4 ms·
First, I've reread both your and my posts and I have absolutely no earthly idea how you decided _I_ was the one with the condescending tone. Second, you've cre
by lbrandy 18y ago
First, I've reread both your and my posts and I have absolutely no earthly idea how you decided _I_ was the one with the condescending tone.
Second, you've created a "counter-point" which doesn't even prove what you claim. You think your Microsoft example is "proof" of something and you are indignantly stamping your feet around making demands of others on some self-appointed perch of the intellectual high ground. Companies, markets, and economics are gigantically complicated things and trying to "prove" that H1B employees don't make better or worse companies by using a single example over some non-trivial period of time is ridiculous. Completely ridiculous. Absurd, even.
Maybe the reason none of us are citing examples is because examples are altogether meaningless. Unless you want to actually do the statistical analysis, control for all the proper variables, and try to make a statistically significant statement at the end, all you'd be doing is talking out of your ass. So, to that end, for the purposes of internet discussion between anonymous people, -theory- is about as good as we are going to do.
So excuse me for trying to correct your theoretical mistake while altogether ignoring your anecdotal evidence.
- timr 18y ago"Unless you want to actually do the statistical analysis, control for all the proper variables, and try to make a statistically significant statement at the end, all you'd be doing is talking out of your ass." I've never claimed a proof -- just a counter-example. But more importantly, I stop trying to have civilized discussions with people when they can't summon the maturity to avoid profanity.
- kragen 18y agoIn my book, saying things that make sense counts more than not saying "ass".
- gravitycop 18y ago>>> Somewhere along the lines you got really confused >> It's possible to state your opinion without >> questioning the competence of the person with >> the opposing view. > I've reread both your and my posts and I have > absolutely no earthly idea how you decided _I_ > was the one with the condescending tone. You violated the HN guidelines: http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html http://ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names.