5 ms·
The cost of transparency: Living with schizoaffective disorder in tech
- rini17 1y agoSigh. I too would like to know an employer that can accomodate unpredictable performance or a partner willing to do emotional labor.
- carlosjobim 1y agoAs for unpredictable performance, employers never want to have that. But it is possible if you have your own business or consultancy. Or if you work with art and creativity, where it is the norm to have ups and downs.
- rini17 1y agoIdk artists I know have to work hard whenever there's some opportunity, regardless of whether they are up or down at the moment.
- carlosjobim 1y agoI don't think it's about working hard or not, it's about predictable performance. Artists work harder than most people when they are active, but also have hiatuses. It's completely expected for artists to have break periods.
- runjake 1y agoPerhaps one option: work at a non-profit whose mission deals with your disorder. They probably understand it more than most disorders and likely have some level of skills to cope with it and it makes them look good employing them.
- bethekidyouwant 1y ago[flagged]
- zero_shift 1y ago> What do you want the healthcare professionals to do? It is scary, but, when you work in adult mental health, that is something you sign up for. Ideally it would be paid better.
- Spooky23 1y agoAlso, there’s usually more than one side of the story. I work for an organization that is supportive of employees. I managed someone with this diagnosis, who was a fabulous colleague for several years. Then stuff happened. We ended up in a situation where there were significant personal safety concerns. That’s not the situation here, but without the framework of support for both the employee and the people around them, these situations become untenable.
- stewartbracken 1y agoI agree, I would not willingly suffer certain behaviors of coworkers with severe mental disorders. However, most of the time people with severe mental health disorders are not a danger to others, unlike what pop culture tells us. It’s only ‘terrifying’ because of general lack of understanding and empathy which is what the post is about. We are capable of emotional regulation— jumping straight to ‘terrified’ and fear serves no one, including us, and shuts us off from a potentially great coworker (John Nash, anyone??) or community member.
- arp242 1y ago> Im certain this guy is terrifying when he’s having an episode Why are you "certain" of this? Whatever else can be said about all of this, this seems little more than stereotypical fear-mongering, and is exactly the sort of discrimination the post talks about.
- bethekidyouwant 1y agoRe-reading my post I would like to clarify, I am not assuming anything physical about the author. he’s clearly hyper intelligent and I meant only psychologically terrifying.
- zemvpferreira 1y ago"Schizoaffective disorder is a mental health condition that is marked by a mix of schizophrenia symptoms, such as hallucinations and delusions, and mood disorder symptoms, such as depression, mania and a milder form of mania called hypomania. Hallucinations involve seeing things or hearing voices that others don't observe. Delusions involve believing things that are not real or not true." I'm not sure this is an employable condition unfortunately. As progressive as anyone wants to be, I can see the disruption an illness like this causes not being tenable. Businesses are competitive entities, not machines for inclusion. My heart goes out to OP but I don't think I'd want him on my team either.
- kamranjon 1y agoI would hope that there would be some possibility for folks like this to utilize platforms like Patreon or GitHub sponsorships to help pay their bills - they are obviously motivated and productive coders and also talented writers. In my experience there is sort of a discrepancy often times. Someone discloses a severe mental health diagnosis and the company just goes on pretending they are just like every other employee - making no changes to accommodate them. On the flip side, employees with severe mental health disorders often want to be treated exactly the same as other employees - so it seems a bit of an un-winnable situation.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- zdragnar 1y agoIt is a condition that is employable in the abstract, as symptoms are as varied as individuals are. The difficulty begins with the treatment- the medications can be extremely unpleasant, and it is not uncommon for patients to cease taking them. Unfortunately, people with the condition can be unreliable narrators, so to speak, and so any deviation from perfectly normal becomes suspicion of medication refusal, as the author noted in the article. Even when they are perfectly honest and accurate, just having a rough day will mean being met with distrust at best. The thing that struck me as odd in the article is the repetition of fear as a reaction in others. There's not enough information to understand if this is accurate or not. One of my friends growing up had a cleft lip; his low self image had him constantly assuming the worst in others despite it (from my observations) contributing far less to people's reactions than he'd imagined. So, we are left wondering: is the author of the post a reliable narrator, or are their symptoms coloring their perception of the interactions with others in a way that they are misjudging?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- 34nabxgyF 1y agoRegarding the Python Documentary, that is just the old boys boosting their personal brands and valuations again. If you aren't part of that club, you are nothing in the Python world. It does not matter what you have done, whether you just maintained an email module throughout Python-3 or had your broken code fixed and completely rewritten by people who came later: The only thing that matters is that you have been there before around 2000-2005.
- inanutshellus 1y agoOk so I was writing python professionally in this time period and ... if I were making a python documentary I'd expect it to honor folks that were active back this far much to the exclusion of late comers. I presume you were one of those? Back then the language felt like a quiet little also-ran behind Perl and we looked with jealous eyes as Ruby On Rails took over the mindshare. If you were a python advocate then, you were really singing into the void. My personal low-effort view has been that Python is only on the map today because MIT switched to teaching it as the language of choice in their CS classes. A quick internet search says that happened in 2009 though so ... maybe that's not fair. I thought it happened around 2005 causing the popularity to surge around 2010 but... them starting in 2009 seems like it wouldn't've been that quick to spur change. Sounds like I should go watch the documentary. ;)
- rbanffy 1y agoBesides that, any documentary about something as vast as the Python ecosystem will leave some people out. It's not personal - it's the nature of any work with a finite and limited scope. Feeling attacked in these situations is a relevant issue, and, if one struggles with mental health issues but can recognize the symptoms from within, this is one of those moments when you take a step back and try to deescalate your own response, not only for the benefit of others, but for yours as well.
- runjake 1y agoThe Python community didn’t exclude Kenneth because of his condition, at least directly. They excluded him because of his actions and history of shady, manipulative behaviors. And while workplaces should be accommodating, there’s a point where it gets to be too much. I worked at a place with a person with similar behaviors and it destroyed that company because they refused to acknowledge reality: this was a business, not a care facility. One thing is clear: Kenneth is suffering. I hope that he is able to see his behavior from the outside and heal. He’s a great programmer who ships products. For those who don’t know, Kenneth created the Requests library which is nearly ubiquitous in the Python world.
- sfn42 1y agoThis blog I found seems to support your view https://vorpus.org/blog/why-im-not-collaborating-with-kenneth-reitz/ https://vorpus.org/blog/why-im-not-collaborating-with-kennet...
- runjake 1y agoYeah, I’m on mobile, sorry. You can Google or HN search these past events. In fact, Kenneth lurks on HN, too.
- 481Jqgat 1y agoWritten by Nathaniel Smith, who also got Oliphant out of the NumPy Steering Council? And that linked post was approved by the CoC compliant Python Steering Council, a later version of which canceled and defamed Tim Peters? Maybe Smith is right on the facts here, but the methods are despicable.
- alphazard 1y ago> Silence means constantly monitoring my behavior for signs that might reveal my condition, avoiding discussions of mental health that might trigger suspicion and living with the constant anxiety that discovery will lead to rejection. This framing is at the very least maladaptive and possibly indicative of the mental illness they are writing about. Mentally healthy humans regulate their behavior around other humans depending on the context. Sometimes this produces anxiety. And the fact that the author can pull that off at all (even with some difficulty) is a positive sign. There is no reason for an employer or professional colleagues to be aware of an employees medical issues. Maybe there are exceptions for in-office workers with conditions like epilepsy. There are plenty of companies with no questions asked PTO, and as long as they do good work (which the article indicates) no one will bother them for using it.
- standardly 1y ago> There is no reason for an employer or professional colleagues to be aware of an employees medical issues. Totally agree, but it can get a bit weird. I struggle with depression, and at times I have felt like I owed my co-workers/manager/boss an excuse as to why I "suck" sometimes. IE; I didn't show up late for the meeting because I am irresponsible, rather because I'm just in a bad spell this week and have brain fog. If I don't tell them, they may think the former. If I do tell them, who knows.
- alphazard 1y agoThe rationalization matters far more to you than it does to your coworkers or boss. I have no opinion on how you should frame it to yourself. However, I think it's genuinely good advice to say that professionally, people are just trying to build a mental model of how reliable you are. The reasoning doesn't really matter to them, and a psychological diagnosis is a predictive theory about how you will behave. Unfortunately, people will assume close to worst case for any condition you tell them about. The mental model you put in someone's head with a psychological diagnosis is always worse than how they currently perceive you.
- 1y ago
- Dachande663 1y agoPage seems to be down now. Archive link: https://archive.is/UjCgv https://archive.is/UjCgv
- sfn42 1y agoI had never heard of Kenneth Reitz and I was curious about his Python contribution so I googled him and this was one of the first results https://vorpus.org/blog/why-im-not-collaborating-with-kenneth-reitz/ https://vorpus.org/blog/why-im-not-collaborating-with-kennet...
- Rumudiez 1y agoThat post is all about money. The author came into someone else’s project, acts miffed that he isn’t treated as a founder right off the bat, and then complains endlessly about where the donations went. Even belaboring the “dishonesty” of rounding 28k to 30k. I won’t read to the end because clearly this person has major faults of their own and just wrote an attack without making any reflections on himself
- sfn42 1y agoIt certainly isn't all about money, though I think the money is worth talking about. Anyway you're welcome to make up your own mind, I thought the blog seemed credible and reasonable and it certainly cast some light on why this person is having social problems beyond just a diagnosis. I wasn't really looking for information to discredit Reitz, it was just the first thing I stumbled upon.
- rlmcdonald 1y agoAll the comments here about how it's okay that he got excluded because he did the bad things fall right in line with what he's describing. Mental health awareness is easy when you just throw away all the people who make you uncomfortable! I thought it was a pretty good read and I'm not discounting it because it was written by someone struggling with mental illness.
- squigz 1y agoI don't think anybody is dismissing it. But what are you suggesting? That a company should just ignore mental health issues that affect other members of the company, potentially in a very serious way?
- ModernMech 1y agoNo on is suggesting that, but at the same time, such companies offer zero ways for people experiencing a mental health crisis to heal. And maybe that's not their role, but more and more the government also is pushing people toward the private sector for their healthcare needs, so no one wants to deal with it. The choice is either hopping from job to job just to get healthcare, or homelessness. Which, if you look at who is on the streets, that's the choice many schizoaffective people are left with. It's very easy to end up on the streets when you are mentally ill; most people who are ill and manage to stay off the streets are fully supported by family. Mentally ill people sometimes just need a good 7-8 months to get off a bad manic episode. It doesn't fit with corporate next-quarter hustle culture, and it doesn't fit with our "the private sector must monetize your misery" healthcare system. Which means they slip through the cracks, onto the streets, and everyone says "well what are we supposed to do, we've got a business to run here!" Until of course you're stepping over them sleeping on the sidewalk your way to the office. Then it's time to send in the national guard to "clean up the streets". Which is a travesty a national failure. What people are suggesting is there should be another option. Things don't have to be so dire.
- gedy 1y agoI think there’s just a practical matter of if you have a person in this situation, you need to consider the others around him - as they may just leave to easier situations instead of dealing with it. I agree that "Companies tout their mental health benefits and neurodiversity initiatives" really should not do this token performative crap without fully understanding what they are implying.
- squigz 1y agoI imagine I could write a similar blog post about my experience in the field while suffering from autism and severe depression. But the thing is, if you asked my employers, I'm sure they'd give very good reasons as to why I was let go. I wonder what some of those 20 companies he's worked for would say if they were allowed to share their side. I'm not trying to blame Kenneth here, but things are not often as clear cut as he is implying here.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- morleytj 1y agoThis is very unfortunate and I'm sorry to hear that the author has been excluded and is suffering to this extent. On another note though: "This isn't paranoia—it's pattern recognition honed by lived experience." I can't stop seeing the LLM verbiage everywhere I look. I feel like once you recognize the repeated syntax that got RLHF'd into all of these models you never stop seeing it. Maybe everyone is learning those patterns from reading AI-generated language now too.
- nemomarx 1y agoYeah, I also kind of wish he published the blog in his own words instead of using what seems to be LLM polishing. It seems ironically like the same defensiveness and lack of transparency he wants to avoid?
- JohnBooty 1y agoI don't mind AI polishing any more than I mind somebody using a spellchecker. The article overwhelmingly reads like a (painfully) honest and personal account of what he's going through, it's not AI slop.
- nemomarx 1y agoIt's definitely not slop, but there's something kind of sad about a very personal and emotional account needing to be fed through the corpo speak grammar checker? At least in my opinion. It feels like if a friend wanted to vent to me on discord but didn't trust me enough to do it without editing their post for hours, or something.
- erikerikson 1y agoHah. Indeed and also this person was posting to the, on average, uncharitable Internet.
- JohnBooty 1y agoThere's a very large range of situations (many highly personal) for which I'd consider an AI writing assist to be super valid. They may have dyslexia. English may not be their first language. They may have brilliant ideas but otherwise struggle with writing. They may simply be highly invested in making sure they are expressing themselves clearly. They may be too physically or mentally tired to polish their writing "manually." They may be under unfortunate time constraints. Maybe the guy has kids to take care of, or just needed to finish his blog post by a certain time so he could get a good night's sleep. The list of possible reasons is so vast and varied that I coalesce this down into essentially "I don't care and I don't need to know. As long as the end result is an honest representation of the author's intent, i.e. is not AI slop" It feels like if a friend wanted to vent to me on discord but didn't trust me enough to do it without editing their post for hours, or something. I'm being pedantic but as a good comparison. A friend DM'ing you is explicitly asking you to spend your time reading the message. Additionally you and your friend have preexisting context and rapport. If they don't express themselves in anal-retentive detail clearly in the DM, you can fill in the gaps with your shared context, a luxury that a person writing for the public doesn't have. (again, pedantic on my part, I know!)
- drcongo 1y agoI was reading along with great sympathy until I got to this bit... Schizoaffective disorder carries stigma that depression and anxiety don't. People can relate to feeling sad or worried; they cannot relate to experiencing reality differently. Depression is not "feeling sad" and very much is experiencing reality differently. Flippantly calling something so horrifically painful "feeling sad" is exactly the kind of thing he's accusing everyone else of.
- jerlendds 1y agoYoure right its not just feeling sad but relative to the extreme symptoms of Psychosis, delression is very mild by comparison
- blazarquasar 1y agoThese disorders don't exist on the same spectrum. There is no point in comparing the two. Both can be absolutely debilitating. People that feel the need to compare severity of disorders like you do actively contribute to the stigma and invalidation of severe disorders. Tell the families of the more than 700k people that commit suicide every year that "depression is very mild by comparison". An absolutely ignorant comment.
- jerlendds 1y agoWell we agree they exist on different spectrums. The suicide rate is also very bad for psychotic disorders although far fewer people suffer from them. Having faced stigma and invalidation for my issues I suppose I let that rub off on me to the point I stigmatized others. Thanks for pointing that out, I suppose I should be more mindful in the future
- blazarquasar 1y agoI appreciate your reply. Psychotic disorders are absolutely debilitating and any stigma and invalidation towards those is just as shameful. I understand your reaction and I apologize if I was being a little too confrontational. I guess we both share a similar history of stigmatization.
- swayvil 1y ago[flagged]
- nemomarx 1y agoMasking sucks but everyone has to hide parts of themselves in normal corporate workplaces, so it's part of life really. If you're struggling at home or going through a messy divorce, if you're stressed and anxious, if you're dealing with illness, you're supposed to keep some of that held back so it doesn't affect the 'squares' yeah
- tux3 1y agoThe post echoed some similar points from Freddie DeBoer on real mental illness not always being pretty. There's limits to inclusivity that you quickly run into with schizoaffective disorder or bipolar. Companies are proudly supportive on paper, but that rarely extends to mania or psychosis. It's a reality that most people are absolutely not equipped to deal with a coworker (or any contributor) that has manic or psychotic episodes. Mental illnesses is not anyone's fault, but there are still behaviors that will make it difficult to work with others, even for someone like Kenneth who is very good on the technical side.
- JohnBooty 1y agoNon-negotiable tenet(s): all human lives are valuable, all humans deserve dignity, and when we as a society can't find a place for a valuable and talented individuals like the author then we have failed in some sense. That said, within the current system... Morally and legally, what are the limits of accommodation? Accommodation, in my uninformed layman understanding, is about accommodating people who can do the job, but need to do it differently than others. For example, wheelchair accessibility for white-collar office workers. Does it include the inclusion of people who can't perform all aspects of the job? Communication and collaboration are absolute pillars of nearly any engineer's job, but by the writer's own statements it seems like his condition often prevents this. How do we resolve this?
- squigz 1y ago> Non-negotiable tenet(s): all human lives are valuable, all humans deserve dignity, and when we as a society can't find a place for a valuable and talented individuals like the author then we have failed in some sense. This sort of framing assumes the author bears no responsibility at all, and it's just society that has failed. The thing is though, even in an ideal society, it would be not reasonable to expect people to deal with someone's issues indefinitely, particularly when they chalk up all criticism as "discrimination"; I'm quite certain there are legitimate reasons, completely unrelated to his mental health, that he was fired or passed over for promotions.
- JohnBooty 1y agoI wholeheartedly agree. Individual responsibility is, really, a crucial pillar of just about anything. Especially this question. The thing is though, even in an ideal society, it would be not reasonable to expect people to deal with someone's issues indefinitely Agree 100%. Now, in that somewhat narrow perspective, this seems unsolvable. If we accept that communication and collaboration is an essential part of nearly any engineering job then I don't know that many companies are going to be able to accommodate an engineer who can't do those things. That gets back to the fundamental distinction between "is able to do the job, but needs to be able to do it differently" versus "cannot do the job." Zooming out a bit, though, it's also true that in an ideal society we'd be able to use everybody's talents to their full potential. Getting to 100.0% of that is surely not achievable but getting as close to it as possible should be our "north star" if you'll forgive the cliched corpo-speak term. The author has proven himself (unless I am mistaken) to be a valuable and dedicated Python engineer, and creates code that helps others, and it really is a loss to society if those talents cannot be utilized.
- arp242 1y ago> A perfect example: the Python documentary releases tomorrow, featuring interviews with Python community leaders and contributors. Despite creating one of the most foundational Python libraries in history, I wasn't even contacted about participating. No email, no mention, complete invisibility. The omission speaks volumes about how mental health disclosure transforms you from community asset to community liability It features 22 people, which already seems quite a lot for a 90 minute documentary. And I can think of several other prominent Python people who are not listed. And lets be real here: "I made a Python library people like" really doesn't compete against "I was a core Python dev for 20 years". requests being "one of the most foundational Python libraries in history" seems quite exaggerated. This kind "I need to be front and centre of attention and when I'm not I am being oppressed" type stuff is a big part of the reason why so many people found it hard to work with Kenneth. His constant self-aggrandizing and need for endless validation gets very tiring very fast. I appreciate that Kenneth's mental health struggles are very real and I do not mean to devalue that in any way, but his constant use of his mental health to dismiss and and all criticism of his behaviour is another thing that gets very tiring very fast. Of course I have no insight in many aspects of Kenneth's life and can't comment on any of it. I am perfectly willing to believe that sometimes in some places he has been discriminated due to his mental health diagnosis. I can however comment on the state of things in Python because much of it is public, and the problems there have been mostly or entirely unrelated to his mental health diagnosis.
- throw18376 1y agopeople in states of psychosis often behave in frightening ways out of their control, and do and say hurtful things to those around them. if someone hurts you or does something very frightening, fear and anger are natural emotions. but it’s not morally wrong to experience psychosis. so how could it be right for me to feel fear and anger towards that person when they haven’t done anything wrong? it is a tough contradiction. you can resolve the contradiction by just deciding to hate and fear anyone who shows signs of psychosis, treat them as if it is a morally bad trait, which many people do, see discourse about homeless people in NYC. or you can just try to pretend that psychosis doesn’t exist, which a lot of people do, like when some public figure shows obvious psychotic symptoms but people act like it’s rational behavior. or you can disavow the fear and anger, but if a person does actually frighten and hurt you, the resulting negative feelings often tend to be expressed in weird and unfair ways. i suspect this author’s employers and doctors probably do a lot of this. personally I think the least bad solution is to acknowledge that anger towards a person can be justified even if they’ve done nothing morally wrong, just feel anger, and express it only in controlled ways. but this is philosophically confusing, easy to state, hard to really believe deep down.
- notmyjob 1y agoMany people are crazy, few are honest. Most people say they want diversity but they really don’t. But mentally ill people will trust what people say because they can’t trust their own instincts and this makes them prone to being victimized and othered, often by the systems and people that are supposed to help.
- awolven 1y agoI have schizoaffective disorder and work in the tech industry and have not noticed any of the things this author talks about. While I am medicated, even if I inform bosses, coworkers or HR that I have this dangerous mental illness, I am treated completely normal. It is only when I have an episode of psychosis that things get difficult, and rightfully so for the people around you, because it is extremely difficult for someone to have any sort of normal relationship with someone who is psychotic and delusional. Psychosis happens when there is a failure in the healthcare. Psychosis does ruin relationships, but I don't blame other people for this. As a patient, while still in my right mind, I must insist that my healthcare needs are adequately addressed. This includes retaining a qualified doctor, setting up a medical power of attorney, reminding myself that I must take medications that work, despite the side effects, and possibly asking for reduced hours or responsibilities. It is neither everyone else's fault for the difficulties I face, nor my fault, it just is the way it, and pointing the finger at everyone else is not helpful. I am grateful for the consideration and forgiveness people do offer considering the objective circumstance.
- kennethreitz 1y agoFYI, I updated the post to acknowledge the public criticisms of my previous behavior: > I need to be clear about something. I'm not claiming innocence in every workplace conflict or community dispute. I've made mistakes, handled situations poorly, and there's been legitimate criticism of my behavior in some cases. The Requests 3 fundraising situation, in particular, was handled badly - I took on commitments I couldn't deliver and didn't communicate well about the problems. I've apologized for this, though I understand the damage was already done. Mental illness doesn't excuse harmful behavior, and I'm not asking it to. Thanks for the feedback!
- 0x3444ac53 1y agoHi Kenneth, I read through your post and the other one linked here and I want to take a moment to speak directly to you. I also struggle with my mental health, and was diagnosed with PTSD and OCD a few years ago. Until I started treatment, and even some while in treatment, I managed to hurt a lot of people around me. I struggled to take accountability for my actions, and often felt I was being persecuted in one way or another. The world is awful, and we don't have the support systems or safety nets for those with mental health struggles that we should. Most of what I'm seeing in discussions about your actions, and what I'm getting from your post, is a lack of accountability. That said, I recognize that you're trying. A lot of people, myself included, have struggled to learn how to take accountability for harm while still holding compassion for themselves, and that seems to be where you are. You are correct that workplaces often discriminates against people with mental illnesses, but true understanding and compassion means holding you accountable for your actions. You're more than your illness, but it's still a part of how you engage with the world and others, and is your responsibility. Obviously, I don't know why you've been let go so much, or if there was more to it then just being open about your struggles, but I wanted to give my two cents as someone who has often felt the way you speak about feeling. Best of luck <3