6 ms·
When founders put 996 in their job descriptions or Tweet about their 996 culture it’s a helpful signal to avoid that company. The only time I’d actually consid
by Aurornis 1y ago
When founders put 996 in their job descriptions or Tweet about their 996 culture it’s a helpful signal to avoid that company.
The only time I’d actually consider crazy schedules was if I was the founder with a huge equity stake and a once in a lifetime opportunity that would benefit from a short period of 996.
For average employees? Absolutely not. If someone wants extraordinary hours they need to be providing extraordinary compensation. Pay me a couple million per year and I’ll do it for a while (though not appropriate for everyone). Pay me the same as the other job opportunities? Absolutely no way I’m going to 996.
In my experience, the 996 teams aren’t actually cranking out more work. They’re just working odd hours, doing a little work on the weekends to say they worked the weekend, and they spend a lot of time relaxing at the office because they’re always there.
- robterrell 1y agoIf you're smart enough to get hired for one of these roles, and you're willing to work 996, be just a little bit smarter and found your own startup and take all the upside.
- scubbo 1y ago> and take all the upside And all of the risk. Encouraging anyone to start their own company is deeply irresponsible. Most startups fail. If you're needing encouragement to do it - if you're not already fully deluded that you're the special snowflake unique genius who will succeed where all others have failed - you shouldn't be doing it.
- whstl 1y agoFirst: regular employees are already taking the risk of being jobless some time in the future when joining startups. Second: there is no CEO in tech taking a smaller salary than their employees.
- wombat-man 1y agoWell, sure, if you can raise capital then go for it. But if I'm burning savings trying to bootstrap that is just riskier than enjoying a salary with some risk of job loss.
- jvanderbot 1y agoCounterpoint: is that because to become a CEO one most first obtain money to fund themselves and others? An employee has the opposite arrangement, they find a job to receive money. A CEO finds money to have a job.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- smilliken 1y ago> Second: there is no CEO in tech taking a smaller salary than their employees. That's not just false but very often false.
- scubbo 1y ago> regular employees are already taking the risk of being jobless some time in the future when joining startups. Never said they weren't. But they're taking _less_ risk because they are at least taking a salary the whole time.
- komali2 1y ago> Most startups fail. So, where's the risk? You still just were working anyway, pulling a salary from someone else's bank account for a couple years. And now you have "Founder" or "Founding Engineer" or "CEO" or "CTO" on your resume. So you didn't have a good exit. So what?
- scubbo 1y ago> pulling a salary from someone else's bank account for a couple years We have a difference of understanding of what "startup" and "failure" mean. I'm not just saying "most startups don't have an exit event" - I'm saying "most startups make negligible money (either through revenue or investment), so the founders are taking a loss the whole time they're working". If that's not correct, then a) I need to update my mental model of the whole situation, and b) thank you for bringing it to my attention!
- komali2 1y agoAh well we must just know different folks. Every startup I've been aware of in my personal life was a weekend project amongst people who kept their day job, until they could get into yc or something, and then get to a seed round. The only self funded quit your day job startup I know of in my personal life is the restaurant I opened and closed within a span of a year. Learned my lesson!
- scubbo 1y agoGenuinely astonishing - and I mean that literally, not pejoratively. Thanks for this perspective. I do know myself to be very risk-averse and pessimistic, and undoing that mindset is a personal project at the moment. Thanks for these anecdata, it's helpful to be reminded that real people can and do succeed there.
- komali2 1y agoFor some more anecdata, I just had another potential new client call in to my co-op wanting to spec out an MVP that they can farm around to investors to get seed funding. He said him and his partners are keeping their day jobs for now. These kinds of projects in my experience usually cost 5-20k USD of self funded money, so of course not nothing, but well within the range of a couple working professionals pooling their money. If they can't get funding off the MVP then yes they're 20k in the hole, but at least they were working in the meantime.
- skeeter2020 1y ago>> Most startups fail. so how is it different being a salaried employee at one of these companies? You say they're likely to fail; shouldn't you get the bigger lottery ticket then?
- jvanderbot 1y agoIt is different because you collect a salary the whole time and build your resume. Its not like you file an LLC and then receive a check in the mail for two years of whatever you want. For a CEO founder, 996 is necessary to even have a shot at building and fundraising, and even then you're likely to quickly fail. Instead an IC banks on joining a founder who has funding and can get more while you build and collect a reasonable salary, and save for rainy day.
- moron4hire 1y agoIf you're a founder and not paying yourself a salary, you're one of the class of dumb canon fodder founders that VCs have indoctrinated to create a steady supply of cheap assets they can acquire and cheap engineers trained and vetted for their real investments.
- scubbo 1y ago> paying yourself a salary From what?
- alchemical_piss 1y agoFrom what I’ve heard the startups nowadays are only interested in people who already have a resume.
- _0ffh 1y agoThat's the fun part: If you find investors, then they're taking the actual risk while you pay yourself a nice salary.
- bigbadfeline 1y ago> If you find investors It's a big if. Few can get funding especially without connections. In that case, the odds are heavily against you. I'm not sure what is being argued here - if you have connections, can get the money and the opportunity is clear, go for it. However, you should be clear with the above before you put your assets at risk - a job, property, savings or whatever. It doesn't make sense to follow hype into adventures with odds of success lower than gambling. That seems obvious, but what do I know.
- _0ffh 1y ago> It doesn't make sense to follow hype into adventures with odds of success lower than gambling. Don't get me wrong, I agree. I'm just pointing out that for those who do manage to get funding (however fickle and/or unfair the process may be) all the natural risks of true entrepreneurship are moot.
- qcnguy 1y agoEr, we're posting this on a website run by a VC firm that routinely gives out investments to huge numbers of tiny teams from around the world. Literally anyone can apply. And we're supposedly in an AI bubble caused by investors ploughing hundreds of millions into any company with .ai in the name. It can't be true that getting investment is hard and requires connections.
- vlod 1y agoYep as the corporate job is super stable nowadays. /s I speculate that most people here, have come under the receiving end of what "At Will" contact.
- robocat 1y agoThere's a lot of people on HN that are not from the USA: at-will doesn't exist in many other wealthy countries. E.g. I'm from New Zealand, and at-will contracts are not legal for employees. A company can use contracts (employing a contractor) but contracts are effectively restricted to professional specialists. A company can use temping agencies but the agency takes a big commission on top of wages. A company that has to sack someone can often get hit with financial penalties through the employee rights protection laws.
- throwawaymaths 1y ago> just a little bit smarter and found your own startup does that work? how do you convince investors to give you money if you don't have a network/didn't go to stanford?
- petralithic 1y agoNot all startups are venture-backed.
- throwawaymaths 1y agomost of those aren't startups, they're lifestyle businesses. (no shade to ppl who want to do that)
- petralithic 1y agoDepends what you want to define startups as, "lifestyle" businesses are often just a derogatory term that VCs use that don't mean anything in real life.
- godelski 1y agoI don't think you answered the question. I'm pretty sure everyone knows this. But I think most people also know that it can be very difficult to pitch investors and that this is exponentially more difficult when you don't have the backing of some ostentatious pedigree.
- petralithic 1y ago> this is exponentially more difficult when you don't have the backing of some ostentatious pedigree. This has not been the case these days, to be honest. While a pedigree helps, the playing field for investment has been much more level than, say, a few decades ago. Harder, sure, but exponentially more so, definitely not.
- throwawaymaths 1y ago
- margalabargala 1y ago> If you're smart enough to get hired for one of these roles I think your framing is backwards. Getting hired as a random employee, going in expecting 9-9-6, with the sort of comp these companies manage to pay, means there is a smartness ceiling, not floor.
- martin-t 1y agoOr nobody could take the upside. Imagine if ownership of a company was divided according to the amount and skill level of work.
- vkou 1y agoA co-op or a partnership? But how will the non-productive class make money from it?
- martin-t 1y agoFunny that you say that because at some point I started dividing people in my head into what I call builders and redistributors: - Builders produce food, mine resources, build houses/machines, do research, provide essential services, etc. - Redistributors take a cut from builders, by providing a non-essential service like salesmen or assistants who call themselves managers, by getting themselves into a position of power where they have many builders work "under" them or simply by holding and "renting" limited resources like housing I feel like this division is at the core of inequality (money per unit of work only as long as you work vs money for no work in perpetuity). Yet at the same time it's not talked about at all.
- vkou 1y ago> this division is at the core of inequality Of course it is. You are limited to 168 hours in a week that you can do work. But there is no limit to the hours that other people can work for you.
- martin-t 1y agoNow the question is how to get the message out and change how it works. Because this can't be that hard to understand even for the average person.
- WJW 1y agoDo you think this is some revolutionary insight you've stumbled upon? Most people already know this, and yet the system is still the way it is.
- dvfjsdhgfv 1y ago> If you're smart enough to get hired for one of these roles s/smart/stupid/g
- marqueewinq 1y agoWell sed
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- CalRobert 1y agoIt's been popping up in the who's hiring thread, embarrassingly. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45105207 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45105207
- Sharlin 1y agoThat one's [flagged] [dead] at least, fortunately.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- gambiting 1y agoI think even if someone offered me couple million a year I still wouldn't do it. My kids will only be kids once - all of the money in the world is completely worthless if you miss out on your family. I appreciate some people here don't feel this way but to me that's not a trade off I would ever make. Especially since as software engineers we are privileged enough to usually command both high salaries and the ability to log off at 4-5pm and not think about work anymore.
- SilverElfin 1y agoIt’s impossible for anyone not in their 20s or who has kids or just a healthy balanced life.
- AnIrishDuck 1y agoThe reality is also that nobody (aside from Mark "I Want To Buy a State of the Art AI Research Lab" Zuckerberg) is even offering millions in cold hard cash. Instead, they're offering something worse: the _chance_ to cash out equity that _might_ be worth that at _some_ point in the future. Versus spending time with my kid right now. Or any of the hundreds of other more enjoyable things I can do with my time. They're dangling a lottery ticket in front of us. I've seen the end of that movie several times myself now; enough to know the odds are long. So yeah: no thanks.
- lr4444lr 1y agoConsider 2 million carefully, though. Collectively in a 9-5 job over decades you would probably lose more time with your kids than you would with how much earlier you could retire with even doing the 2 million grind for one year. Depending on the specifics, for that level of comp. I would consider it even having 2 kids.
- footy 1y agoI don't even have kids and I wouldn't do it for any amount of money. I have my own (and only) life and I don't value money above that.
- NaomiLehman 1y agoI don't understand what kind of job, except for some very, very fringe cases like a NASA active mission or an atomic threat, would require a person to pull all-nighters. And how is that productive in the long-term? It's not exactly easy to hire talent.
- HPsquared 1y agoCollege trains people for this. Basically anything with strict deadlines. Most of my coursework was done at the latest possible time, in the early hours of the morning. I think these workplaces just carry over that vibe.
- skeeter2020 1y agoCollege does a terrible job of training you for anything like a startup; it's a marathon game, unlike the 12-16 week semester sprint. What you do in the most "polished" college project is like < 25% of what goes into a marketable software product.
- Kwpolska 1y agoCollege doesn’t train you for this, you just suck at time management and planning.
- jaccola 1y agoPeople who enforce 996 or whatever other schedule are treating the symptom and not the cause. What they really want is for all of their employees to be so in love with the work, so bought into the mission and so compelled by the vision that they want to work until late. Of course building a company that inspires that is actually very difficult (though is possible for sure) so it’s easier just to enforce a crazy and unproductive schedule.
- robocat 1y ago> building a company that inspires There's a lot of grit-flavoured cool aid being sold by CEOs Here's one that came up recently selling work as the answer to life: https://joincolossus.com/article/the-amusement-park-for-engineers/ https://joincolossus.com/article/the-amusement-park-for-engi... And another saying that burnout only exists if the work is not inspiring: https://substack.com/inbox/post/172406264 https://substack.com/inbox/post/172406264
- SomaticPirate 1y agoWe need to collate this. Is there a repo where we can mention companies that do this? I’ve talked to HR reps who extol their amazing work life balance only to find engineering is expected to work close to a 996
- Kwpolska 1y agoAnd can we include on-call in the list as well?
- scott_w 1y agoOn-call is different because it’s usually paid. Lots of businesses outside of tech do on-call and it’s not controversial at all.
- Kwpolska 1y agoIsn’t 996 paid more than 955? Software engineers on-call is not a great practice, especially if you’re not in a life-critical industry (and most engineers aren’t), even though it’s been normalized.
- scott_w 1y ago> Isn’t 996 paid more than 955? Not necessarily. On-call is not the same either, there’s pay for being available then there’s pay for being called, so they’re not comparable at all. > especially if you’re not in a life-critical industry Most on-call isn’t in life critical industries. My dad had to drive to Leicester through the night with a generator in the bed of a pickup so the Walkers factory there could get back to making crisps. I’m sure Britain would have survived a slight reduction in supply of salt and vinegar crisps, so again, your idea that on-call should only exist for critical industries is an idea that seems to only exist in the heads of a relatively small number of software engineers. And I’ve no idea how you came to this conclusion.
- gedy 1y agoThese founders who tout this nonsense are convinced they got to their position by "hustling" (and not their background, privilege, etc) and think motivated employees should do the same (even if it makes no economic sense for them). Besides, their 996 is the usual nonsense of posting faux thought leader crap on linkedin. Not being shoved Jira tickets and hurry up with it.
- blooalien 1y ago> "convinced they got to their position by "hustling" (and not their background, privilege, etc)" [1] "If you're rich, you're more lucky than smart." [1]: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/making-sense/analysis-if-youre-rich-youre-more-lucky-than-smart-and-theres-math-to-prove-it https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/making-sense/analysis-i...
- couscouspie 1y agoYour refusal of 996 is relatable for senior or mid level workers. But that's something less experienced people can not afford and in this market even unlucky seniors are forced to accept things they wouldn't have to 2 or 3 years ago.
- malfist 1y ago> forced to accept things Don't be a scab
- yesimahuman 1y agoThey're taking advantage of kids right out of college that don't know any better and don't have any other personal obligations. Anyone with experience or a few more years of life can see right through it. I agree, if you expect these hours you better be offering significant skin in the game to balance the scales.
- paulcole 1y ago> When founders put 996 in their job descriptions or Tweet about their 996 culture it’s a helpful signal to avoid that company. Or a helpful signal to join that company if it’s something you’re excited about. It’s crazy to me that people are so arrogant to say that somebody else is “wrong” for being excited about something.
- tikhonj 1y agoperformative hours ≠ excitement if folks were actually excited and motivated, you wouldn't need forced hours, you'd just trust people to work in the best way for them
- paulcole 1y agoDo you think there are 0 people in the world who are excited about long hours at work?
- ohdeargodno 1y ago996 done on your own time without expectations of it being done can be understood if you're excited about it. It's dumb, it ruins your health and your social experiences, but whatever, you're usually young and dumb. A good employer would actively tell you to slow down and manage your energy if it goes on for too long.. 996 mandated by the company is 1/ illegal 2/ straight up illegal 3/ a clear signal that they do not see you as a human being. Worst case scenario, 996 is dumb. Not a super high bar to clear.
- garciasn 1y agoHow is 996 illegal for legally exempt employees in the US who meet requirements to be marked as such? Hint: it’s not.
- paulcole 1y ago> 996 mandated by the company is 1/ illegal 2/ straight up illegal 3/ a clear signal that they do not see you as a human being. 1 & 2. I don't believe this to be true in the United States. 3. If a company mandated 9 to 5 for 5 days a week isn't that equally distasteful for someone who is excited to work 996?
- annoyingcyclist 1y agoA founder who commits to 996 is as a side effect building a brand of "grit", "hustle", etc with their investors. That gives them options, regardless of whether 996 is actually useful for productivity and regardless of who is actually working harder as a result of 996: a golden jetpack into an executive role elsewhere when the company is sold for scrap, fundraising terms that give them liquidity not available to employees, a VC job, etc. They're also insulated from 996 to a degree that employees aren't. No one is going to count hours or badge swipes for the CTO/CEO of the company, and no one's going to tell them they can't leave the office early to spend time with their family. Even if they do work those hours, their job is different enough from normal employees to provide some protection from burnout. As a rank and file employee, you get none of that. The investors don't even know who you are. The outcome for you if the company fails is that you're looking for another job while fighting burnout from longer hours and from working somewhere that doesn't respect you enough as a professional to let you manage your own time (which tends to come with other things that encourage burnout). All that to juice an "hours worked" KPI that research tells us is a questionable thing to focus on. You can do better.
- godelski 1y agoI think you're right about your analysis but this only moves the question to ask what is the utility of this Kabuki theater?
- qcnguy 1y agoPeople who work more get more done. Yes, there are limits. It's not obvious 45 hours a week is that limit. Observe that the two places in the world with cutting edge AI startups are America and China. Europe has none. Maybe Mistral if you're generous, or DeepMind if you ignore that they got bought by Google, which IMO is OK because a lot of US startups have no plausible future outside of being bought and nobody claims that makes them not an AI startup. But US and China lead. Americans work way more hours than Europeans do, mostly through taking fewer holidays rather than working Saturdays. And the Chinese have caught up to the cutting edge of AI very fast, despite facing trade sanctions, Great Firewalls and other obstacles. It is reasonable to infer that they did this by working really, really hard. I was once told by a US executive that the rule of thumb is people in America (vs "Americans") work ~20% more than people in Europe. Skill level is the same, but Europeans both get more vacation time, have more national holidays, and are harder to fire for low performance. It adds up to a big difference, especially compounded over time. If 996 adds another 20% for China over America, then the Chinese will take the lead. They might burn out a lot of devs along the way (in fact they will), but maybe not as many as you think - after all America has not suffered mass burnout from having 15 days of vacation a year instead of 25 - and success will continue to accrue. This is a painful truth. I myself work part time and get European vacations. It is pleasant. Yet I know it cannot last. Europe has become a vassal continent, in which Trump dictates terms and the EU accepts them without negotiation, because of the decisions its society has made; one of the biggest being to take life easy.
- ForOldHack 1y agoCrunch time for companies? Making billions? Hire more staff. A lack of planning on your part, does not constute an emergency on my part. The jackpot payday helped, but not by much. I worked from 10 til 10 6 days a week, and the product still stunk in ice.
- bko 1y ago>If someone wants extraordinary hours they need to be providing extraordinary compensation. That's a naive approach. If you're in a place where people are fanatically devoted to the mission, it's a benefit in it of itself. First you'll learn a lot. Residency is often grueling in terms of hours. The payout is much later as you learn more. Also you're surrounded by very smart hard working people. Every high achiever I know hates working with low achievers or people who are lazy, incompetent or don't care. This is selection. So you learn a lot, in a very intense way, you'll learn a lot from smart people in a very short period of time. But the most important thing I learned is that there is a huge universe of knowledge you can't learn from books or derive logically. You would learn more doing 996 following around a high performer over a short period of time than you would from years of school. Some people like doing hard things. People do Ironmans and marathons, they train months for them and what do they get in return? Some endurance and strength that will dissipate within months of the end. Finally it depends on your stage in life. If you're coming out of college, I would definitely recommend doing the most challenging thing you can find in your area of interest. If you have a family and kids, maybe pull back a bit.
- zarzavat 1y agotl;dr: it's just ageism in disguise. Anyone in their 30s need not apply.
- bko 1y agoYeah, you're right. I think every job should be available to every person regardless of the things required from the job, personal circumstance, skillset or anything else. If some job requires more than strictly 9-5 and cannot be done by a paraplegic, visually impaired, neurodivergent individual, the job should just cease to exist, lest we be called some kind of 'ist'.
- zarzavat 1y agoIt's an office job. There is no requirement. Working extreme hours is a betrayal of your fellow workers with families who are put in the impossible position of having to choose between competing against such people or spending time with their family. It's also a betrayal of your future self, because maybe you don't have a partner or a family now, but later if you do you will be in the same position as your coworkers. Workers' rights are for everybody, even if they're not for everybody right now.
- tinktank 1y agoYou've hit the nail on the head. If you own the company, feel free to do your 996 bullshit. If you want me to work that hard, give me an equity stake that makes it so.
- MontyCarloHall 1y agoA company touting its 996 culture is unfurling a huge red flag that it doesn't have the best talent. The very best companies/workers accomplish extraordinary things in ordinary working hours, because they are extremely good at what they do and thus extremely efficient at it. Work smarter, not harder, as they say. If a company needs to work 996, it simply means it isn't all that smart.
- godelski 1y ago> if I was the founder with a huge equity stake A few startups have reached out to me to be a founding engineer. The largest equity stake offered was 3% for being employee #2. This kind of equity is batshit insane to me. These very early employees are much closer to co-founder than to a typical employee. I wouldn't demand to split the founder's equity with me but 3% seems pretty low to their 50% considering they're asking that I essentially be a founder but with <1yr delay. Unless I completely misunderstand startups, there's a lot that matters far more than the first year. At this low of a rate it generally makes more sense to go work for big tech where you'd get (near) guaranteed profits and much greater work life balances. TBH, the low equity to founding employees makes me almost think there is a conspiracy to disincentivize people to work for them. I mean you see these 0.5-2% numbers seem crazy. It's got to be a real "unicorn" company for you to make more money than you would at the big tech. I imagine it's got to end up with a lot of bad feelings too. I mean let's say that 3% gets diluted to about 1% while founder has 50% and gets diluted to 20%. Is their value 20x more than mine? Don't get me wrong, if we got to a real unicorn and did like a $10bn IPO I'd be happy with my $100m, but I can imagine a lot of people feeling ripped off seeing the person they worked neck and neck with become a billionaire. I agree, 996 is insane. Like the author said, pulling an all nighter just results in the next day being unproductive. I think of it like going to the gym, but with your brain. You can't become a body builder by just lifting weights every single day and pushing yourself to the limit every day. That only results in injury. It can be worth it for a short period of time, but I think we've also created this weird situation where no one sees that it is not worth it for anyone but the founder. IMO, if you want a successful startup, one of the key aspects is that your founding members need to be as dedicated as you. And I just don't think you're going to get that kind of investment if you're pricing yourself as 20-50x more valuable than them. It just seems doubly bad and I can't figure out why we've normalized such situations.
- __rito__ 1y ago> In my experience, the 996 teams aren’t actually cranking out more work. They’re just working odd hours, doing a little work on the weekends to say they worked the weekend, and they spend a lot of time relaxing at the office because they’re always there. That's exactly what happens. Some companies' management values asses in the office, and the fitting kind obliges. They come in at 9, leave at 8/9 in the evening, but a lot of the times they are scrolling the social media, doing chit chat, reading blogs, etc. whenever they can (can't do other serious work/learning, as such companies tend to actually spy on what you are doing). They take 90 minutes long lunch breaks, take walks to smoke, etc. But the bossman can hold a meeting with them at 1 or 3 in the morning sometimes. These get a lot of praise at such companies. They retain the worst kind of 'talent'. These companies often hire decent technical talent, but with another dimension lacking, like poor communication skills, or a no-name college- knowing that they won't land better offers soon. Often fearing market, some good people oblige, too, but then tend to quit after a year or two due to burnout. Managers are the worst. They are perpetually in meetings having conversations much worse than free ChatGPT, but they can say that they are 'working' long hours, and in weekends, setting the bar for ICs. Productivity is lower than 9-6-5 teams. But many people haven’t come out of the sweatshop/manual labour mentality.
- rcd2 1y agoPortugal also has a bit of the culture of working long hours. People joke when you leave at 6pm/7pm and ask “are you taking the afternoon off?”. We also have the “manager + 5 minutes” rule to leave work. Most of the time, when I worked in these types of companies, I was killing time and feeling depressed. After moving to the UK the culture changed. Less working ours so I started attending meetups and doing Udemy courses (most are all 60/70% finished but still!). I’m much more productive here.