9 ms·
Cape Station, future home of an enhanced geothermal power plant, in Utah
- barbazoo 1y agoReminds me of another geothermal company Quaise: https://www.quaise.com/ https://www.quaise.com/.
- filenox 1y agoMost wells at Cape Station are between 8,000 and 9,000 feet deep, and the deepest one extends a mind-blowing 15,000 feet below the surface. That is about the depth you'd get to if you stacked 50 Statues of Liberty on top of each other! For those who prefer a less American-centric metric: 8,000–9,000 feet is approximately 2.5 kilometers. 15,000 feet is about 4.5 kilometers — roughly the height of 14 Eiffel Towers stacked on top of each other!
- divbzero 1y agoThat’s close to the deepest geothermal wells which are about 5 km deep: https://en.renovablesverdes.com/iceland-is-drilling-the-deepest-geothermal-well-in-the-world-volcano-heart/ https://en.renovablesverdes.com/iceland-is-drilling-the-deep... https://global.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202411/07/WS672c6803a310f1265a1cc11c.html https://global.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202411/07/WS672c6803a310f...
- ajkjk 1y agoIt's so silly to use statues of liberty as a metric when nobody really knows how tall it is either (famously it's a lot smaller than people expect).
- pwython 1y agoI'm actually shocked how big the Eiffel Tower is. https://www.size-explorer.com/en/compare/buildings/eiffel+tower/statue+of+liberty/ https://www.size-explorer.com/en/compare/buildings/eiffel+to...
- daemonologist 1y agoIt was the tallest freestanding structure in France from 1889 to 2004 (when it was surpassed by one of the pillars of the Millau Viaduct; it's still the second-tallest). Must have been absolutely mind blowing at ~312m when it was new - the record was around 150m for centuries before it.
- catlifeonmars 1y agoAU would have been the most universal measurement.
- rplnt 1y agoThe idea is you assume it with the base while they only used the statue itself, making whatever they are measuring look more impressive.
- thaumasiotes 1y agoI think the idea is that nobody has any sense, even a very rough one, of how tall the Statue of Liberty might be. It's not like you ever see it in person, and if you did most of it would be in perspective, which ruins your chances of determining its size. Most people have enough trouble believing that their foot is the same length as their forearm. You never see your feet close up, either.
- 3eb7988a1663 1y agoWhelp, I just had to put my foot onto my arm, so point made.
- daedrdev 1y agoFootball fields, despite being a meme, are very easy for Americans to visualize
- defrost 1y agoInternationally ambiguous though, the world at large equates football with FIFA and Australians picture something much larger with more foot to ellipsoid than a tiny US handegg court.
- rascul 1y agoCanadian football fields are bigger
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoI'll have you know my Canadian friends have told me it's OK, American football fields are average sized (definitely not less than average).
- Tempest1981 1y agoHelpful but pointless metrics: 1 Statue of Liberty (including foundation) is roughly 1 American football field (excluding end zones) 1 Eiffel Tower is around 3 Statues of Liberty (each with foundation)... which is almost 1600 bananas
- mooreds 1y agoWow, so the deepest well is about 27k bananas deep. Amazing!
- checkyoursudo 1y agoOne statue of liberty (Liberty Enlightening the World, Liberty Island, NYC) is approximately 4 times the size of one statue of liberty (Liberty Enlightening the World replica, Île aux Cygnes, Paris). Easy peasy.
- adrianmonk 1y agoIt's probably done because Statues of Liberty is the ultimate "freedom unit".
- lostlogin 1y agoMetric? That unit of measure must surely be imperial?
- ajkjk 1y agoSurely
- Animats 1y ago> 8,000–9,000 feet is approximately 2.5 kilometers. The usual value for the geothermal gradient is 25 to 30 degrees C per kilometer. So at 2.5km, in most locations they might be able to get boiling water, but not superheated steam. Most of the geothermal enthusiasts are talking about needing to go down 4 to 12 kilometers. Is there something special about the geology at this site?
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoI couldn't see anything that said, but... probably. Beaver County, Utah, has at least one hot spring, and I suspect more than that. I'm pretty sure that the location for this project was not chosen at random.
- Animats 1y agoFound a geothermal potential map of the US.[1] Utah is in a different basin, but Colorado has a nice big hot spot. It's not a fully renewable resource. It's possible to pull out too much heat too and deplete the resource. The entire geothermal heating of the planet is only 50 terawatts, which seems big, but it's spread over 500 million square kilometers. Or 100KW/km^2, which is not much. Solar is orders of magnitude larger. [1] https://www.britannica.com/science/geothermal-energy https://www.britannica.com/science/geothermal-energy
- metalman 1y agolikely it is hot, porous rock that is capped in such a way that injected water will heat to the super critical point for water , or water exists as a super critical fluid there already
- jandrewrogers 1y agoThe site is part of the largest high-quality geothermal basin in the world. It is larger than most countries, encompassing almost the entirety of Nevada and large parts of adjacent States. The geothermal potential of the region is enormous, even just using classic geothermal technology. The US has long been the world's leading producer of geothermal power, mostly generated from this basin.
- apitman 1y agoBoth made by the French
- yread 1y ago> 4.5 kilometers — roughly the height of 14 Eiffel Towers stacked on top of each other! Or about one Mont Blanc from sea level
- realityfactchex 1y agoActually, 3 miles means a lot more to Americans than 15,000 feet, much like your 2.5 kilometers. And 50 football fields would mean a lot more, to less measurement-aware Americans.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoThe Statue of Liberty was made by France. This IS us Americans trying to use less American-centric units of measure.
- QuantumNoodle 1y agoToday I discovered that geothermal energy is a thing, cool! An immediate question that comes to mind is how much "energy potential" does the earth store and "how is it generated"? I'd imagine something about gravity or magnetic waves that move the iron* core and stuff. Anyone know some resources I can read more about this?
- giggyhack 1y agoAssuming we can drill deep enough and harness it, the thermal energy in the earth's crust is essentially infinite.
- b112 1y agoPeople said "the Earth is too big, human activity can't change the climate". Now look at where we are. I wonder, if we draw enough heat out... would the core cool enough to shrink? And if so, would the crust collapse to the new size? Pure speculation of course, but did the first guy burning coal know the outcome? Anyhow, I love geothermal, think you're right, but just got tweaked on the word "infinite".
- rkomorn 1y agoIsn't the atmosphere we're affecting on the order of 1 millionth of Earth's mass? It'd take multiple orders of magnitude more impact from humanity for us to actually affect the core, no?
- thehappypm 1y agoJust some rough physics.. Q = m c ΔT m = mass of the crust (roughly 10^22 kg) C = specific heat of crust (roughly 1000 J/kg·K) ΔT = 1 K Q = 10^25 joules would be needed to lower the earths crust by 1 degree K About 10,000 years worth of today’s human energy consumption
- conditionnumber 1y agoI wonder how much ΔT you need at the crust to meaningfully change Earth's magnetic field by altering convection patterns in the outer core. I don't know enough physics to attempt an answer.
- giggyhack 1y agoI have been following this company and several others (Quaise, Fervo, Sage) in the EGS Space for a little bit now, and I think we are on the cusp of a huge breakthrough in baseload renewable energy. This site in Utah is one of the largest test cases that expands the use of EGS to a much broader area than just a few geothermal hot spots. Prices are dropping dramatically, and these things are moving quickly beyond the R&D phase. There is a world where every major data center across the Western US has its own base load power supply that has essentially no pollution, no footprint, no hazardous waste, and no need for complicated permitting. EGS truly could be a game changer in the world's push to decarbonize. I'm super excited.
- skipants 1y ago> no pollution, no footprint, no hazardous waste As a layman, I assume waste heat would still be an issue? Even so I would also assume it's still way less damaging to the environment than everything else.
- aDyslecticCrow 1y agoI'm not quite sure about that. The earths core should generate the same amount of heat (through gravitational friction and radioactive decay) regardless if we tap it or not. If the heat didn't escape somehow already it would slowly get hotter. Whaste heat from nuclear or fusion does contribute to earth heating, though insignificant compared to any source pf c02. But my intuition tells me geothermal wouldn't... Mm. Actually, water vapor is a potent greenhouse gas; and that's how to covert heat to energy. So mabie it would indeed be significant.
- metadat 1y agoTFA states the Cape Station plant (created and operated by a company called Fervo) are closed systems - they capture the emissions so no water is wasted or spewed into the environment as steam. They deserve big props for this innovation and effort, as historically Utah has frequently been been treated as an industrial dumping grounds. The long-term ecological damage and visual eyesores due to strip mining, chemical dumping and other pollution is significant.
- cyberax 1y agoWhat was the power plant's cost? I can't find it in Google/Kagi.
- ericfr11 1y agoIt's been very common in Europe for years. People even have individual heat pump at home. US is so much behind on new technologies
- Ozarkian 1y agoYou didn't understand the article. A home heat pump isn't a power source.
- foobarian 1y agoNit: yes, home geothermal is a power source, technically. But yea not in the way an electrical generation plant is.
- lazide 1y agoThey didn’t say home geothermal, they said home heatpumps. In that setup, the earth is not an energy source, just a very massive source of thermal inertia. They are not the same thing. ‘home geothermal’ isn’t really a thing unless you’re already living on a hotspring, which is quite unusual. (delta-v is not sufficient) At the point someone is drilling km+ boreholes and installing MW+ turbines, it’s safe to call it commercial.
- foobarian 1y agoHow is it not an energy source? The point of a heat pump is to move more heat energy around than was consumed running the device.
- lazide 1y agoHow does that make it an energy source? It makes it a pump. That still consumes energy to run. And none of the home heat pump setups I’ve seen are tapping into enough thermal inertia (or high grade heat) to do more than keep a house warm. They also, of course, PUT HEAT BACK there in the summer to help cool the house. They’re just moving heat around, and not with any particularly high quality either. If they used the atmosphere for thermal inertia (also common), would you say they were using the atmosphere as an energy source? Geothermal turns turbines with steam that then produces massive quantities of electricity. That makes it an energy source. The water way down under the ground in these cases is superheated by the surrounding rock, and provides plenty of high quality heat. There are no heat pumps involved. It’s like the difference between having a pool in your backyard, and damming a huge river and installing turbines.
- RobinL 1y agoThis provides a lot of interesting info on geothermal: https://worksinprogress.co/issue/watt-lies-beneath/ https://worksinprogress.co/issue/watt-lies-beneath/ And more: https://www.complexsystemspodcast.com/episodes/fracking-austin-vernon/ https://www.complexsystemspodcast.com/episodes/fracking-aust... One interesting point made here is that the cost of turbines puts a floor price on any form.of generation which uses them, whether renewable or not, meaning in the long run solar has a big advantage: https://www.dwarkesh.com/p/casey-handmer https://www.dwarkesh.com/p/casey-handmer. I don't know how accurate that is
- loeg 1y agoKinda. We have a lot of existing coal plants that we want to offline to decarbonize, and they've already got turbines.
- codingdave 1y agoIf anyone is interested in some history, there have been geothermal plants in that area since the 80s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blundell_Geothermal_Power_Plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blundell_Geothermal_Power_Plan...
- pcdoodle 1y agoSee site is bill gates. Hard pass.
- shadowbanurmom 1y ago[dead]
- mattferderer 1y agoIf memory serves me right, the 2024 Energy Geek Out episode touched on this topic. https://www.dotnetrocks.com/details/1931 https://www.dotnetrocks.com/details/1931 If I recall they touched on how US oil drilling companies with lots of experience in horizontal drilling were being used by these companies & the financing that goes into them.
- Ken_At_EM 1y agoSuper glad to be a part of this. Our MicroPulse Measurement While Drilling Systems have been used to drill numerous wells for Fervo. We also developed a first of its kind navigation system for the first full scale Eavor loop in Germany. Heres a presentation we did on the system last year alongside Schlumberger. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kfOGKfEoPb0?t=7852s https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kfOGKfEoPb0?t=7852s Potatoe quality but my part starts at 2:10:52. It’s absolutely awesome deploying our super rugged, super high temp drilling technologies for GeoThermal. If you’re interested in working on this kind of tech we’re hiring.
- mooreds 1y ago> If you’re interested in working on this kind of tech we’re hiring. All jobs onsite in Houston: https://www.erdosmiller.com/jobs https://www.erdosmiller.com/jobs Interesting that the tech sales job is bilingual (haven't seen that too often).
- Ken_At_EM 1y agoThank you!
- msandford 1y agoHey Ken! It was great working with you at DigiDrill. Glad to see you're still pushing the frontier of high temp, high G MWD systems. Keep up the good work!
- AndrewKemendo 1y agoHow do you do inspections on the buried assets?
- Ken_At_EM 1y agoNot sure what you mean, our equipment is conveyed in and out of the well during the drilling process.
- 1y ago
- kensai 1y agoGeothermal is not without its dangers, as the story of Staufen (https://www.researchgate.net/publication/279963863_Damage_to_the_historic_town_of_Staufen_Germany_caused_by_geothermal_drillings_through_anhydrite-bearing_formations https://www.researchgate.net/publication/279963863_Damage_to...) showed, but I am glad there is still good research going on about it.
- genghisjahn 1y agoI hear the voice of Stephan when I read this title.
- hexpeek 1y agoFrom a Bill Gates documentary, I saw research with partner companies aimed at improving nuclear power generation mechanisms to reduce waste and increase efficiency. Bill Gates’ endeavors always seem positive and fascinating.
- swayvil 1y agoPipes, steam, turbines... We need better peltier devices.
- tipidNasuada 1y agoI thought exactly the same thing. Peltier's themselves don't really have a pathway for becoming as efficient as steam turbines but there are other methods currently in research. One promising idea is to use sodium vapor in a fuel cell style device: http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jpowsour.2017.10.022 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jpowsour.2017.10.022
- quickthrowman 1y agoThe maximum COP for a peltier device is 1, in practice it’s far below that. Heat pumps go way beyond a COP of 1; an open-loop cooling system with an evaporative cooling tower can have a COP of 7. A closed loop heat pump alone can have a COP of 4. Peltier devices are a dead end for moving heat around outside of specialized applications where you can’t drag around two heat exchangers, a valve, and a pump (like active cooling clothing). It’s impossible for them to even approach the efficiency of resistive heating (COP of 1).
- swayvil 1y agoThe aim here is to get power from temperature differential, not vice-versa