9 ms·
The link between trauma, drug use, and our search to feel better
https://web.archive.org/web/20250921171337/https://lithub.com/the-link-between-trauma-drug-use-and-our-search-to-feel-better/ https://web.archive.org/web/20250921171337/https://lithub.co...
- giantg2 1y agoThis article makes a lot of assumptions or claims with nothing to back them up, mostly the parts about a system built to traumatize, Charlottesville as an example, etc. It seems to be entirely lacking any context of what life was like in preindustrial times vs modern times. Death was way more common back then, including losing your children. Let's not forget the impacts of religions and superstitions as societal frameworks and how those tended to handle anything different. Even punishments like stoning, flogging, or crucifixion were much more brutal. One of the main premises of this article is that society today is more traumatic than in the past, which I find to be laughably incorrect. They took what could have been a good article simply exploring modern drug use and ruined it with all these tangential and unfounded claims.
- grvdrm 1y agoI read the article and said “so, what was that about?” Felt more like a journal entry. Anecdote: try everything but the drugs if you can. What helps me: regular exercise, cut alcohol, do my best to sleep/wake up with a schedule. Make a list of what I need to do every day that isn’t insane. Not going to solve everyone’s problems. But I’ve consumed clonapen here and there for very specific reasons and otherwise don’t need it when I keep all of the above as top life priorities.
- cwmoore 1y agoSure, but if alcohol and clonopin are not drugs, neither are any of the others.
- walleeee 1y agoIt can be read charitably as claiming that society is traumatic in different ways, maybe, and in a wider variety of ways. Which is much more defensible. A rapid change in everyday psychological or physiological reality is traumatic, by definition, as one must adapt to it or bear the consequences. There may be less instances of stoning and flogging but many more of subtle conditioning, for instance. Quantity comparisons are challenging when there are big differences in kind
- giantg2 1y agoI think it would have been more interesting if they spent any amount of time exploring the causes. Such as basic life sustaining tasks being easier so there are fewer distractions from trauma. Or feedback mechanisms around effort, success, struggles, and triumph are reduced compared to a hunter gatherer. Etc
- Aurornis 1y agoThe social media definition of trauma has diverged from the clinician definition. The social media version of “trauma” is used to define anything stressful. When we start redefining trauma to cover everything down to the basic realities of life like having to pay for rent to live somewhere, the term loses meaning. With a definition this broad, where do we draw the line between stress and trauma? Is there a line between basic inconvenience and trauma, if the person suffering the inconvenience doesn’t handle it well? The less discussed problem is that some people have a problem of exaggerating everything into catastrophic stressors, thereby turning common experiences into traumas. This itself is a problem that is addressed through therapy, but it’s not as amenable to garnering sympathy on social media. It’s not appealing to read someone whine about having to work a job to eat food in a first world country, because that’s life and it’s a hundred times easier than it was for our ancestors. However, reframe that as a high-brow article about the perils of capitalism and how it inflicts trauma on us and causes PTSD and now it feels like we are the victims who deserve sympathy.
- wswope 1y agoThe article is tailing off a well-established historiographic narrative that it cites at the beginning (Will Self) but doesn’t dwell on much. Basically, the common argument is that life WAS emphatically much more brutal in the preindustrial past, and people felt the same grief that we do today — however, such events were less likely to serve as an etiology of chronic anxiety-centered conditions like PTSD for a multitude of reasons. E.g. you can’t lay around depressed in bed all day if you rely on subsistence agriculture because you’re going to slowly and painfully starve, or you’re exposed and desensitized to brutality from a younger age, or you have less strict social requirements/expectations than a modern 9-5 would impose so you can grieve and act out on your own terms, etc. Dan Carlin’s “Painfotainment” is a good self-contained intro to these ideas for a casual audience, if it seems up your alley.
- colechristensen 1y ago> you can’t lay around depressed in bed all day if you rely on subsistence agriculture because you’re going to slowly and painfully starve What makes you think this wasn't common?
- giantg2 1y agoYes, and the article explores none of that. Complaining about stress from rent being high would be much more palatable if they explored those types of things, or simply didn't mention it at all. Instead they focus on the stress being from high rent vs from the reasons you point out. The way they use that quote makes it seem like they didn't read or understand the larger text, but just cherrypicked what fit with their narrative.
- discreteevent 1y agoWell, I remember reading an article some time after 9/11 where they studied the incidence of PTSD in New York following that event. Even in areas that were some distance from the towers there was a relatively high incidence. They put it down to a background level of stress including sources like violence on TV. This was in comparison to other parts of the world that were less modern and less busy than experienced more traumatic events but had less PTSD. The conclusion was that if you generally have a more boring/ quiet life you will be better able to absorb trauma if it occurs.
- ants_everywhere 1y agoThere's been an attempt to redefine "trauma" broadly. Technically trauma is acute stress. That is, a great deal of stress delivered all at one time. There's been an attempt to redefine it to include chronic stress. That is, generally living under stressful conditions. I don't know why people are doing this, but it's almost always closely bound to politics. For example, the commenter below mentioning the political commentators Will Self and Dan Carlin as evidence for the theory. I've noticed generally that people who talk about trauma being broad in this sense also tend to have a confused understanding of psychology in general. > One of the main premises of this article is that society today is more traumatic than in the past, which I find to be laughably incorrect. They are definitely incorrect. One pop culture way of looking at this is fairy tales. Not too long ago we used to tell children that if they went into the woods they could get eaten by people who lived there and lured children into their houses.
- elmomle 1y agoDo you think another term is more appropriate to describe the experiences underlying CPTSD? It's now quite broadly recognized that its effect on the psyche is severe and if anything broader in impact and more difficult to heal than acute trauma.
- Aurornis 1y ago> Do you think another term is more appropriate to describe the experiences underlying CPTSD? True CPTSD as diagnosed over time by a clinician is the result of complex traumas (complex, specifically, as that’s part of the definition. It’s what the C is for). The term is valid in that context. In common social media language, even the term CPTSD has become diluted. It was intended to represent complex cases of PTSD which were edge cases, and correspondingly rare. At some point the social media version of CPTSD emerged as a generic term and nearly everyone who self-diagnosed as having PTSD started upgrading themselves to CPTSD. The comment above is right that “trauma” has become so generic as to cover everything stressful or saddening in common vernacular. The concept of CPTSD was supposed to be a step above even normal trauma, but now even CPTSD is being brought out as a generic term for any post-trauma response, which was never the definition of CPTSD. A similar trend is happening on social media with the ADHD influencers now upgrading themselves to “AuDHD” which they say is a special more difficult variant of ADHD combined with Autism. My friends in psychiatry are at their wits end with all of the people coming in and demanding Autism diagnoses or “AuDHD” diagnoses despite not showing Autistic traits at all. There’s an arms race going on where some people try to amplify experiences into something much more dramatic. These therapy and psychiatry terms start to lose their meaning when they get adopted by social media.
- 6stringmerc 1y agoCounterpoint: The instance at the cheerleading convention here in Dallas where a knocked over piece of equipment prompted a panic and viral news spread with incorrect assumptions. The "ripple effect" of trauma is magnified more than ever. You don't even have to go out of your way to get the news, as with the past, oh, before 30 years ago...now it's in our pockets. I think the assumption passes the intuition prima face test in my world, too bad not yours. Equipment may need better calibration.
- bendigedig 1y agoI like the fact that it attempts to provide an alternative narrative to the artificial medicalisation of 'mental illness'. Maybe it isn't totally factually accurate but it has enough truth to me that it represents a small flicker of hope in what is too often a chronically invalidating world.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- akk0 1y agoAs a piece of generic advice, I suggest turning one's search to feel better into a search for feelbetter. Notice that how we feel is not stable, but changes constantly from moment to moment. Notice that moments of feelbetter and moments of feelworse basically even out over the longterm. Notice that feelings are causal, that everything is a consequence of something prior according to consistent and comprehensible rules. Notice this on anjimmediate moment-to-moment here-and-now emperical basis. Notice that attributing feelings here and now to decade old stories and narratives is spooky action at a distance.
- pinkmuffinere 1y agoYou might have a real point here, but it is very hard for me to understand what you’re saying. Why is “feelbetter” preferred to “feel better”? Your second paragraph is parseable imo
- grvdrm 1y agoYes, was looking for the plain English version too.
- NathanaelRea 1y agoWhat I take from it is that feelings are elusive, that you can never "reach" them. Your mind is constantly popping into existence feelings, emotions, and thoughts. Rather than trying to force yourself to "feel" a certain way, just notice how your mind reacts to the world or environment. The grasping or aversion of mind states leads you to spirals of thoughts or suffering.
- lanstin 1y agoUsing emotions as data rather than judging emotions as moral choices, clever.
- bonesss 1y ago> attributing feelings here and now to decade old stories and narratives is spooky action at a distance. Pattern recognition, recurrent excitation of particular stimulus chains, formative psychology, neuroplasticity, and extraordinary stimulus leading to categorical responses. There seems to be deep evolutionary roots and reasons for all those behaviours and their collective expression. I was bitten on the face by a dog as a child. I attribute feelings around curious dogs now to that decades old experience. My nervous system seems to think it’s an obvious connection, not spooky. Feel better is easier outside of fight/flight conditioning.
- DaveZale 1y agophysical exercise results in 2000 myokines active throughout the body which have many actions, including anti-anxiety, and better sleep. But the pharma industry can't put it in a pill form. So it's not advertised like the pills are.
- andoando 1y agoI think we really ought to force patients to demonstrate a history of exercise before prescribing them anything in all but the more serious cases
- DaveZale 1y agogood idea maybe even including those weight loss peptides depression, anxiety, sleep issues for sure
- DaveZale 1y agospeaking of depression and ocd, some guy is stalking me to downvote my posts. Dude get some exercise
- kelseyfrog 1y agoIt remains one of the minor curiosities of digital modernity that every recipe blog insists on beginning with a 5,000 word ethnography of the Hugo Spritz, SEO-optimized invocations of Tuscan terraces, grandmotherly hand-gestures, and the precise terracotta shade of sunset, only to resolve in instructions amounting to little more than "insert beverage into rectum." Meanwhile, I occupy a less celebrated corner of culinary praxis: crouched in the dirt, literally on my hands and knees, begging the search bar to reveal how many meprobamate tablets one is meant to dissolve into a lukewarm gin glass to properly constitute a Miltini. There are no Medium posts, no Substack manifestos, no "Ultimate Guide to Recreational Tranquilizer Mixology (2024 Edition)." The epistemic silence is total. The Hugo Spritz has a cathedral; the Miltini does not even have a footnote. And so we encounter, yet again, the asymmetry of knowledge production: the internet, glutted with spritz-bloggers optimizing for engagement, yet barren when it comes to cataloguing the rituals of genuine desperation. Borges, in his Library of Babel, anticipated this imbalance: an infinity of recipes for lining the pockets of the prosecco-producing class, but not a single one for escape.
- kens 1y agoYou're wondering why you can't find a Miltini recipe online? One trick for finding out historical information is to search archive.org. That quickly turns up a 1956 article [1] with the recipe: a Miltini is a six or seven-to-one Martini [i.e. ratio of spirits to vermouth] with a Miltown substituted for the lemon peel or olive. The dramatically overwrought article continues: "It is doubtful if any other creation of the mid-20th Century so typifies this frantic, uncertain era in which no man can know what the next hour will bring." and suggests that a hermetically-sealed shaker of Miltinis should be placed in time capsules "so that posterity can know what real cool cats we were and how extraordinary the civilzation we wrought." Personally, it sounds a bit like an urban legend. As the Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia said: "Unlike most drugs, its name was easily pronounceable and, better still, lent itself to punsters and jokesmiths on TV screens in the homes of millions of people. Example: 'Miltown Berle,' or 'The Government is giving out a Miltown with every income tax blank,' or 'Use a Miltown instead of an olive to make a Miltini'". [1] https://archive.org/details/palm-springs-desert-sun-1956-11-14/mode/2up?q=%22miltini%22 https://archive.org/details/palm-springs-desert-sun-1956-11-... [2] https://archive.org/details/sim_business-review-federal-reserve-bank-of-philadelphia_1959-03/mode/2up?q=%22miltini%22 https://archive.org/details/sim_business-review-federal-rese...
- Aurornis 1y agoI advise a lot of caution when reading articles like this. This is more of an opinion piece or stream of consciousness writing style, even though it’s presented as if it was well researched authoritative material. The article starts with buzzword bingo for topics that appeal to a certain group: Trauma, drugs, capitalism is to blame for our pain, and so on. The sections describing the drugs will make anyone familiar with basic pharmacology groan. Meprobomate isn’t a drug with unknown action like he claims. It’s a GABA-A agonist with adenosine reuptake inhibition activity. When we say it isn’t fully understood we mean there’s more to it, but that’s the case for literally every drug. This person has misunderstood that as if don’t know how it works at all. The sections about GABA are also full of similar mistakes. Benzos don’t “flood your brain with GABA”. They bind to part of the receptor that modulates its activity. We switched to them because they are much better in overdose relative to older drugs. The author’s drug use is also in an unfortunate pattern. Modern prescribing practices only suggest benzos for short term situational use. They are not a primary treatment for chronic anxiety and they do not address psychological issues. SSRIs, buspirone, and therapy techniques are indicated for long term treatment, not benzos. Benzos are also not good for sleep quality even though a high dose can help someone get to sleep. The number of issues with the treatment described in this article is large, and I feel sorry for anyone who gets misled into thinking this is normal psychiatric practice. These days most doctors are hesitant to prescribe benzos at all because many patients want them and can start abandoning the better long-term treatments while they seek more benzos (a strategy that doesn’t work, as this author sadly discovered). There is also an undertone of “America bad” in the article (not surprising for an article that opens by blaming capitalism for all of our suffering) but many would be surprised to learn that benzos are currently far easier to acquire in many other countries. France has some eye-popping numbers of benzo prescriptions across the population right now, whereas you’re going to have a hard time walking into an American doctor’s office and getting a benzo prescription (there are exceptions, of course).
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- PaulHoule 1y agoTake a heavy dose of benzos and you will look superficially like you're asleep, someone might try to rouse you and be unable to do it. My take on benzos is that by binding to the receptors it does it opens up ion channels that drain the electricity out of your associative networks, suppressing just about everything. Sleep it turns out is a structured state of unconsciousness and the EEG will show the person "sleeping" under the influence of beznos isn't actually asleep but they're unresponsive and amnesiac so they think they slept and so did onlookers.
- bbminner 1y agoRe ending - while it probably alludes to the fact that we need community to feel better - expecting another person to be able to help you with your emotional state (or expecting from yourself that you might be able to fix someone's emotional state) is a slippery slope. One might argue that if someone is appreciated on the basis of whether that person makes one feel good in the moment - they are being treated no different than a drug (alcohol, etc). Some argue that such unhealthy dependencies on soothing agents (drugs or people) stems from lack of self soothing skills. Apparently, most "happy healthy people" (there are ofc caveats with this definition but for arguments sake let's assume that we share some understanding of what that means) have an intuitive understanding of how to take care of themselves both physically and emotionally in ways that return them to a baseline state of sorts. If you lack such skills, you often resort to less healthy coping strategies to draw yourself towards this baseline state. Funny quote from sir Terry Pratchett: Death: "THERE ARE BETTER THINGS IN THE WORLD THAN ALCOHOL, ALBERT." Albert: "Oh, yes, sir. But alcohol sort of compensates for not getting them."
- WarOnPrivacy 1y ago> One might argue that if someone is appreciated on the basis of whether that person makes one feel good in the moment - they are being treated no different than a drug The efficacy of psychology can vary widely with each party - both the patient and the helper. While mood-altering drugs are more consistent in general, their effects degrade, depending where one is on the usage timeline (1st use, 10th, 100th). I use Kratom to somewhat dull the effects of mild anxiety. It is enough to preserve general functionality - and that, in-turn, makes causes (of anxiety) less forbidding to consider. Doing this means I tend to live in a '10th use' space. To preserve that benefit, I don't try to increase dosage if I venture into distress territory. My current regimen is helpful or it isn't.
- munificent 1y ago> One might argue that if someone is appreciated on the basis of whether that person makes one feel good in the moment - they are being treated no different than a drug (alcohol, etc). I think this is a very consumer-centric reductionist way to look at human interaction. We are a social species and have been so for millions of years. Social connection and interaction is deeply encoded into our genes. We have dedicated cranial hardware for recognizing faces and emotions in others. We have a complex larynx and tongue entirely so that we can make sounds that convey meaning to other humans. Given that, it's entirely reasonable to state that we need human connection not as a drug-like balm to cover a failure to be a sufficiently hardcore individualist, but because that as what it means to be human. You wouldn't say a worker ant dying on its own is a failed ant. Ants need their colonies to be ants. We need our tribes to be people.
- raybb 1y agoI recently read the paper "Opioid Crisis: No Easy Fix to Its Social and Economic Determinants" which argues that the opioid epidemic isn't as supply driven as we tend to think and that places with weaker social ties and economies recently changed for the worse tend to see more overdoses. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5846593/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5846593/
- alecco 1y agoThe Sacklers did nothing wrong (?) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sackler_family#Reputation_laundering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sackler_family#Reputation_laun...
- LorenPechtel 1y agoYeah. Drug use is mostly a result of something horrible about your life. The drugs might legitimately help (such as opiods for pain), or they might just provide a temporary escape. The only real fix is to remove the source of the problem, then dealing with the habituation can actually work.
- logicchains 1y agoThis matches my personal experience that people who feel some kind of emptiness inside are more likely to develop problems with drugs/alcohol.
- reenorap 1y ago"As capitalism has invented ever more ways to be miserable, so too has it invented ever more specific ways to ease that misery." What? Is the author saying that misery didn't exist in socialism or communism?
- crawfordcomeaux 1y agoNo. That's your bias injecting that interpretation.
- esbranson 1y agoIgnorance is bliss.
- dyauspitr 1y agoIf this is a guy and he says things like a platonic snuggling with a lesbian made him feel good, then it’s an automatic disqualification. I can’t look up to this person. Being staunchly leftist, as a man, I hate this and the exact opposite of what I want a man to represent. You can ask any follow up questions you want but the baseline assumption is someone that acts like this is an automatic, baseline, fundamental opposite of a role model. We desperately need a centrist party that is contemporarily “sexist” to pull men back from the brink. Honestly, thought most feminists are going to recoil from this paradigm, this is way better than the alternative where we essentially lose the men (of all races) to the far right void.
- crawfordcomeaux 1y ago"Man" is a dualistic made-up term devoid of connection with reality. Enjoy your fantasies. The world is nondual, not Boolean.
- em-bee 1y agowhich part bothers you? that the woman was lesbian, or that the man enjoyed a platonic interaction with a woman? what exactly should he have done? demanded sex? or reject her because she is lesbian? not allowing platonic interactions with the other gender is what is making life difficult, especially for men. this idea that any intimate interaction between different genders has to be sexual. that men and women can't just be friends. that being in the friendzone is bad... that's not the world i want to live in.
- dyauspitr 1y agoPlatonic, lesbian, generally being weak and ineffective
- munificent 1y agoA trick I learned a few years ago that has made writing like this and the entire web much more useful to me is this: Instead of asking myself "is this piece overall correct?", I ask myself "what can I take away from this piece that is useful to me?" Instead of striving to come to some sort of overall conclusion about a written work, I just treat it as a potential source of nuggets that I can choose to keep and use. Do I agree with the overall premise that capitalism is an unbridled source of trauma and that a pre-capitalistic world was better? No, that's obviously silly leftist absolutism. Yes, being forced to work in a coal mine is traumatic. But watching your kid die of starvation because you don't have fertilizer is too. So what? No one cares what conclusion I come to about the author's worldview. What I think this article does a good job of is pointing out that our modern physical and cultural environment, which is largely a product of capitalism, is structured in a way that creates new traumas that we aren't well-equipped to deal with. I think of widespread psychological drug use as a social warning light, flashing to tell us that we aren't living right in some way. That doesn't mean we should throw out the entire capitalist baby with the bathwater. But if you don't think something is seriously off about the world today, maybe this article that help open your eyes to that.
- nurettin 1y agoSo capitalism bad bad ptsd and communism good? What's the point of mentioning economic regimes every two sentences as if it makes a lick of difference in how much suffering people can inflict on each other and what people use to cope with that? What is the revelation that I am missing here?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- esbranson 1y agoThe frame on capitalism is classic Kool-Aid. The broader truth is that industrial modernity, regardless of system, generates trauma, and people reach for substances to cope. Others blame capitalism. Alcohol is endemic in communist societies for a reason. (China does not have alcoholics, don't ya know.) Under socialism or communism, you still had/have factories, railways, 996 culture and regimented time. Trauma from pace of change, regimentation, and accidents still exists. Under socialism or communism, instead of gig work being bad, gig work is good. Patriotic even. Under socialism or communism, profit is not the motive. It is chemical pacification of undesirable elements. Under socialism or communism, instead of each generation of pills being marketed as desirable, they would be part of mandatory education as desirable or just given through Directly Observed Therapy. On and on we can go. There is a direct translation of every point in this author's make-believe reality of capitalism. Also, a very weird, Hollywood picture of the 20th century.