8 ms·
With AI Boom, Dell's Datacenter Biz Is Finally Bigger Than Its PC Biz
- s3p 1y agoWas the word 'biz' used for a character limit?
- bgwalter 1y agoThe paperclip maximizer story, where an AGI directs all economic resources towards manufacturing paperclips, was wrong. We have the the graphics card maximizers, where humans voluntarily redirect vast economic resources towards generating a maximal stream of tokens that hardly anyone wants. Or perhaps call them token maximizers. There used to be the notion that "talk is cheap". Now we are spending $trillions on generating idle talk.
- ksec 1y ago> that hardly anyone wants. People continues to mis-weight the benefits of AGI / LLM or in the case "graphics card maximizers". It is precisely because of this, we can continue to extend semi-conductor improvements for at least another 5 years, brings in 1200W CPU in server and liquid cooling along with new DC and Rack design 5 years earlier. Partly continues to fund Gaming GPU where the industry itself were not able to sustain it. New improvement to Networking Gear due to heavy use of LLM. HBM profits that drives current EUV DRAM innovations. As far as I can tell, I see very little down size to all these investments where Big Tech would have spent those money on stock buy backs or dividends. And this is assuming AGI really is a bubble and brings little to no productivity, and exclude all the improvements that is adjacent to it.
- gizajob 1y agoI always found this a bit of an omission in Bostrom’s argument in Superintelligence - on one hand he’d say we should avoid giving AI a goal like paperclip maximisation while overlooking that the method of transistor maximisation used to attempt to build the Superintelligence was the same kind of goal. Same goes for whatever system he fantastically proposed to run his fanciful “mind uploading” Cartesian scenario.
- dwood_dev 1y agoThe difference is the demand for paperclips is already met. Each additional paperclip is almost pure waste of resources. The demand for silicon, even outside AI is not, and advances in silicon are going to benefit pretty much every industry in the long run, even if during the short term they are distorted by the AI demand.
- gizajob 1y agoWell we have 8 billion non-artificial general intelligences walking around on earth yet we’re dedicating enormous resources trying to electronically replace them. This is in the name of tech companies stealing value rather than spreading it out more evenly.
- antisthenes 1y ago> Now we are spending $trillions on generating idle talk. We were spending $trillions on generating idle talk before AI as well. It was just done by meatbags.
- bee_rider 1y agoThe first artificial intelligence was the market. Just like the rest, it produces some wonderful tools, but putting it in charge of everything is a sure path to some kind of paperclip optimizer.
- _2d30 1y ago> ...that hardly anyone wants. Meanwhile, in reality, ChatGPT is the fastest growing consumer product ever and LLM provider revenues are like superexponential.
- no_wizard 1y agoThreads broke the record within 5 days of launching, surpassing ChatGPT adoption, has less pressure from competitors, and Threads very likely makes money for Meta. On the other hand, OpenAI’s ChatGPT has more intense pressure from competitors, isn’t making any money, and costs are still rising for its operation. I don’t know where you’re getting the idea that it’s the “fastest growing consumer product ever” and “revenues are like super exponential” as it’s demonstrated repeatedly that OpenAI has yet to turn a profit or even meaningfully dent their burn rate
- _2d30 1y agoThreads did grow very fast at launch as Meta leveraged IG to supercharge growth but has fewer DAU than ChatGPT does today so it does seem a bit odd to suggest Threads is growing faster than ChatGPT or even has. In fairness to your point, "fastest growing consumer product ever" isn't well defined per se. If a consumer product gets 1 sign up and then 1e-32 seconds later it gets a second, maybe THAT'S the "fastest growing ever". > On the other hand, OpenAI’s ChatGPT has more intense pressure from competitors, isn’t making any money, and costs are still rising for its operation. This isn't the first time someone has suggested that the social media space is low competition but I always think it's completely incorrect. Threads competes with IG, FB, WA, Snap, TikTok, Bluesky, X and many more. All are well funded and most have comparable or greater DAU. In terms of making money, Threads only recently began to show ads at all. During this time, Threads has also been cannibalizing IG engagement. It's quite UNLIKELY that IG is making very much money and even less likely that on the whole has been a positive revenue tailwind for Meta even with the actual revenue they are starting to book. Meanwhile ChatGPT, which apparently isn't making any money, has a revenue run rate of ~$12B. > I don’t know where you’re getting the idea that it’s the “fastest growing consumer product ever” and “revenues are like super exponential” as it’s demonstrated repeatedly that OpenAI has yet to turn a profit or even meaningfully dent their burn rate Revenue != profit. Their revenue is growing unbelievably fast. Their user base has and is still growing extremely fast. Current revenue run rate ~$12B which is >3X 2024 total revenue. That is enormously fast especially at that already sizeable ~$4B base! That their losses are so large is in large part a choice as they provide a huge amount of inference for free today. The same argument you're making about losses is the same tired one people made about FB, Uber, Amazon and plenty of other high growth companies all of which are highly profitable today. Anyone sitting around arguing that LLMs are a low-demand product that "hardly anyone wants" is one or more of an idiot, willfully ignorant, highly misinformed by a trusted source or actively spreading bollocks.
- pclmulqdq 1y agoI'm still not sure why anyone would buy a dell server. Supposedly xAI buys from them, which probably accounts for this, but it is generally a much more sensible choice to buy from companies that are lower-cost and less focused on selling you "enterprise support" (supermicro et al).
- throwaway48476 1y agoProbably iDrac. AI servers are mostly just white boxed nvidia reference designs. Not much markup.
- bluedino 1y agoHPE is finally moving away from their 'Cray' systems which are just whitebox AMI systems. You get none of their iLO etc even though they are 'HPE'
- alephnerd 1y ago> buy from companies that are lower-cost and less focused on selling you "enterprise support" (supermicro et al). From past experience, vendors like SuperMicro aren't much cheaper at scale because Dell can give 80% discounts on volume, and most Dell server sales are done via Channel with an MSP who will manage and administer the system. Ofc, this continues to reinforce my belief that the "AI boom" in it's current form (and once you remove the scooby doo monster mask) is basically a "Datacenter/Telecom Bubble" 2.0 like back in 2000-01. The multiples, messaging, vendors, and margins are almost the exact same. During the Dot-com Boom, Telecom and hardware companies were also expanding DC and telecom capacity massively (to surf and host a website on the Internet, you kinda need Internet and web hosting), and when the Dotbomb happened, the Telco bubble collapsed subsequently as well (remember WorldCom/MCI?) That's why the 2000s were horrible for anyone with a CS/CE/CSE/EE degree, because both software AND hardware industries collapsed. Imagine a world in the late 2020s where you cannot land a job as a Fullstack Engineer OR an ML Infra Engineer - that was the 2000s except with older stacks. That's also why I'd be optimistic if a bust happens - the overcapacity in compute that arose from the Telecom and Dot-Com Busts both helped usher the Cloud, SaaS, E-Commerce, and Social Media boom because the infra has been laid and became cost effective. It is also in this context that Paul G's "cockroach" and "ramen profitability" essay came to the fore.
- xnx 1y agoAlternate title: Dell's PC business keeps shrinking.
- alephnerd 1y agoFrom TFA: "Don’t blame the PC business. Dell’s Client Solutions Group had $12.5 billion in sales in Q2 F2026, up seven-tenths of a point, but net income was up 4.7 percent to $803 million, representing 6.4 percent of revenues and marking the highest level seen in the past seven quarters"
- Mistletoe 1y agoHow long do you think we have before the AI Bust? This isn’t a rhetorical question, I’m looking for estimates before I have to exit all financial markets and go full defensive in my portfolio. Can it make to 2026? Or will the bust be several years from now? I know no one really knows, but estimates can be very helpful. Sometimes you can feel the wind change.
- alephnerd 1y agoThe kind of person who can time market crashes is not the kind of person who comments on HN on a Wednesday morning. Market booms and crashes come and go - such is life.
- Mistletoe 1y agoBut HN is the kind of place where someone notices that less gpu orders are coming in or that Donna from HR said the CEO said X or “we can’t get anyone to listen to our AI pitch deck”.
- alephnerd 1y agoNot anymore sadly. Most YC founders have been using BookFace for years now, and the most decisionmakers in the space have our own personal GCs or in-person meetups. Also, take into account what time it is in the Bay Area - it's only 7.30am, and this post and most commenters before this point will have likely been in the East Coast or Western Europe. HN's signal to noise ratio has dropped significantly over the past few years. Heck even I only use HN because of social media addiction the same way a chain smoker will smoke a cig due to oral fixation.
- simianwords 1y agoShare your thoughts if you are a decision maker or have any insider knowledge? What do you think about the bubble?
- iamacyborg 1y ago
- AtlasBarfed 1y agoI'm hoping we get some good competition for AWS that comes out of this. This is probably the largest data center build out push in a long time. It would behoove a lot of these companies. There again say $13 billion series f to make an AWS competition stack. I mean you have all the infrastructure to magically write the code for you right?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- xp84 1y agoI'm skeptical, it's not like the competitive offerings we already have don't bring anything to the table. If anything, GCP is a lot more pleasant to use. Yet AWS still maintains its dominance, imho out of inertia. No org wants to make "Migrate to [Other Cloud]" its main project for the year for some small savings or "because we've heard great things about it." The opportunity cost is too high. And new firms who spin up go with the cloud the founding engineers know (have used before) because they want to ship asap, not to learn another cloud provider. So I predict AWS continues on like this for decades.
- varelse 1y ago[dead]
- ivanjermakov 1y agoFinally or unfortunately? We (customers, hackers) get further and further from owning hardware and running software on our terms.
- RajT88 1y agoIn a few years when all these rack servers are outdated for AI workloads, there will be a glut in the market of cheap only-slightly-dated servers. My JellyFin setup in 5 years is going to be fucking awesome.
- ivanjermakov 1y agoSame, after getting into homelabbing, "post-lease" became my favorite word.
- rbanffy 1y agoWhen this bubble bursts, we'll have a lot of number crunching capability being sold for peanuts.
- bee_rider 1y agoUsing these tiny floats for classic engineering workloads—if I were starting gradschool right now, that’s definitely what I’d look at. Mixed precision numerical algorithms are already a topic, but with the hardware glut there’ll definitely be room to push things. So it’s in a nice spot where there’s some scaffolding, but it isn’t totally done, and the hardware is probably going to make things possible.
- rbanffy 1y ago> Using these tiny floats for classic engineering workloads I think that's the idea. Back in the stone age, I did that with Apple II floats (40-bits) because I was hitting quantization problems in a Mandelbrot explorer program I wrote. Wrapping my head around it in BASIC was hard. You can only go so far when your abstraction level is that low.
- jakedata 1y agoMy company sells them all. Dell, Lenovo, Supermicro, HP (if you insist). I can have anything I want and pretty much for free. Internally we are 90% Dell, our remote employees all have laptops with ProSupport and on-site service because the price is lower than a single day of downtime. They have the infrastructure and logistics to fix anything nearly anywhere. No qualms about recommending them for anything.
- yftsui 1y agoInfrastructure Solutions Group - is that Dell or the acquired EMC?