5 ms·
Jimmy kimmel should have strong odds at the Supreme Court
- jjtheblunt 1y agoSince that was written, Disney evidently published the back story that, days earlier, they were looking to fire Kimmel themselves (before any FCC threat), because he alienated the viewer base repeatedly, costing advertisers. Hard to know if that's true, of course.
- lawlessone 1y ago>Since that was written, Disney evidently published the back story that, days earlier, they were looking to fire Kimmel themselves source?
- jjtheblunt 1y agohttps://www.cnn.com/2025/09/18/entertainment/abc-jimmy-kimmel-what-comes-next https://www.cnn.com/2025/09/18/entertainment/abc-jimmy-kimme... is one article discussing such. gets more vague the further in.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoHaha not only is Disney submitting to the bullying they are now making up a story to protect the bully.
- yongjik 1y agoRiiiiiiiiight, I totally believe that.
- queenkjuul 1y agoTurns out corporate merger > constitution
- eth0up 1y agoI could say a lot of mean things about Jimmy. But what good would it do? I can't stand him. But I will stand up for his right to say whatever he says. If this country, this side or that side, on a razor's edge or done gone cosmic can't see what looms in this direction, just take a chance and oppose it while you can. You don't want to live the alternative. Quite seriously
- FredPret 1y agoHe has a right to say whatever he says, but surely his private employer have a right to fire him for it? He has a right to speak his mind, not to have a show.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> surely his private employer have a right to fire him for it? Short answer: depends on his contract. Longer answer: if ABC fired him because of illegal threats from Carr, one could construct the argument that ABC and Carr conspired illegally to subvert Kimmel’s First Amendment rights. (Whether this is legal nonsense is beyond me.)
- FredPret 1y agoThat would be wrong, but I think the conservative backlash was such that he'd have been very much fired anyway, FCC or no. People were publishing lists of his advertisers on X to organize a boycott.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoMurder of someone with late stage cancer is still murder.
- FredPret 1y agoGood point
- 1y ago
- mrangle 1y ago[flagged]
- lawlessone 1y ago[flagged]
- mrangle 1y ago[flagged]
- lawlessone 1y ago[flagged]
- mrangle 1y ago[flagged]
- jjulius 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoTo be fair, neither of these are gating requirements for a terrorist group.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Terrorists Terrorists do terrorism. What terrorism has Antifa done? (Answer: little to none [1].) I’m not a fan of them. But they’re about as obnoxious as several far-right groups that have been legally sanctioned by both parties. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jul/27/us-rightwing-extremists-attacks-deaths-database-leftwing-antifa https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jul/27/us-rightwing-e...
- tptacek 1y agoJust noodling on this: He has better-than-typical odds of clearing the standing hurdle. He was directly harmed, right. But he's going to have some pretty high evidentiary hurdles, right? Discovery may well turn up that Nextar pulled his shows preemptively, both because of political affiliation and because of an upcoming merger. They didn't need to be "jawboned", and there's not much indication that they were even contacted by the FCC. When the largest affiliate network in the country pulls your show, it's harder to make the case that ABC itself was responding directly to the FCC, which is what Kimmel will need to establish. These are positive and not normative arguments and my confidence level is extremely low.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> he's going to have some pretty high evidentiary hurdles Hmm, with ABC or the government? (Can individuals claim damages in court against the government for First Amendment violations?) If it were found Carr was acting unconstitutionally, and thus clearly outside the colour of law, could he be found personally liable? (Side note: thank you, this is what I was hoping for when I posted this here.)
- hackingonempty 1y agoYes, you can sue government officials for violating your well established constitutional rights. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/1983 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/1983
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoOh, I really like this!
- hackingonempty 1y agoIANAL but I'm pretty sure there's massive amounts of litigation around this statute and the law is a lot more complex than it looks on its face.
- macinjosh 1y agoKayfabe all around. Late night has been dying for a decade. Disney gets cover to end the show. Kimmel knows it’s over. He gets to go down looking like he’s fighting instead of unentertaining. Trump gets to claim he took down Kimmel, red meat for his base. News and Social Media gets something to boost their numbers.
- cosmicgadget 1y agoOn the other hand, this fits a very consistent pattern with the administration and businesses or personalities that it deems critical. Plus of you're going out in a blaze, it's something more substantive than what he said.
- avidiax 1y agoHow does any other media personality know that it's "kayfabe"? The chilling effect is not "kayfabe".
- TYPE_FASTER 1y ago> He gets to go down looking like he’s fighting instead of unentertaining. Even better: he uses the opportunity to make it clear that any kind of comment that is out of line with the administration will not be tolerated. He didn't go down fighting. He went out demonstrating the consequence of not agreeing.
- thisisit 1y agoIt’s amazing to me that every time something like this happens some people paint it as some grand conspiracy and 4D chess move involving a large set of people. It’s like 4chan leaking all over the Internet.
- UncleMeat 1y agoKayfabe is when the events are scripted by people who are working together even as they play enemies in the show and where everybody involved knows it is fake and plays along anyway. Do you believe that Trump and Kimmel are actually coordinating this behind the scenes? Do you believe that the large majority of both of their audiences understand this to be a show rather than reality?
- bandyaboot 1y agoThe author seems to underestimate this Supreme Court’s willingness to make nakedly partisan rulings. Edit: oh here we go. Partisan first amendment issues were perfectly fine to discuss here when it was about Twitter. But, different ox being gored now, so we’re going to flag this into oblivion. Absolute frauds.
- nick__m 1y agoI would not blame dang for keeping that flagged. The quality of the one on Gaza was appalling, it must have been really hard to moderate one and this one wasn't going to be much better.
- soganess 1y agoIf only; he is not. Huq is a U Chicago professor of con law and understands what is happening [1]. He is just having a really bad lawyer brain moment as the eroading rule of law crosses the line he probably uses in class as an example of "too far." 1: https://www.law.uchicago.edu/news/aziz-huq-writes-about-liberal-justices-dissents https://www.law.uchicago.edu/news/aziz-huq-writes-about-libe...
- starchild3001 1y agoI've seen this happen before. President ordering people to be sued, and even jailed. There's a name for this kind of system and it isn't congressional democracy.
- Skullfurious 1y ago[flagged]
- RickJWagner 1y ago[flagged]
- cosmicgadget 1y agoThe ACLU, for one.
- bmitch3020 1y agoAssuming Kimmel wins a lawsuit, if that lawsuit is against government officials, couldn't Trump immediately pardon those officials, overriding the courts?
- hackingonempty 1y agoNo, lawsuits are civil and pardons are criminal.
- throw0101a 1y agoExcept that Roberts et al are basically on Trump's side. "The umpire who picked a side: John Roberts and the death of rule of law in America": * https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2025/aug/21/justice-john-roberts-supreme-court https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2025/aug/... "The Rule of Law Is Dead in the US": * https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/the-rule-of-law-is-dead-in-the-us/ https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/the-rule-of-law-i...
- suzdude 1y agoYes, but Roberts really doesn't want to be worse than the Taney court. Throwing out freedom of speech with the first amendment would probably put him down there.
- throw0101a 1y agoSee perhaps: > Anna Gomez, the FCC’s lone Democratic commissioner, tells TNR that chairman Brendan Carr’s move violates both the First Amendment and the Communications Act. Democrats must extract consequences. * https://newrepublic.com/article/200649/trump-ouster-kimmel-anna-gomez https://newrepublic.com/article/200649/trump-ouster-kimmel-a...
- daft_pink 1y agoI’m confused. It would be the broadcaster that was harmed right? Jimmy Kimmel wouldn’t have standing? The Supreme Court can’t order a private company to give Jimmy Kimmel back his job?
- incomingpain 1y ago>The constitution doesn’t guarantee Kimmel a talk show, but it does guarantee that the government won’t quash his speech because of what he chooses to say. Kimmel now has a straightforward suit for damages and forward-looking relief that he can and should file — not just against ABC, but also against the government officials who were the driving force for his embarrassing public disciplining. The threat made by the government to censor him is a tool that has been there since 1992. A tool made by George H Bush and used often by every administration since. Oddly enough, nobody ever challenges it and I see 0% chance Kimmel has any chance of winning. Absolutely no way Kimmel has any odds of winning in court. I consider as well, lets say he does win and this rule is thusly struck down. It's going to be a nightmare situation for everyone in the usa after.
- grumio 1y ago> used often by every administration since. When else has the FCC chair threatened to take a license away for someone saying something they don't like? Source?
- hypeatei 1y agoIf we can award $5M to the family of a January 6th insurrectionist, then we sure as hell can award money to Kimmel for unconstitutional threats made by Brendan Carr. Right?
- reop2whiskey 1y agoWhat about all of these unconstitutional threats? http://judiciary.house.gov/media/press-releases/weaponization-committee-exposes-biden-white-house-censorship-regime-new-report http://judiciary.house.gov/media/press-releases/weaponizatio...
- hypeatei 1y agoWhat threats were made? Linking a 98 page PDF argues nothing. Especially when the chairman of the committee that produced it is Jim Jordan, a MAGA sycophant.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]