48 ms·
Anduril's product engineering machine
- conorh 1y agoIt is a very interesting article, but I'm a little horrified at the amount of effort going into military projects to kill more efficiently.
- Animats 1y ago"You may not be interested in war, but war is interested in you."
- fooblaster 1y ago[flagged]
- ares623 1y agoOr coming soon to a “protest” near you
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- XorNot 1y agoYeah you might want to take a look at what's happening in Europe then. Because your options are "have an effective conventional military force, ideally enough to deter an invasion" and "have nuclear weapons and threaten Armageddon at the smallest of provocations" (which was correctly identified as impractical during the Cold War: would the US trade the Eastern Seaboard to protect Berlin? Fairly obviously no...)
- theyinwhy 1y agoEurope has nuclear arsenal so I really don't get your point.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- spookie 1y agoHumans never learn, there will always be some crazy moron controlling some country.
- TiredOfLife 1y agoTell that to russia
- rramadass 1y agoOh Man; You need to shake off your naivete asap! Our entire Social/Economic/Psychological value system has been completely remade to value only Money and Power. Humanity/Ethics/Morals/Community/Individuals are only useful in so far as they sustain the system in pursuit of the above objectives else they are all just a hindrance and must be manipulated/overlooked/removed. Our very mastery of Science and its consequent Technology has enabled the exercise of all "our" (i.e. Individuals/Groups/Corporations/Governments/etc.) powers in service of Money/Power to a degree unimaginable before the Scientific Revolution. Nothing matters but only the sustaining of "The System" which has taken a life of its own independent of the Humans (and other life forms) who inhabit it. To explain using pop-culture references, you are mere disposable "Soylent Green" in "The Matrix" all of which are embedded in omniscient "The System". References: 1) Notes on Nationalism by George Orwell - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notes_on_Nationalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Notes_on_Nationalism 2) Brainwashing: The Science of Thought Control by Kathleen Taylor - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brainwashing:_The_Science_of_Thought_Control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brainwashing:_The_Science_of_T... 3) Reflexive Control - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflexive_control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reflexive_control 4) Propaganda: The Formation of Men's Attitudes by Jacques Ellul - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda:_The_Formation_of_Men%27s_Attitudes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda:_The_Formation_of_M... 5) The Technological Society by Jacques Ellul - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Technological_Society https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Technological_Society
- edfletcher_t137 1y ago"Amusement Park" has to be one of the worst headline choices here. So these people are amused by building killing machines? They are amused that their work is directly related to death & destruction? They are monsters if so.
- thomascountz 1y agoI actually thought it was an excellent title! But then I read the article and realized there was no irony in it.
- GaggiX 1y agoWhat's the acceptable state of mood that you are allow to be in when building killing machines?
- maest 1y agoDour.
- walthamstow 1y agoListen to a Joy Division record
- userbinator 1y agoAngry.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jijijijij 1y agoI hoped someone had hijacked that name for an actual "amusement park for engineers", coincidentally hitting all the right key words, but in terms of trademark protections occupying a completely unrelated commercial domain. Would be really, really funny if Anduril (not the amusement park) sales and marketing folks would have to append "not the amusement park", when speaking about Anduril (not the amusement park).
- Aurornis 1y agoWhat’s the latest about Anduril’s work environment? They’ve been pushing vibes-heavy approaches to recruiting like making videos sneering at remote work and highlighting how quirky Palmer is, but the last I heard it wasn’t a great place to work. When I start seeing PR puff piece journalism about a workplace to make it seem extra fun, they’re usually compensating for something (low pay, long hours, bad work environment) in my experience.
- laidoffamazon 1y agoI think Anduril's mission is great but I'd never work for a man who directly funded fascism in my own country. Would be cool if there was a more woke defense contractor that wasn't captured by institutional rot like Raytheon and Lockheed
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mingus88 1y agoIt’s important to know that Andruil is culturally very similar to Palantir and is run by many ex-Palantir folk. My experience with the latter is very outdated but assuming Andruil is at a similar phase of growth as Palantir was a decade ago, you pretty much nailed it Someone correct me if I’m wrong: Underpaid compensation, with a justification that they are only hiring people who are “mission driven”. Heavily military based culture with a “need to know” approach to projects and overreliance on acronyms to align thought. Perks are golden age startup perks with full meal service, massages, fitness classes, laundry because of you are looking for a 9-5 then this is not the job for you
- crinkly 1y agoSounds like when I worked for a defence contractor in the 90s. Felt owned from the moment I woke up until I fell asleep. Didn’t feel human. Just woke up one day and thought fuck it and never went back in. Took 6 months off, went on holiday, slept on my parents sofa and eventually got a shit job wrangling C. Best job ever that was. Better money, unlimited decent coffee, 9-5 hours, a window, a phone on my desk and my own SPARCstation 20.
- sleazebreeze 1y agoAnduril employees think they're Tony Stark, but they're just cranking out cheap shit that kills people. America's enemies or whatever. The employees seem to be laboring under the idea they're a family and the author sure seems to think so, but the 10% desired attrition rate and the weeks without sleep is really just an indicator they're expendable resources. They don't love you like that, man.
- terminalshort 1y agoIf the Ukraine war teaches us anything, cranking out large amounts of cheap shit that kills people is incredibly important.
- bigyabai 1y agoIf the Chinese trade war taught us anything, cranking out large amounts of cheap shit is something America cannot even threaten to do.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- galacticaactual 1y agoIronic that everyone talking shit about "building killing machines" probably also has Ukraine flags next to their PFPs. How you think Ukraine fighting their war right now fam - with sticks and bottle rockets?
- kg 1y agoSome people really sincerely do believe in pacifism. That doesn't seem misaligned with 'the victim of an immoral war should win'. One can also believe multiple things at the same time, like: * Waging war is immoral * If someone wages war on you, it's acceptable to defend yourself instead of allow them to kill you * Enabling war for personal profit (by selling weapons) is immoral * Making weapons for self-defense is acceptable i.e. during WW2, many countries repurposed existing industry in order to build all the weapons that were needed to win the war. That's a very different thing from spinning up a new startup with the stated goal of making weapons to sell for money. You can personally think it's okay but it seems totally reasonable to me that someone would believe "weapons should not be manufactured for personal profit the way we manufacture toys or food".
- galacticaactual 1y agoCool. How should they be manufactured? You know. For the self defense in the immoral war you mention.
- dotnet00 1y agoTry reading the last bit
- galacticaactual 1y agoSo you want a bombed out shell of a country to repurpose a destroyed industrial base and ramp up manufacturing for a technology it has no history of producing. Very logical.
- 1y ago
- ohdeargodno 1y agoThe amount of variants of "I missed <X> important event of my life to build a drone made to [kill people|break shit|arrest small time drug dealers]" in that article makes me think of complete fucking insanity instead of amusement park, but sure. Skipping your paternity leave to release a shitty SaaS for a startup is already dumb shit, but doing so for the US military is some sociopathic behavior. Also, for all their jerking off: congrats, you reinvented Skunkworks. Inevitably, in a few years, Anduril will be captured by political interests greater than them, and will become the same kind of crap company that Lockheed Martin is. And the world will be better off knowing there's fewer people making things to bomb brown people. (And before any "uuuh but what about ukraiiine" response: the US will. never. be. attacked. Its conventional force is plenty enough to threaten any adversary. You can relax, the Chinese aren't coming to conquer Alaska, put down the power armor)
- delta_p_delta_x 1y ago> the US will. never. be. attacked. Its conventional force is plenty enough to threaten any adversary. That's what the Romans, the Spanish, the Portuguese, and the British said. There's no need to attack an 'empire' that implodes from within.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bsaul 1y agothe us have already been attacked. Terrorists don't care about conventional forces.
- ohdeargodno 1y agoThank you for providing even more proof that a conventional army will never attack the United States. But hey, if you think the next Bin Laden is going to smuggle Shaheds in the country, and that the solution is to militarize every single city, have fun.
- 650REDHAIR 1y agoAn amusement park that kills people. That doesn’t seem super fun to me.
- ks2048 1y agoMore importantly to the plan than killing people - is running away with billions in tax dollars.
- etjeyjeyjeyjrky 1y ago[flagged]
- ramraj07 1y agoOne would think you'd need to be a citizen to work on defense stuff
- Yossarrian22 1y ago>On a Saturday afternoon in April 2024, I was on the rooftop pool deck of a Marriott hotel, setting up radar equipment aimed above the Hollywood Hills in Burbank, California. My five-year-old son, still damp from swimming, darted around as I calibrated the system. This has to be an FCC violation of some sort.
- fooker 1y agoNo, FCC doesn't care much about what you do with radar.
- jonplackett 1y ago> I spent my paternity leave developing a 3D radar system This just makes me so, so sad. This person no matter what they may or may not achieve has all their priorities upside down.
- ramesh31 1y ago[flagged]
- john-h-k 1y ago> A 3D radar system intended to better facilitate the more efficient vaporization of third world orphans, too, no less. This feels like something I’d read on twitter, not HN. Literally zero substance, just designed to be as controversial sounding as possible
- bigyabai 1y agoNobody builds a classified synthetic aperture radar for the public good.
- XorNot 1y agoBecause everyone knows the best way to run a military is to ensure at all times your adversaries are fully informed of the full scope and capability of all your systems. /s
- GuinansEyebrows 1y agoIt’s true. Ghoulish work.
- RealityVoid 1y agoAre those orphans flying in a drone by any chance?
- renewiltord 1y agoThe first three months of childcare are practically memoryless for the child. Provided they are cared for, you're not usually going to do any damage to their lives. An absent father during that period will be irrelevant so long as the child is fed, clothed, and kept comfortable. It's more about mechanical things. It's pretty reasonable choice.
- yahoozoo 1y agoThe author seems to be really happy helping Israel commit genocide.
- howdyhowdy123 1y agoThis sounds like such a sad and awful place. Some brilliant yet naive young people are being taken advantage of. (source: I was just like that at that age)
- tho2i334324 1y ago> Palmer and his team had already recognized the need for better defense technology to deter a greaey't power conflict and to maintain American hegemony. I wonder if religious "saints" (nearly all of them were terror-mongering scum) of old had such confidence. Funnily, you'll even find "post-religious" liberals and Protestants defending their supposed enemies if they were killing/raping and plundering the "heathens" (forget Xtian-saints, they'll defend Islamic rampages and skull-mountain-building exercises the likes of which would have made both Genghis & Mohammed proud.) "St. Xavier had already recognized on the need to start a inquisition against the heathens of Goa to maintain the hegemony of Christ so that the evil heathendom could not flourish any more in the piece of land Christ had promised." Oh yes, we're so proud running 1000x foreign bases and dropping bombs on innocent civilians around the world for "freedom" - we definitely need to preserve our "hegemony". Serious question - are Americans really this stupid ? I can remember 5-6 wars in the past 2 decades that all turned out to be regime-change ops because they wouldn't play ball to US diktats. Atleast British colonization of the world was honest (and those that were colonized were British subjects), without all this 3-d chess propaganda non-sense.
- renewiltord 1y agoStupid, perhaps. But the idiots have brought us Pax Americana - an unprecedented peace across the world, with technological innovation never seen before, and America has been a river to humanity: through research, development, and open market access to the world. Ideally there are no hegemons and we live in a multipolar peace, but if there must be hegemonies then you can't do much better than this.
- rf15 1y agoBut there isn't peace across the world? At all? Stop spitting Cool-Aid everywhere
- renewiltord 1y agoYes, the much desired weakening of America is having its effect. With the US no longer able to enforce, and actions like Operation Prosperity Guardian failing you have what you desire: the end of hegemony. Let's see now if you like it.
- renewiltord 1y agoThe point of war is to make the other dumb bastard die for his country. I think everything we make to kill should kill efficiently and well. Then we can choose not use the device. But whichever arm it is that is meant to do the job should do the job well. Then the civilian government arm can choose to not fight a war or engage in whatever. Good for them. Sounds like a hell of an experience riding that train as employee #20. Haha, at $250 m one would have thought a lot of the growth was baked in. But it 100x from there. Very nice.
- davedx 1y ago> That makeshift tower, which we built on our own dime to prove what was possible, helped intercept nearly 1,000 pounds of marijuana and led to dozens of drug trafficking arrests—ultimately earning us a pilot program with Customs and Border Protection Wow such high impact work. Surely making the world a more better place than those Silicon Valley leftists
- torginus 1y agoI can draw only 2 conclusions from this story: - Anduril is overstating the effectiveness of their cheap and cheerful elbow grease solutions, and for example, you can't replicate the functionality of a Mach-whatever interceptor like the Patriot to shoot down a cruise missile with a cheap and slow drone that just tries to 'stand in its path' - Anduril is replicating the cambrian explosion of combat systems (drones, jammers, whatnot), we've seen in the Russian/Ukraine war. These are made out of largely commercial components, or stuff that can be built in any well-equipped machine shops and commercially available components, and a country of . Both can be true at the same time, but especially the latter should be concerning to the defense industries and militaries of the world. It means, that if systems build out of commercial components for hundreds to tens of thousands of dollars can either replicate or counter a large chunk of million to billion dollar systems, then that means that, huge parts of the defense expenditure conferred no advantage. Considering we saw columns of both Russian and Western tanks blown up, each worth millions, this I'm confident is true. The other thing is that this means the US has lost its technological edge when fighting even third-tier militaries who decide to procure and manufacture these system. I'm sure after the war, the expertise to build these will be readily available on the market, and the components (both used by Anduril and these smalls shops) are nothing special.
- terminalshort 1y ago> you can't replicate the functionality of a Mach-whatever interceptor like the Patriot to shoot down a cruise missile with a cheap and slow drone that just tries to 'stand in its path' But they weren't trying to shoot down cruise missiles. They were shooting down drones.
- torginus 1y agoFrom the article: Consider the challenge of defending vast territories against cruise missiles. Conventional systems, like Patriot PAC-3 and NASAMS batteries, typically cost millions of dollars per installation. So we asked ourselves a simple question: What if we could create a forcefield of low-cost drones to intercept cruise missiles worth millions? The concept seemed absurd at first, even to our team—the overmatch appeared too extreme. But we stripped the problem again to its fundamentals. Cruise missiles are fast, but they follow predictable flight paths. If we could accurately determine that flight path using two ground-based IR passive sensors (what we called Wide-Area Infrared System for Persistent Surveillance, or WISPs), we wouldn’t need expensive targeting systems on the interceptor itself. We modified our Anvil drone to carry no sensors at all—the drone would simply position itself in the projected path of the incoming missile, aligning with where the missile would pierce our virtual “force field.” Despite the initial skepticism, we demonstrated the concept successfully, destroying a target that could fly an order of magnitude faster than our interceptor.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- nikolay 1y agoWith all due respect, those who monitor the war in Ukraine will tell you that Anduril is overengineered and expensive. New Russian drones, produced in the thousands every day, are kits, assembled in minutes on the battlefield. Nothing fancy, crappy looks, nothing exciting, but it works and it's cheap and it manufacturing can be ramped up in no time. Not to mention that Russian innovate on the battlefield, everybody tries different modifications, and what works is communicated back. Also, commercially, there are tens and tens of private and government companies working on drones in Russia - one company can't do better than many in a competitive environment. So, unless there are 10-20 Andurils competing on speed of innovation, costs, materials, simplicity, and manufacturing speed, this is no match.
- deburo 1y agoWhy are you comparing Anduril against Russia's drones? Shouldn't you use Ukraine, surely it has access to higher tech than Russia and is just as battletested? Or does Russia use Chinese tech?
- daemoens 1y agoRussia has the strategic depth to mass manufacture specialty drones in a way that Ukraine cannot. Even though Ukraine used fiber optic drones first, the Russians were the first to produce them in large numbers and it took Ukraine months to catch up. Lancet/Shahed drones are even bigger examples of this.
- amunicio 1y agoShahed where originally designed and manufactured by Iran. Russians initially bought and licensed them. And I assume are now improving upon the original design. Russian is top down innovation with a thick layer of corruption. No matter how much you want to claim strategic depth, they are always several steps behind Ukrainians. No matter how many advantages due to size they have. Sorry you picked the wrong team.
- 1y ago
- mindcrash 1y ago"The Amusement Park for Engineers" A company which needs you to build things to kill anyone and everyone with AI. BIG FUN! /s But maybe I am the only one who thinks this is just SICK.
- biosboiii 1y agoWhat is a cocaine-fueled "amusement park" to Silicon Valley techbros is another humans hell. I look forward to you guys joining it. >I no longer love blue skies. In fact, I now prefer grey skies. The drones do not fly when the skies are grey. >When the skies brighten, though, the drones return, and so too does the fear. Zubair, 13 yrs old https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/2013/10/saddest-words-congresss-briefing-drone-strikes/354548/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/2013/10/saddest-words-c...
- didntknowyou 1y agoanduril paying for PR puff pieces and public billboards on the london underground prob means they're going to IPO soon. would also explain the recent war hawks and fear mongering to drive up defense stock prices.
- Peter4455 1y agoIs Anduril developing any products to protect schools? Perhaps R2D2-like sentinels?