Thing
- hooande 14y agoHilary Mason is brilliant. But Yahoo knows what they're doing when it comes to their advertising. YahooMail is one of the most valuable properties on the web in terms of CPM. Their ad display makes for a crappy UI experience, but it also makes them a lot of money.
- hexis 14y agoIt's easy to see the money they make from ad clicks, but it can be hard to see the money, reputation, and respect they lose to get it.
- jmount 14y agoAnd that has always been the problem with Yahoo and their toolbars: they are predatory so you can't trust them or recommend them.
- wpietri 14y agoI'm amazed that you can look at the wreck Yahoo has become by blind optimization and say they know what they're doing. In the particular case of Yahoo Mail, their crappiness has driven off large numbers of high-end users. They also lost a lot of great staff who were tired of working on crappy things for managers who didn't give a shit about the users or the workers as long as the numbers were good and their political power increased. Yahoo's a classic example of what happens when you know the price of everything and the value of nothing.
- mbesto 14y agoAs someone already pointed out, these types of CPM offer NO value to the customer. Does it help Yahoo in the short term? Probably. Long term? Probably not.
- wpietri 14y agoA great example of how user testing is a necessary complement to click data.
- DataJunkie 14y agoPeople that work in "ad operations" usually do that work by performing A/B tests etc. To me, it is a very unglamorous step child to a data scientist.
- wpietri 14y agoIn this context, i think A/B tests would generally be the opposite of user tests. Typically with an A/B test you'll test something like clicks. With a user test you'll have people in to try it out to see things that you can't see in the data. In this case, I think you could look at an A/B test and say, "Ad clicks are up! Great!" But in the user test you might say, "Oh, these clicks are accidental, so although it makes more money in the short term, it will decrease the value of the click and the value of the property.
- ceslami 14y agoThis piece confused me for several reasons. First, if anything, this seems like an accessibility problem that would be hard to solve. Shakiness affects many of us as we get older, but it is hard to design a website around this constraint. Second, there is an implication that this ad placement is somehow "surely wrong," and a step further, is likely only successful due to pseudo-fraudulent interactions. I want to rebut this, but she does not actually substantiate it. The most I can say is that the top-left corner of the screen is the hottest hotspot, so placing an ad there is savvy at worst. I too have been reading her blog for a while, but this piece caught me off-guard as awkwardly personal and lacking in substance.
- smacktoward 14y agoShakiness affects many of us as we get older, but it is hard to design a website around this constraint. Is it? Large link targets surrounded by empty negative space seem like an easy way to solve this problem. The issue is only an issue because Yahoo puts the links in tinytext and crowds the ad link right up next to the "Inbox" link, so a twitch can send the cursor scooting past the link you want to click on to the ad you don't.
- verisimilidude 14y agoLarge link targets surrounded by empty negative space seem like an easy way to solve this problem. That's correct. Adding a tasteful mouse-over effect also serves as a nice additional visual cue. (Speaking from experience: I have a very shaky hand due to an old injury.)
- talmand 14y agoJust curious, why do you feel a hover effect helps in this situation? As an indicator that the pointer is where you expect it to be? How does the hover effect help in cases of shaking hands that cause the pointer to move upon click? Also, do you use a mouse or trackpad? Seriously, I'm curious.
- 14y ago
- webwright 14y agoThings get tense when ad-supported companies have to make money. When I ask my mom or dad to click the first Google search result, they click on an ad. When I ask them if they realized that it was an ad, the response is "no". A good portion of the ad business is confused clicks/taps (it's worse on mobile).
- debacle 14y agoAs someone who has worked on all three sides of the equation (selling ad space, brokering ad space, and buying ad space), I can tell you wholeheartedly that ad purchasing companies do not want these clicks. They're paying for something of no value. I don't know how companies can be convinced to do ad placements like these, or if they simply rely on getting enough conversions from accidental clicks from unknowing users to make out in the end. Either way, it's a bad practice and something I'd equate with a torrent site or rapidshare.
- mattmaroon 14y agoAds like this are typically bid on on a CPC basis. Shaky grandpas who click ads on accident and don't convert drive down the cost of the clicks. If you assume shaky grandpas account for 50% of the clicks, and 0 convert, then they'll make the CPC worth half what it would have been without shaky grandpas. As a result advertisers will bid half as much and pay half as much as CPCs. Just like click fraud, unless it's an orchestrated attack on one specific company, it comes out in the wash. In the end, the advertisers don't really care (at least if they understand the math, which many don't). They care only about their ROI. If they pay 20 cents a click and make 40 they're happy, if not they aren't. Sure you could perhaps get rid of all the shaky grandpas, pay 40 cents a click, and make 80, but it's the same ROI. What you really end up with is a cottage industry of people making websites that can convert shaky grandpas better than real advertisers because just like spam, some non-zero percentage do convert. That's why you see some stupid ID fraud ad there. Shaky grandpas are terrified of the evil hacker who wants to steal their identity.
- debacle 14y ago
- ernesth 14y agoIn yhis case, trackpad clicking is at fault, not yahoo. Whenever I use someone else's laptop, I find myself clicking things I didn't want to click. I believe, that the default should be for trackpad to not interpret a tap as a click.
- aresant 14y agoThe ad is well placed to ensure most users will see it - check out the average horizontal attention graph below to understand the necessity of that placement in the UI vs further right or lower on the page: http://www.conversionvoodoo.com/blog/2010/04/test-your-horizontal-layout-to-maximize-conversion-rate-with-our-free-tool/ http://www.conversionvoodoo.com/blog/2010/04/test-your-horiz... That ad unit is available only through Yahoo's CPM program - not self serve and I know for a fact that ad unit sells out months in advance with huge CPM volume commitments. Modern ad platforms optimize media with backend ROI tracking via pixel-fires / cookies and Yahoo optimizes their inventory to that metric with their advertisers Pain for users in this units placement? Maybe yes. Could do better? Always. But pressing first priority problem for a business that can't afford to screw with their profit centers, no.
- kreilly 14y agoI'm speculating here, but my guess is that part of the reason it sells out is because the person buying it is measured on CTR. If this placement has a high CTR it is going to lift the overall media campaign and make the buyer look good.
- recoiledsnake 14y agoAds on download pages are far worse, and usually served by Google ads. http://wiki.darkpatterns.org/Disguised_Ads http://wiki.darkpatterns.org/Disguised_Ads
- dkarl 14y agoSounds like her grandfather needs a nice heavy mouse. She could disassemble a modern mouse and add lead weights to the inside until the weight and balance were right.
- mistercow 14y agoOr just, you know, turn off tap-to-click.
- vadman 14y agoTouchpads are IMO less ergonomic and less intuitive than mice, sounds like her grandfather could use an extra bit of both.
- mistercow 14y agoA touchpad on a laptop is less ergonomic than a mouse on a properly arranged desktop. But a touchpad on a laptop is more ergonomic than a mouse on a laptop unless you set up your laptop like a desktop (place it on a stand on a big, clear desk with an external keyboard in front and a mouse pad to the side). Trying to use a mouse with a laptop that is sitting on your lap is, in my experience, invariably awkward.
- mycodebreaks 14y agoAll clicks by accidents are unfair to the advertisers. They pay for clicks which were never intended.
- mistercow 14y agoInasmuch as clicks are a valid metric for advertising performance, it is only because they prove that an ad is prominent on a page. So in that sense, there's really nothing wrong with accidental clicks.
- DataJunkie 14y agoCompanies that I have worked for have developed models (approximate) to remove accidental clicks to prevent charging the advertiser. Usually, these clicks are "absorbed" into a CPM though, and detecting accidental clicks is very difficult and requires many assumptions about user behavior.
- mistercow 14y agoCan someone explain to me what the appeal is of tap-to-click on trackpads? It's obviously terrible for usability for anyone with less-than-perfect motor control, but even for someone with ordinary dexterity like myself, it can be infuriating. I don't want to have to tread lightly around my trackpad just to keep from accidentally clicking on stuff. And it's not just me; I watch other people use laptops, and their usage is generally littered with unintended taps; they just don't seem to care that they keep randomly misplacing their keyboard focus or switching to other applications. I mean, I get that it's slightly easier to tap on the trackpad than it is to click with your thumb. But how can that possibly make up for all the time lost to accidental input?
- jmount 14y agoI think tap-to-click is an abomination (on Windows, OSX and Linux). The worst was Windows when I re-imaged a laptop without the OEM drivers the generic Windows driver could no longer turn the feature off (argh!). But I think the attraction for designers is trying to support a pickup and drag gesture on the trackpad without using a toggle button.
- erikpukinskis 14y agoI use it on my MBP for one reason: less strain on my clicking finger, which in the past has led to RSI. Using my old Thinkpads with the TrackPoint and clicking was much more stressful on my hands than my current setup. I don't have any trouble with errant clicks, but I may have altered my typing style. Right now my hands are both entirely off the keyboard (elbows resting on armrests on chair). I also understand there are some improvements in Mac OS X over other operating systems with respect to errant clicking.
- tullidil 14y agoI've never had this problem personally, and I use tap to click very regularly.
- themckman 14y agoMaybe it's just the Mac trackpad or I have perfect motor control, as you imply, but I very rarely have a problem with unwanted clicks due to tap-to-click. I certainly feel more agile not having to apply the pressure necessary to initiate the click and I also don't have to hear the clicking noise the trackpad makes every time I do click. All around better experience for me with little to no downside.
- j_s 14y agoHey Hilary Mason's grandpa, pay $20/yr for Yahoo mail with no ads! Yahoo has already solved this problem.
- dredmorbius 14y agoYet another reason I: - Use a Thinkpad with a trackpoint. - Disable the touchpad. - Use ad-blocking. - Don't use Yahoo.
- yen223 14y agoAs a guy with tremors, the trackpoint is even worse than a touchpad.
- dredmorbius 14y agoWhat is your preferred pointing device, if any? Know a few folks who have to deal with Parkinsons, which a lot of computing devices don't accommodate particularly well.
- yen223 14y agoGet a mouse, preferably one with more mass in it. Helps to dampen some of the shakiness. My tremors are not that serious though, so I'm perfectly OK with a touchpad (I'm a huge fan of Apple's glass touchpad). With trackpoints, it's hard to get a good level of sensitivity.
- cbsmith 14y agoIt's unfortunate that the person who wrote this article didn't consult with someone more informed about the online advertising world. As someone who has been in the belly of the beast, I'm going to try to summarize the various ways that this article is getting it wrong. * Most Yahoo Mail ads generate revenue based on impressions, not clicks. So Yahoo isn't directly making more money by grabbing these "random" clicks. * Where clicks do matter, major ad platforms including Yahoo throw away a LOT of clicks as fraud, and accidental clicks tend to disproportionately get thrown out along with them. * In general, random clicks are considered a real PITA for major ad networks, as they confuse the heck out of ad optimization. While small players do tend to soak up that revenue, the big players really, really hate the phenomenon because it makes them far less efficient. * It turns out what most impacts ad effectiveness online is whether people actually see the ad. An incredibly number of ads are just never seen by the audience. As a consequence, a good publisher will try to find locations for their ads that are highly visible. Highly visible and likely to evoke accidental clicks are, unfortunately, highly correlated. * Most advertisers who are paying per click are very performance driven. They look at ROI, which means they look at conversion rates. When you charge an accidental click, it's almost certainly not going to convert, so in the end you look worse and they pay less for your clicks. * One unfortunate bit of truth: advertisers do pay too much attention to clicks and CTR (click through rate). Even advertisers doing brand awareness campaigns, which are not looking for immediate response from their audience, tend to look at CTR. * Yahoo has actually tried hard to establish other metrics that they should look at, like "Bounce Rate", which attempts to factor in whether visitors immediately exit after clicking. They use those metrics internally for optimizing ad performance, so accidental clicks are likely to discourage showing an ad more than encourage it.
- pkeane 14y agoWise comments. If Yahoo was smart, they'd hire Hilary Mason.