41 ms·
U.S. Taxpayers Are Gouged on Mass Transit Costs
- leeoniya 14y agohavent read it yet, too in love with appropriate mobius rail graphic
- mmphosis 14y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_conspiracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_streetcar_consp...
- mturmon 14y agoNot a downvoter, but this theory gets tossed around in bars and over dinner in LA sometimes (LA was one of several cities where this scenario played out). Short summary, it's not clear, in LA at least, if the GM/Goodyear "intentional destruction" scenario really did the Red Line in. The ridership had been decreasing for several years before the purchase of the Red Line. Long-time residents say predictable things -- autos were more convenient and faster than streetcars. Short of doing your thesis on this, it will be hard to separate the truth from the legend on this story. (Not a public transit hater.)
- kevinconroy 14y agoSeems questionable to me. Yes the Second Ave Subway is expensive, but how many cities are building new subway lines underground through incredibly dense existing infrastructure? Also, US taxpayers may be making up for it by paying more upfront but less per ride (unless you live in DC or San Fran): City Cost per Ride Mexico $0.15 Beijing $0.29 Seoul $0.55 Moscow $0.69 Tokyo $1.68 Barcelona $1.76 NYC $1.96 Boston $2.00 Paris $2.25 Chicago $2.25 Toronto $2.37 Berlin $2.95 DC $3.08 San Fran $3.18 Stockholm $3.96 London $4.41 Source: http://www.treehugger.com/cars/subway-fares-around-the-world.html http://www.treehugger.com/cars/subway-fares-around-the-world...
- lucaspiller 14y agoIn London the Crossrail project (started 2005, due to open 2019, estimate £16b / $26b) is going from the East to West right through the middle of the city. Tottenham Court Road station (and many of the buildings surrounding it) are practically being rebuild. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossrail http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossrail
- DannyBee 14y agoSince these numbers were published in 2009, D.C.'s metro has raised fares ~80-100%. Mainly due to construction costs and ridiculous maintenance costs for the stations, like many millions to repair escalators that break every year
- burnsbothends 14y agoI disagree. Pittsburgh, for example, is worse than all those listed. $3.25-$4.50. And much of it is above ground, in residential areas. Only including major metros leaves out a large part of the picture- across the US, transit is VERY cost prohibitive.
- yxhuvud 14y agoWell, it is cheap to build above ground, but there is also a lot more maintenance.
- vidarh 14y agoAt least for London, that list is very wrong. The most expensive single zone journey on Oyster is 2 GBP, or $3.20 at current exchange rates.
- lifeisstillgood 14y agoHate to be pedantic about it but the oyster is a discount card (that everyone but tourists uses) - a single is really about 4 quid all zones
- 14y ago
- spqr 14y agoNews flash! Government workers cannot spend money efficiently. You do not get efficient spending when the people you put in charge of spending have no idea what a dollar is worth, no incentive to save money, no directive to make money and can't be fired for any reason.
- scottfr 14y agoI few years back I was thinking of running for the board of AC Transit in the bay area. I did some research: the cost per mile to move a person on AC Transit was ~ $1.50 (total cost including subsidies, not what you pay). Compare that to a cost to pay for a cab to take you one mile of ~ $3.00. So if you have two people in a cab, that cab is just as economically efficient as a bus. Literally, a car that waits for your call, comes right to your door, and chauffeurs you around, is as economically efficient as our bus system. This is crazy! We could replace AC Transit with a fleet of cabs. Also, I've heard that the "Nextbus" system which makes those predictions for when the next bus is arriving makes most of their money fixing the next bus sensors. The reason the sensors are broken is AC Transit employees continually sabotage them because they hate being tracked. Truly, it is an incredibly screwed up system. Anyways, I was too busy to run for the board of directors, but someone really need to fix AC Transit!
- tokenadult 14y agoLiterally, a car that waits for your call, comes right to your door, and chauffeurs you around, is as economically efficient as our bus system. This is crazy! I recall that when San Francisco retrofitted its city buses so that all are accessible to people using wheelchairs, an economic analysis showed it would be cheaper for the city taxpayers simply to provide free taxi service to all wheelchair users. The reason for putting people who use wheelchairs on city buses seems to have been wholly political--to mainstream such persons into a form of transportation that makes them more visible to other members of the public (at least, the members of the public who use buses). I have both an emotional reaction and a rational reaction to this policy trade-off. On the one hand, my own late father was confined to a wheelchair as a quadriplegic (after a slip-and-fall accident on an icy parking lot here in Minnesota) for the last six years of his life. So I totally get why friends and relatives of persons who use wheelchairs want public places, and by extension public transportation, to be accessible to persons who use wheelchairs. That allows many more family outings with grandparents and their grandchildren than might otherwise be possible, for example. But my rational reaction is still that we all have to work hard to pay our taxes, so "public" money (money derived from taxation) should still be spent responsibly. If devoting taxi service (and, I hope, someday a self-driving car service) with public subsidies helps needy members of the population more than bus service, so be it. Spend the least money to get the positive externality is generally the way to go in public policy.
- mcphilip 14y agoThe recent article in Esquire about rebuilding the world trade center sheds a lot of light into the particularly inept NY & NJ Port Authority mentioned in this bloomberg piece. http://www.esquire.com/print-this/world-trade-center-rebuilding-0912?page=all http://www.esquire.com/print-this/world-trade-center-rebuild...
- tnuc 14y agoI wonder why Bloomberg has such a problem with the NY & NJ Port Authority? Oh that's right, Bloomberg is the Mayor and would rather give the contract to someone more cough _deserving_.
- angdis 14y agoA bunch of right-wing baloney. The transportation systems in NYC are what make that city even possible. It is very easy for an uncreative bean-counter to look at the price tag of public transportation systems and then not be able "add up" all the long term benefits of having a city where people and businesses can thrive and get around and that are enjoyable and aesthetic. If you really want to talk about "gouging" the taxpayer, instead look at highway funding and regulations that practically enforce sprawl by requiring parking spaces, and multi-lane streets through urban cores.
- tayl0r 14y agoAre we reading the same article? The author isn't trying to say that the cost isn't worth it- he's just saying that it could be done much cheaper if the system wasn't so screwed up.
- notJim 14y agoIt doesn't sound like you read the article. The article doesn't say the US shouldn't spend money on transit (the point you refuted), it says that other countries pay less for transit because they mange projects better.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- antidaily 14y agoNo one is arguing the value of public transportation in our cities, just that it could probably be built for less. If anything, this article could be a left-wing talking point - using private companies instead of public workers costs more.
- bane 14y agoAbsolutely, absurdly true. The D.C. metro is adding a new line, almost all of it will be above ground and on existing right-of-way reserved specifically for the eventual construction of the line decades ago and operate in fairly low density part of the system. It'll be 37km long and run $6.8 billion dollars. It'll have 29 stations. Compare to the new Seoul Bundang line which is 32.8km with 28 stations in some of the most dense urban areas on the planet. It'll run a bit under $400 million to build or about 1/17th the cost. Once open, it'll probably cost riders under a dollar for most trips, compared to over $3 on the DC Metro. No matter how you figure it, cost of labor, eminent domain, legal, whatever, there's simply no way to figure the D.C. costs as making sense when a world away a similar line, in another developed country with far more difficult construction issues is much cheaper in every way possible.
- whatusername 14y ago7 Billion for 29 stations and a full line? I wish. http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/south-morang-finally-gets-its-line-20120422-1xf4u.html http://www.theage.com.au/victoria/south-morang-finally-gets-... 1/2 a billion for extending the line 3km and building 1 station. (All in the suburbs - where there used to be a train line that was ripped up)
- rosser 14y agoJust an off-hand observation: Australia also has a common-law legal system, which TFA suggests correlates strongly positively with out-of-control prices on such projects.
- 001sky 14y agoHollywood. Accounting.
- 001sky 14y agoA huge part of the problem is that agencies can’t keep their private contractors in check. Starved of funds and expertise for in-house planning, officials contract out the project management and early design concepts to private companies that have little incentive to keep costs down and quality up. --Citation from the article.
- michaelochurch 14y agoMisleading title (in the current political environment) because the gouging is done by contractors who've figured out how to exploit an antiquated (lowest-bidder wins) system. The article is not suggesting that we have "too much" mass transit, but that we pay too much for what we get, and this is undeniably true. The gouging doesn't stop once the infrastructure is built. U.S. transit is also expensive when delivered (it costs over $100 per person round-trip to go from New York to Harrisburg, PA; for two people, it's cheaper to drive). Finally, we pay again through exorbitant real estate prices because our transport infrastructure, in this country, is so poor.
- Anechoic 14y agothe gouging is done by contractors who've figured out how to exploit an antiquated (lowest-bidder wins) system. As someone who works on transportation projects, I find this to be incredibly unfair. Yes, there are a few shady contractors out there, but there are a lot of things that can happen during design and construction that can increase costs through no fault of our own. For example: change orders. A project gets designed and approved, the contractor gets his contract and starts digging. Two weeks into excavation, the project engineer tells the contractor "oh, that tunnel needs to be built 20 feet deeper and moved 15 feet to the south." Why? It could be for any number of reasons, maybe construction uncovered a gas line that couldn't be moved, maybe some politician wanted the line moved further (or closer) to a friend's business, etc. There are also the inevitable lawsuits, environmental issues and so on. One of my big beefs, and one of the factors that IME increases costs for architectural/engineering consultants like me are the hoops we have to jump through to demonstrate that we're not ripping off taxpayers. There are all sorts of audit requirements (including the dreaded DCAA audit), insurance requirements and so on that increase our costs and so we have pass on those costs to the taxpayers. Recently we had an issue when negotiating a contract for transit design project - my firm's is relatively new, and we don't have a revenue history with which to develop audited rates, so we intentionally set out rates low in an attempt to convince accountants that our lack of audited rates wouldn't be a problem. We spent a munch arguing with the prime's accountants who wanted our audited rates to we could demonstrate that our profit on the job wouldn't exceed 10% (they were obsessed with the 10% profit number), depsite the fact that our rates were 40-50% lower than other similar contractors. We had to get someone from the Federal government to step in and tell the prime that our rates were fine as-is. Insurance requirements are the other big issue. General liability isn't so bad, but E&O can be costly for big engineering projects, even if you're exposure is low. However many projects have a "one size fits all" with respect to insurance requirements and require everyone to carry $10+ million in general liability and $5+ million in E&O. If you're the general contractor responsible for digging up streets which can have all sorts or negative effects, that's probably reasonable. If you're the graphic designer responsible for creating the signs for the project, that's probably a little excessive.
- SODaniel 14y agoThis I believe is NOT news.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rickmb 14y agoSeems to me like the author is very selectively shopping in non-US examples in order to just go on an anti public-transport rant. In most places in Europe costs of mass transit projects are notorious for spiraling out of control, and unlike the Madrid example other Western countries tend to do exactly the opposite and usually spend a lot more money on prestigious design and architecture of public works than is common in the US. And that's okay, because besides the notoriously crappy and corrupt management of these projects by government officials, the results are worth it.
- Symmetry 14y agoYes, but they spiral from 1/3 of what a typical US bid would be to 1/3 of what the final US price tag would be. It isn't more than an order of magnitue like with Spain, but France, Germany, etc all still end up paying much less than the US for comparable rail systems.
- jt2190 14y agoI'm not trying to pick a fight here, but the United States strongly rejects, on a cultural level, the notion of a professional class of government employees. From the article: > A huge part of the problem is that agencies can’t keep > their private contractors in check. Starved of funds and > expertise for in-house planning, officials contract out > the project management and early design concepts to > private companies that have little incentive to keep > costs down and quality up. And even when they know > better, agencies are often forced by legislation, courts > and politicians to make decisions that they know aren’t > in the public interest. All you ever hear about at election time in the U.S. is "big government waste." My colleague from Spain tells me that in Spain everyone goes to work for the government, and that entrepreneurship is lacking. Perhaps that means that in order to have cost-efficient mass-transit projects in the U.S. we need a Spanish-style government and culture.
- Anechoic 14y agoI'm not trying to pick a fight here, but the United States strongly rejects, on a cultural level, the notion of a professional class of government employees. This is an excellent point. When the US Federal or a state government agency decides they need to link point A and point B with a transportation project, the agency typically only provides a basic outline of project requirements. Outside contractors are used to develop the more detailed requirements, and even the RFP for design and construction. This creates a situation where big engineering firms try very hard (and often succeed) in creating RFPs that only they are qualified for. Yes, this really happens. In fact, whenever I read an RFP the number one question on my mind is "is this written so that only XXX firm can win it?" The answer tends to be "yes" in many cases and we don't bother bidding on it. The obvious solution would be to prevent companies that write RFPs from bidding on the project. The problem is that no one (or at least no one good) would want to bid on the RFP prep work! If given the chance to win a $250,000 RFP preparation project, or a $500 million general engineering contract/$10 billion construction contract, the highly qualified firms will wait to take a shot at the larger work.
- ImprovedSilence 14y agoI wouldn't go so far as to say that outside contractors are writing those RFP's, and turning around and winning them, that would lead to allll sorts of legal trouble for all parties involved, a risk no large contracting company would be willing to take. I will say however, that often times, the particular govt office/personal have a working relationship with a contractor, or have done business with them in the past, and will tailor an RFP so that only the company they want to work with will win it. Sometimes this is bad, but sometimes if there is already an established relationship, and a good management structure in place between the two parties, it may be the most effective way to accomplish a task.
- DenisM 14y agoFWIW, I spent some time researching the cost of tunnel-digging online, and off the top of my head, the costs were $30m/mile in India, $100m/mile in US, and $1b/mile in New York city. The reason I dug through this was to explore possibility of building an entire city where all motorized transportation is under ground, and surface area is reserved for pedestrians, wheelchairs, and bicycles. IIRC, the cost of tunneling came out comparable to the cost of housing, so it's not a completely unreasonable idea. Imagine a 10km grid of 20-40 story residential buildings spaced out with trees and parks and bike/walk paths among them for miles on end? And an underground entrance every 1000 meters. No cars on the street, no noise, no traffic lights - go/ride where you please. Now if only I had the budget to build a brand-new city I would start now. :)
- aristus 14y agoHigh-rises separated by green space was the original vision of high-rise designers. But what developers and financiers heard was "more salable square footage in less footprint" and we ended up with what we have now. I personally don't enjoy living in high-rises. If I had to design city, it'd be more like San Francisco: buildings 5-6 stories high, tops. Lots of walkspace, lots of trees, definitely a lot more greenways as you describe. But I don't see the point of having all that greenspace if the majority of people will be 20+ stories away from it.
- DenisM 14y agoPopulation density is required to make all amenities to be within walking distance, and to make meaningful public transportation (one you can rely on). In your scheme, low density would mean one has to drive to see your friends or visit favorite caffe (hello traffic gridlock) or take a bus, which will take forever over longer distances and all the traffic light stops. My concept is to build a city as a 10,000m square with building spaced out at 100m from each other in a grid for a total of 10,000 buildings, each one of 20 stories, 4 flats per story, each flat 12 meters to the side, three persons per flat. This way I could fit 2.4 million people in lavish 1400sqf condos in the city size of 10km to the side, and have the bus to cross the city in 10 minutes through underground tunnels with no traffic light stops. Large population density creates huge opportunities for development of arts, as there is more audience and a bigger chance of there being enough supporters for a given new art thing in one place.
- robomartin 14y agoThis article is one-sided. The problem is that it is aimed at the wrong side. Yes, government purchasing and management of projects is a disaster. I have first hand experience in this realm. As a taxpayer you almost want to cry when you see it happen. I won't get into the nitty-gritty of the details. I saw, as an example, a government agency pay DOUBLE what they would have paid for a commodity computer accessory. They had bids (mine, among others, I am sure) that cut their costs in half. Yet, they went with the bid that doubled their costs. Why? Because those doing the buying were so incompetent and insecure that they wanted one supplier to provide all the components rather than allowing the best suppliers to come in and provide them with competitive pricing. It was "cover my ass" at it's best. Let's not even mention the ridiculous rules that make it nearly impossible for small businesses to participate and expensive for others to do so. To make matters worst, this particular contract was awarded to a foreign supplier. The funds came from Obama's "American Reinvestment and Recovery Act". Money that was supposed to create jobs in the US went out of the country. When confronted with this reality they came back saying that the company in question had sales offices in the US and that they had formed a corporation in the US and that this qualified them as a US entity. Holy crap! I firmly believe that we'd do far better if government wasn't involved in most of this stuff. I'm not sure how that can happen, but the idea is appealing to me. I said that the article is one-sided because it completely ignores on of the real reasons why these construction projects are so expensive and take so long: unionized workers. To put it plainly, their purpose in life is to rape the US taxpayer for as much as they can get and, in the process, provide themselves with as much pay, benefits, vacation and short work days as possible. And we keep paying for them once they retire in the form of ridiculous lifetime pensions. The real cost of that tunnel is probably far greater once you take into account having to pay those workers' pensions for life. Examples of ridiculous union behavior abound. If you've ever had to work with or within a unionized system you've probably experienced the state of disbelief most rational people experience when they realize what's going on. Take, as an example, doing a trade-show in NYC. I have dozens of examples of union bullshit, but I'll just mention one. We did a show where we needed to have a light turned off above our booth. That's it. The request was that simple: Please turn off the light above our booth. Of course, a union electrician had to do this. The fee? $368. Three hundred and sixty eight dollars for the guy to go over to the breaker panel and flip a switch. OK, here's another. You are not allowed to plug in your devices into the electrical system. You know, what you do at home and at the office all the time. Nope, a union electrician has the necessary expertise to install an extension cord and plug in your computer into the AC outlet. I forget what the fee was for that, but it was ridiculous. Our solution? We did all of our booth setup work at night. The union workers in the night shift are lazier than shit. They don't want to work. So, they let you do almost whatever you want as long as you let them sleep on the job. Sometimes you'd have to slip someone a hundred dollar bill to be left alone. Far better than dealing with their bullshit. I have not had to work with unionized construction crews. I can only imagine how much worst the whole thing must be. The best thing that could happen to this country is if unions were outlawed. Of course, that will never happen. I'd sure be nice though. Imagine, people actually having to work for a living. And, produce, behave, be responsible, be capable, compete, etc. What a concept. Dont' get me started about the planned California high-speed rail. It's a $68 billion money grab designed to feed unions and keep politicians who favor them in power. The money will never be recovered. The line makes no sense whatsoever. Sick.
- sutro 14y agoConsider: it took about 3 years in the heart of the Great Depression to build both the Golden Gate Bridge and the Bay Bridge. Since the 1989 quake, a project has been underway to rebuild the Bay Bridge's eastern span. That project continues today, 23 years later, at a huge multiple of the inflation-adjusted cost of the original bridge.
- rdl 14y agoI wonder how much of the "libertarian" bias in the US overall is a result of the particular inefficiency of government projects in the US (obviously purely private projects are more efficient than US government funded projects), and how much is a cause (by forcing use of contractors/consultants). Maybe this explains the difference between the US and Asia/Europe rationally, rather than as some major difference in philosophy given the same facts in each place.
- devs1010 14y agoI spend probably $350 a month commuting in the SF Bay Area on public transit, its ridiculous but its my only option since traffic is bad and parking expensive enough to make public transit the better option by far
- xbryanx 14y agoSeems like some of the comparisons being made here should be divided by average wage for skilled workers on these projects.
- aswanson 14y agoWhat's even worse is that they overcharge on the same properties they gouge taxpayers on, that the taxpayer supposedly owns. Crossing the GW bridge? $12. Going up the turnpike from DE to NY? $13. Going from Jersey to Philly? $5.
- ChrisNorstrom 14y agoI'm trying my best to see things from both side's point of view. Maybe it has to do with Supply and Demand? Because Europe and Asia invest substantially more in their public transit networks, there's more of a market, more companies that build the networks, more competition, more experience, and more tried and true cheaper methods. While in the USA, we've got less public transit, less experience building it, a smaller market for building it, less companies that construct networks, and less competition between them, thus the cost is higher due to it being a specialty that few companies understand.
- JumpCrisscross 14y agoThe hypothesised condition could be easily aleviated by hiring those non-US contractors who are performing so well overseas. Bombardier's bid for the high-speed Amtrak line between New York and Washington, D.C. being messed up by U.S. regulators [1], however, points to political factors. [1] http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2012/07/amtraks-high-speed-ambitions http://www.economist.com/blogs/gulliver/2012/07/amtraks-high...
- rayiner 14y agoAmerican construction projects suffer from tremendous over-engineering. Here in Chicago we have the El and the Metra, which were built a hundred years or so ago. The El runs through the city mostly on elevated tracks above the existing roadways. The elevated tracks are supported by simple steel frameworks above the roadway. There's not a lot of room for stations, so they are simple platforms hovering over the intersections with stairs leading up to them. The floors are wood plank and there are some metal railings. The Metra is similarly simple. Metra tracks run on embankments across the city. They're simple dirt embankments with a retaining wall. Simple metal bridges cross the roadways, without a huge amount of clearance. The stations are mostly just wood and metal platforms with wooden railings, with wooden stairs leading up from street level. This all works really well--Metra is the busiest commuter rail system outside of NYC, shuttling 300,000 people into the downtown core every day. Now, compare this to the new Silver line in DC. It's monstrously over-engineered, even though it runs on a dedicated right of way. Instead of running the train on a simple embankment in the middle of the road or on a simple raised platform, it runs on a huge elevated concrete platform: http://transportationnation.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/07.03.12news-cooper-silver-line-edit.jpg http://transportationnation.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/0... And this is in a low-density suburban area! Compare this to the El: http://marcel-marchon.com/img--117945132--Chicago-El-train--m.jpg http://marcel-marchon.com/img--117945132--Chicago-El-train--... Transit does not need to cost a billion dollars per mile. Just build elevated metal-framework tracks above the existing roadways. It's cheap, durable, and actually much more pleasant for riders than going to a stifling underground subway station.
- ericdykstra 14y agoWhoa wait, this article is saying that [some significant subsection] of government projects is something like an order of magnitude inefficient? Hard to believe, I bet next we'll see articles saying that [some other significant subsection of government] is inefficient, too!
- ianb 14y agoHow do private companies arrange infrastructure-sized projects? Oil companies seem to have substantial arrangements like these. Railroads maintain a lot of infrastructure privately. I'm guessing these companies don't get gouged like the government, but they really have all the same issues, like internal corruption, the bid process, change orders, competing interests in the company, etc.
- mleonhard 14y ago"The California High-Speed Rail Authority’s new CEO, Jeff Morales, arrived at the agency after a stint as senior vice present at Parsons Brinckerhoff." This is how corruption works here in USA. Cheaters move between government management positions and overpaid contractor positions. This happens all throughout the country, from local governments up to the vice president.