7 ms·
How resilient is a nation state? This is a question I keep asking myself. I was kind of surprised how the USA bounced back from Trump I. But I really wonder if
by jacquesm 1y ago
How resilient is a nation state? This is a question I keep asking myself. I was kind of surprised how the USA bounced back from Trump I. But I really wonder if there is going to be a similar recovery this time around. The amount of outright destruction is overwhelming. So, you raid the Hyundai facility. And then in a few years time you wonder why foreign companies no longer want to invest into factories on US soil. The knock on effect of all of this stuff is enormous and the consequences are going to be many years in the coming. And yet, it all just happens, there is no meaningful pushback against any of this.
- serf 1y ago> I was kind of surprised how the USA bounced back from Trump I. what'd we bounce into? what did we bounce back from? what effects are you talking about specifically. I work in aerospace and the sentiment was exactly opposite. People cheered both Trump elections and were dead terrified of a blue win ruining contracts and business. I don't ask because I am overtly political, I ask because I think it's fascinating that both sides seem to think we're a stone's throw from the apocalypse.. which very much seems to be projected onto the voter base on purpose..
- krapp 1y ago> I think it's fascinating that both sides seem to think we're a stone's throw from the apocalypse.. which very much seems to be projected onto the voter base on purpose.. Projected by whom, by what means, and to what end? Consider that both sides may have legitimate reasons to be concerned with this term that didn't apply to Trump's first term, and that what you see isn't simply some form of mass-manipulation or "projection onto the voter base."
- nkozyra 1y agoIndeed, the 2nd term is a radical departure from the first, which was more muted than most would have expected given the campaign. The 2nd term is making fundamental changes to our economy that carry a promise of bearing fruit. Not only are those promises generally contested by economic experts, the short-term results have been unsurprisingly poor.
- nkozyra 1y agoIf there's a dichotomy that I can't really reconcile politically, it's the fundamental idea that people coming here is bad. That we cannot allow anyone else in. We can't even allow things from other countries to come here. The effects of this insular isolationism can only be explained by simplicity that doesn't hold up in reality: things will be more prosperous for us if we keep what we have to ourselves. But in truth growth is growth. To build prosperity, we need more production, which means more people. Perhaps your share gets bigger, but the pot gets smaller.
- defen 1y ago> If there's a dichotomy that I can't really reconcile politically, it's the fundamental idea that people coming here is bad. That we cannot allow anyone else in. We can't even allow things from other countries to come here. "People coming here" is not inherently good or bad. Some people would be good for the country, and some people would be bad. I'm speaking of individuals here, not groups. The issue is that the electorate at large feels like it has been given a choice between two extremes: "Effectively allow ANYONE to come here and stay as long as they want" and "Don't let ANYONE come here". If you give a people a choice of two extremes, don't be surprised if they choose the extremism you don't like. Reconceptualize MAGA as voting AGAINST what the Democrats are offering, instead of FOR what Trump is offering, and it might make more sense.
- lbrito 1y agoIn what world were the dems advertising allowing anyone in though? Did I daydream Harris saying "do not come" a few years ago?
- defen 1y agoI want to make it clear that we're not having an object-level discussion about this. This is not about "the actual stated policy" of the Democratic party. This is also not about "are those policies good or bad". It is not about my own views on those topics. So when I tell you my perception of other people's perception, please don't come back and say the equivalent "that's not actually what they said" or "yeah but that's a good policy." You might think that my perception of the electorate at large is inaccurate, and that's fine - it's purely based on vibes and anecdotal conversations with people. The issue is trust. Why should voters trust that Kamala Harris will implement immigration policies they want? Why should they expect her not to yield to the most extreme elements in her party, which believe that borders are a fiction and should not exist? Look at Barack Obama's "evolution" on gay marriage over the course of his political career. Now take an issue that is far more important than gay marriage - how is she going to stop unlimited unskilled immigration? How is she going to stop fraudulent claims of refugee status? How is the whole immigration problem itself going to be solved, if you posit that every one of the 10 million "unauthorized immigrants", and every one of the refugee claimants, needs multiple appearances in court to resolve their situation?
- andrewflnr 1y ago> dead terrified of a blue win ruining contracts and business This is expected behavior, but not to be taken seriously as a moral argument. Preserving liberty and rule of law vs preserving money, so hard to choose...
- rustystump 1y agoI dont understand why you are downvoted. It seems like people have a real knee-jerk reaction to anything contrary to their world view which is exactly what you are commenting on. All most all the replies to your comment have nothing to do with the substance of what you said. The reality is that the us system is predominantly run by bureaucrats which make sweeping changes hard. This is a feature of the system. This means that whatever party is in charge will have a harder time enacting the crazy. I never understood the “my side”/“us vs them” from people. There is only one side and we are all on it.
- biophysboy 1y agoThe belief that the voter base is easily manipulated and does not have earnest opinions is an overtly political belief.
- tripletpeaks 1y agoIt’s also a topic of scientific study with a century or more of literature. It’s a little more complicated than what you wrote, but basically: yes. [edit] Example study construction: pick some issue where there’s been a heavy propaganda push against it from one party, but a law they opposed passed anyway. Ideally, something like a tax increase, that can directly affect voters in a way they might reasonably be expected to understand and know about. Observe that the (say) tax hike affects not more than 2% of the population you’re studying. Survey. Observe that 35% or 40% of people say the new tax law increased their taxes, and very nearly all of them favor the party that opposed the hike and was claiming or implying it would affect more people than it did. Repeat similar studies over a period of decades, always with familiar outcomes. Draw conclusions. Separately, you can probe basic understanding of how our government & various policies or laws work. You’ll find half of everyone not knowing how marginal income tax rates work, that almost all the people who think our foreign aid spending is way too high believe it’s 10x, 20x, 30x higher than it actually is, et c. Generally speaking, voters hardly know how anything works, so of course they buy lies about it. That’s not me being shitty, it’s what the evidence overwhelmingly says is true. And this is far from an exhaustive treatment of alarming traits & behaviors of the electorate.
- detaro 1y ago"was exactly opposite"? What is it currently?
- tripletpeaks 1y agoThings Red Team worries about: 1. If a democrat is elected, they will take all their guns (their campaign rhetoric keeps saying this will happen, but it continues being no part of democratic presidential campaign messaging, and hasn’t happened the times they warned it definitely would—this one’s fake) 2. Election security. But republicans keep getting into positions to investigate this and either not doing it (because they know it’s BS) or doing it and finding only a handful of mostly-accidental cases that don’t favor either party. Also fake. 3. Leftward shift around acceptance of non-standard sexual and social norms. This one’s real. Whether it’s a problem or just… fine and not worth worrying about? That’s another matter. 4. A bunch of totally wacky shit like litter boxes in classrooms. Fake. 5. Healthcare prices. Real! Democrats also worry about this. 6. Socialism. LOL we’re not remotely near it, very nearly nobody elected in the Democratic Party is left of center-right in most of the rest of our peer states, on economic issues and social safety nets and such. Fake issue. 7. Illegal immigrants increasing the crime rate (fake) and taking our jobs or driving down wages (true, with an asterisk that the effects are complicated, but sure, true) and bringing in drugs (you want citizen drug mules, they cross the border easier, or to just use shipping containers or cargo trucks entering the ordinary way with some greased palms as you can do crazy volume that way, this is fake) 8. Crime being out of control. Broadly, fake. (“But police stats could be…” yeah we have victimization surveys too, people study this and already thought of your objection. Again, fake) 9. Colleges being too liberal. Look at all that “fake” stuff above. Yeah gee I wonder why, dude. Real, but wholly self-inflicted. 10. Rampant fraud in social programs, by the people receiving the aid. This is extremely well-studied. Fake. 11. The budget deficit. Except Republicans are even worse for the budget than democrats, over the last 40 years. By, like, quite a bit. Mostly because they think tax cuts magically pay for themselves, plus Bush’s wars. They mocked the shit out of Gore for talking sense on this topic, and elected cut-taxes-and-spend Dubya. So. Real issue but they are extremely confused about who to vote for to improve it. There are more but you get the idea. Yes, Fox News and Mark Levin and all them have convinced republicans the world is going to end if democrats win elections. But it’s largely based on completely made-up shit. Left as an exercise for the reader to make a list for Democrats’ side. Nb how much of its worry about Republicans causing harm by trying to address the fake issues above. Probably most of it. And that’s a real thing that happens, to be worried about.
- 1y ago
- adam_arthur 1y agoThe US nuked Japan in the 1940s and only a short few years later were close allies. Similarly, Germany was the de facto enemy of the Ally aligned world in the 40s and only a few short decades later best friends with most. You can identify countless similar atrocities in US history after which relations stabilized within a few years. Most in life are short term oriented and it's rare that these things produce lasting effects on perception. Does anyone care or even remotely think about what Bush did as president 20 years ago? Some politically oriented and historically minded folks yes, 99% no. They really have to be long lasting and persistent transgressions to produce generational distrust e.g. Japan invading China/Korea many times over the last few hundred years. However the new gen seems far less concerned about this too. Given Trump's larger than life character/ego/presence, it's more likely that anything he does will be attributed to him instead of the country as a whole. Which makes his actions perhaps even less impactful than a more neutral presenting president doing the same.
- vdupras 1y agoI think it's important to note that they were friends after a regime change.
- adam_arthur 1y agoLike the US presidential elections every four years?
- vdupras 1y agoGoing from an empire/reich to a democracy ain't quite the same thing as a presidential election. The USA will have a hard time recovering from institutional damage being done to it right now.
- adam_arthur 1y agoIt's irrelevant whether change in policy is due to losing a war, revolution, or democratic election. If the numbers swing 5%, the US may suddenly have a radical change in foreign policy and governorship. Seen as recently as the 2024 election. Regardless, I'm discussing the opinion of the populace, not the political leadership. You can't endear a country's people to you by installing a puppet government
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- gdulli 1y agoHopefully foreign companies understand the nuance that Trump is a perfect storm of having been a reality show celebrity for several decades, born into money, bad upbringing, personality type that's immune to shame. Others trying to be him have not been able to replicate his success electorally. Lowest common denominator celebrity is key to his success. Theres a good case to be made that he's an aberration and there won't be another demagogue after him to so effectively capture his audience and survive the corruption and incompetence that follows. He has potential heirs that are smarter and more disciplined than him, but ironically that path doesn't lead you to a life of pop culture/paparazzi/TV celebrity. Thats not to say we don't deserve to have lost significant trust and respect. But if you take the long view, it's not an extrapolation of this.
- vkou 1y agoThe long view is that it's clear that the voters can be trusted to vote someone like him in twice, and the Republican party can be trusted to completely emasculate itself to maintain a petty fraud's cult of personality. Neither is encouraging for the future.
- gdulli 1y agoI get it but also he lost the popular vote 2/3 times, has never defeated a man in the general election, and is a minus 7.6 million in 3 popular votes. He lost the popular vote to a very unpopular and polarizing Hillary Clinton, and that was with help from Cambridge Analytica and James Comey.
- vkou 1y agoThe same media mechanisms which made Hillary 'very unpopular and polarizing' instead of just a milquetoast dem will make the next dem candidate 'very unpopular and polarizing'. And they weren't playing for the popular vote.
- notahacker 1y agoI think the flip side is that whilst Trump's personal quirks and appeal might be unique, half the American polity unquestioningly does his bidding and endorses his insanity and it's not like his positions on the rest of the world are particularly unpopular or institutional trust and credible business-friendly conservatives are going to magically appear out of the ether when he's gone. The long view might not look like "Trump's boot trying to stomp on you forever", but it doesn't look like "America is a trustworthy ally, especially in business" either. It isn't going to stop the world from suckling on the US money teat, but it is going to make them a lot more selective about if and when they do so.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- lbrito 1y agoIn a bizarre plot twist, the US is gradually easing into the very same role of a cult-personality, unreliable, non free trade State that they've been bitching about for almost a century now.
- em-bee 1y agothis may well be like the downfall of rome. slowly but surely, the country will sink into irrelevance (ok, maybe not completely irrelevant, but certainly less than now). i think the reason there is no pushback is that things are happening too fast at an unprecedented scale that we can't even envision the consequences, let alone predict them. we are completely unprepared for this and by the time we can figure out how to deal with it, or even stop it, it will be to late. it is also possible that many believe that this will stop by itself with the next president, and so there is no point in trying to stop things now. in a way i actually agree with that. walking in unity but realizing your error and changing course is a better choice than risking a civil war. civil war sounds alarmist, and maybe it is, but i fear that without consensus on what is the right course of action, worse without consensus that the current trajectory is bad, i don't see any other outcome. before anything can be done, a consensus on what that should be is simply necessary. and unfortunately, it should be obvious that there is no such consensus now. if there were, we wouldn't even have this controversy.
- MarcusE1W 1y agoMy optimistic interpretation is slightly different. So far the US is still a democracy with a President wo doesn’t take the law too seriously. On the other side every democracy looses a bit focus over time and laws to keep government clean get softened, IMHO. But let’s say the next election happens and the opposition will be voted in (if not, god knows where this ends) , then there will be a government with a state apparatus in tatas. They have the burden but also the opportunity to rethink how things are supposed to work and can make changes that most previous governments did not even thought possible. Maybe, I don’t know. But maybe this slightly painful time is part of a renewal process that in the end will be helpful. And Trump of all people makes it involuntary possible.
- em-bee 1y agoi can pretty much agree with that. while my comment focuses on the negative "the US will be less relevant", yours focuses on the positive. but they are both possible at the same time. heck, being less relevant may even be a positive in itself. the current events provide a wakeup call that has the potential to galvanize change. as i said, what we need is a consensus. hopefully the next government will realize that too, and work towards that. otherwise it is up to us individuals to work on that too.
- throw0101d 1y ago> I was kind of surprised how the USA bounced back from Trump I. But I really wonder if there is going to be a similar recovery this time around. The amount of outright destruction is overwhelming. It is as resilient as the people (in power?) want it to be: > To suppose that any form of government will secure liberty or happiness without any virtue in the people, is a chimerical idea. If there be sufficient virtue and intelligence in the community, it will be exercised in the selection of these men. So that we do not depend on their virtue, or put confidence in our rulers, but in the people who are to choose them. * James Madison, Papers 11:163, https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-11-02-0101 https://founders.archives.gov/documents/Madison/01-11-02-010...
- cjs_ac 1y agoWhy is it that every high-brow discussion of US politics soon ends up quoting one of the founding fathers? As an outsider, I think the fundamental issue in the US political system is that there doesn't seem to have been any new ideas since the eighteenth century. It's just a bunch of rhetoricians quoting the same ancient texts, as though the US faces exactly the same problems it was facing two and a half centuries ago.
- stripe_away 1y agomaybe for some of the same reasons that discussion of computer science likes to quote Knuth? or big-O notation? The political theories/philosophies developed by the founding fathers remain foundational for reasons.
- yongjik 1y agoFirst mover disadvantage. The US was among the pioneers of modern democratic system, and arguably the most successful one, which paradoxically trapped its descendants into thinking there must have been something magical about how it was initially set up and it should never get updated. Many other latecomer nations didn't enjoy that kind of success - in fact many of them started with their first few presidents being brutal dictators, so they're under no illusion that their own "founding fathers" were infallible angels.