5 ms·
What We Can Learn from Nordic Socialism
- logscope 1y agoSocialism works on paper and maybe the first couple of years, but we who are living with it now can clearly see the downsides. I would prefer capitalism over socialism and communism and to be honest I now believe socialism is the road that leads to communism in the end, it just take longer time to get there. If you want to see how we have progressed over time time please watch the debate between Olof Pamle and Thorbjörn Fälldin from 1982 and compare that to any "modern" debate. Same topics, same "solutions".
- jghn 1y agoWhat country do you live in where you're experiencing living with socialism?
- brabel 1y agoThe examples given are from Sweden, so I guess that's where they're from. I live in Sweden and this is absolutely not a socialist country. Capitalism is very strong here, you're mostly free to invest capital in whatever you want with many ways to avoid taxes, just like in the USA, for example. There's higher taxes for the average, salaried person (though it's not at the highest levels compared with similar OECD countries[1]), but for investors, it's not so bad. Also, salaries vary wildly between professions, lots of things, like rail lines, which are usually thought of as government concerns are privatized, neighbourhoods are more and more unequal (in Stockholm, you can go from a place where the humblest dettached house costs above 12 million SEK - around 1.3 million USD) to another where the starting price is more like 3 million SEK without travelling very far). It's definitely not "the same" everywhere (segregation based on ethnicity is crazy high, but that's another story). So, I find it hard to consider Sweden to be anything like what you would associate with socialism (the only "socialist" thing in my opinion is the sales of alcohol - which is monopolized by the Government - but even that started opening up recently as they allow producers to started selling directly to the public from their production locations - like breweries). [1] https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/topics/policy-issues/tax-policy/taxing-wages-brochure.pdf https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/topics/policy-issue...
- PaulHoule 1y agoThe difference is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_democracy as opposed to the "workers control the means of production" idea of Marx, Lenin and such. You tax individuals and businesses and use those provide certain services. There's also the idea that you have legislation to protect workers (minimum wage, 40 hour week), consumers (air bags in cars) and the environment (no lead in gas.) Other than that you let capitalists do what they do best. What I can't get is that so many people get so angry at the idea that poor people, or at least poor people younger than 65, could have access to health care in the US.
- delichon 1y ago> What I can't get is that so many people get so angry at the idea that poor people, or at least poor people younger than 65, could have access to health care in the US. That's a pretty glib dismissal for real pain. Before Obamacare, in the nearest major city I could make an appointment with a gastroenterologist on a Thursday and see him on the following Tuesday. Now it is over six months for an appointment, and then for every subsequent appointment ... to see a nurse, not a doctor. There used to be five doctors in my rural county, now there are zero. While insurance premiums have skyrocketed. From my point of view healthcare has crumped. You then summarize my dismay as anger at the idea of poor people getting access to healthcare, like what else could it be other than class bigotry?
- PaulHoule 1y agoSo what you're saying is that the services are oversubscribed and if more people have access to them than you won't have access to them?
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoAfter steeping in Fischel's tract on the proximate cause of housing inflation (linked to from Klein).. I gather that the main (meta-)issue, as you are kind of insinuating here, is that, for healthcare, there is a conflation of inflationary and deflationary processes.. (Sorry to go on what might seem to be a reductive tangent here, as I often do when pressed. I have further takes on Klein vs Shapiro for later) My roughshod framing of (one) solution is that there has to be sustained deflationary pockets in a mildly inflationary phase Probably mirrored by such proposals for housing as https://devonzuegel.com/for-the-greater-good-the-game-theory-of-zoning https://devonzuegel.com/for-the-greater-good-the-game-theory...
- lawlessone 1y agoCapitalism work on paper too, lots of competition everyone wins but i now believe is the road that leads oligarchy in the end, it just take longer time to get there.
- os2warp5 1y agoRemove their fish and oil and see 5 years span
- whirlwin 1y agoFor Norwegian situation, I can recommend the book "The country that got too rich" which in fact is very accurate. Socialism works to a point but if it continues to spiral into more aggressive socialism you will end up in a much worse place for everyone, this is where Norway is heading the moment unfortunately even though we are a social democracy on paper.
- karmakurtisaani 1y agoThat sounds vaguely terrifying! Seriously tho, care to elaborate?
- whirlwin 1y agoThe socialists’ rallying cry has long been, “Finally, it’s ordinary people’s time.” But in reality, ordinary people have seen their wealth steadily decline, while the state has only grown fatter and richer. The slogan should be more honest: “It’s the state’s time now.” Now the state has more employees and will continue growing to attain more power, and thereby more voters. Having worse public services than 10 years ago while the spending has increased drastically is a bad sign. That being said, it'll have to get drastically worse before ordinary people realize where their money went, and then it might shift
- DengistKhan 1y agoYou could say the same about the US, regardless of if you meant the last year, last 5 years, or last 30 years.
- throwaway0236 1y agoThe book has some valid points when it states that the government has too much money and does not need to make the hard prioritizations. It has however been heavily criticized. It seems like he had a point to prove and found numbers that fit with his view, and not a neutral description. He also seems to ignore that the trends he points to, also exists in other countries. That said, he does raise some valid concerns. The number of employees in the public sector grows, even under conservative governments. Part of the reason is that Norway can afford it at the moment. Another reason is that the number of rules and regulations increases, and the government needs more people to enforce them. The latter is mostly a political issue, and something that also happens in countries that are not wealthy. The author's solution is to reduce taxes and cut public spending.
- CyMonk 1y agoI often wish I lived in a world where people understood that social democracy, socialism, Marxism, and communism are not synonyms.
- jimbokun 1y agoEspecially among the people who advocate for them.
- snapplebobapple 1y agoRedo the whole justification and analysis based on network effects and utility to payor instead of from each according to his ability to each according to his need and this statement would become a lot more practically believable
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoInsurance! -is based on network effects -has utility to both payor and payee -long modelled as "from each according to his ability to each according to his need" -is already practically believable -only synonymous with "gambling"
- snapplebobapple 1y agoIncorrect. Insurance is modelled on expected value with premiums that provide a profit on average across a pooled group. Try again.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoSo is gambling but we also know that is a joke. The point is that leveraging some subtle disparities in EV* would what'd be necessary for something like the above "ideologies" to "work" over time (although so far the politicians on the whole don't think like this) *usually supported by better data and models, which is what governments that don't piss the people off with taxes are good at
- jimbokun 1y ago> Instead, following and citing the Marxist sociologist Erik Olin Wright who argued much the same, Dragsted proposes that societies are hybrids, frequently containing noncapitalist elements — cooperatives, public institutions, solidaristic welfare systems — even under capitalism. Is this controversial on the left?
- spwa4 1y agoThat depends. Are there literal seas of oil money available in a modern democracy, allowing to do all these programs and things without requiring free or very cheap labor from socialists? If the answer is no, then it's very controversial.
- pploug 1y agoOf the scandinavian countries, only Norway has money, Dragsted is danish.
- hagbard_c 1y agoYou forgot the word 'oil' between 'has' and 'money'.
- spwa4 1y agoLooking things up: 1) Norway oil + mining, which finance a large service sector that "is the bulk of the economy" (except not really: it would be 90% smaller without the resources) 2) Sweden mining + chemicals, which finance a large service sector around that 3) Finland mining + forestry, a large chemicals sector, which finance a large service sector around them like in Norway They all do large scale resource extraction, which then supports the economy on top of them. They all have oil money. Frankly the closest country to them that doesn't have a large resource base is Belgium, and they only have a service sector because they used to have a large resource extraction base recently that is dying (still not quite dead). Now they're ... well, pretty much their business is becoming government (they have a lot of huge governments and large international organisations on their territory. EU, NATO, SWIFT, Benelux, at least 10 Belgian govenerments, ...) This is what people don't seem to realize. This is how it works. The question, of course, is how to make it work without resources. Even the Ottoman arabs were doing fine in economy until the west conquered them and decided Jesus demands we force them to stop the resource they were exploiting on a large scale (black slaves, not that they didn't exploit European, Indian or even Chinese slaves, but in much smaller numbers)
- cindyllm 1y ago[dead]
- spwa4 1y agoThe real thing you can learn from Nordic Socialism: big government programs are easy with oil revenues, where you get goods and services from foreigners with very little effort on the part of your own citizens. At that point then everyone takes credit for how well that all works. This is like pointing out that Bill Gates' household proves how communism works on a small scale.
- throwaway0236 1y ago> big government programs are easy with oil revenues Sweden doesn't have much oil revenues as far as I know
- pploug 1y agoOnly norway has significant oil revenue - sweden and denmark specifically are primarily economies driven by a highly educated workforce and well regulated job markets - Lego, Novo, Maersk are all exemples of this kinds of companies depending on those socalled big government programmes to produce highly educated and specialised workers.