8 ms·
>It’s a heads we win, tails you lose strategy. That’s the brilliance... Amazon wins so long as you consume media content from Amazon, no matter if you play it o
by notatoad 14y ago
>It’s a heads we win, tails you lose strategy. That’s the brilliance... Amazon wins so long as you consume media content from Amazon, no matter if you play it on a Kindle Fire or an iPad. Apple only wins if you buy an iPad.
It's amusing that Gruber can see the brilliance when amazon does it, but not when Google does it. This is exactly google's strategy with android, except that it doesn't involve users buying content. Google makes money when you use the internet. They win whether you use an iPad or a Nexus or a Kindle, Apple only wins if you buy an iPad.
- dantiberian 14y agoThe key quote from Asymco's analysis of Android's revenue: >It might be hard to see the Android section of the chart so I expanded it below at 400% the original: http://www.asymco.com/2012/05/15/android-revenues-in-perspective/ http://www.asymco.com/2012/05/15/android-revenues-in-perspec...
- majormajor 14y agoIsn't that a comparison of hardware revenues vs Google Android ad revenues? And isn't that exactly Google's play—keep the market from being dominated by a single hardware company that could cut them out from those revenues? ('Course, Amazon has forked it to do basically the same thing, in some regards, so while it might work as an anti-Apple-hegemony move, the openness may have been too much, even from a business persepective.) "Android" revenue as a whole to be compared against Apple's hardware revenues would need to include Samsung, HTC, etc. And then I'm sure Apple's margins would still be higher due to their excellent supply chain, but it's not like they aren't spending any money making all that hardware.
- 2muchcoffeeman 14y agoRemember when Apple was making 75% with only 8% market share? http://www.asymco.com/2012/02/03/first-apples-rank-in-mobile-phone-profitability-and-revenues/ http://www.asymco.com/2012/02/03/first-apples-rank-in-mobile... Linking to asymco is getting cliche ...
- cooldeal 14y agoRemember how Microsoft makes >75% of the money and "wins" in the web server market with IIS? Or the majority of profits in the server OS market with Windows Server? Didn't think so, because there's no blog roll pushing that on the blogosphere and then given traction on HN. Asymco does pretty partisan analysis which has previously been debunked earlier. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2471026 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2471026 Wasn't he and Gruber making a lot of predictions and analysis that Android would never overtake the iPhone in sales? When that did happen,iPhone on Verizon was surely going to kill Android's ascendancy. When that failed to stop Android, they moved to the next metric that favors Apple, profit share. It's like, before he writes some articles, he thinks.. okay here are some new numbers, how do I make Apple look good and Android/others look bad with these numbers? The only problem is that some people on HN give the Apple fan blogs too much traction on HN. Hell, Paul Thurrott's http://winsupersite.com http://winsupersite.com is even hellbanned on HN from being submitted for the crime of being a Microsoft watcher site for which the punishment here is flagging to death.
- guelo 14y agoApple hasn't turned on Amazon yet. As soon as they do Gruber will be the first to tell us how awful Amazon's strategy is.
- timfrietas 14y agoI think they've taken shots across the bow. Charging 30% for IAP right as they released iBooks was pretty squarely aimed at Amazon.
- mcav 14y agoApple stopped the Kindle app from linking to the amazon bookstore. That's as close to war as you can get.
- jcrites 14y agoNot really. No apps are allowed to link to places where purchases can be made for that app. The purchases need to happen within the app itself, at which point Apple gets a cut. If the app decides not to allow in-app purchases and cut Apple in, it may not link to other places where purchases can be made.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bergie 14y agoThis may be, in the end, the worst mistake that Apple is doing with their platform. What shape would for instance web shops, or the SaaS market, be in, if the only way to run one was to give 30% of your revenue to Netscape. Netscape could still be alive this way, but web would be way smaller.
- batista 14y ago>Netscape could still be alive this way, but web would be way smaller. Now, think your argument again.
- 14y ago
- insaneirish 14y agoI, and millions of others, don't think Google when I think content. I, do, however, think Amazon. This is the difference between Google and Amazon.
- Tloewald 14y agoAmazon is, like Apple, a "sell people stuff at a price they're willing to pay" company, versus a "free but we will auction slivers of your soul" company. Apple makes most of its money up front, Amazon makes most of its money... um no one is quite sure how or if Amazon makes money. Google "gives" away goods and services and makes money selling ads ... like an old fashioned TV network. Not exactly the same thing at all. Oh, and how much net profit has Android yielded Google?
- StavrosK 14y ago> Oh, and how much net profit has Android yielded Google? Probably a whole lot. When my sister, who would otherwise be in front of a computer at most half an hour a day, can get an android smartphone for 150 euros and idly browse the Web all day, Google makes a shitload of money they wouldn't have if all these people were on cheap nokias.
- eli 14y agoDon't iPhone users make just as many (probably more) Google searches as Android users? Or do you think that without Android, nobody would have put out cheap smartphones by now?
- ekianjo 14y agoProbably more? As far as I know, there are more Android devices in the market than iPhones.
- jccc 14y agoAndroid users are not using their devices the same as iOS users: http://techcrunch.com/2012/04/21/real-time-research-ios-dominates-over-android-when-it-comes-to-usage-says-chitika/ http://techcrunch.com/2012/04/21/real-time-research-ios-domi...
- eli 14y agoNo doubt, yet iPhone still generates more mobile web traffic than Android.
- ThomPete 14y agoGoogles strategy with android is to serve ads but they do not have a model to get that to work. Until they do that Android is not a win.
- notatoad 14y agoGoogle doesn't have a strategy to serve ads on android? sure they do, it's called a web browser. Google has the largest ad network on the internet, and just about every time you view a webpage google gets a cut of it. It doesn't matter whether you use an android device or an iOS device or a windows computer or a potato, google makes money. if google can encourage people to use the internet more by selling smartphones, they win. The point of android is not to cannibalize iOS market share, it's to eliminate the dumbphone. They don't want anybody to ever be without internet.
- ThomPete 14y agoThat's not a strategy for mobile. If what you said where true more of their revenue would come from mobile. It doesn't, look it up.
- trimbo 14y agoAndroid is winning for Google in a massive way once you understand their goal. Google's Android and even Chrome strategies are that _no one_ should win at the OS/platform level. They never want another Windows, or Mac, or IE, or anything that prevents them from leveraging the open web because it's fronted with proprietary code that can block them. The best way to win at that game is to either force the market to adopt the system they can manage ("with Google" approved Android phones and the market) or make the web the only worthwhile source of truth among a hodge-podge of OSes that try to bolt on proprietary components. Even the major commercial forks of Android have not yet proved to derail this from succeeding.
- rimantas 14y ago> that try to bolt on proprietary components I will always prefer something that has no ads bolted on.
- hboon 14y agoAmazon makes money from selling digital and physical media content as well as physical goods. Google makes money primarily from search-based advertising — YouTube which is digital content is around the order of 1B revenue whereas total revenue is in the range of 30B. Amazon makes money whenever you buy their content. Google not so much. When you have a strong platform player that have decisive power over how they locate information — in the case of Apple, (1) control over the default search engine in Mobile Safari, (2) control over what web browsers are approved for their App store (3) has their own maps app backed by their own services and partners, which doesn't include Google (4) demonstrated capability and intent to build alternate ways to access information such as Siri (5) demonstrated animosity — I'd say Google doesn't feel like they win if you buy an iPad. So correction, it should be "Google makes money when you use their services".
- Johngibb 14y agoThe difference is with Amazon you're the customer, and the device and content are the products. With android, _you_ are the product and the advertisers are the customers. This distinction means that Apple/Amazon's interests are more aligned with consumers than Google's.
- option_greek 14y ago"This distinction means that Apple/Amazon's interests are more aligned with consumers than Google's." Not necessarily. It simply means they have more incentive tying you down to their 'product' and stifle any competition. Google on the other hand couldn't care less about what device you use as long as you use their services.
- chii 14y agoso instead of tying you down to the device, they tie you down to their services. In my eyes, thats not too different. At least with a physical device, you may be able to subvert any ill intentions.
- 14y ago
- blinkingled 14y agoTalking about amusements - another one is that Android activations are still "activations" for Gruber, long after Jobs and co doubted if Google is truthful with their number. Gruber definitely gets his % numbers wrong though - half percent instead of 5% :)
- schraeds 14y agoGoogle makes more money off iOS users/devices than Android devices, in addition to all the cap ex goog has dropped on the effort.
- batista 14y ago>This is exactly google's strategy with android, except that it doesn't involve users buying content. Google makes money when you use the internet. They win whether you use an iPad or a Nexus or a Kindle, Apple only wins if you buy an iPad. Well, it's not the same at all. For one, Google wins a minuscule amount of money if you use the internet. Amazon probably makes more off selling 1 (ONE) Kindle book than Google makes from you using their search engine all year around on their tablet. Second, noone buys those other tablets (apart from iPad/Kindle). The numbers are 1/10 the iPad numbers and less. Third, Google doesn't even win when people use Kindle Fire, despite it being Android. IIRC, Amazon switched the search engine to Bing. >Google makes money when you use the internet. They win whether you use an iPad or a Nexus or a Kindle, Apple only wins if you buy an iPad. And how does that work for Google vs Apple revenue/profits so far?
- grogglesbegone 14y agoThe iPad to alternate tablet market is more like 6:4, at worst 7:3, pre-Nexus 7. 1/10th or less is utter nonsense. Google is a $220 billion dollar company with great earnings based upon people "using the internet". Your comment on Google not winning with the Fire makes the assumption that Google only wins if you use their search engine. Not really.