5 ms·
Inflation erased U.S. income gains last year
- argentinian 1y agoDo people in the U.S. have a good understanding of the causes of inflation?
- OgsyedIE 1y agoNot even most economists do, by analogy to how opaque the questions of lifting bodies and rayleigh scattering are to physicists.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 1y agoYeah no, economists and a lot of people understand the the causes of inflation. There are economists who are paid very well to not understand it though, and such positions are often high in the government and financial sector hierarchies.
- OgsyedIE 1y agoNo really, transonic flow and turbulence are less complicated than what's really going on underneath the quantity theory of money. If it was easy there would be fewer economists.
- ajross 1y agoThe only people certain about economics are the kind of folks who run around on HN talking about "printing money". Too lazy to look up your post history to see which camp you belong in. But no, macroeconomics is understood from sound general principles, but it is not a robust predictive theory. The analogy upthread to Navier-Stokes is apt.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- chrisco255 1y agoAre these the same Fed economists that claimed the elevated inflation levels were transitory in 2021? There are multiple schools of thought on causes of inflation, but generally I agree with late Milton Friedman that it is "everywhere and always a monetary phenomenon". Money supply expansion growing faster than GDP expansion causes inflation.
- ceejayoz 1y ago> Are these the same Fed economists that claimed the elevated inflation levels were transitory in 2021? But… that was correct? It went up, then back down, due to a very unusual (almost unique, thus far) external cause. https://www.statista.com/statistics/273418/unadjusted-monthly-inflation-rate-in-the-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/273418/unadjusted-monthl...
- opo 1y agoThe economist Noah Smith graded the predictions of economists who made public statements once the Biden administration started its large spending programs: >...In 2021, Krugman tweeted: "I like it and plan to steal it. This report does look like what you'd expect if recent inflation was about transitory disruptions, not stagflation redux". As Smith pointed out: >...But in late 2021, inflation spread to become very broad-based. Services inflation was always significant, and took over from goods inflation as the main contributor in 2022. >The notion that this was just some transient supply-chain disruptions that was only affecting specific products was absolutely central to Team Transitory’s claims in the summer of 2021. And that was incorrect. >...Team Transitory also called the end of the inflation at least a year and a half too soon. On October 13, 2021 Krugman tweeted "Three month core inflation. Why isn't everyone calling this a victory for team transitory" >...So they didn’t entirely whiff here. They just greatly overstated their case. And their complacency in 2021 probably fed into the Fed’s decision to delay the start of rate hikes until 2022, which in retrospect looks like a serious mistake. What did get vindicated was mainstream economics as taught in our textbooks. As Smith wrote: >...Mainstream macro’s first victory was in predicting that the inflation would happen in the first place. In February 2021, Olivier Blanchard used a very simple “output gap” model to predict that Biden’s Covid relief bill would raise demand by enough to show up in the inflation numbers. His prediction came true. He didn’t get everything right — he thought wages would rise more than consumer prices, and he neglected the lagged effects of Trump’s Covid relief packages and Fed lending programs. But his standard simple mainstream model got the basic prediction right when most people made the opposite prediction, and this deserves recognition. >More importantly, mainstream macro appears to have gotten policy right. https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/grading-the-economic-schools-of-thought https://www.noahpinion.blog/p/grading-the-economic-schools-o...
- taneq 1y agoThe money goes faster on the top side of the wing, which means the money underneath the wing is more compressed, lifting up both sides of the wing. This is known as the "trickle-down" theory of lift.
- dennis_jeeves2 1y agoNo. To me the answer is very simple, the primary (not sole) driver is govt printing currency indiscriminately.
- throwawaymaths 1y agoIt's more complicated than that (lending also increases the money supply) though you're right that "printing money" loosely speaking is the primary irreversible driver.
- dennis_jeeves2 1y agoOf course the printed money has to be put into circulation ( either lending or spending by the gov)
- somewhereoutth 1y agoIn modern economies, banks create money by originating loans. The government controls this process with various policy levers.
- orwin 1y agoDepends on the default rate, and I'm pretty sure the past year in the US, default created more money than what was printed (even taking QE into account). Basically why everybody decided to go with money printing during COVID btw, people realised in 2008 that a 2B default is the equivalent to printing 2B, so if that's the case, why not print money instead (that's a bad calculation imho, in my opinion in a capitalist market economy you need defaults for the market to work, and I would say, you need defaults that pierce the corporate veil).
- throwawaymaths 1y agolending increases the money supply and amortizing and default decrease.
- kattagarian 1y agoThis is something being debated across the world. I'm not american and in my country economists wages war over the "inflation is the result of monetary expansion". I know nothing about it, the only thing i know is that inflation is getting worse (almost) everywhere.
- throw__away7391 1y agoPeople in the US believe that if inflation eases, for example from 4% to 3%, that means that prices are going to go back down to what they used to be before inflation started rising. They furthermore believe that if that does not happen it is proof that the media is lying.
- _--__--__ 1y agoPoliticians love communicating about 2nd and 3rd derivatives of prices and debt in ways that even mathematically literate people have trouble immediately interpreting. There's a famous quote about Nixon doing it but it's honestly the current standard mode from all sides trying to avoid blame for the state of the deficit and monetary supply.
- bithive123 1y ago"Inflation" simply refers to a rise in general price levels. The cause of inflation is known: someone sets a price. There isn't a single reason why someone might raise a price. It could be that they have some ideology about the size of the money supply (i.e. "printing money") or it could be that the costs of their inputs went up ("inflation") due to tariffs, or other supply chain problems. Or it could be a cynical bet that the market would bear a higher price ("using inflation as an excuse"). Blaming inflation on this-or-that cause is most definitely a political rather than theoretical exercise.
- argentinian 1y agoWhy would it be impossible to research it's cause in a specific context? You are not offering an argument about why can't it be investigated.
- esseph 1y agoAbsolutely not, as a rule.
- pavlov 1y agoThis year both inflation and unemployment are going up, so it’s only getting worse.
- deepsun 1y agoAnd debt is going up as well.
- estearum 1y agoOn the plus side so is energy costs
- themafia 1y agoWhich would all be fine if wages were being adjusted at the same rate inflation is. The American worker class and the ownership class drift further and further apart.
- msandford 1y agoI can't wrap my head around anyone being happy about this who isn't extremely rich. Would love to understand.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- teachrdan 1y agoI believe that comment was meant to be sarcastic.
- throwawaymaths 1y agoopec just announced production hikes
- tzs 1y agoAt least /r/leopardsatemyface has plenty of material.
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoMe as an European with this issue for 3+ years: "first time?" /meme
- jus3sixty 1y agoConst economy = [ “People living check to check”, “Landlords living month to month”, “Corporations living bailout to bailout”, “Governments living war to war” ];
- Esophagus4 1y agoI’m nervous Trump seems to be pushing so hard for rate cuts given this reality of what seems like uneasy inflation. That will likely benefit hard assets like real estate and those with big stock portfolios, as top blue chips generally have some pricing power to offset increased cost, but I think real income will drop and you’ll get all sorts of weird second order consequences. If I had enough confidence in it, an interesting bet might be borrowing to invest in big tech blue chips. You’re betting that Trump gets his way with the Fed politically, tech benefits from low rates, tech has power to raise prices, and that Trump will inflate away your debt. Won’t be good for most Americans, but if you can’t beat em, join em? {not financial advice}
- hiddencost 1y agoRelatively benefit. Everyone will be poorer in real terms but they'll lose less quality of life.
- NewJazz 1y agoDebt is usually one of the best hedges against inflation. Instead of buying stocks on margin, though, people usually buy more price inelastic assets like homes.
- Esophagus4 1y agoYeah, I’ve just never really liked the carry costs of a house… taxes, maintenance, utilities, transaction costs, etc. and never wanted to deal with being a landlord. Plus, while the real estate market on a whole might go up, I have a hunch the chances of one individual house appreciating are more varied than the chances of one of the big tech stocks appreciating… as they are the market at this point. Edit to add: I think for the average American, real estate is the only plausible way to invest on margin, as you’ll never get 5:1 leverage at your brokerage, if you even have a brokerage.
- ajross 1y agoThat's because the median person qualifies for a vastly larger mortgage than margin limit. Margin trading is for the already-wealthy. You can get a home with near-zero assets.
- cramcgrab 1y agoTime to cut interest rates. I’m tired of paying high mortgage interest and loan interest.
- PieTime 1y agoWhen I see sub 40 percent approval rate for both parties in congress… we’ve almost reached the moment where a majority of people believe both democrats and republicans have a negative view yet the 3rd parties will remain elusive due to gerrymandering districts.
- vcryan 1y agoYes, I have absolute disdain for both parties.
- cameldrv 1y agoThis is because very few people have even an extremely rough understanding of the difficulties our nation (and world) are facing. This is an very difficult situation for a democracy. When people are confused about important matters, the most reassuring thing is to be told that there is a fairly simple and understandable solution, and that they should just let the adults get in there and solve it. People will always vote for people who say these things. The reality is that we've gotten ourselves into knots upon knots upon knots.
- hkpack 1y agoI don't know why downvotes but that statement is true. Population is confused on what the actual problems are vote for politicians solving wrong problems making things worse.
- danaris 1y agoThird parties are nonviable in most of the US due to our voting system. In order to make it mathematically possible for a third party to compete, we need to switch to something with more nuance than single vote, first-past-the-post winner-take-all elections. Ranked Choice Voting has some momentum right now, and AFAICT is no worse than any of the other options (they all fail in certain edge cases, I believe; it's just a matter of which ones).
- 1y ago
- denimnerd42 1y agoErased the spending power of my savings (investments) as well.
- mitchbob 1y agohttps://archive.ph/nw8i9 https://archive.ph/nw8i9