4 ms·
If we could live off of a handful of ideas and had no want of food, shelter, or clothing, I'd be in complete agreement.
by astrodust 14y ago
If we could live off of a handful of ideas and had no want of food, shelter, or clothing, I'd be in complete agreement.
- baddox 14y agoWe (the human race) would be worse off if we only had a handful of words or numbers, yet I believe that respecting words and numbers as property is nonsensical and harmful.
- chris_wot 14y agoYour fallacious argument intrigues me. Fallacious because we can still live quite well without there being intellectual property. Could you expand upon your theme? Perhaps I'm not following.
- chii 14y agoBut you are confounding physical property with "intellectual property", which is infinitely reproducible once discovered. The only reason patents exist is to "promote the science and the useful arts", and it seems to be theres a growing body of evidence that this goal is not being achieved (at least, in the field of software - may be its working great for the manufacturing/pharma industries).
- icebraining 14y agoThis is the point where you demonstrate with evidence that a lack of recognition of IP would cause such problems, right? As someone who gets paid for developing software that can be freely shared, I'm particularly interested.
- astrodust 14y agoIf there's zero protection for "intellectual property", it becomes a lot harder for the majority of the software industry to even function. Apple, as an enterprise, has been very successful by building a profitable operating system platform and channeling those profits back in to both hardware and software engineering. That kind of enterprise would not exist if Apple's software could be used by anyone for anything. Any hardware vendor of any consequence could use that as they see fit, resulting in a stew of mis-matched standards and rampant confusion, not unlike the Android tablet market. While there are good products in this space, they are often difficult to differentiate from superficially similar yet technically inferior alternatives. This is not helping people on the whole. Personally I like the choice between a premium product which is commercialized and free, open-source alternatives that are, for many applications, good enough. I would not want a market that's locked in to one model at the expense of the other.