8 ms·
Starbucks: Location closures and elimination of roles
- corvad 1y agodupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45375444 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45375444
- ChrisArchitect 1y agois it? or is this the actual source.
- ChrisArchitect 1y agoTitle was: Message from Brian: An Important Update
- sciencesama 1y agoDismantle unions as they are dangerous for our profits is the message !
- soperj 1y ago"Each year, we open and close coffeehouses for a variety of reasons" Wonder how many of these are being closed because they've unionized?
- hyperbovine 1y agoattempted to unionize -- they are known for nipping that one in the bud. Happened to one of the locations in my town.
- tonyarkles 1y agoHeh, we had one that was very popular for university students to work at and they did successfully unionize. The thing with university students, though, is that they’re not going to be around forever… so the store experienced pretty much complete staff turnover every few years. This store would perpetually end up in weird situations like not being allowed to make coffee because the supervisor had a family emergency and had to leave. The staff could serve cold drinks and snacks but the union regulations required a supervisor to be on-site if there was any risk of burns. None of the people who had done the original push to unionize were still around. They had been students, graduated, and moved on. Eventually the staff got frustrated enough with their own union rules that they successfully voted to un-unionize and the store improved a fair bit. Bizarre situation.
- Gud 1y agoWhy didn’t they just change the rules? “Having a supervisor around” isn’t necessarily a requirement from the union.
- dpoloncsak 1y agoStarbucks told them it was because the union
- tonyarkles 1y agoFrom what I understand talking to the staff, it was because none of the staff (at the time, who weren't part of the original unionization push) actually cared enough about the union to do all of the union stuff (like going through the CBA finely and and renegotiating the rules, regular meetings, shop stewards, all of that). They all had a mentality of "this is a coffee shop I'm going to work at for a year or two, not something that I want to put any extra time into beyond the shifts I need to work to pay my way through school" Edit: If I'm remembering right, the thing that finally sealed the deal for them was that Starbucks corporate was offering better benefits to the entire company than the union (which was made up of like 10 people) had negotiated for themselves.
- teachrdan 1y ago> Starbucks corporate was offering better benefits to the entire company than the union (which was made up of like 10 people) had negotiated for themselves. This was union-busting by Starbucks. The union was more than happy to accept the better benefits, but Starbucks corporate refused to negotiate with them to update their contract. Starbucks was acting in bad faith to undermine the union the workers had organized for themselves.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoAs of this comment, 12,000+ baristas at over 650 stores have unionized. The effort continues, and will persist beyond Brian Niccol’s tenure as CEO (and his $95M pay package). https://sbworkersunited.org/map/ https://sbworkersunited.org/map/
- FireBeyond 1y agoYeah, here, they removed the floor mats, which were intended for the comfort of employees standing for long periods, as a tripping hazard. But, strangely, it was only considered a tripping hazard at stores that had unionization efforts afoot...
- ugh123 1y ago"Second, we’re further reducing non-retail headcount and expenses. This includes the difficult decision to eliminate approximately 900 current non-retail partner roles and close many open positions." What are the non-retail partners?
- mambo_giro 1y agoIt’s their term for corporate employees.
- lawlessone 1y agoIs partner here a way of saying employee but without saying employee?
- xrd 1y agoI was a GAP employee long ago. That was a "good" job because I saw how the "Associate Managers" barely made more than me, the "Assistant Managers" were stuck at 30, so I spent my lunch hours reading computer science textbooks. I mean "good" job in that it taught me exactly what I never wanted to do long term. I recall they had this management consulting team come in with an acronym "GAP ACT" (Greet, Approach, Product add-on, Accessorize, Close/cashier (?) and then Thank"). I suppose they were right because 30 years later I have not forgotten it, but I do recall quitting when they told me to take a toothbrush and clean the plastic fronts of the jeans racks. What a shitty job, and I bet it is not much better for Starbucks employees.
- giraffe_lady 1y agoYeah pretty much. IIRC they give each employee like one share of stock each year to justify the language.
- strongpigeon 1y agoReally surprised about the closing of Starbucks Reserve in Seattle. That place was always bursting at the seams and must have had a major halo effect for the brand. It's hard not to associate the closure with its recent unionization.
- YC873498723 1y agoNo way! I've been there and had the best tasting coffee and pizza of my life. Surprisingly good combo. And it was right next to the old Living Computer Museum. It was for sure the highlight of my trips to Seattle. :(
- shawn_w 1y agoThe museum is also gone for good. Thank Paul Allen's estate for not wanting to keep it going or find an organization to take it over.
- ethagnawl 1y agoI absolutely believe that the Reserve location in Seattle was busy and can second that those locations had a halo effect for the larger brand. I've only been to the Reserve location in Midtown Manhattan once and it was very different experience than your run-of-the-mill location. Specifically, I had a drink replaced without asking because the barista said it had "died" while I was in the (nice, clean, great smelling) restroom. Overall, it was just a nice, pleasant experience and I definitely would have frequented that location if I was working in that area regularly. I wonder if this shop was a union one? That might explain why everyone was so pleasant and why it seems to have been closed.
- widowlark 1y agoFortunately we have ample local alternatives in Seattle to pick from
- jsbisviewtiful 1y agoFeel bad for those employees. In the last 10 years I've gotten Starbucks maybe twice, both times because we were on the road and needed coffee... and it was the only option. A true fall from grace; The drinks are either sugar bombs or taste burnt and corp loves union busting.
- throwfish3000 1y agoThey blow it more than half the time when it comes to regular drip coffee. I still remember my first starbucks visit as a 13 y.o. Sitting down, having a coffee, not knowing what caffeine was, and having the best conversation of my life.
- bombcar 1y agoSometimes I think Starbucks is more properly classified as a milkshake joint. The calories!
- betaby 1y ago> taste burnt It was the case since forever ( ~15 years+ ). Starbucks is not a speciality coffee shop. There is nothing wrong with that. One has to acknowledge that high volume coffee shops have to rely on basically burned beans in order to be consistent with the taste.
- 1y ago
- jypepin 1y agoIt's always funny to me how they are still insisting on customer experience and good coffee house. In the bay area most starbucks have become the burger king of coffee shops: housing of drunk homeless people
- HnUser12 1y agoBay Area isn't rest of US and Canada. Based on my limited experience most of Bay Area looks like that, not just Starbucks. The Starbucks's near me in Canada are fine. If they get rid of the long line of mobile order people, they'd be pretty fine.
- DarkNova6 1y agoI never understood Starbucks. I live in Europe, we have good coffee places everywhere. They are cheaper and serve significantly better coffee. I can't think of anything I ordered from Starbucks that didn't taste artificial.
- ausbah 1y agoi think it’s mostly for american tourists
- morkalork 1y agoWhich is really sad, when I go to Europe I love trying all the different types of pastries you can get at the coffee shops there. A strudel with an intensely sour filling is not something you will find in North America for example.
- quantumwannabe 1y agoIt most definitely is not. The vast majority of customers at European Starbucks are locals, not tourists.
- ausbah 1y agothat is indeed sad
- mothballed 1y agoThe ones in Seattle were solid. Not sure why, but I could never order a coffee from any of the other ones again after that, it seemed like the rest were fake ripoffs. I think they basically developed a quality brand then just gutted the quality everywhere else to expand and it worked.
- Poomba 1y agoFor me, I just order a drink when my wife stops by one to order one. I hardly go out of my way to order it myself. Everything from the drinks to the pastries are mediocre
- 1y ago
- mostlysimilar 1y agoCEO makes $95 million dollars a year by the way.
- techietim 1y agoHow much should he make?
- ProjectArcturis 1y agoMaybe 1/100th of that?
- supertrope 1y agoMaybe put it to a shareholder vote for approval instead of having a board of directors compensation committee rubber stamp.
- bombcar 1y agoIf estimates are right he makes 2-3 cents per coffee sold.
- jihadjihad 1y agoImagine logging into Gusto etc. and seeing $3,958,333.33 under Gross Pay for 10 business days of work.
- numa7numa7 1y agoYou could max your 401k real quick.
- brk 1y agoThis corporate word substitution bullshit really needs to die. Nobody on the receiving end of this is a "partner". Partner implies some amount of equality in things, a voice, a considered opinion. The people being cut almost certainly did not want to be cut, and I would wager none of them were asked for their input. Zero "partners" are impacted by this. The people impacted are employees. Also, Starbucks do not operate "coffee houses", they're coffee stores at best, or even just "retail locations".
- andrewmcwatters 1y agoI have noticed for well over a decade or more, perhaps 20 years or longer, really, I'm not sure when it started, but companies are reluctant to call people "employees." Edit: I'm too young for this, but it's along the lines of Personnel from the '60s becoming Human Resources in the '70s and '80s, and Human Resources from the '90s and '00s now becoming People Operations in the '10s and '20s. I suspect in the '30s it'll change again. Maybe one day there will be a culture change towards boring and we'll just call people "customers," "employees," and the departments responsible for hiring the "Hiring Department." And people will get mad about that, too, because the HD will be responsible for the paperwork required to fire people, too.
- McAlpine5892 1y agoThis pains me so. Every time I have to hear "individual contributor", "leadership", or "the brand" I die a little inside. Please just call me an employee or engineer. As for "leadership", I am somewhat convinced that the word "management" would lead to a mid-life crisis. Such inflated egos. As for "the brand", they are my employer. This Newspeak has benefits though. Mainly that it hides in plain sight the top-down hierarchy of power that exists. Despite that fact that some employees are on food stamps while others make millions, it _sounds_ like everyone is on on somewhat equal footing.
- orsenthil 1y agoReal Deal here is. Store Closures: North America coffeehouse count will decline by about 1% in fiscal year 2025 Will end with nearly 18,300 total Starbucks locations (company operated and licensed) across US and Canada Staff Reductions: Approximately 900 non-retail partner roles eliminated Additional open non-retail positions closed Store employees (partners) at closing locations will be offered transfers where possible, or severance packages if transfers aren't available Who's affected: Non-retail partners (corporate/support roles) - notified Friday morning Retail partners at closing coffeehouses - notified during the week of the announcement
- orsenthil 1y agoTLDR Starbucks is closing about 1% of its North American stores due to poor performance or unsuitable locations. The company is eliminating approximately 900 corporate/office jobs and closing many open positions in support roles. Store employees at closing locations will be offered transfers to other stores when possible, or severance packages if no transfers are available.
- sota_pop 1y agoWeren’t they just celebrating record profits and patting themselves on the back about the profitability of their clever new giftcard/digital payments program a couple of years ago?
- numa7numa7 1y agoDoes any one go to S-bux for the 'elevated experience'? Or do we go for our 1200 calorie 'coffee' milkshake on the way to work every morning?