18 ms·
Have You Ever Tried to Sell a Diamond? (1982)
- lwat 14y agoSo... why is there no second-hand diamond marketplace? Lots of people would want to buy cheaper diamonds and there has to be people wanting to sell theirs.
- jquery 14y agoGood question. There is a second-hand diamond marketplace. But the discount you get is proportional to the extra effort you must exert to get the diamond you want. Do you want a 2 carat triple-A GIA certified round brilliant with VS1 clarity, >I color, and an HCA score under 2? Good luck. You'll spend months tracking that down. And you better know what you're doing or you could get scammed. Or you could go to a diamond wholesaler and get what you want, right now, no hassle, and pay the associated overhead.
- caf 14y agoSo there's an opportunity here, for a market facilitator. Hire a few qualified gemstone appraisers, set up an auction site and take a small rake off the top.
- lisper 14y agoEven better, write some image-processing software that can automatically grade diamonds more quickly and accurately than human appraisers.
- simonh 14y agoDiamonds are already largely graded automatically. DeBeers has invested heavily in grading equipment that can specifically distinguish natural from artificial diamonds.
- Kadin 14y agoSuch places exist. I know of one (http://eragem.com/ http://eragem.com/) but I'm sure there are others. The euphemism "Estate jewelry" instead of "secondhand" or "used" seems to be preferred.
- kamaal 14y agoSorry but is this the real reason why somebody buys a diamond? The number one reason why anybody buys anything expensive is because they wish to make a statement for that moment. Now if you go by what this article is trying to convey is the value of diamonds in the investment per se. No body I know buys diamonds as an investment. My father once gave me a gift which his father gave it to him. Which is basically a wrist watch that automatically winds a spring inside while a person is walking. That watch is practically useless by today's standards. But that is totally besides the point. He gave it to me because that has some 'emotional value' and the fact that it was expensive at that time, and his father went through a lot of work to buy him that has some sentimental value attached to it. That is the whole reason behind its existence, He gave it to me because it means something to him. Many of my friends have asked me if I want to sell it, but I've turned them down. It looks awesome and is a jewel. My mom also wears a diamond, and she has told me once she passes away that is supposed to given to me and never to be sold to anybody else. No, De Beers didn't whisper in her ears not to sell it. Its just my dad gave it to her and that diamond reminds her of her days when she was young, and the moment when it was given. That thing reminds her of those days. She just doesn't want some other women to wear it. You can argue these things in the investment per se. But you don't give the diamond to your girl and that moment is gone forever. You can earn that money back again, but you can't earn that moment back. She won't have that diamond with her which she can remember you gave it to her. As nerds we can argue about rationality, but what is that worth to human sentiments? Besides you can expand this argument to everything around. And the only way to live will be to live frugal.
- HorizonXP 14y agoSo why do I have to buy my future fiance a diamond to experience that moment? Why not give her a piece of coal? It's the same element/material, just in a different, albeit less attractive, form. No one's arguing about the idea of giving a gift or a token or your love. The issue is about why this token needs to be a diamond. I know that in our family, and my girlfriend's, there is a lot of jewellery that is passed down between generations. This is usually gold though, which at least has some value associated with it. It's not like we consider melting any of it down or selling it. But it's nice to have real value associated with generational possessions on top of their sentimental value.
- spyder 14y agoRelevant: http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Global-News/2012/0917/Russia-reveals-shiny-state-secret-It-s-awash-in-diamonds http://www.csmonitor.com/World/Global-News/2012/0917/Russia-...
- sp332 14y agoThose are tiny, tiny diamonds that could be useful for industrial purposes but will never be useful as jewelry.
- ksherlock 14y agoThe story is from 1982. Yet still timely.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoA little odd though: "the quality of the diamonds, measured in dollar value, had declined by nearly 100 percent." I wonder how that was calculated ?
- matt4711 14y agoSo which of these "predicted" events actually happened?
- tptacek 14y agoThe diamond cartels continue to prop up a fake market fed by the product of human misery largely by convincing people that diamonds have always been a clear symbol of social status and of devotion.
- chris_mahan 14y agoIs it me or is the article way too long?
- tptacek 14y agoIt is just you. That article is a classic in long-form investigative journalism.
- yeoldestuff 14y agoGod how I miss that. Where can I find 100's more like this, _on the web_?
- tptacek 14y agoEasy: Longform.org. Slate aggregates and curates some of these: http://www.slate.com/articles/life/longform.html http://www.slate.com/articles/life/longform.html
- yeoldestuff 14y agoSweet. Thanks.
- zalew 14y agohttp://longreads.com http://longreads.com http://longform.org http://longform.org
- henrikschroder 14y agoSweet! Found an old longform article I had lost the link to and couldn't google back either. Thanks!
- vidarh 14y agoEntirely off topic to this post, but given the HN audience, this is one of my all time favorite long form articles: "Mother Earth Mother Board" by Neal Stephenson. Wired. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/4.12/ffglass_pr.html http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/4.12/ffglass_pr.html It's about FLAG - Fibre Optic Link Around the Globe. 40k+ words.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- fallenapple 14y agoHa, they quickly stuck a date in the title. ;) I was going to comment this is a "pre-internet" story. The film Blood Diamond came to mind as I was reading this, and the "Diamond District" in New York City. Lots going on behind the scenes in the "diamond industry". This is a superb lesson in 1. artificial scarcity and 2. how consumers can be conditioned to accept new symbols (a diamond is just a rock; but what does a diamond "mean"?). Both are principles that, for better or worse, apply to how business is done on the web.
- neverm0re 14y agoAnother fantastic bit of information about the history of the diamond trade, courtesy of Frontline, circa 1994: http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6186684678299366197 http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-6186684678299366197
- TheAmazingIdiot 14y agoBy fallenapple ( from showdead): Ha, they quickly stuck a date in the title. ;) I was going to comment this is a "pre-internet" story. The film Blood Diamond came to mind as I was reading this, and the "Diamond District" in New York City. Lots going on behind the scenes in the "diamond industry". This is a superb lesson in 1. artificial scarcity and 2. how consumers can be conditioned to accept new symbols (a diamond is just a rock; but what does a diamond "mean"?). Both are principles that, for better or worse, apply to how business is done on the web.
- yeoldestuff 14y ago"A diamond is forever." Translation: Please, please, please don't resell it. You'll screw up our cartel.
- tammer 14y agoSimilar article, although a less historical perspective: http://harpers.org/archive/2010/06/page/0059 http://harpers.org/archive/2010/06/page/0059 (warning: paywall)
- jonnathanson 14y agoIt's a fascinating piece, for a number of reasons. The first, and perhaps most interesting, is that the story behind the De Beers cartel is well known. Perhaps not in this depth, but still, it's no secret. Pretty much everyone knows they exercise a monopoly on diamond production and distribution, artificially keeping prices high. And yet, nobody takes the red pill and opts out of the illusion. Call it the power of the diamond industry's marketing. Call it adherence to tradition (created by the diamond industry's marketing). Call it what you will. But it's a powerful force. Consumers know it's a lie, and they choose to live the lie. Second: a major prediction made in this article did come to pass, but it didn't have the predicted effect on diamond pricing. A serious contender to De Beers emerged in the early 2000s in the form of a multinational, "breakaway" cartel. Yet, both cartels -- and all other minor, independent players in the market -- seem to be acting in concert to keep supplies artificially low, and prices artificially high. In fact, the rate of price increase is at its highest in modern history. Economics tells us that this shouldn't be the case, especially given the emergence of new market entrants. And yet, the rate of price increase took off at precisely the same moment as the entrance of the new competitors. (Source: http://www.ajediam.com/investing_diamonds_investment.html http://www.ajediam.com/investing_diamonds_investment.html) What could be causing a major, year-over-year price increase in the face of new competition? Well, one guess would be that the two cartels are colluding in some way. Perhaps they've made an arrangement to fix prices or production. Or perhaps they've carved up the map, and reached some sort of non-competition agreement in each other's territories. Perhaps both. Ordinarily I'd call these ideas paranoid. But the history of the diamond business tells me that we can't put it past these guys.
- zizee 14y agothe story behind the De Beers cartel is well known. Is it really? Or are you assuming that because you and your friends know about it that you think that everyone knows about it? (not an attack, just a easy trap to fall into). players in the market -- seem to be acting in concert I think that whenever a new participant enters the market they find that the most profitable path is to collude with the existing cartels. After all, if diamonds are really worth nothing, why would you enter the market unless you planned to keep the status quo? What could be causing a major, year-over-year price increase in the face of new competition I seem to remember reading somewhere that the growing affluence of Asian markets was increasing demand. But that might be the marketing spin. edit: added everything under "or are you assuming" sentence.
- HorizonXP 14y agoWow, absolutely brilliant. I can't believe this article popped up on HN's front page tonight. I just got back from looking at engagement rings with my girlfriend. I've known about this monopoly for a while, and so has she. Heck, one of the first movies we watched together when we first started dating 7 years ago was Blood Diamond. Here's the conversation we had while in the jewellery store tonight. Me: "Sweety, I really don't want to buy you a diamond. I really would rather buy you something that at least has some more value associated with it, like a sapphire." Her: "Well, I've always pictured a diamond ring. That's what everyone gets." Me: "Well, what do you like about the diamond that the sapphire doesn't give you?" Her: "I like the sparkle." Me: "Ok, that's fair. What about moissanite? (Link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moissanite http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moissanite) It's supposedly even more sparkly and brilliant than diamonds." Her: "What's it made of?" Me: "You know how diamond is just carbon? Moissanite is silicon and carbon in the same type of crystal structure." Her: "And it's natural?" Me: "Well, it can occur naturally, but it's extremely rare. So the ones you buy are usually created in a lab, but are more brilliant than a diamond, but actually cost less. I can apparently get a 1.5 carat stone for $800." Her: (annoyed) "I don't want something fake!" Me: "Oh, so it's not about the sparkle then?" I swear, De Beers has probably pulled off the greatest marketing stunt in the history of humanity. The fact that it's so ingrained in our minds, to the point where a smart, educated, and informed person like my girlfriend still wants a diamond even after knowing all the issues with them, is fascinating. Honestly, as a community of people in the startup ecosystem, we could stand to learn a thing or two here.
- humbledrone 14y agoIf you end up going with a diamond, you might consider a company like Brilliant Earth [1], which offers "conflict free" diamonds (and other gems), and recycled precious metals. Their gems come from mines that employ adults at reasonable wages. I'm not associated with the company, but they made my fiance's engagement ring and we're very happy with it. [1] http://www.brilliantearth.com/conflict-free-diamonds/ http://www.brilliantearth.com/conflict-free-diamonds/
- HorizonXP 14y ago
- Wingman4l7 14y agoIf you want a ring that shimmers brightly with color, is unique from stone to stone, and actually has value, try opal. The only downside is that it's not as tough as diamond, so you have to take some care not to damage it, although this can be mitigated by the way it's mounted in the ring.
- mixmastamyk 14y agoA classic, I read it first almost a decade ago. My advice, take her on a trip to Paris and Versailles instead... or climb Mount Everest if you're more adventurous. We have great memories.
- Tichy 14y agoTry not to get her killed, though. Hasn't climbing Mount Everest something like a 20% mortality rate?
- brazzy 14y agoAccording to Wikipedia there have been 4.3 fatalities for every 100 summits (generally decreasing over time), but that can't really be meaningfully expressed as a mortality rate because the fatalities include people who never reach the summit (and may not even have planned to). What can be said is that of those who successfully reach the summit, 1.1% die during the descent.
- niggler 14y agoCan't believe its on the front page, given my comment a few days ago: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4523063 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4523063
- Gustomaximus 14y agoGreat read. Amazing what wealthy interests can do to a market. I had to smile at the ending: "By the mid-1980s, the avalanche of Australian diamonds will be pouring onto the market. Unless the resourceful managers of De Beers can find a way to gain control of the various sources of diamonds that will soon crowd the market, these sources may bring about the final collapse of world diamond prices. If they do, the diamond invention will disintegrate and be remembered only as a historical curiosity, as brilliant in its way as the glittering little stones it once made so valuable." As the diamond market hasn't collapsed 30 years on, De Beers must still be doing something right.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- Nick_C 14y agoI've held a plastic bag of raw Australian diamonds -- they look like dirty grainy sand. Almost all of the Kimberley pipe's output is industrial quality, not gem quality, although the pink gemstones are very nice. Australian gem quality output was never going to seriously disrupt De Beers, just challenge them a bit. That was known at the time, and I'm slightly perplexed why The Atlantic's article says what is does.
- creamyhorror 14y agoThis article is regularly submitted to HN, but it's good reading every time. Winning the war against the marketing of the diamond industry will be hard, but a start is to keep spreading articles like the following: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ira-weissman/7-reasons-why-you-shouldn_b_1720870.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/ira-weissman/7-reasons-why-you... 7 REASONS WHY DIAMONDS ARE A WASTE OF YOUR MONEY I've been in the diamond business for over 10 years. I've traveled all over the world buying and selling diamonds. I've passed through most of the major airports across the United States with about a million dollars worth of diamonds in a leather wallet stuffed inside my pants. I've bought and sold diamonds in Dubai, Mumbai, Moscow, Hong Kong, Paris, Stockholm, Tel Aviv, Madrid and Barcelona. Even today I am involved on the fringe of the diamond business, running a diamond education site helping would-be buyers. Considering my deep personal involvement in the diamond business, my opinion might surprise you -- diamonds are a terrible waste of your money. Even if this article doesn't convince your female friends, it'll spread some awareness and cause more people to view diamond engagement rings with a bit of doubt. When I shared it on Facebook, I got likes from only male friends and arguments from a female friend. This was slightly unusual because such topics normally get a few likes from female friends. I guess there's a serious uncertainty among my friends about throwing away the valuing of diamonds that's been strongly ensconced in the minds of wider society. Fundamentally, a large part of the worth of diamonds comes from their cost and the sacrifice they represent. This in turn is a conspicuous signaller of value, when women show their diamonds to friends ("look how much he loves me"). So any alternative to diamond rings has to show a similar level of value/worth. We have to try to beat diamond marketers at their own game - with equally powerful anti-marketing. I'd advocate an approach of laying the groundwork early by sharing such articles regularly, and when actually in a relationship, offering a display of value that she appreciates (e.g. memorable trip to Europe, endowment to a cause of her choice, a custom-designed gemstone) in tandem with asking her to consider other gemstones, perhaps one in her favorite color. If the ground's been softened by our combined anti-marketing campaign, she might be willing to select and customize a stone that she genuinely finds beautiful and accept your specially planned trip (maybe extend it to Asia too, to up the friends'-envy quotient). Or at least I hope as much.
- TomorrowMars 14y agoAfter some terrible early experiences with gold diggers, I am now very happy to be with a woman that despises any and all status symbols, and instead of buying them invested some money in gold and silver bullion early on, as part of a diversified portfolio. She routinely spends the money that status-affected women waste on social symbols on travel, sports, fitness and healthy leisure. My advise to all startup entrepreneurs is simple - plan your mating like your startup - lean and goal-driven. Identify your goals, budget, deadline and overall strategy. If you cannot meet the woman that meets your demands where you are, travel and diversify.
- miraj 14y agoon another note (also on todays HN homepage!) "Russia reveals secret diamond field containing 'trillions of carats'" http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4534468 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4534468
- sayYaeah 14y agoWell, it is a perceived value, but we all perceive it. Like someone pointed out, it is not an investment. It is a demonstration for your future marriage. She wants to see how much she's worth to you. Buy the ring. If you indeed have moral issues, buy the conflict free one.
- christiansmith 14y agoThe discovery of the South African diamond mines in 1870 and its impact on the diamond industry seems to be a good analogy for what the music industry is going through today. In both cases there is rapid shift from scarcity to abundance, and in both cases, the supply side of the market try to save their businesses by engineering artificial scarcity. Somehow I doubt the record industry in its present form will fare quite as well though.
- ngm-hn 14y agoMost of the article seems critical of the diamond industry. Have they not done people a service by providing them with a nice product that they can enjoy? There are certainly moral problems with how they built their empire, but why are clever marketing and aggressive pricing bad things? The former is simply how you tell people about new products. Remember diamonds went from being owned by almost no one to being owned by lots of people. If those rings make them happy, then why is it our business? How is DeBeers marketing any different from Apple marketing? Of course, the article does do a good job in warning people that their diamonds may have little resale value. But that's a risk most buyers are willing to take. After all, most non-divorced people don't sell their wedding and engagement rings.
- Quizz 14y agoIt's bad because it's a vertical cartel, from mining to distribution. Cartels are illegal in that it limits the free market using artificial price controls. It's the artificial price controls that are illegal. Apple faces competition from Android, RIM and Win8. DeBeers diamonds do not face any competition from any other diamond producer because they spent 50 years establishing their network for "gem" quality diamonds. DeBeers is beyond marketing. Why did the U.S. government go after Microsoft? Standard Oil? Why did the U.S. prevent AT&T from merging with TMobile?
- ngm-hn 14y agoWell no, that argument does not work. Apple is the monopolist supplier of iPhones. And it charges whatever price it wants for iPhones. If DeBeers is a sole (or near sole) supplier of a product, then Apple certainly is. Further, DeBeers must face the same competition that Apple faces. In these comments, we see lots of people looking at other gemstones (sapphires, etc) in place of diamonds. The other gemstone producers compete with DeBeers in the same way that other smartphone producers compete with Apple. I'm not sure it's helpful to reason from the fact that something is illegal to why it is wrong. Sort of like the joke about the three storekeepers in jail: The first charged higher prices than everyone else and was convicted of price gouging. The second charged lower prices than everyone else and was convicted of dumping and cutthroat competition. The third charged the same prices as everyone else and was convicted of collusion. Laws will be made against all kinds of things, and there are many incentives (e.g. law firms revenue) to make laws against very profitable enterprises.
- obi-nine 14y agoLooks like the price of diamonds is about to head sharply south: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2204566/Russia-diamonds-Source-Siberian-asteroid-crater-supply-world-markets-3-000-years.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2204566/Russia-diamo...
- dimitar 14y agoThe Russians just announced that they have a huge amount of quality diamonds on their territory in some site that they haven't started exploiting yet. To profit they basically have to ape De Beers and create a huge demand in Europe or Asia (I think diamond engagement rings are that big only in the USA)
- guard-of-terra 14y agoI think that most of diamonds sold Russia are mined in Russia (Yakutia probably). Still they are expensive and luxur-ish. I guess Russian jewelers are just riding the world-wide hype wave, not interested in disrupting or "harming" the market.
- bduerst 14y agoTo be fair, the diamonds at that site are from/the result of a meteor crash, and most are small in diamond terms.
- startupfounder 14y ago3 Days ago Rohin (http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=rohin http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=rohin) the co-founder of Pricenomics posted the article: "We Need a Warby Parker for Mattresses" (http://priceonomics.com/mattresses/#industry http://priceonomics.com/mattresses/#industry) to which I responded: "We need a Warbly Parker for Diamonds" (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4522922 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4522922). Niggler posted a comment to this Atlantic article (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4523063 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4523063) and then submitted it as a new post that didn't get traction because I am guessing of his new status (green name text) in the HN community. Olalonde (http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=olalonde http://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=olalonde) who is an old hat commented on the article, but didn't get that many up votes or reply's (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4525901 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4525901), but submitted the Atlantic article (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4535611 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4535611) that Niggler found and brought to the HN community. Now this great article from 1982 is on the front page of HN.
- olalonde 14y agoActually, I posted this article just after reading the story about Russia revealing a secret diamond field containing "trillions of carats" http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4534468 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4534468 (I don't recall reading niggler's comment or yours honestly). I think that's why it got so many up votes. In fact, it seems this article is regularly submitted on HN: http://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/submissions&q=Have+You+Ever+Tried+to+Sell+a+Diamond&sortby=points+desc&start=0 http://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/submissions&q=Hav.... Now that I think about it, I think I first discovered this article through HN 2 years ago.
- shrikant 14y agoPrevious good discussions on this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1405698 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1405698 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1110283 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1110283
- Quizz 14y agoIt appears that the diamond market has reached its peak, and is on its way out: http://www.economist.com/node/21538145 http://www.economist.com/node/21538145 The Oppenheimers have sold their entire stake in DeBeers - they've cashed out. They went from producing 80% of the global market (in the 90's) to 35%; clearly, the writing is on the wall, and without strong centralized vertical management, the diamond market will collapse. Time to short diamonds.
- squarecat 14y agoOne-page, seizure-free view: http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/print/1982/02/have-you-ever-tried-to-sell-a-diamond/304575/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/print/1982/02/have-you-e...
- finkin1 14y agoFantastic read. Bernays (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Bernays http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Bernays) was also an interesting character.
- rondon1 14y agoI got my wife a moissonite ring. I took it to a jewelry store once to get it cleaned. The person there went on about how beautiful it was. I said it was moissonite and she quickly said we don't work on moissonite and handed the ring back and left. Everyone assumes it is diamond because it is double refractive and actually brighter than diamond. Only a gemmologist would know the difference.
- laic 14y agoGeneration after generation of brain wash, there is nothing you wouldn't believe, such as Kim Jong Il is the savior of the world.