4 ms·
> Can someone that is actually interested in this explain the appeal? It’s light and the thinness is just fun. I’m not putting a case on it. And I really don’t
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> Can someone that is actually interested in this explain the appeal?
It’s light and the thinness is just fun. I’m not putting a case on it. And I really don’t understand why a phone needs to sit flat on a table—if anything, the angle is a plus.
- zargon 1y agoIt’s only 12 grams lighter than my iPhone XS. And it’s 20 grams heavier than my Pixel 4a. For a product called “air”, It doesn’t even succeed at being light-weight.
- cogogo 1y agoAt least for me something so thin feels better with a bit of heft. And if you read the article the idea was to use any space saved for the battery. Seems pretty slick
- PartiallyTyped 1y agoHigher density makes objects feel a lot more premium than their less dense counterparts.
- crossroadsguy 1y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> That weight is perfect weight It’s just less. Less means it hits the ground softer when I drop it. Less means I’m less pissed off when I lose my AirPods and have to hold my phone up to my ear. Less means little moments of delight over how this engineered slab of minerals can do these things. Do you remember the ad for the first MacBook Air? Even if you didn’t connect with it, can you recognise how someone else might?
- crossroadsguy 1y ago[flagged]
- kasey_junk 1y agoThe commenter was specifically asked why they might be interested. They responded reasonably and in good faith. _You_ went wild and viewed it as any attack of some sort. If anything is off it’s your belligerent anti-fandom. You are coming off as on tilt. Over someone else’s preferences in phones of all things.
- crossroadsguy 1y agoReally? I was literally calling out a "company" and an individual jumped in and I responded to that and now you are jumping in the middle and trying to teach me how I should see it? Is Apple attachment this strong around here? It just doesn't make sense to me. Is it some kind of cultural aspect of something? (And I respectfully want to make it clear here that these are rhetorical questions, I didn't really mean to ask them, and I do not hate you or that other HNer, it's just feels/felt weird).
- kasey_junk 1y agoThere isn’t much apple attachment on display in this thread. You should recalibrate if that’s what you are reading.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> can you not appreciate how such cloying fandom (or apparent fandom) can kind of be, in a way, almost nauseating for someone and just move on? No, I really can't. I'm not into most sports. That doesn't make those games' fans nauseous. They've found something they love. I don't get their particular attachment. But that doesn't make it dumb, must less disgusting--I can empathise with their joy because I, too, have found things which delight me. I can articulate, respectfully, why I think their games are dumb. But I can also recognise that's a subjective opinion about aesthetics.
- coder543 1y agoOf course, the iPhone 5 weighed significantly less than either of those! The iPhone Air has a larger screen than all three of those. I don't see what your comparison has to do with anything. The Air is a light phone relative to its screen size. It is also an incredibly thin phone. I'm probably not getting one, but I don't see the point of comparing it to physically smaller phones.
- bluSCALE4 1y ago17 Air - 2025 - 156.2mm x 74.7mm x 5.64mm, 165g Sony Xperia Z2 - 2014 - 172mm x 266mm x 6.4 mm - 439g Sony made nearly equally thin but lighter devices 11 years ago.
- coder543 1y ago> Sony Xperia Z2 - 2014 - 172mm x 266mm x 6.4 mm - 439g Again, not nearly the same screen size, so weight is irrelevant. But also, 439g? Wow! If that number wasn’t completely wrong, that would be impressive. 6.4mm is nowhere near as thin as 5.6mm, but I’m actually seeing 8.2mm for thickness on reliable websites, not 6.4mm: https://m.gsmarena.com/sony_xperia_z2-6144.php https://m.gsmarena.com/sony_xperia_z2-6144.php Did an LLM hallucinate those specs that you quoted? I honestly don’t know how the thickness and weight you quoted could be that far off if you did the research yourself. But, even if you were right, which you don’t seem to be, it’s all moot. No one is cross-shopping a 2014 phone to a 2025 phone. But even if they were, the real numbers speak for themselves.
- bluSCALE4 1y agoIt's not wrong. I own 2 and we haven't caught up. These were 3G compatible as well.
- SirMaster 1y agoIt's a 6.5" screen. Weight alone isn't the metric. It's weight to screen size ratio. People like bigger screens it seems as evident by phone screens keep getting bigger and bigger.
- jonathanberger 1y agoFlat doesn't seem best to you? Next best for me would be a symmetrical bump. But the asymmetrical bump (I think) all iPhones have seems the worst of all alternatives. This results in that bad restaurant table wobble feeling.
- teaearlgraycold 1y agoThe Air and 17 Pro have symmetrical bumps.
- jkubicek 1y agoThe lenses aren't symmetrical though. These phones are still going to be super wobbly. That said, it looks like the clear case for the air has a plastic ridge to protect the lens and keep the phone from wobbling
- crossroadsguy 1y ago> if anything, the angle is a plus Right. I am sure flatness would have Revolutionary™ had Apple decided to make it rather flat (of course with the "First Time Again In An iPhone™" tag).