5 ms·
These are challenges for people sharing housing, but they're not the legal reason why letting out rooms is illegal. Prohibitions on multifamily housing are all
by tptacek 1y ago
These are challenges for people sharing housing, but they're not the legal reason why letting out rooms is illegal. Prohibitions on multifamily housing are all rooted in racial animus. It's the entire reason we have single-family zoning (a related legal proscription), which emerged very shortly after the Buchanan v Warley decision that outlawed outright racial zoning. There's a long and well-documented history of this, all the way down to regulations targeting multi-generational households (Black and Latino families are more likely to have a grandparent or aunt living alongside a younger family).
"The Color of Law" is a good starter read here.
- tw04 1y ago>There's a long and well-documented history of this, all the way down to regulations targeting multi-generational households (Black and Latino families are more likely to have a grandparent or aunt living alongside a younger family). That really doesn't track with the laws actually written. Every single city I've lived in with restrictions on number of unrelated tenants, simultaneously has an exception that there are no limits on related parties, whether through blood or marriage. They are very much limiting the number of unrelated people in a single dwelling and it's targeting slumlords, not the renters.
- danaris 1y agoOr they're targeting polyamory.
- toomuchtodo 1y agotptacek nailed it with regards to it being historically racial, but I've also seen, to your point, animosity towards anything that isn't a "traditional" or nuclear family. Fear of the different and unknown is a powerful motivator of the people who bring these complaints. Also animosity towards poverty and the belief or perception of material increases in crime and/or traffic. (property owner, many units, yimby, have to interface with the citizenry at zoning meetings, etc)
- SoftTalker 1y agoI'm sure in some/many cases there were racial motivations but also SROs that have many unrelated people in individual rooms often become seen as flophouses and are seen as undesirable by other property owners. So they are often prohibited at least in single-family zoned areas.
- toomuchtodo 1y agoCertainly, but I'll also argue that single family zoning needs to go, and upzoning enabled anywhere reasonable. Do existing owners not like flophouses? Do they not like density? Do they not like any change at all? All of the above. Property owners are entitled to their property, they are not entitled to stop efforts around them to increase housing supply or density. (as someone who has acquired lots, rezoned, and have contracted to have multifamily built in such areas)
- SoftTalker 1y agoI do agree that one contributor to the housing crisis in many areas is the lack of SRO and boarding houses, which used to be much more common at least in urban areas. Those are all largely gone now, and they used to be common entry-level housing options for young singles. If I owned a house would I object to the neighbor taking in a boarder or two? No, but I could see being unhappy about them moving out and turning the house into an SRO rental, especially if those tenants created a nuisance in the neighborhood. Same as a problematic Air BnB. I think a good compromise might be allowing SRO/boarding if the owner also lives in the house. That is what my town is discussing for at least some residential neighborhoods. SROs should also be more often allowed in already multifamily/high density residental areas.
- bpt3 1y agoProperty owners absolutely are entitled to stop efforts around them to increase housing supply or density, and I say this as someone who also has done similar work to you. If a community wants to remain SFH-only, that is their right, even if other people who can't afford to live there or would just like to see higher density would really like them to change their mind.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bsghirt 1y agoWhy are the cities that you happen to have lived in a relevant data set here?
- tw04 1y agoWhy aren't they? Because what appears to have been an obvious point to everyone else isn't you you: My point is, across multiple states, and various cities, I've never run across an instance without a family carve-out. I even went through the trouble of picking random large cities throughout the US and literally every one of them has a carve out. Unless you can provide some data otherwise, why is your comment relevant to this discussion? What value were you trying to add?
- brazzy 1y ago> it's targeting slumlords, not the renters. That's the stated reason. The real reason is of course to target the renters who cannot afford anything else.
- pseudalopex 1y agoHe didn't say all prohibitions rooted in racial animus targeted multi generational households. I knew a city where people said they supported unrelated tenant restrictions because they didn't want migrant workers living in their neighborhoods. Secondary suites are desirable for multi generational households. They are or were banned in many places. The cities where you lived allowed any number of related people in a 1 bedroom apartment? A 2 person per bedroom limit seems common. Related or not. And prohibition of a child sharing the bedroom of an adult or a different sex child or a different gender child.
- ipaddr 1y ago"Prohibitions on multifamily housing are all rooted in racial animus". That's not true even if part of your statement is true. Many prohibitions are based on moral reasonings outside of race. You couldn't rent a hotel room in most places if you were not married regardless of race.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- stocksinsmocks 1y agoI’m pretty sure the law has a lot more to do with existing property owners trying to preserve the value of their own property, than it has to do with lobbyists hating Democrat party bloc voters for literally no reason at all. Though the latter story does get out the ol’ vote. I guess working class people with a mortgage are the Kulaks now.
- tptacek 1y agoWe're discussing zoning codes that were essentially set in the 1940s and 50s, and have only been incrementally adjusted since then. "Democrat/Republican" wasn't a salient distinction for this issue at the time (and much of the Democratic base had the opposite racial salience.)
- kronicum2025 1y agoSo, people were not allowed to have their grandparent live in the same household as the parents? That seems awfully bad for social health.
- lazyasciiart 1y agoA grandparent is the parent's parent, so that would be fine by all the variations that I've seen.