5 ms·
The USA might as well put up a 'closed for business' by now. Outside of manufacturing all around me there is talk of ditching Azure, Google and even AWS in spi
by jacquesm 1y ago
The USA might as well put up a 'closed for business' by now.
Outside of manufacturing all around me there is talk of ditching Azure, Google and even AWS in spite of massive lock-in because the feeling that the USA is a trustworthy partner is completely gone. You can't just 'joke about invading Greenland' and expect everybody to move on as if it didn't happen. And I'm pretty sure that this isn't just local sample bias either, NL used to be pretty laid back when it came to silly details such as hosting providers and such.
How long until the .COM registry becomes fair game for the nationalists?
- Insanity 1y agoAWS announced that they'd have an EU 'governed' region with only EU citizens working on it.https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/security/establishing-a-european-trust-service-provider-for-the-aws-european-sovereign-cloud/ https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/security/establishing-a-europea.... I'm not sure if that'd fully alleviate the risk for EU companies & governments, but I'd imagine it alleviates some of it.
- classified 1y agoThat doesn't help when every US company is under US jurisdiction.
- jacquesm 1y agoYes, they're panicking. And I'm not sure that this is going to be enough to offset the various concerns.
- Insanity 1y agoI agree that it might not be enough, but at the moment there also aren't good EU competitors in the cloud space. Good not in the technical sense, but good as in - people would be comfortable putting their eggs in the basket. Plus, hiring for AWS / Azure / GCP experience is still much higher than for the smaller EU clouds.
- ahartmetz 1y agoHetzner is pretty well established and has a good reputation - but they don't offer the same high level services as Amazon.
- jacquesm 1y agoThis isn't about reputation or high level services. Ultimately this is about certification and there are precious few alternatives with sufficient capacity that are certified and not somehow indirectly or directly owned by US entities. And there is a run on the ones that are.
- perching_aix 1y agoThe same way encryption at rest and encryption in transit checks the security box I'd imagine. Great until it can be admitted it isn't.
- MarcusE1W 1y agoThere was an interview with a high ranking Microsoft lawyer the other week where the lawyer conceded that even if the company would be a European subsidiary and the employees would be European then Microsoft still would have to obey the new US laws. Of course the employees would be bound by European law, let’s see how that pans out.
- Insanity 1y agoInteresting, do you have a link to that? I can probably google for it but I'm being lazy. :D
- ericmay 1y ago> Microsoft still would have to obey the new US laws This shouldn't be a surprise to anyone given that it is an American company. Being a multinational corporation like Microsoft or Mercedes Benz means you have to navigate rather complex legal situations, follow not just your home country's laws, but also the laws of the countries that you are operating in.
- hshdhdhj4444 1y agoAmerica is not even pretending to be a lawful nation anymore, so even if the executive had truthfully said the opposite it would be irrelevant. The real question is where the CEO lives and whether their family and kids are susceptible to being kidnapped by the US govt.
- parchley 1y agoIf it’s in any way owned by a US entity, then no, then it’s just smoke and mirrors.
- x0x0 1y agoIt's all a game of lets pretend. The fundamental risk for the EU is the Cloud Act. Since that facility is still owned by a company that is owned by a US company, the Cloud Act applies. Microsoft tried a similar thing in Germany and it failed.
- detaro 1y agoSadly there are more than enough entities in the EU, including states and other critical sectors, that are more than willing to play pretend too. We've seen it with privacy deals, I fear this will be similar.
- Insanity 1y agoI'm sure you're right, but having worked on both sides of the ocean, I can say that EU companies do keep the privacy angle in mind a bit more. I did work on medical devices though, so I might just have been in a bubble.
- jacquesm 1y agoMedical, financial and insurance are all handling this quite well now, but many other fields are still - hopelessly - lagging behind.
- x0x0 1y agoI'd call it realpolitik. The eu doesn't write its own software. This is the downside case of that. I personally would be open to trying to change that, but I keep looking at the EU and they don't want to. Many countries are actively hostile to entrepreneurs and eg can charge taxes/fees/exit fees on unrealized cap gains. etc.
- Insanity 1y agoYeah EU is not competitive in tech. They missed the boat by.. decades. And the salary of engineers in EU is not good enough to make it attractive either for those who can and want to live abroad. I’m an EU citizen, and think life generally was better in Belgium. But the salaries being so poor means I’m unlikely to move back.
- jacquesm 1y agoThat's not enough. The only thing that would be enough would be a change of ownership but that clearly isn't on the table. Yet. But I would not be surprised if AWS/Azure/Google ended up divesting some of their DCs in Europe as a result of the exodus.
- whimsicalism 1y agohow is this better than what the US is doing? at least in the US, they allow non-citizens to build
- eesmith 1y agoIf the US government decided to invade Greenland and ordered Amazon to cut off all network connections to Denmark, would this region still operate for Danish users? If it did, and the US ordered Amazon to shut down the region, would it? If the region kept on operating, and the US ordered Amazon to stop providing software updates, security updates, new license keys, etc. - how long could the region keep running?
- jacquesm 1y agoYou can't 'just' invade Greenland. You'd be invading the EU.
- CamperBob2 1y ago"B....b....but Trump can't do that!" How many times have we heard that? He owns the party, the courts, the legislature, and the guns.
- eesmith 1y agoThen change the parameters slightly and imagine the US using the threat of cutting off Amazon, Microsoft, Google, and Apple services to Denmark as incentive to transfer Greenland to US control.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mrits 1y agoWho is a trust worthy partner? If you talk to a European as an American they often have a lot more dislike for each other. It hasn’t been a century since they tried to genocide each other
- bobbylarrybobby 1y agoThey dislike each other but my understanding is that, at least in the EU, they view each other as stable and trustworthy. No jokes about invasions, no deporting (or worse, imprisoning) legal immigrants, in general no caprice. Meanwhile the US simply cannot be counted on to be the historically stable and trustworthy partner that had defined us over the past 75-odd years.
- jacquesm 1y ago> Who is a trust worthy partner? Until very recently the USA was the preferred technology partner for many EU ventures and was seen as a trustworthy ally because of mutual history since 1945. > If you talk to a European as an American they often have a lot more dislike for each other. A lot more than what? And what exactly did Europe do in recent times that would give American citizens that feeling? > It hasn’t been a century since they tried to genocide each other This is a complete nonsense statement.
- disgruntledphd2 1y agoI believe the OP meant that European countries dislike one another, and the genocide refers to the Holocaust.
- mrits 1y agoWhen you want to put aside your feelings and discuss facts I'll be around.
- DougN7 1y agoFrom my experience, anti-Trump Americans are still embraced and appreciated by Europeans. That doesn’t mean they can trust the US gov’t and probably won’t be able to again for a few decades.
- ludicrousdispla 1y agoIt will be interesting to see how this plays out economically. It's like a repeat of Covid but only for the USA, and I expect it to negatively impact large corporations more than small businesses.
- sailfast 1y agoGreenland wasn’t a joke. Nothing that is said is a joke. It’s all real. If there isn’t push back of a substantial amount it will happen. With some pushback or indication that effort will be required personally on the part of the president then it gets delayed or conveniently forgotten.
- graemep 1y ago> Outside of manufacturing all around me there is talk of ditching Azure, Google and even AWS Lots of talk, but how much action? People are still building things that depend on American cloud, American controlled OSes (especially for mobile), American supplied hardware, American cloud services (especially AI) and the moves away are tiny by contrast.
- jacquesm 1y agoPlenty of action. This has gone way beyond 'mild discomfort but we'll just pretend it is all ok'. The last 6 months have seen a massive change in attitude.
- graemep 1y agosome examples of action?
- frm88 1y agohttps://windowsforum.com/threads/european-governments-shift-from-microsoft-to-open-source-software-for-digital-sovereignty.370819/ https://windowsforum.com/threads/european-governments-shift-... Directly from the Windows Forum. https://www.slashgear.com/1888658/microsoft-office-alternative-denmark-libreoffice-linux-why-move-important-explained/ https://www.slashgear.com/1888658/microsoft-office-alternati... Government's in Denmark, Germany, Spain (on the state level ) A couple more links for companies, but I trust the above is enough? The trend is definitely there and picking up speed. Edit: a couple of days ago there was a post on HN about SAP spending 20b on cloud https://www.theregister.com/2025/09/04/sap_sovereign_cloud/ https://www.theregister.com/2025/09/04/sap_sovereign_cloud/
- graemep 1y agoSo over the last 15 years the solid examples of moves that have been committed to are: 1. Denmark’s Ministry for Digital Affairs 2. Two Danish cities 3. One German state 4. The Italian Ministry of defence 5. One Spanish region They also say French education ministry advised schools to move off the free versions of the "free versions" of MS Office 365 and Google Docs. They do not say anything about how many schools followed the advice, or what they moved to (a paid version of the same? another American supplier?). Not much for a whole continent. There will be a lot of resistance to any change. There will be a lot of people like this making the same arguments made here: https://www.theregister.com/2025/08/13/debate_for_microsoft_in_public_sector/ https://www.theregister.com/2025/08/13/debate_for_microsoft_... Microsoft has successfully had such decisions reversed in the past: https://www.linux-magazine.com/Online/News/Munich-Plans-to-Ditch-Linux-and-Go-Back-to-Windows https://www.linux-magazine.com/Online/News/Munich-Plans-to-D...
- Dig1t 1y ago> How long until the .COM registry becomes fair game for the nationalists? What does this mean? Like “the nationalists” would start taking away domain names of people they don’t like or something?