6 ms·
Why Everybody Is Losing Money On AI
- candiddevmike 1y agoThis is a really well written article and contains references to back up the claims made. This part was mind blowing though: > Cursor sends 100% of their revenue to Anthropic, who then takes that money and puts it into building out Claude Code, a competitor to Cursor. Cursor is Anthropic's largest customer. Cursor is deeply unprofitable, and was that way even before Anthropic chose to add "Service Tiers," jacking up the prices for enterprise apps like Cursor.
- pimeys 1y agoInteresting to see what will happen if Cursor goes down...
- boron1006 1y agoI don’t think it’s necessarily bad to be unprofitable but definitely weird to be sending 100% of your revenue to what is essentially your main competitor
- dmonitor 1y agoIt's even weirder from Anthropic's standpoint. Your #1 customer is buying all your product to resell it at loss.
- joenot443 1y agoWhat are the odds that Microsoft acquires Cursor eventually, folding those users into a VS Code Premium of sorts?
- rcarmo 1y agoMicrosoft has an arguably better and more generally useful solution in GitHub Copilot.
- ciconia 1y ago> total revenue: $4B > compute for training models: -$3B > compute for running models: -$2B > employee salaries: -$700M Though not really representative of what users of said models may experience financially, at this point the question should be raised: if AI compute is 7x more expensive than developer salaries, what's the point? I thought the whole idea was to save money on human resources...
- sejje 1y agoSomeday (probably), a model will be trained once that is better than a human at coding, and it will only need trained once. It can then be used indefinitely for the cost of inference, which is cheap and will continue getting cheaper.
- dpritchett 1y agoThis sounds a whole lot like Pascal's wager (or Roko's basilisk, if you prefer) for trillionaires.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- eu 1y agoso the bubble will burst at some point…
- FL33TW00D 1y ago"Please don't waste your breath saying "costs will come down." They haven't been, and they're not going to." Yes, every new technology has always stayed exorbitantly priced in perpetuity.
- warkdarrior 1y agoThe first mobile phone, the Motorola DynaTAC 8000X, was launched in 1984 for $3,995 (more than $12k in 2025 dollars). So we should expect a 12x cost reduction in LLMs over 40 years.
- floren 1y agoAdjusted for inflation the Model T cost about $25k. A new car doesn't cost $2k today. Are LLMs phones, or cars?
- undefuser 1y agoIBM 3380 Model K introduced in 1987, has 7.5 GB of storage and costed about $160000 to $170000, or adjusted for inflation it is $455000 in 2025 US dollars, that's $60666/GB. A Solidigm D5-P5336 drive that can store 128 TB costs about $16500 in 2025 US dollars, that is $0.129/GB. That's a 470279x price reduction in slightly less than 40 years. So what is likely going to happen to LLM pricing? No one knows and both your example as well as mine doesn't mean anything.
- leptons 1y agoComputers do get more powerful, but the price for a decent system has been about the same for a long time. $1500 got me a good system 10 years ago, but I'd still be paying $1500 for a good system today.
- cwmma 1y agoHe isn't saying they won't ever come down, he's saying they will not be coming down any time soon due to structural factors he discusses in the article.
- cmrdporcupine 1y ago
- umbauk 1y agoI mean, we know everyone is losing money on AI. I thought from the title it was going to explain why. As in, why are they choosing to lose all that money?
- candiddevmike 1y agoIrrational exuberance
- tristor 1y ago> As in, why are they choosing to lose all that money? Executive egos and market hype
- hall0ween 1y agoThe market hype is real. Check-signers at businesses expect LLMs to have the ability the AI CEOs talk about in their interviews and conferences but don’t exist (and are no where near existing).
- GuB-42 1y agoThe obvious reason is that they think it will pay off in the future. Google didn't start profitable, it is now one of the most profitable companies in the world. Those who invest in money-losing AI believe that it will be the next Google and that profits will come. Or alternatively, they hope to sell to the greater fool.
- mewpmewp2 1y agoI'm not making any claims as to whether AI will become profitable or when, but if there's a new tech that has high potential or is highly desirable, I think it's expected that initially money will be lost. Simply because strategically if there's high long term potential, it initially makes sense to put more money in than you get out of. Not saying that AI is this, but if you determined that you have a golden goose that laid out 10 trillion USD worth of eggs when it got 10 years old, how much would you pay for it in the auction, and what would you have to show for it for the initial 9 years? Now what if the golden goose scaled to 10 trillion each year linearly? First years people sound of mind would overpay for what it makes.
- pphysch 1y agoThe issue is we're moving past the "initially" phase and people are starting to suspect that the $10T golden goose is mythical. GPT-5??
- mewpmewp2 1y agoI think it's more complex than that. You need to get really specific to calculate the potential value. It's entirely possible that there's 30 use-cases where it's very valuable, it's possible there's 80 use-cases where it's not valuable, and it's unclear how these use-cases are going to balance out in the future. To calculate whether all of this is over or undervalued would require analyzing and understanding all of those use cases and their impact very carefully. There's a lot of direct and indirect value, presumably no one is capable of currently calculating all of that anywhere near accuracy so people are making intuition based guesses on whatever data they can get hold of, but again - not so clear. I personally think that there's many levels of innovation still to come in terms of robotics, APIs/Frameworks/Coding languages/Infra specifically for LLMs to provide easier and more foolproof ways to code and do things otherwise. I think it's far from played out. I personally think that a lot of potential is still untapped.
- patall 1y agoThan why don't they raise prices? If AI developers were only worth 200k a year, nobody would pay X times those salaries and development would be cheaper. Similar, if none of the AI coding companies had free offerings, they would have less inference cost or more revenue. Yet they have the feeling that they need to offer those, likely because of competition. The article paints it as if the big companies are a factor of 2 away from profitability. Would absolutely nobody use AI if their tokens were double the price? I highly doubt that.
- m_a_g 1y agoThe cost can be significantly reduced immediately and drastically if OpenAI or Anthropic were to choose to do so. By simply stopping the training of new models, profitability can be achieved on the same day. With the existing models, we have already substantial use cases, and there are numerous unexplored improvements beyond the LLM, tailored specifically to the use case.
- crooked-v 1y agoAh, but see, those existing uses cases allow for merely finite profit, instead of the infinitely growing profit that late stage capitalism demands.
- antiloper 1y agoCurrent frontier models are not good enough because they still suffer from major hallucinations, sycophancy, and context drift. So there has to be at least (and I have no reason to believe it will be the last, GPT-5 demonstrates that the transformer architectures are hitting diminishing returns) one more training cycle.
- ten_hands 1y agoThis only works if all the AI companies collude to stop training at the same time, since the company that trains the last model will have a massive market advantage. That not only seems extremely unlikely but is almost certainly illegal.
- palata 1y ago> By simply stopping the training of new models, profitability can be achieved on the same day. But then they stop being up-to-date with... the world, right?
- km3r 1y ago> At this point, it's becoming obvious that it is not profitable to provide model inference, despite Sam Altman recently saying that OpenAI was. Except the authors own provided data says it cost them $2B in inference costs to generate $4B in revenue. Yes training costs push it negative, but this is like tech growth 101, debt now to grow faster leads to larger potential upsides in the future.
- ASinclair 1y agoTraining costs keep exploding and several companies are providing frontier models. They'll have to continue shoveling tons of money into training just to stay in place with respect to the competition. So you can't just ignore training costs.
- orbital-decay 1y agoDeepSeek alone demonstrated a massive reduction in training costs, and there's a ton of low-hanging fruits nobody even started to use.
- palata 1y ago> Yes training costs push it negative But training will have to stay forever, right? Otherwise the LLM will be stuck with outdated information...
- qcnguy 1y agoIt's not just training. Look at all the other costs in The Information's graph. Salaries, general admin, data licensing - all huge costs.
- golergka 1y ago> OpenAI spent 50% of its revenue on inference compute costs alone This means that they operate existing models with very healthy 50% profit margin, that’s excellent unit economics actually. Losing money by investing more into R&D that you make is not the same as burning it by selling a dollar for 90 cents.
- hall0ween 1y agoI’m confused. If 50% of the revenue goes to inference, that means the other 50% goes into research?
- toddmorey 1y agoMy understanding is it means half of what a subscriber pays is spent just on the compute required as you chat with the models. Which leaves the other have to be divided up among salaries, marketing, R&D, etc.
- habinero 1y agoRevenue minus compute is not profit lol. You still have to pay salaries and rent on your buildings, which are usually the biggest expenses.
- toddmorey 1y ago50% margins would be actually low and concerning for a saas business. What makes software an attractive business is how well it scales. The standard for saas has been at least 80% or higher margins. Most all saas accounts require lengthy and generous free trials and boy AI compute throws a bit of a hand grenade into that PLG strategy. It’s just new economics that the industry will have to figure out.
- sumeno 1y agoYou're ignoring the fact that there are more expenses than just inference. Salaries, infrastructure, training new models (a requirement for the model to stay up to date with the changing world) You can't just eliminate all the costs except inference
- soneca 1y agoI think the most interesting part is that, in AI, software does not have zero marginal cost anymore. You can’t build once and scale to billions just investing in infrastructure. Still, companies like OpenAI and Twitter are doing just that. Thus losing money. Will AI evolve to be again as regular software or will the business model of tech AI become closer to what traditional non-tech companies are? How the WalMart of AI will look like? Does SaaS with very high prices and very thin margins even work as a scalable business model?
- gdbsjjdn 1y agoI think Ed hits on an interesting point about the new user who spends $4 on a TODO file. Current LLM users are very enthusiastic about finding different models for different use cases and evaluating the cost-benefit of those models. But the average end user doesn't give a shit. If LLMs are going to "eat the world" they need to either be a lot better in the median case (bad prompts, bad model selection) or they need to be so cost-effective that you can farm out your query to an ensemble and choose the result dialogue-tree-style.
- exe34 1y ago> If LLMs are going to "eat the world" they need to either be a lot better in the median case (bad prompts, bad model selection) or they need to be so cost-effective that you can farm out your query to an ensemble and choose the result dialogue-tree-style. LLMs have been around for two years. it took decades before the PC really took hold.
- gdbsjjdn 1y agoSegways existed for a long time and they never took off. Zeppelins too. Not every technology automatically gets good just because time passes.
- BobbyJo 1y ago1) Chat GPT is nearly 3 years old, and LLMs were around before that. 2) Yes, they still have some time to fit the market better, but that doesn't change what they'll need to do to fit the market better.
- wood_spirit 1y agoThe IBM PC was an overnight success. It was less than a decade after the first “PCs” and it was the hockey stick moment. I remember x86 clones being seemingly everywhere in just a year or two
- exe34 1y agoPretty much everybody I know is using an LLM for something. some are even using it for things they shouldn't be using it for.
- simonw 1y ago> Please don't waste your breath saying "costs will come down." They haven't been, and they're not going to. Cost to run a million tokens through GPT-3 Da-Vinci in 2022: $60 Cost to run a million tokens through GPT-5 today: $1.25
- cwmma 1y agoyes but due to reasoning models the same query uses VASTLY more tokens today then a couple years ago
- simonw 1y agoSure, if you enable reasoning for your prompt. A lot of prompts don't need that.
- orbital-decay 1y agoIn most use cases the main cost is always input, not output. Agentic workflows, on the other hand, do eat up a ton of tokens on multiple calls. Which can usually be optimized but nobody cares.
- simonw 1y agoWith multiple calls an important factor to consider is token caching, where repeat inputs are discounted. This is particularly important if you constantly replay the previous conversation and grow it with each subsequent prompt. GPT-5 offers a 90% discount on these cached tokens! That's a huge saving for this kind of pattern.
- jjfoooo4 1y agoI think what we'll eventually see is frontier models getting priced dramatically more expensive (or rate limited), and more people getting pickier about what they send to frontier models vs cheaper, less powerful ones. This is already happening to some extent, with Opus being opt-in and much more restricted than Sonnet within Claude Code. An unknown to me: are the less powerful models cheaper to serve, proportional to how much less capable they are than frontier models? One possible explanation for why e.g. OpenAI was eager to retire GPT 4 is that those older models are still money losers.
- smeeth 1y agoAnother day, another person not getting discounted cash flow. Models trained in 2025 don’t ship until 2026/7. That means the $3bn in 2025 training costs show up as expense now, while the revenue comes later. Treating that as a straight loss is just confused. OAI’s projected $5bn 2025 loss is mostly training spend. If you don’t separate that out with future revenues, you’re misreading the business. And yes, inference gross margins are positive. No idea why the author pretends they aren’t.
- bionhoward 1y agoIs this really surprising given how VC funded capitalism works? Spend money to build amazing technology and gain market share, then eventually flip into extraction mode. Yes, a pullback will kill some weaker companies, but not the ones with sufficient true fans. Plus, we’re talking about a wide-ranging technological revolution with unknown long term limits and economics, you don’t just give up because you’re afraid to spend some money. I don’t want to pay Anthropic, because I don’t trust them, but I will absolutely pay cursor, because I trust them, and I doubt I’m alone. My cursor usage goes to GPT-5, too, so it’s definitely not 100% Anthropic, even if I’m the only idiot using GPT5 on Cursor It’s fun to innovate. Making money is a happy byproduct of value creation. Isn’t the price of success always paid in advance, anyway? Why would winning AI tech companies pack it up and stop crushing it over the long term just because they’re afraid to lose someone else’s money in the short term? Wouldn’t capitulation guarantee losses moreso than continued effort?
- panosv 1y agoWhat about Google? Anyone has any insights on their unit economics since they own the models and the infrastructure (which is also custom TPUs)? Are they doing better or are they in the same money losing business?
- seanalltogether 1y agoIt feels like Google should be able to come up with a revenue figure for search ai results right? How many people do a search but don't click on any links because they just read the ai blurb, but advertisers are still charged for being visible on the page.
- tim333 1y agoIt must be hard for them to figure how much of their revenue is down to AI and how much to other stuff like search. They certainly make a lot of revenue and it would be foolish for them to ignore AI and have OpenAI and Perplexity eat their lunch.
- vb-8448 1y agoNice read, but I'd add an objection here: even if models don't improve any more, and they raise the standard subscription to 100$/month, I'd still buy it (and a lot of other people, I guess) because I'd extract far more value from it.
- patall 1y agoThat's also what I do not get. The companies are unprofitable because of competition, not because what they do cannot be profitable.
- leptons 1y agoIf it costs more to produce a result than a customer is willing to pay, then the company will either be unprofitable (sell at a loss) or just close up shop. The cost for running LLMs is much higher than what customers are likely to want to pay, and that has nothing to do with competition from other LLM companies, it's a result of high cost of cutting-edge hardware, infrastructure, and the massive amount of electricity it consumes - so much electricity that tech companies are now building power plants to power them (which are very expensive to build). It's a massive cost, and all for the hope that people will continue to accept AI slop.
- vb-8448 1y agoAccording to the data in the post, the cost of running the model for open AI in 2024 was 2B and if we strip out all training/research costs they had a loss of about 1B, peanuts. They can raise a little bit the standard subscription prices and turn profitable. The bulk of the cost was model training and research(~4B). They are forced to train new models and improve existing one because of the market and competition.
- sumeno 1y ago> if we strip out all training/research costs You can't just strip out those costs. You have to train new models or the information in the model will be out of date.
- bbreier 1y agoDoes controversy cause articles to slide on HN? I noticed that this had more points in less time than several articles ranked above it, which surprises me a bit e.g. at time of writing a post about MentraOS has 11 points in 1 hour compared to this article's 51 in 53 minutes, but this is ranked 58th to Mentra's 6
- bbreier 1y agoIt has dropped to 100th while the MentraOS post remains at 5th. Is HN pushing negative PR for AI down the ranks?
- wood_spirit 1y agoSome people must be flagging it Dang, can we chat about collaborative filtering bubbles please?
- uncircle 1y agoYes. Too large a comment/vote ratio causes articles to be defrontpaged, as well as some domains. Moderators do a lot of manipulation behind the scenes to keep what they deem ‘hot-button topics’ down in 3rd page or shadow-banned altogether. Then there’s the user flagging system that is abused whenever some popular article goes against the grain. That’s why I use https://news.ycombinator.com/active https://news.ycombinator.com/active to find the interesting topics instead of having to rely on the strict moderation algorithm
- deeviant 1y agoI don't understand these posts. Do people not understand how venture capital works? The majority of these companies know they are burning money, but more than that knew they would be losing money at this point and beyond. That is the play, the thesis is: AI will dominate nearly everything in the near future, the play is to own a piece of that. Investors are willing to risk their investment for a chance of getting a piece of the pie. Posts that flail around yelling companies 'losing money', without addressing the central premise are just wasting words. In short, do you think AI is not going to dominate nearly everything? Great, talk about that. If you do believe is, then talk about something other than the completely reasonable and expected state of investors and companies fighting for a piece of the pie. As a somewhat related tangent, people seem to not understand the likely cost trajectory of model training/inference costs: * Models will reach a 'good enough' point where further training will be mostly focused on adding recent data. (For specific market segments, not saying that we'll have a universal model anytime soon, but we'll soon have one that is 'good enough' at c++, might already be there). * Model architecture and infrastructure will improve and adapt. I work for a company that was among the first use deep learning to control real-time kinetic processes in production scenarios, our first production hardware was a nvidia Jetson, we had a 200ms time budget for inference, and our first model took over 2000! We released our product, running under 200ms, *using the same hardware* the only difference was improvements in the cuDNN library and some other drive updates and some domain specific improves on our YOLO implementation. Long story short, yes inference costs are huge, but they are also massively disruptable. * Hardware will adapt. Nvidia cash machine will continue, right now nvidia hardware is optimized for balance between training and inference, where TPUs, the newer ones are more tilted towards inference. I would be surprized if other hardware companies don't force Nvidia to give the more inference based solution and 2-3x cost savings at time point in the next 5 years. And for all I know, perhaps a hardware startup will disrupt Nvidia, it would be one of the most lucrative hardware plays on the planet. Focusing inference cost is a deadend to understanding the trajectory of AI, understanding the *capability* of AI is the answer to understanding it's place in the future.
- serjester 1y agoThe big labs have 50+% margins on serving the models, the training is where they lose money. But every new model boosts OpenAI's revenue growth which is unheard of at their size (300+% YoY). Therefore it's completely reasonable to keep doubling down and making bigger bets. Most people miss that they have almost a billion free users that are waiting to be monetized. Google makes 400B a year and it's crazy to think OpenAI can't achieve some percentage of that. Why would you slow down and let Google catch up for the sake of short term profitability.
- jjfoooo4 1y agoThe article claims otherwise: > In fact, even if you remove the cost of training models from OpenAI's 2024 revenues (provided by The Information), OpenAI would still have lost $2.2 billion fucking dollars.
- Incipient 1y agoYou also need to remove the research cost, and probably a bit of the people cost. The issue however is, can an AI company actually go "yep. We're done this is a good as it gets!"? I don't believe they can do that, so removing training cost is kind of a moot point.
- Jimmc414 1y agoCursor burning cash to subsidize Anthropic's losses to subsidize Amazon's compute investments is their problem, not mine. The people writing all of these "AI is unprofitable" pieces are doing financial journalism similar to analyzing the dot-com bubble by looking at pets.com's burn rate. The infra overspend was real as well as the bankruptcies, but it existentially foolish for a business to ignore the behavioral shift that was taking place. I have to constant remind myself to stop arguing and evangelizing about AI. There is a growing crowd who insists that AI is a waste of money and that AI cannot do things I'm already doing on a daily basis. Every minute spent explaining to AI skeptics is a minute not spent actually capitalizing on the asymmetry. They don't want to hear it anyway and I have little incentive to convince anyone otherwise. The companies bleeding money to serve AI below cost prices won't last, but thats all more the reason use them now while they're cheap.
- uludag 1y agoI think the main fear is that these products will become so enshitified and engrained into everywhere that, looking back, we'll be wishing we didn't depend so much on the technology. For example, the Overton window around social media has shifted so much to the point that it's pretty normal to hear views that social media is a net negative to society and we'd be better off without it. Obviously the goal of these companies is to generate as much profit as possible as soon as possible. They will turn the tables eventually. The asymmetry will go in the opposite direction, maybe to the extend that one takes advantage of the current asymmetry.
- Jimmc414 1y agoI don't disagree with anything you've said.
- watwut 1y agoBut back then, you was better off not depending on pet.com. If products of one of those vaporware companies became important in your process, your company went down along with. Those were companies that had multiple expensive IT restructurings one after another, each making them more innefective and then either run out of cash or barely made it. It worked well for companies that were choosing smart.
- username135 1y agoAmazon was unprofitable for years (like over a decade), famously. I don't see any difference with AI companies. There is clearly some kind of market for this technology. It will eventually be profitable either through some technology breakthrough that allows creating/processing tokens cheaper or by finding a cost structure consumers can live with. The cat is already out the bag. This technology isn't going away.
- Ekaros 1y agoTo succeed like Amazon you actually have to have cash-flow in first place. The comparison only works when company can stop investing and immediately make profit. And I do not think any of the AI companies are at that point. Or could continue to run for any length of time if they choose to.
- tuatoru 1y agoOf course they are losing money. If they are not losing money, they are not investing fast enough. Standard market share logic.