7 ms·
>>You are not correct. If anything with information travels faster than the speed of light, then there are frames of reference in which that information arrived
by enraged_camel 14y ago
>>You are not correct. If anything with information travels faster than the speed of light, then there are frames of reference in which that information arrived at the destination before it left the origin.
No. If you send a radio signal to Mars, and then warp to Mars to find yourself there 0.1 seconds later, you are still 0.1 seconds after the moment on which you sent the signal from the point of origin. You are traveling faster than light, in the sense that you are traveling at [Earth-Mars Distance]/[0.1 sec] speed, but you are not actually traveling backwards in time to a point where you have not sent the signal yet.
- nessus42 14y agoNothing you just said contradicts my statement, which was, "there are frames of reference in which that information arrived at the destination before it left the origin." I suspect that you don't know anything at all about Special Relativity, in which case, there's not much more I can tell you except to go educate yourself.
- teamonkey 14y agoSpecial Relativity only applies to cases where there is uniform relative movement in two or more inertial frames of reference. That is not the case with this theory - the relative movement is clearly not uniform and although I've not read the paper I'm certain that the time warp provides a non-inertial frame. TL;DR - ignore Special Relativity completely, General Relativity is the only thing that applies here.
- nessus42 14y agoSpecial Relativity applies ANY TIME that you transmit information from one point A in an inertial frame to another point B in an inertial frame. If you can use your warp drive to transmit information from A to B, then Special Relativity applies. If you cannot use your warp drive to transmit information from A to B (e.g., from Earth to Mars), then what good is it? (I've mentioned several times in this thread that you might be able to come up with some sort of FTL drive that doesn't violate causality if you put enough constraints on it to make it useless.)
- teamonkey 14y ago> Special Relativity applies ANY TIME that you transmit information from one point A in an inertial frame to another point B in an inertial frame. Not true. It also implies uniformity of space-time in all inertial frames and the space between them. Since the theoretical purpose of the warp drive is to create a non-uniformity by definition SR does not apply.
- enraged_camel 14y agoYeah, pretty much. I'm actually amazed that so many people (nessus included - as he seems to be the most vocal poster on this thread) do not know this.
- nessus42 14y agoAll Special Relativity requires is that space be more or less flat between point A and point B. It doesn't matter if the information travels from A to B through a wormhole and then into another universe and then out the butt of Dumbo, if it ends up at B before light would, then causality has been violated. If, on the other hand, your FTL drive bends up space all around us to be like a giant hyperspace pretzel, (1) we're going to have a lot more problems than just a little violation of causality, and (2) causality still ends up being violated via General Relativity.
- teamonkey 14y agoCausality is a consequence of the physical laws you are currently using, not a law in themselves. It just paints a logical boundary condition around what is possible using the current set of laws that you are using. Compare Newtonian causality where there is only one timeframe everywhere to SR causality with its local timeframes to GR which supports warping of space and time. All different and not interchangable. Wormholes cannot exist in SR, therefore applying SR's brand of causality is equally invalid. Under GR the concept of simultaneity is relaxed: the effect is only limited to the light cone of the cause.
- 14y ago
- lmm 14y agoWe're not applying SR to an observer who warps, just to two observers in inertial frames of reference. Suppose we have guy A and guy B who have clocks. They're on spaceships which are both drifting away from each other (i.e. provide inertial frames) at speed c/root 2; at time t=0 they were in the same place. From SR it should be clear that in A's frame, his clock reads 100 at the same time as B's frame reads 50, while in B's frame, when his clock reads 50 A's clock reads 25. All this should be basic and obvious. So suppose an event happens on A's ship at time tA=100, and he transmits this instantly (or sends a courier C on a warpship) to B at time tA=102, when B's clock reads tB=51. From B's perspective, he's just received a message from A at time tB=51 (which is simultaneous with tA=25.5), which A is not going to send until tA=102 i.e. tB=404. Thus, B perceives a violation of causality. (This becomes very obvious if B can send an insta-message back to A with the same technology; B sends it at time tB=54 which is simultaneous with tA=26, A receives it at tA=26, well before he sent the original message at tA=102)
- Dylan16807 14y agoSure, B sees things happen in the wrong order, but I will maintain that causality is not actually violated until an effect actually disturbs a cause. In other words, if B sends that message back to A, you have violated causality. If B just sits there and watches events happen out of order, then the causality is obscured but not broken.
- lmm 14y agoMaybe. I can't directly see an event disturbing a cause after the first message, but that doesn't mean there's not a way to make it do so. Of course the cheap answer is that it violates SR (and common sense, given the complete symmetry of the situation) for A to be able to send an insta-message to B but B not able to send an insta-message to A.
- Dylan16807 14y agoWell, either one can send a single message. It's the reply from a different frame that causes trouble. In fact you can have unlimited FTL messages sent in a single reference frame. It's only when you combine multiple FTL reference frames that things get wonky.
- bluedanieru 14y agoThis is as good a place to start as any: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_of_simultaneity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relativity_of_simultaneity