3 ms·
>nobody had any explanation for why flu "disappeared" The flu didn't disappear, and we know very well why it almost disappeared: it is far less contagious than
by aredox 1y ago
>nobody had any explanation for why flu "disappeared"
The flu didn't disappear, and we know very well why it almost disappeared: it is far less contagious than SARS-CoV-2, and masking and the huge dip in international travel stopped it.
>It's a hypothesis
Here in Switzerland (and in France), it hasn't been presented by pediatrics societies as an hypothesis at all, but as a fact and the main argument to reopen immediately. It has also been used again and again to explain the huge waves of infections of many illnesses that surged after the end of lockdowns, and absolutely none of them ever quoted that "immune debt is just an hypothesis", and none of them have suggested any other alternative hypothesis such as "SARS-CoV-2 has a detrimental effect on the immune system or health in general".
Because to admit so would be to admit the mass infection of children had been a massive mistake on their part.
>I don't like to resort to appeal to authority, but the article quotes Ashish Jha (hardly a Covid minimizer) as dismissing the "immune damage" narrative
And Jha has no explanation for the increased, sustained (and now synchronised) waves of infections and illnesses that are plain to see. He has nothing. This is the fiasco of "masks aren't proven to work" again.
- nostrebored 1y ago… masks literally aren’t proven to work, and in every true RCT (hint: there are almost none!) there is neutral to negative impact. they are a creative fiction to help people feel like they have control over their environment, not a substantially evidenced intervention.
- aredox 1y agoRandomized controlled trials are not a silver bullet. There is a reason why meta-analyses spend a good amount of ink sorting out and excluding RCTs for lack of power or other design mistakes. https://www.statnews.com/2023/05/02/do-masks-work-rcts-randomized-controlled-trials/ https://www.statnews.com/2023/05/02/do-masks-work-rcts-rando...